And All That Could Have Been-Cloud/Tifa

[flom54321]

"please stay quiet in my memories"

good stuff

[JoshKoen]

Beautiful

[molo252]

I love Nine Inch Nails, Trent Reznor is a genius. Loved the vid, great song.

[=

[ienjoyopium]

I hate anime, but I love NIN.

[rainelinden]

I really like this, and I think you did a good job. The song goes really well with the clips you chose and the editing. The subtitles make it a bit clunky at times, but there are also times when they make the video more emotional. 5/5. The haters can bugger off!

[samfukunishi]

The song is great... Couldnt think of a better song to put to final fantasy which has such dramatic graphics...however...you murdered it! What the hell is with the subtitles? Nothing was in time, it seemed like it was just a whole bunch of images. Sorry to be harsh but seriously, i mean it has a lot of potential but it deserves to be put together by somebody with more skill. Nothing personal, but edit your work before you put it up.

[InsipidNight]

I apologize. But I downloaded this movie when it first came out, so the subtitles stayed. Plus, I didn't have Sony Vegas at the time and Windows Movie Maker is incapable of doing anything except transitions and freezing my computer.

[samfukunishi]

lol i hear that. if thats the case then you're excused.

[samfukunishi]

actually no - if you know you didnt make it well then dont post it.

[drakenhoff]

Dude I think he meant he downloaded the whole of advent children THEN made this video

[samfukunishi]

"Windows Movie Maker is incapable of doing anything except transitions and freezing my computer."

[Gutmann795]

I really like this video and every time I hear this song I think of this video. I've watched it so much that I think it became a part of my dream. The subtitles to me add depth to the meaning of the song placed with this movie.

[hansaru]

@InsipidNight I know EXACTLY how you feel about Movie Maker. Sony Vegas FTW!!

[HARRYET23]

a truely beutifull song

the video goes really well with it and the subtitles make it more vivid

i love this :)

[dude018219293]

great song

depressing, sadening, chilling, but either way makes you want to rise against those feelings or fall to them, and wonder what happens after you fall to them........

and im unfamilliar to what the video is, is it a tv show or a videogame?

[Seth6071]

movie, check it out final fantasy advent child

[ZombieSlaver]

Wonderful video, although why are there subtitles? Even if you had the Japenese version of AC, you could still turn them off...but still, fantastic job! <3

[InsipidNight]

Yeah, but I downloaded it when it first came out...so the subtitles stayed. XD

[ZombieSlaver]

Ah, I see. Okay.

[ValiumandDolls]

I think the subtitles add a very poetic installment to the music/film. It works in various places very well together.

[InsipidNight]

You're the first person who's said that! 8]

[LilWhiteBunnyRabbit]

really well done... great song choice too

[SAladin888]

The whole "Still" CD is awesome. "Adrift and at Peace" and "Leaving Hope" are just class. I wish I could find more music like this.

[Karola801]

When I've first listen to it about five years ago I thaught that I've never heard anything as beautifull as this.And that's what we're here for! To discover the beauty of the world.Thank you Trent.

[Karola801]

A true masterpiece!Love it!(The song ofcourse)

[theotherfarley]

This song was released on the Deluxe Edition of And Of That Could Of Been CD. It's a rare track to find, but a great song.

[ryuho14]

Great video it was really wel done. but i have a question, where do you get this song? When was it released?

[DEadJACK4090]

="( loved it omg some 1 give me a tissue

[party2death]

omggg luv it :)

[ahmedhammam]

Awesome song

[XOnederXCam]

Yo I really liked the video and the movie make it completely changed the story of advent children and made it into a love drama kind of thing. lol. It was all good though. propz son.

[HeadphoneHalo]

The movie sucked a lot, but the choice of song is awesome.

