Added: 3 years ago
From: chadspacey
Views: 86,272
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (142)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • horrible. stay in your studio. please

  • This is not bad, considering that this is their first live performance and it looks they are nervouse it was really good C:

  • well they, unlike almost every band out there now, obviously don't use pitch correctors when they are live, they are working on talent only

  • I really don't see what people are complaining about. This is a fun live performance from them. Considering it was recorded on a little camcorder, this is f***ing great! I'd love to see them live!

  • I am a huge fan but this was not good and I love her. Maybe stay in the studio and stay away from live stuff

  • this guitarsound.... awesome

  • you can't bash the mix of a live show by listening to a camcorder recording.

  • Jack seems to be completely possessed by his intense artistic passion when he is performing. Not saying that's a bad thing! In fact, that's something money can't buy. (Well, okay it can rent.)

  • what energy shot!!!!

  • Звук - как говно.

  • Comment removed

  • OH Jack.....lolz!

  • GREAT STUDIO BAND, not so good live.

  • @TheJosh1111111111111 completely disagree. i think they bring a totally different feel to their live shows that can't be reproduced in-studio. and their in-studio music is tough to exactly reproduce on-stage. you get an amazing performance either way.

    and yah--the recording isn't the greatest, but they're still an amazing band.

  • Really bad recorder.

    Love this song to pieces, though!

  • I figured they would be using Reason or Mainstage for the entire instrumentation that is involved in their studio cuts...but guess what? They do just as great this way as well! That's the mark of a great artist, but in this case, three on one stage. :-)

  • I wish I could of been there. I love these guys. how fun!

  • Haha, I enjoyed this. If you like pomplamoose, you should check out The Rugg Brothers on youtube

  • Ouch?

  • HI Can you guys do a cover of my song "Penelope Pitstop" ???

  • She is having major pitch issues

  • @ternqwest You are so right. Is she wearing in ear monitors? if so. the mix is just bad for her. These guys are magnificent but not perfect live yet apparently.

  • I love this song. It is becoming one of my favorites. It is impossible for two people to do live, ... Pomplamoose, ... a household word? Definitely!

  • Think of the Beatles performing the Sgt Pepper album live, and I think there songs are more complex than the Beatles . Plus its fun watching Jack do the Riche Havens Woodstock dance.

  • i probably would have walked out on this performance...pretty weak

  • Ouch! They need their protools program live! Need to work on the live show.

  • You guys are giving them so much crap. Why? This is one of their first live shows. Are you forgetting it's just those two? Considering they play everything by themselves, it's hard to do that live. Eventually, i'm sure they'll get some people to help them. Until then, be glad they're making music.

  • what a disapointment...

  • Sitting down to play and sing live? That's...different.

  • They totally remind me of Steely Dan... wonderfully gifted producers of their own music... with more than just a bit of a problem on stage.

    And you know what? That's totally OK. It works for The Dan. It will work for them.

    I just hope they will be around for just as long. That would make for plenty of unique music.

  • @trufiend138 WTF?? If they suck to you sooo much why in the hell do you go out of your way to comment on them and waste your time watching them? FUCK OFF! Go watch what you like and stop bashing on them! They have more fucking talent in their little fingers then you have in your entire body! Jealousy makes people do weird crap!

  • @trufiend138 troll

  • @alexg42288 no troll..im here defending my POV...and they suck shit...

  • @trufiend138 troll

  • S U C K S  SSSSOOOOOOOOOOOOO BAAAAAAAADDDDDDDDD

  • @loatfeild- they could get a harmonizer or more female singers. The multitracking and interesting videos seem to be the biggest appeal. It is hard to hear any song here live. They should try to reinvent the live show like they did with their recordings and videos. Live they aren't doing anythin to distinguish themselves from the pack. would be interesting to see how they improve the live show.

  • Live not so good. Those wonderful soft subtle vocals don't work with all that noise.

  • Looks like Jack spun out a bit there!

  • but also on an artistic level, and home produced Music Will hardly Ever get the same spirit than music created by the meeting of artists and Music pros... That is why pomplamoose should have sign in a label, and why their live performance are so limited

  • but also on an artistic level, and home produced Music Will hardly Ever get the same spirit than music created by the meeting of artists and Music pros... That is why pomplamoose should have sign in a label, and why their live performance are so limited

  • To me, this vidéo is evidence that majors are very important to "internet auto-produced artists", because they help them adapt their songs for live performance (which in this case is not very good...), they can introduce great musicians That can be very efficient to recreate the spirit of a song on stage. Nowadays people tend to Forget that majors have always played a great role in the quality of Music production and performance, not just on a financial point of view, but also on an artistic le

  • @nicky1703 what a tool....producers yes, labels no..they are parasites..

