Haley Reinhart - I Who Have Nothing (2nd Song) - Top 4 - American Idol 2011 - 05/11/11

[nikolamujdzic]

The best performace yet! Ever

[CD4L7]

I'm still in love with this!

[japzbene1562]

That was an AMAZING performance. Smartest thing J-lo ever said on there. Love you Haley

[woohoojazelyn]

...IJUSTGOTGOOSEBUMPS!

[1900brittany]

That performance was perfect her voice the song the dress everything I don't watch American idol but she should have won !!!!!!!!!!! ......and was I the only one who spotted Nikki reed with Paul at the end :)

[craps3344]

Haley, you sang "I who have nothing", You Have In Fact Won Everything!!! Believe me!! :))

[MuteMusicalMorgan]

Personally, I like Jordan Sparks' version better, but I still loooovvveee hailey!!

[Angeliqueinparis]

This season her performances were the most memorable. Love you Haley!

[ruinestoky1]

this girl should have win .. advise from portugal.

[Snipercop65]

Haley is simply amazing! Not knocking the final two, they were good but nowhere near the ranges of Haley. Seems the best always get voted out in the #3 spot IE... Chris Doughtry, Casey James to name a few. But Haley Reinhart? WOW!

[hattiehedgehog]

@Snipercop65 chris daughtry came 4th not third, but agree he was the best that season

[destroyer878]

FUKN BEAUTYFUL...perfectly executed

[MrJakendrick79]

Simply amazing. Words alone fail to describe the brilliance of Haley in this performance.

[srnd2008]

I'm blown away by her professionalism on stage. 0:39 is my favorite part. Love you Haley! :)

[peopleloveloveme]

OMG, when I got into the character she sings about... I almost cried...

[cornnful]

Pia toscano is smoking hot and the best singer ever on ameran idol and Haley reinhart is smoking hot and the 2nd best singer on American idol season 10

[bookfreak115]

won.

[bookfreak115]

This is a testament to true talent and perseverance. Hardly 5 minutes before that performance, the judges took the top 4 out on stage, and, when asked who had "won" the previous round, Randy replied that it was a tie between the other 3, basically singling her out. Before they went to break, the camera zoomed in on her, and she was looking the other way, probably trying not to cry. Five minutes later, she goes out and absolutely SLAYS the song. The judges can go to hell. We know who should have

[123ELEW123]

Truly amazing

[PrettyInPlaid92]

Best part !!

0:00-1:59

[rng4evr]

I made an American idol playlist but I should have named it Haley considering I only hav her performances!!!

[DelxD]

gosh dang it needs an album

[littlelittlemoe]

She is AMAZING I love you

[kmc9008]

Months later and I still can't get enough!!! She is so captivating!

[rng4evr]

Even better than her voice, is the emotion she delivers with each song!

[Rahetor2]

I'm blown away

[12345RachelH]

I'm for sure buying her cd! I just have to have it! :) she's amazing!

[rafb1]

excelente interpretacion, me impactó, era mi favorita

[RolandsPrincess]

1:00 mark is the best.

[MRBBJC]

Fantastic! Should've won. If it was one vote per phone she would be the Idol this year.

[bellcj1990]

Listen up record companies; Sony, Virgin, Capital, Atlantic, Universal, etc. SOMEBODY SIGN HER NOOOOW!

[CallieAnn111]

@1:10 is the best part!!

[Youssymeerkat]

She gives me sooo many goosebumps!

[linux2216]

I tear up every time I watch this. I can't wait until her first album is released.

[amk377]

GOOO HALEY!!! So amazing...I love your voice...Chills here!!! Kick ass girl!!!

[portolinco]

YOU GO GIRL AMAZING

[NellieWs]

I'm so glad I don't have to listen to jlo in this version... She socks soo bad...but Haley omg she is just... Her voice kills me. The moment after window pane when she growls is AMAZING!!!

[simplywilly1]

ME to im so sick or randy dogging her every week..

GO haley i hope she has b future career in the music industry

[quenquen411]

singing songs is one thing... I think an even greater gift is writing music... you can put out stuff you fell so strongly... and Haley does poetry. she can actually make something of herself... as a writer she can make sure stuff fits her and isn't just like 'oh, okay.. Ill sing it' ..l

[immortallovers1218]

This song goes out to the person who I though loved me and was crazy for me, it so happens It was never true. I feel no guilt for I was always honest during our relashionship , but people that are insecure and controlling won't stop at nothing to prove that their partner was cheating or to find something to point out at their loved one, until they find nothing or something so simple like a closed site or even open but no evidence of cheating cause that person was faithful,and u let ur insecurit

[FaadumoArdo]

Jordin Sparks sang more beautiful than this Halley sang.