[DEadJACK4090]

you've really created a great wee tragic love story here 5 stars exellent

[InsipidNight]

Thank you! 8D I'm glad you liked ittt! ^_^

[greyishblue666]

Dude, I TOTALLY GET THIS! I like how it linked up with her touching him when Trent said: "I know you tried to rescue me". Very moving. Good job :)

[InsipidNight]

YAY! I'm glad you caught that!! ^_^

[Xenogias044]

I can't help but wonder all the things you tried to get across with this video. Cause I saw another version a few minutes ago of an AC AMV using the same song, anyways I think I understand, and its great, though if its better than the other one I saw, I can't say, I liked them both.

[meow777777777]

i love this song one of nine inch nails best great video!

[salomon999]

Oh god that was horrible.

Fanboys and girls are the cancer killing FF7

[mamacue]

HAHA, that was great

[voodoochild127]

this song is amazing both sound-wise and lyrically

[reiko12]

Even If the music isn't that clear enough, I like it! The meaning is something so special actually...

[cyberculprit]

Have you seen this yet victoria

[Maaikiepaaikie]

Lol, Maaike is watching right now!!!

very nice clip too!!!!!

love, Vic aka Maaike

[cyberculprit]

Have you seen this yet victoria

[envirovore]

great video for an amazing song.

[cephjiwu]

This video has enhanced the song... so it has done a great duty. Cheers for adding it so I had the privilige of watching it!

Matt

[spygirly]

This is a brilliant,PERFECT video.Being an already die-hard fan of CloTi,this has just made me like the couple even more than ever.You did an awesome job ^^ 5 stars for you!WOOHOO!!!*waves the CloTi flag proudly*

[Magratheazaphod]

I can't even watch the video yet because I haven't seen the movie. I just love the song, and the few glimpses I've gotten

[sahrabaloch]

This is a very nice Video, why always Cloti's or Clerith's. I'm neither a Cloti or a Clerith! Yes....That's right, this rumour should spread.....i'm a half a Clan(Cloud and Fran{FF12}) and half Clashe(Cloud and Ashe{FF12}). Awesome or what? Aerith went with Zack happily ever after, When did Tifa ever help in AC? apart from give him a lecture? and throw him to the sky:(

[DanteSephiroth]

Amazing.Great job.

[completelygorgeous]

i cried to this

[InsipidNight]

Wow! I'm flattered...8]

[9224935]

I love this song, and the video compliments it greatly!, 5 stars and a fav

[duckophile]

And once again, I come back to watch this awesome video.

[InsipidNight]

Thank you so much! I believe you were my first commenter on this video too! ^_^

[duckophile]

Yep! What am I doing?! I should totally subscribe!

[butseckser]

bf.c ot ftw

[Poijka]

Just awsome!

[nightbryan]

love Cloti.

[adamxxvii]

.......in my nothing, you meant everything to me.....

[Adrian7462]

In my opinion this is the best NIN song trent ever wrote

[Gutmann795]

I couldn't agree with you more.

(& i've heard and listened to quite a few of trent's songs)

[RedEyedMoody]

This is my favourite NIN song.

[Adrian7462]

FUCKING ACE

[slackpakas]

dope!

[PrincessGarnet16]

I LOVE IT! CHECK OUT MY HIT VIDEO lol

that i its caled

Cloud,could you ever love tifa that way

[vicariouspunishment]

Amazing... the last line that tifa says is pure and beautiful.

[1theFRAgILe1]

wow like my favorite NIN song

[hathor98]

I have to say, I loved this video. Wow, good job. The song fit the mood perfectly, good choice. I am an Aeris/Cloud fangirl myself. But watching a good vid like this give me an appreciation for Tifa.

[xXxJordanloverxXx]

retard

[squeebor]

I concur.

[nineinchneos]

Great job! Excellent video!

[SorakoAi]

Woooooow. . . . this gave me the shivers. . . .