  • Some bands are better as recording artists, I believe they are in this category. Actually all this type of music(indie style) I love it, but I would rather listen to it on a CD than see it live. When I see artists live, I want to see production. it just makes the whole live experience better. You dont just have your ears when its live. You have your eyes too.

    I love pomplamoose though! They are very talented

  • @vocalruss

    That's true but they do have Video Songs do satisfy your eyes as well.

  • Jack is soooooo animated!!!!!!! Fun group all around. I want to see you guys live so bad.

  • I would go see them.They are very talented. Oh and i could look into her eyes for the rest of my life and be content.

  • Those are the UGG's Jacks parents bought her for Christmass!! XD

  • PIMPplamoose!

  • jacks an effing beast!!!

  • i don't understand why everyone is being so negative about this.. it's a live performance, it's not expected to be top of the line. plus, they're back-up vocals that are missing.. well, i loved it! POMPLAMOOSE-OBSESSED.

  • Not so good.

  • As others have said, pretty difficult to reproduce the clean studio quality live with so few people. With that being said, in a live situation Jack needs to "clean up" the guitar sound so there is some substance to the chords. There has to be more than bass, drums, vocals and "noise". I really love the group, though. Gotta retool that "live" sound.

  • hm....was that last bit at the end a reference to the end of the song The Writhing South by Say Anything?

  • absolutely no problems with me as long as they're having fun ^___^

  • Comment removed

  • vcs são angelicais parabens pelo lindo trabalho acompanho vcs faz 2 anos parabens

  • Beats me why Jack sits down to play when he is so hyper.... =)

  • Seems like this isn't in the best key for her voice.

  • wow. they sound much better in the studio.

  • @david510152025303540

    i don't know what the expectation is. sometimes bands just sound better on the CD. The problem is that they're 2 ppl and have a lot of sound on their studio version that they can't make up for live unless they have more ppl.

    I feel like for a live show they should change up the performance so that it doesn't sound empty without other sounds

  • I love the fun vibe of this band, I'd be totally stoked to see them live!

  • It doesn't matter if they're perfect live or not. If you took a strain of DNA from each of them and put it together, they'd still have more talent than all of today's mainstream artists combined.

  • Good live. Good song. Good yalling. I will rate it: PG (for pretty good). I can't hear the bass tho.

  • @ 2:55 he messes up and he and the drummer laugh it off, i think nathaly did to

  • @BloodStoneRaiders nataly*

  • It's all right. For their first live show, with bad sound and only three people.... it still sounds great, really

  • wish I was there :P

  • they're both amazing musicians and singers. i think thtis was pretty good, for not having all the instruments they always use. it felt quite dynamic, even if they were just sitting down.

  • Very different without the female harmonies. Maybe you guys could try some kind of vocal harmonizer effect. You guys rock. Keep working on that live performance.

  • This may be the best live recording I've seen. Soul, talent, smiles and a wife beater shirt.

  • This is amazing, To all people saying that Nathaly is out of tune, please be so kind and shut up. It is common that a singers vocal range goes down at live concerts, at least if they are nervous, and I think Nathaly still does an amazing job.

  • @SubsonicNoise it's not that it's flat - the sound in there clearly sucks and I'm surprised that the recording turned out as good as it did - it's that she is also clearly off key in several places and can't hold the note in others. Seen lots of acts all over the world that simply can't deliver live. I think they're in that camp. Doesn't mean their recorded stuff isn't good or worth listening to. :) Don't think of it as hating on them. It isn't.

    Obviously, YMMV.

  • @iatsd And I did explain why she's off key, which indeed is obvious.

    She even seems a bit shy in the regular videos, so it's possible that she has a bit of stage fright, which can, as I said, influence the vocal range and therefore make it diffcult for her to sing those songs on key. Nothing unusual about this, happened to many musicians before.

  • @iatsd I dare you be on key while sitting next to a bald guy who's clearly on meth ;).

  • like this song a lot alotalotalot

  • jack totally makes the show

  • I actually really love the drum & bass feel they got going on live. If you seen Imogen Heap perform, you'd realize that it COULD be possible for them to perform their music with three people, maybe even one person... but it's definitely not as fun as this. :)

  • Kind of unpolished, but a helluv' a lot better than a lot of live performances

  • This song live reminds me Yes...

  • awsome like always

  • I would bet if you were there it was bad ass

  • Dude i'm not saying this is the best live show ever but it's not bad at all...its just a simple camera recording so there's no mixing or balance vb...I'm sure this would sound better if it was recorded professionally. Well that's just me

  • Studio allows for layering of vocals and instruments. A live session of some of their stuff would require more than 3 people if it were to sound like the album.