[quenquen411]

12 Alfred and Thelma Lou fans came to dislike this.... go away

[Retr0phistic]

Chilllllss

[robertruss2012rar]

Omg this was just amazing! This is like my 60th time watching this in a row...I can't get enough and its so dramatic...perfect!

[mattkudzu]

Fantastic performance!

[NinjaCupcakeGirl]

Haley and James should have made it to the top two they can perform and they have unique qualities that make them ready to release records they were the best!!!

[1youlisa]

One of the best performances ever on idol.

[sollicious22]

Can't stop watching omg I love her

[lieytAA]

can scotty n lauren sing like this?! Haley s d real WINNER

[novemberainy]

James, Casey, Haley, Pia---all talented ones are gone. AI should change their system. it should be 50-50 from the voters and the judges' vote!! Seriously. 

[MizEmzie]

SHE IS A-M-A-Z-I-N-G.

[linux2216]

My eyes well up at the end. I've watched this at least 10 times and I haven't had enough. Haley is awesome!

[IcedLipGloss]

i cant believe the tOp 3! pia left, casey left, JACOB LEFT! wtf is this???!!!

[DVANGEL67]

Remember a lo times this competition have bussines inside and the judges are not honesty they recibe money in this and a lot times family or "padrinos" pay a lot money not for the best and reality if no for that more inlfuence...is sad but htis USA...is same in every thing...but HALEY IS THE BEST AND NOW NOT NEED AMERICAN IDOLE FOR BE SUCCES SHE IS NOW ANGEL IN THES EARTH...!!!

[newmsuguy]

Anyone who "dislikes" this is (like Haley say's) "a no one with nothing to give"! Haley SLAYS in this performance on every level. The only thing I hate about this performance is that it had to end!!!! I've seen Jordin Spark's performance, didn't make me OR the judges give a standing O!!! and thats not my opinion its a FACT! #TeamHaley4Life!!!!

[3emiii3]

Dios mio! que voz!

:D

me encanta!

[linux2216]

...made me a Haley fan. Haley is the American Idol!

[linux2216]

I hadn't paid much attention to Haley until Benny and the Jets. When she sang House of the Rising Sun with the a cappella intro I was amazed, but this performance

[HugandaKiss]

DUDE...from like, 0:56 - 1:03. WOW! INCREDIBLE! and I'm not even a Haley fan. lol

[elva2011]

Vote Haley this week so we can get her to the top 2!!!she definitely deserves it. She is amazing! And she is the one person who has improved dramatically. At first in wasnt sure about her but now I love her!!!

[hattiehedgehog]

i don't like that randy and j lo are always so hard on her but they did look really happy that she made the final 3 so they obviously like her

[dmp1549]

@hattiehedgehog That's funny, I thought they looked befuddled.

[puurplephoto]

Amazing Voice + Passion = Next American IDOL!

[amber777able]

I love this song and Haley!!!!!

[Megalitus]

No question should go all the way!!!!!!!

[deannastyleshair]

we need to voteee peoplee!!!!!

if we voteee she is safeeee!!!!

lets do thisss.... get that lauren trick off the showww =]

[nmc67971]

she is like mariah carey...go haley just do what is inside of you and let that be your lead up to the top...I I who have nothing but voice.....

[bellcj1990]

Whose up for a DON'T SEND HALEY HOME CAMPAIGN?!

[bellcj1990]

American Idol this year would have "nothing" without Haley. Keep that growl goin HALEY!

[sikmagic]

she is FINE.



[princess1235]

ive watched this 5 times and i still havent gotten enough. i have goosbumps, and i cried the first time i heard this

[pinkbluegreenanime]

@rbrb1558 Haha! No.... u kno wat? I'm not laughing! U DON'T HAVE THE RIGHT TO CALL HER A BITCH! SHE WAS TICKED OFF THAT THE JUDGES PUT HER DOWN EVERY SINGLE DAMN WEEK! WOULDN'T U BE? I MEAN, NOT SAYING U CAN SING, BUT U WOULD BE PISSED RIGHT? SEEING AS THOUGH YOU CALLED HAYLEY A BITCH I WOULD SUPPOSE YOU HAVE A BAD TEMPER! WELL GUESS WHAT! SO DO I! IF YOU DON'T LIKE HER THEN DON"T F***KIN WATCH HER VIDEOS< BITCH! YES, IT IS NOW YOUR TURN TO FEEL THE FUCKIN BURN!

