Added: 3 years ago
From: NICKwalkerx
Views: 60,838
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (101)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Im sorry this made me cringe LOL.. 80% was some robot :o And that awkwardly loud applause after her little baby "Yeah yeah yeeeah"s at the end was too funny lol

  • J'adore ! :)

  • This sucks. The nasal parts were all her. That's it. This movie gives a bad name to music schools everywhere.

  • They digitally enhanced her voice. Love Hil, but the producers should have saved themselves the trouble (and subsequent criticism) and cast a legit singer who could do the vocal exercise sans computer assistance.

  • This bit always makes me cringe ;S

  • Maybe she's just using impostation quite correctly

  • @JoseCarlosCristiano

    .. improvisation?

  • @soxiii67 Yeah, but no, Impostation is tha vocal technique that the singer use in order to make the voice sound more covered and to fill all the sounds, pressing the diafragma and using the right resonators, like the one in the head and in the mouth, your chest, etc

  • @JoseCarlosCristiano

    oh sorry. thank you for clarifying! I have never heard of that term before. :(

  • 0:38 she was like 'Should I go for it?' in a few seconds XD

  • about 75% of this isn't her...if you think other wise your a dumb ass.

  • Now I wanna see the whole movie again ^.^

  • Wow

  • Lol this is beyond cheese!!!

  • O.o

  • ok...i've been a fan of hilary duff for 5 years... but the first time i saw this part of the movie, i could inmediately notice that wasn't her voice.... just in some parts...

  • I don't care what y'all say I think it was all her voice

  • When I was 10 I thought this was soo real.. Now I'm disappointing :(

  • Shite

  • It was so bad and she started good but end bad so I say learn how to sing for the better ;) :) ",)

  • @amoGothic ; well if u think u can do must better then u put up a video of ur self singing if u think hilary duff suck s

  • Too bad it's not real. She can't go that high, naturally, it's not in her vocal scales. She does not have a bad voice, but she doesn't have anything special really about her voice. I love her, and I think she is a great actress, but I didn't like the dubbing they used for this part of the movie.

  • @KatiahMichele she can hit high notes watch?v=P1G3qdgMlCQ

  • It's possible to be a fan of HDuff while still admitting that this is hilarious and awkward. It's part of her Disney Channel charm.

    I'd say it's fairly equivalent to Mkate and Ashley. Terrible acting, which is why their movies are so incredibly entertaining...

  • That was well awkard.

  • Yall do know only some of this singing is her voice I'm not a hater either

  • That's some of the most incredible acting I've ever seen. Applauding instead of looking for that computer who was singing.

  • @ZawmbieDomo ha! good one lol.

  • at the 43 second mark it sounds like she's transforming into something lol

  • I love when she sings at 0:38!! It's so pretty

  • Lmfao. Years ago, I thought this was real, and I was like oooh pretty. It's so obviously fake. But I love Hilary Duff lol.

  • @BillieJeeean It's real. She is professionally trained.

  • @CoreyAlanLong I hope you're referring to the girl who is REALLY singing, and not Hilary. lol

  • Comment removed

  • @BillieJeeean I was talking about Hilary. She is professionally trained, even though she sounds like that. Same goes for Kristin Chenoweth, She can go opera and pop, while her voice dramatically changes. There is no one else credited for (Terry's Singing Voice) whatsoever. It was all Hilary.

  • lmfao.

  • Well.. I liked it. I didn't notice how her voice changed because I wasn't listening to find imperfection. I was listening because it's pure music.

  • @beachbabii0712 I Agree With You EveryOne Was Saying her Voice Sounds Nasaly But I Wasn't Listening For ImPerfection I Totally Agree With You. <3333333333

  • only the easy parts were her. ugh. lame.

  • Love Hilary Duff! She is so real!!!

  • This is actually the best unintentional comedic part of the movie. Do they expect us to believe that's actually her voice?

  • 0:25 - 0:28 not her voice, 0:29 - 0:32 her voice, 0:33 - 0:36 not her voice, 0:37 - 0:39 her voice, 0:40 - 0:46 not her voice, 0:47 - 0:52 her voice.....weird X-P

  • wow that was pretty bad.

  • her voice is SOOOO real

  • Just listening to hilary doing this little freestyle makes me feel better

  • if you guys dont know how Hilary Duff sings then you can stfu. Its her and someone else singing.

  • she starting giving up, that's wat she went flat

  • wow....? tht is NOT her voice lol

  • how the hell is this fake? she's a professional singer. grow up people

  • Are you guys kidding me? You're actually hating on that voice? You're nuts. You don't have a freakin' clue what singing is.

  • 0:43 - 46 seconds is the best part! fake or not.

  • how many times hath hilary duff's voice changed? let us count the ways.

    6.

  • This movie basically has a good plot and somehow Hilary seems to fit in. but not for the singing part. they might recruit a real soprano.

  • unless someone can produce some straight up proof, i think that all claims to fakeness should be disregarded.

  • she doesnt know how to sing at all

  • yuck.

  • My God! Could they not find a female actress who could act and sing?? Hilary fails terribly at both of these !!

  • im soooo confused!!! kinda the end parts it sounds just like her just not the begging :/

  • any good singer can easily mix up a scale like that. obviously why that was hilary singing.

  • This Is My Favorite Part Of The Movie,♥

  • She sounds black 0:38

  • ho!!! well its a movie!!!!! Who said is real!! hee! hilary is a really cool actress! and thats it!

  • hahahahaha so hilarious almost as bad as the voice they used in lizzie mcguire movie

  • hahahahahah

  • @XXFweshXXSwaqqaXX HAhahahah LOL!

  • Bahahahaha. This is so ridiculous.

  • her voice is so nasal and immature.

  • This is my favorite part of the movie !

  • LMAO this is so fake holy shit T_______T

    I love how even though it's fake, she still seems to have trouble hitting those notes. It totally adds to the fakeness of this because it's really not that hard ==

    and the note that she struggles to hit on the first time is only an F# lol...

  • this is a phonky messss!!!!!!!!

  • mine too x

  • 0:40 best part. i listened to it 13807561345 times and can only just sing it!

  • iCan sinq this lmfaao:)

  • Dude her voice is so eddited

  • Thats like 10 ppl doing her voice!

  • yeahh it sound a little fake but its wonderful i love this part

    ive been trying to sing this in weeks

    lol

    i lobb hilary duff

    shes amazin wonderful artist

    lobb her 4 ever

  • so fake lol

  • This Is Like My Favorite Part Of The Whole Movie For Some Reason!

  • PERFECTTTTTTTTTTTTTT

  • only from 0:47 until the end is her really singing.. i can tell

  • oh my god i laugh every single time i see this its sooo fake its not even funny. i feel bad for the director who thought he could pull it off

  • @angelcake478 haha it kinda is but i mean its kinda corny lol

  • isnt that the guy from one missed call?

    btw love this movie!!

    <333

  • Actually, after listening to it a few more times, in some parts it does sound like her voice, but the majority of it sounds like her sister Hayley's voice.

  • I've always loved this part, whether it's actually Hilary or not singing. It's never been confirmed otherwise, at least not that I know of.

  • I HAVE THIS MOVIE : D

  • That's not her voice singing.

  • wow that is SO not her singing. since when can hilary duff sing? T_T

  • geweldig gewoooon

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more