While I agree with most people here that Aaron kinda've ruined the beginning, I think he completely made up for it towards the beginning of the outro. That was an awesome outro!
rudooooooooooooo es la rola mas chingona de nine inch nails si kisiera paraecerme a alguien sería a ti maldito bastardo de trenz komo te admiro mas tu bipolaridad!!
'love the way the lighting is done - everywhere he gives a live performance, everything seems to be precise.. sound and lighting. he is one of the only artists who takes the times to verify that everything is perfect, and he doesn't amp himself up on some crazy new drug for his live performances.
Christ, just when I thought this song couldn't get any more gorgeous...This might be my favorite version to date, and considering every version makes it a bit hard for me to breathe, that is truly saying a lot. Cheers.
Sorry but Aaron's interpretation of how to play the beginning chords of the song just suck compared to Robin's. TDTWWA from "And All That Could Have Been" is literally the best version of the song. It was better live than on "The Fragile". Aaron may be talented, but some songs he just flat out takes the piss on, like this one.
fking awesome
SpiritualMonkey100 1 year ago
While I agree with most people here that Aaron kinda've ruined the beginning, I think he completely made up for it towards the beginning of the outro. That was an awesome outro!
animenice 1 year ago
i like this version is the best
FERNYDL 1 year ago
best song
pererecamoon 2 years ago
treznor rules
rriffrraff 2 years ago
I was that dude with the glasses would move...
wwemagazine 2 years ago
@wwemagazine i think he is triping
crabbyfive 8 months ago
This song is in terminator salvation.
quest8899 2 years ago
this song came out 8 yrs ago bufon!
mrzero21 2 years ago 2
it came out 10 years ago
elech77 2 years ago 2
10 years ago...god...I was high school. That makes me feel so OLD...
40thCapeRifles 2 years ago 4
I was high school.
XxSwissBabyxX 2 years ago
Comment removed
vincentvoyou 1 year ago
ye it came out 10 years ago but it's featured in the trailer.
deanjones19 2 years ago
your stuff is the best Acidfreak. I wish I was good enough to figure out the solo by ear. Would love to be able to play it.
lollerkittenz 2 years ago
what a powerful song damn
TheMissing8 2 years ago
I felt the goosebumps form on my skin as I watched and listened to this. Awesome filming :)
Wildsea320 3 years ago
rudooooooooooooo es la rola mas chingona de nine inch nails si kisiera paraecerme a alguien sería a ti maldito bastardo de trenz komo te admiro mas tu bipolaridad!!
FERNYDL 3 years ago
At the end, there is kind of a pink floyd guitar sound.
vincentvoyou 3 years ago 3
God...the guy in the glasses that's in the way the whole time is really distracting.
BTL256 3 years ago 3
I agree, Mr. Bale.
h0b0ch1c 2 years ago
zing!
tabset 2 years ago
don really like this version. aaron screwed it up
0here1we2go3again4 4 years ago
'love the way the lighting is done - everywhere he gives a live performance, everything seems to be precise.. sound and lighting. he is one of the only artists who takes the times to verify that everything is perfect, and he doesn't amp himself up on some crazy new drug for his live performances.
Sleepless2night 4 years ago 7
I almost shit myself at 5:15. I REALLY wish I had been there.
onima 4 years ago 9
wish I had been there!!!!!!
finnixx 4 years ago 3
I think this version with Aaron has a bigger feeling.. For me this is the best line-up that Trent ever have...
bweskasonako 4 years ago
I agree. I like this version better then the version from and all that could have been.
electrikoptik 4 years ago
In case youtube messes this up, this is a response to bweskasonako: I agree, although the most recent lineup was amazing!
CharlesMans0m 3 years ago
robin finck is a good guitar player for sure. aaron did pretty good.
jrquilty 4 years ago
thanks, great post
mackie127 4 years ago
Christ, just when I thought this song couldn't get any more gorgeous...This might be my favorite version to date, and considering every version makes it a bit hard for me to breathe, that is truly saying a lot. Cheers.
nova1636 4 years ago
I love this song.
It's very personal to me.
OH GEEZ HAUSER:
Finck wasn't even that good it the first place.
Give North a break here. O_O
AggieMaryann 4 years ago
Sorry but Aaron's interpretation of how to play the beginning chords of the song just suck compared to Robin's. TDTWWA from "And All That Could Have Been" is literally the best version of the song. It was better live than on "The Fragile". Aaron may be talented, but some songs he just flat out takes the piss on, like this one.
gatesoftanhauser 4 years ago 6
Actually, you've got a point there.
Screw what I said 2 months ago.
Depends on the song like you said.
AggieMaryann 4 years ago
OMG!!!!!! ITS PERFECT!!!!
Corrupted94 4 years ago 3
This is the greatest song ever......
pudelveli 4 years ago 2
aaron totally fucked up the beginning. *anybody else miss robin*?
gatesoftanhauser 4 years ago 2
give that boy a break its not easy playing trent songs cuz hes a genius. Could u play that part?
mugsy999 4 years ago 3
I Can :D, bassguitar.. n sing too.. yeah its funn.. love nin tho, great video ay? one of my favs :P loll Laterr NIN FOREVER!!! lol
Awag3737 4 years ago
Guess what? Robin Finck wasn't even that great either.
blakxzep 4 years ago
agreed... as soon as the drums start, it's incredible.. long live NIN
Sleepless2night 4 years ago
song sounds badass still and always will..aaron is just different style.
jrquilty 4 years ago
At first it was sucking but then that last 2 minutes it just sounds much more emotional than the other versions.
blakxzep 4 years ago
Didn't really like the beginning, but Aaron proves to be a great addition in the end...
endlightend 5 years ago
ya he sounded off in the beginning. as if he just played the song for the first time. but this was a pretty good performance
why287 4 years ago