Carrie Underwood - George Michael's "Praying for Time" (live @ Idols Give Back 2008)

[SantiMuntaner]

Perfection

[skyechas]

Good performance. Still, I'd go with George Michael.

[lizzyvance]

Carrie vocals are pure perfection.

[BookLoverReviews]

flawless.

[GreenEyes419]

simon cracks me up

[jaycindyrbd]

Flawless performance from the Greatest vocalist on this planet, theres no way she could ever screw up! LOVE YOU CARRIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!

[carriefan0001]

carries version of this song is beautiful!!! nobody else can sing like that live and sound incredible!!! :))) <3

[Betsy0640]

Oh, God...help people understand what you're saying through her voice. You are amazing. and this is a sad, sad ,song...sung by the greatest artist of our time. (I saw Carrie in Calgary Alberta this Christmas and it was THE most emotional,beautiful, performance I have ever seen. She filled a 17000 people auditorium with that gifted voice! seriously amazing. (oh, p.s. yank? you are SO right ,when she sang that song (I know you wont) I bawled, the whole row and behind and in front, weeping.

[RainHNg]

There's different between screaming and singing and this is definitely not screaming.

Also, there are bunch of clips about her live performance out there that prove you're wrong about the 3 secs thing, if you care to find out (search or in the column right here --->)

I prefer this over the original because her raw and angry voice in this song is much better reflecting the serious, bitter & ingenious lyric (an angel, smooth, soft voice doesn't match this song's content at all, IMO)

[Yorgos72]

I really don't like her voice, she screams and no vibrato at all. I bet she can't belt a not for 3 seconds. I dont want to be mean, but in this case..i am. I prefer george Michael.

[yank321]

Please go listen to Carrie sing "I know you Wont" and you will find out she can belt forever. lol but seriously

[jbdanielle20]

@Yorgos72 FUCK YOU!!! dont you dare ever say that again about her!!! she is the most beautiful woman, and has an incredible voice. she CAN hold a note for much longer for 3 seconds...you have NO idea what you are talking about so just shut the hell up

[ssaawwqq]

@Yorgos72 FUCK YOU ASSHOLE. No one talks about carrie that way. No one should ever after hearing how great thou art on girls night out. Look it up you will change your mind.

[92Lyss]

@Yorgos72 GO LOOK AT HOW GREAT THOU ART! She is flawless. She can sing notes better than anybody in the industry! If you want to talk crap... do it about someone else. Carrie fans wont tolerate it about her. #CarrieArmy.

[RainHNg]

@ ClaudiaMoedersheim

I did :) , still, I prefer Carrie version

I guess we have to agree to disagree...

[ClaudiaMoedersheim]

I still prefer the original artist, she made an outstanding contribution but you have to listen to George Michael in 'American Idol'...so beautiful!! That man can sing like an angel, so smooth, so soft, so pure... Love you 4ever, George!!!