Added: 6 months ago
From: cokestudioatmtv
Views: 16,921
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (56)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Disappointing, after watching coke studio Pak version.

  • Who the hell told that Shaan Sings better than Sonu Nigam.After Rafi Sahab there is only sonu who can sing Rafi Sahab's Song..Shaan & Harsheep choose this song it is a great acheivement but don't say that Shaan sings better than Sonu.If anyone have problem just contact with me...

  • chuthiya bna diya lol

  • faking the song

  • mr atisir all muslim brothers have problems with every thing new if u are ill next time dont go to doctor go to muhammad rafi and indian society is not owned by any one every body is free ..........................and will remain free always remember that

  • F....Fabulous, awesome, out of this world!!! HArsdeep is addea new sexyn dimension to this beautiful song!! God bless Shaan.. At least Shaan added his own talent to the already great song, whereas Sonu Nigam murdered this song in his That song really clobbered mercilessly by Sonu Nigam.

    Shaan has beaten Sonu hands down. Congratulations Saan!!!!

  • i respect Shaan as a singer..but 2 b very honest, dis was shit.

  • original is 100 times better...hats off to rafi saabbbb......

    

  • Hats offfff to shaan at 7:00 \m/ Aweeeeeesomeeeeeeeeeee

  • I don't think LL is trying to prove he is better than MM. I have a question for all the critics here. How many of you can sing/compose music half as good as this? It is very easy to criticise someone. I applaud the efforts by the whole CS team. They have done a brilliant job.

  • not such a gud composition dan SIMPLY devin's

    

  • Now I know how a goat feels when it is being butchered.

  • please change the annnnoying harmonium clip at the start of each song ...

  • Definitely sounds like an attempt to a door-esque feel with the keyboards. Sax is good, Guitar riff is pathetic, singers have much more talent than what they're portraying. Still, enjoyable, if not compared to the original.

  • Mohd. Rafi ki aatma ko shaanti mae rehne do...... by NOT singing his songs !!!

  • @atisir ok

    

  • Respond to this video...  i like shaanda performance,great

  • at 6:10 voice of harshdeep broke at high pitch, she is not a good choice for this song..

  • @piyushbjoshi

    what do you mean Harsdep voice "broke"?? YOu dont know jack shit about western music, or jaaz or anything.  Ou dont know music!

  • @reikitube Really? check out 06:10 and tell me if her voice didnt break. Shaan is good in this song, but I hope he doesn't try this again!! Rafi songs are best left to Sonu Nigam.

  • Harshdeep is sexy and fabulous!

  • Coke Studio's Noise...Bakwaas. Shaan has taken so much of liberty, spoiled the entire mood of the song. Harshdeep as she is appearing in a fancy dress competition, weakest link. Wastage of talent of Shaan. I don't know what Lesle Lewis wants to prove. Bad conceived composition. It sucks. This is not fusion this is fission music..everything splitting and flying. My opinion only...Sorry! for getting rude...

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • shaan has really been the showcase in Coke Studio India... Keep it up Shaan .. u simply rock!!

  • Sax is brilliant though.. they need a better bass , guitar player and a drummer .. who play with much more involvements and creative inputs.. maybe Leslie needs to be changed also , India has no dearth of these.. Pak CS has been much superior till this point.. India CS has few very good songs but still a long way to go...

  • Shaan and Harshdeep are brilliant. blown away by this lady.. the arrangement is a nice attempt.. far from appealing . the kbd player is superb but could have avoided a Doors like entry.. guitar player is pretty BAD.playin the same riff whole through the song.. the arrangement has few very delicate moments and this riff just dont fit .. and the song had so much space for chord harmonic improvisation..such a waste .. an avg player just plays, a good player listens. the rest of the bnd is jst okay

  • took much of music.... the song is well sung but the background music doesn't suit... they should change leslie lewis... cost studio pakistan sounds better...

  • Superb!! Shaan's high-octave at 7:00 shows his versatile singing!

  • May b i don't know much of music like you guys.. but am feeling all grooved up after hearing this number. Don't know why you are comparing these classics with their master versions. These are all recreated numbers & has nothing to do with the original. Moreover, its a fusion based show. Guys, don't get confused.

    Shaan... buddy U simply rocked it !!

  • @31anirban I agree! Maybe I don't know as much about music as everyone else that comments, but I actually really enjoyed this! I didn't like a couple of the other recreated songs on this show, but I liked this one a lot.

  • Like it. \m/

  • Why this noise instead of music?

    Was there any need of doing 'murkian' in starting lines?

    Total waste of talents.

  • Looks like I will have to listen to original once again to get rid of bad taste left by this noisy piece !

  • too noisy...nothing like the original..

  • Appalling rhythm on the guitar.. What the fuck ! I don't doubt the singers talent.. But what in earth is with this Bang bang chord pattern.. Can't take it.!

  • Dear CS @ MTV : Plz bring the following songs/ singers in ur nxt season. Piya Haji Ali, Nimbooda Nimbooda,Langa Managaniar- Chirmi,Kesariya Balam, Wadali "s Charkha, Ustad Sultan Khan,Ustad Rashid Khan- Aaoge Jab, Shankar Sahney- Yaar Mangiya si,Satinder Sartaj- sai,Richa's Zindagi mein ,Hans Raj- Sili Sili Aundhi, Pt. Bhimsen Joshi- Maze maher pandhari / Bhairavi, Krishna Beura, Indian Ocean- Bandeh, Hum dil de chuke & Daler mehndi in folk form. Plz consider my rqst.

  • Comment removed

  • where the hell is melody... where the hell is soul of the song... where the hell is beautiful music.... total crap.....

  • what the hack is Leslie Lewis doing... what he has seen in this Guitar... so called guitar... by so loud guitar sounds he has spoiled almost all nice songs... & have spoiled such a nice show...

  • lesle lewis is so terrible.... who the hell gave him the show.... spoiling the reputation of coke studio.

  • ye to bhai bardaasht se bahar ho raha hai....Leslie Lewis....please do not mess up this show and the classics!!!

  • I doubt if the chords are even in the correct scale!

  • Can you please get Amit trivedi for the next season, please please!

  • Both singers need to go and learn some music. Absolutely terrible!

  • @khreedar ...fucking paki

  • @nd8822 You are one lowlife motherfucker. There is nothing Indian or Paki here.

    I was just commenting as a listener but you bring India Pakistan politics in.

    Fucking bitch you are!

  • @khreedar there is nothing wrong with singers dude.... music programming is so so bad.....

  • Cacophony at its best!!

    Sorry guys..but terrible musical arrangement and pathetic production.

    Please don't produce something just for the sake of it.

    Still hoping that you guys can do better than this.

    Thanks!!

  • Please don't spoil such classics

  • ohhhh my god.

    please throw lesle lewis out of coke studio - total fail.

  • horrible!

  • Another classic messed up by our talented Lesle Lewis.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more