[hyperhyper245]

I don't like her at all she's got a reallllllly bad attitude problem but this performance was amazing, the performance of the night easily. Second would be Lauren Alaina singing 'Anyway'

[krzysztoffux777]

Greetings for poland and good luck

[NachoReys20]

the WINNERR!!! i love this women! <3

[rbrb1558]

HAHA THIS BITCH, she lost lots of votes stupid bitch she ruined this & she will not beat* Scotty OR lauren(:

[tmaras64]

@rbrb1558 you are such a loser. Why would you call anyone you dont know a bitch. Grow up.

She has more talent than anyone else left....

[rbrb1558]

@tmaras64 Well WTF ever she went home so she aint meann shit no more(: Much Lovee(:

[mau345]

top quality.

[xuevana]

this song & the house of rising sun really blows the whole season out of the water

[tmaras64]

@xuevana and Benny and the Jets....she has really come a long way since this started...hope she wins...

[pogah1985]

she has to win now!!is it possible to get 2 female finalists lol not likel;y scott will end up winning cant believe hes come this far he is so boring and lauren is sooooooo overrated!!

[DragonBoyAC]

FUCK BITCH SHE SHOULD BE GONE NOT JAMES.

[DshankumMusic]

@DragonBoyAC No, should be Lauren.

[DragonBoyAC]

@DshankumMusic i could even live with that

[Themadfarter1976]

Awesome

[hattiehedgehog]

AMAZING!!!!!

[chiopeefillin]

i cant believe she's still on the show

[jovyniel1234]

@chiopeefillin no offense to her fans but me too xD

[DshankumMusic]

@jovyniel1234 Lauren should be gone.

[Skrunch123]

Amazing, deserves to win!!!

[legalglitz]

This is great, but she is hit or miss. And I'm not sure where she would fit into the music business today. Pop music currently sucks and she is not country. The other two are going to fit in to the country genre just fine and sell lots of records. It's a techno/rap/Miley world and talent doesn't really have a place in pop. Sucks for her, but it's true.

[5Mantoe5]

@legalglitz What about people like Adele? and Duffy? Someone like you by Adele has over 13million views on youtube... I'm pretty sure Hayley can fit into that..

[askysoblue]

why does AI recycle all the same songs??? it drives me crazy. this was really good but I get distracted thinking about when j sparks did it.

[MsCatzi]

omg, such a sultry sexy voice... I hear a touh of Billie Holiday/Janis Joplin/Stevie Nicks with a hint of Celine Dion. I do not get how there are people who don't absolutely fall to the floor when she sings. I get chills. I really don't know who will win... but Hailey will NOT go away.

[WandaMullens]

Great Job. Talent like yours only comes around every 75 yrs. Haley's Comet. Go girl.

[lorenrJLo]

Jennifer say in the began of the competence on idol she want Girl Power and the results is two amazings singer in the top 3, amen thanks JLo

Haley with unique voice is our of this world

[thonycinq]

Thumbs up if you too were laughing your ass off when you saw Casey going crazy after her performances haha :P

[WandaMullens]

Great Job.  Talent like yours only comes around every 75 yrs. Haley's Comet. Go girl.

[epi8]

Seriously, one of the greatest songs every written or arranged. Y'all go check out Shirley's version. Pure drama.

[TheBigDylan13]

I'm so glad to see our little dark horse make it tis far. I mean top 3? Who would have thought? People are eating their words right now! Let us not forget the horrible loss of James Durbin. I will not be getting over that any time soon. He and Haley are tied for my fav. I would been happy with either of them winning, so now that he's gone, all my votes will go to Haley. I hope we can get her into the finale! I just really do not want to see the dreaded cleche Lauren/Scotty finale....

[xxrileylynnxx]

so so so good <3

[catherinebasa]

its true Haley is haley shes so beautiful.,total performer

[akjadestar]

GOOD JOB HALEY! TOP 3, YEAH MAN.

[8mybrain1]

Haley and Lauren Alaina are fantastic. I HATE Scotty!!!! So uncomfortable to watch!!