  • I love how the camera zooms in to the drummer like, "Who is THIS fellow??" :D

    But uh... who IS that fellow? :)

  • no no I like it..I like the Ugg boots too...

  • Looks like it was fun. Shame I don't live near Frisco.

    Keep it up, Pomlamoose, you've got the music and the fans and the musical know-how to wow people.

  • They were better in studios and I think its their nerves but they will get there!!Still love u and pls work on the LIVE performance,:) its a little off..

  • D0ug... for shame, you loutish so&so...!

  • Eeek, Nataly! I'm sure it's just nerves and a new environment, but you're singing pretty out of tune...

    Props to pomplamoose's recordings, but live needs some work.

  • Too right, they spend thier whole time in studio fixing and perfecting, and it will take time to do that outside the studio

  • They are doin it PERFECT cuz they are bein them. If they were doin it the way it "should be" then it would be bad. They had fun, and they were unique.....so.....(^_^)-b to Nataly and Jack!

  • @relyts1990 (^_^)-b

  • this is on a camcorder, the sound is obviously going to suck.

  • I love them but they suck live..

  • Agreed, but very few bands are good their first show.

  • This is NOT how I would have expected it to go. I hope they've fixed their balance issues. Nataly's mic needs to be turned the fuck UP.

    I'm not sure how I feel about this... hmmm...

  • i looked up "crazy" in the dicitionary. it said: "describing a behaviour similar to Jack Conte on stage"

  • This is actually a lot better than I was expecting. I love Pomplamoose, and this tune in particular (it's on my official Pomplamoose thumb drive right now) but I wasn't convinced it would work live. I can't wait to see the rest of the show!

  • geez! Don't getchur panties all in a wad! Haha, everyone knows that Jack and Nataly are wonderful! And this is clever and cute. I'm happy with it. I wish I could have been there.

  • jack is crazy....what energy lol

  • Love this song..

  • "nice to see that jack dressed up for the occasion"

    QFT

  • if you guys need a keyboardist... sign me up...

  • I would travel lihyears to see this.

  • how can you call that terrible? they're having so much fun up there

  • Don't worry SH, I truly appreciate their (off-stage) musicality and it makes me smile they can have fun on stage, but from a sound,audio&performance perspective (professionaly speaking), it is really bad :) I luv them nonetheless.

  • they were probably incredible in person (reflected by all the cheers and applause). you have to consider what type of recording equipment is being used.

  • Well this wasn't a professionally recorded show, and they were only three people.

  • They don't use auto-tune.

  • They don't use autotune, because they don't suck. I too, am one of those guys whom are critical of bad use of autotune, such as (c)rappers.

    However, the actual reason her voice sounds (barely) off tune, is because in videosongs, they don't play multiple instruments at once. Here, shes singing, AND playing bass.

    If you're gonna be pissy about autotune, take it out on a band that actually uses it.

    Oh, and they only used a digital effect in the original song 'cause it sounded good there.

    Jeezus.

  • Altercations on a false-positive:

    1. If you're a hater, looking for a detester(to subvert), sorry to disappoint you.

    2. Is the pot calling the kettle black? lol

    I only wish you feel better now for venting your vitriol about auto-tune (&its supposed proper implementation or prerequisite),rappers, sound designers/engineers' professional opinions (who are actual fans).

    I cannot say I found your diatribe insightful, but It does convey conviction.

  • Wait, what?

  • those guys who* are critical

  • this band is awesome

    ithink they're meking new and different music

    sorry for my bad english

    greetz from germany!

    i <3 pomplamoose

  • i may have just shit.

  • nice to see that jack dressed up for the occasion

  • haha!

  • Very nice, . I was mildly surprised by how well the performance went considering the lack the different sounds compared to the original track. The beginning of this song reminds me a little of arcade fire No Cars Go ... at least the live version.

  • dude... who is the drummer? that guy is going offff

  • It's Louis Cole. He toured with Jack Conte.

  • Oh man Jack was awesome and so was the rest of the performance.

  • This performance just makes me smile.

  • I wanna go see them!

  • WEEEEEY! Brilliant! :D

  • YAY!

  • i love how they didnt just get a keyboard player, they SANG the organ part :P

  • I like rythm to this song

  • hahaha, the begining is the best!!!

  • if only i werent 25 hours away!

  • Yay! Love 'em.

  • hehehehehe!

    They ae soooooo damn funny!

    that was awesome!

  • awesome :)

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more