[Nydiwiel]

This was really cool, sent chills down my spine. Even tough I have a different opinion about who would have been that everything, but this worked only because it was those two. This was really good, I mean really good. The subtext's were a bit annoying. But still, just awesome, Bravo :)

[KittyHex]

This is so very well done and one of my most favorite Nin songs too.

Watching this makes a lump appear in my throat.

I like how you put in the subtitles and all the best bits of this movie.

You did a great job. ;3

[Gutmann795]

I love how the subtitles tell part of a story, or the story for that matter. Such a perfect combination of audio and video <3333333

[InsipidNight]

Haha, I didn't mean for that to happen, but I'm glad it worked out anyway! 8D

[rinoawings]

it's so good! Al your videos are excellent!

[pugnaxacies]

Wow! This is such an amazing video and you couldn't have picked a better song to put it to! Great Job!

[Gutmann795]

One of my favorite things to do in life is listen to this song and watch this video. simply great job.

:)

[Gridlok88]

take of subtitles

[aquasixio]

This was one of the best amv's I've ever seen! The song fit so perfectly XD *watches it 20 more times*

[InsipidNight]

Thank you! I'm glad you liked it! 8]

[mischa12]

tifa i meanwhen there sitiing on the bed,the bike, the church,when she's attacked all those looks a ''friend'' would give you

[mischa12]

well have you seen all the looks he gives her in the movie,little sly looks so obvious he's into her.

[InsipidNight]

I don't know which "her" you're refering to...

[winnryautomail]

Awesome video. I also make NIN/Anime videos. Take a look @ my Kingdom hearts one. Really really love this video.

[animeluver7793]

ohmigosh i loved this i'm barly learnin about the whole tifa and cloud thingy but i like them i think cloud should be wit her

[InsipidNight]

Yaay! I'm glad you like Cloud/Tifa now! heheh

[bluebirdie252]

awesome song

[BoAandFFXluver]

yea awesome vid i luv playing the game too

[nsza]

CLOUD AND TIFA-CLOUD AND TIFA-CLOUD AND TIFA!!!!!

[InsipidNight]

Yaaay! *waves CloTi flag* Go Cloud and Tifa! I'm glad you liked the video..^_^

[nsza]

hey,did cloud really like tifa in the end?

[TifaClyne]

Cloud x Tifa 4evah *_*·

[InsipidNight]

Right on! ^_^

[Kukiee]

aeris and cloud <3

[azmina]

Hey, i like it... Aeris was not his girlfriend ryte? Aeris was zack's girlfriend, ryte ryte?? Ermm... Tifa was cloud's ex-girlfriend (not really his girlfriend, just a close friend) but then cloud met aeris and kindda like her.. True? But aeris was just one of his supportive friends... Hey, i'm a big fan ya know.. Hehhehe...

[InsipidNight]

Er...the details are a bit long to type it in. Haha...perhaps you should just google it...O_o

[aquasixio]

Such an awesome video! It went great with the music! Wonderful, wonderful job!

[InsipidNight]

Thanks muchlyyy ^_^

[InsipidNight]

Hahah thank you!

[xxxxboysdontcry]

Honestly brought a tear to my eye. Excellent combination of NIN with AC. Absoloutely awesome. Friggen loved it.

<3

[InsipidNight]

Oh, thank you!!! ^_^ I'm so glad you liked it ! 

[azndragongod]

i still think the main couple is cloud and aeris!! tifa is too tomboyish.

[InsipidNight]

To each his own. 8]

[YukiKun92]

Thats a very touching video I love the couple very much!

[InsipidNight]

Thanks! I'm glad you liked it

[duckophile]

Wow, that was really touching. I liked how you added more Tifa flashes to what's most important to him. I love Cloud and Tifa to death. <3 I think after AC they deserve happiness together, since Cloud moved on from Zack, Aeris, Sephiroth, etc... he's ready to continue  the life he started with Tifa. :D

Anyways, sorta emo, but I loved ittt.

[InsipidNight]

Thanks!