[iloveorangeandblack]

This song was FANTASTIC. Every single thing she did was right on. She has an incredible voice even without all the growling and screaming and I think this song really showed America that. She is going to go very far.

[MsVolleyballgirl1016]

It's the judges opinion not yours, you can get over it, it's not a big deal! They aren't even helping choose who leaves

[ShadowDog415]

Randy needs to shut his ass and not diss her everytime, I hope she stays

[luvgush1983]

GAG!

[naschburger2]

Why did Haley cut out a whole verse of the song. I liked her version but it was quite different from Jordan Sparks and the missing verse ruined the song for me. I know Idol has time constraints but is this another conspiracy to get rid of Haley?

[megloler123]

AGHI DONT LIKE SCOTTY!! although, his prformnce last night did entertain me. hehe it was hillarious.

[Angelat413]

I love her. She is supet good! Her nnd lauren should be in the two top. The cowboy in top 3. Sorry the rocker guy was wack!

[geo0o0o]

the best contestant of season 10

[000nadette000]

Haley I like your voice quality from the start of this season. You're not snooty , keep it going til you become a star. I'm your asian-fan. Wish I may add your FB acct ? (my great honor if you can reply this request- thank you)

[ROFLindsey]

I'm so sick of Randy dogging her out every week. He sits there and praises everyone else for "taking risks" showing different sides, but keeps criticizing Haley for it. Why do the judges wanna put her in a box? She is more than another Janis Joplin or Joss Stone. She's HALEY and she's winner material.

[carlos312]

@ROFLindsey They dog her because shes the best!

[didi0803msm]

She seems so angry when the judges say negative things about her performances.I love that .And then she sings like this. IN YOUR FACE!!! Randy and Jennifer!!

[oke00306]

i just got mad when j-lo and randy start judging at her first performance,,,

i love steven tyler, he know whos the best in the competition...

HALEY FOR IDOL



[epi8]

Haley is a beast. She has the potential to be up there with the 3 greats, Whitney, Celine and Mariah. The other contestants pale in comparison. Judges are on meth.

[puddya]

@epi8 You are right. Haley sang the MJ song and this song like a "beast" - and that is the problem. America wants to listen to the voice of a human being, not the voice of a growler and an ear splitting screamer.

[oke00306]

HALEY FOR IDOL

i vote for her straight almost two hours

i just can't be calm, after the greatest performance in stage ever, but the judge seems dont like it.. thats looks crazy!!! she move me to vote... perhaps she move us america

[bonggarrs]

hailey's take on 1:00-1:05 is hailey-cious! woot! woot!

[nuvamusic]

I would say this was a wrong song choice for Haley. Jordin Sparks knocked it out of the park both vocally and performance wise back in season 6, so yeah, the comparison was inevitable. Jordin's was way better.

[bonggarrs]

@nuvamusic that jordin's karaoke take, splendid nonetheless but this is what version's should be, see that spin on 1:00-1:05? holy hailey!

[roecar13]

know it will come down to Haley and Scotty she uses the full range of her vocals and still has a little Joplin in her she.s country she's rock she's jazz. and consistent

[crism1980]

thats the way to do it haley! love it!

[ismaro99]

She is the ONE!

[irockvery]

PLEASE DON'T LET HER BE ELIMINATED, GUYS!!! PLEASE!!!!!!

[aloscheles11]

@irockvery sorry we will

[akitayo]

GO Haley go

[lilcoffeebean]

Thank you!!

[kevinskater11]

She was pure perfection! Amazing!! Please vote for her. She has unique talent and doesn't sound like all the other singers out there. That's how adeles so famous.

[leaderofkidworld]

I just voted for this amazing woman about more than 20 times already, because she does not deserve to get eliminated tomorrow. Go Haley! Show those judges what you're made of.

[jbs24601]

if you think haley's amazing and she didnt deserve to be singled out like that, thumbs up, and keep redialing for haley!

[FAllingMemories25]

OMG haley is gettin better and better every week!!!!!

[rrapkryeziu1]

100 votes go for Haley!!!

[FAllingMemories25]

@rrapkryeziu1 vote for her like a 1000+.., lauren fans are mad now on voting bcoz lauren is in the bottom 2 last week

[ronhep49]

Take that you asshole judges. This was by far the best of the night! The other performances were all fluff by comparison. The best I have ever heard Haley sing and is the best of the season in my mind, and her 1st song was the 2nd best of the night!