@realthin3 The reason why alot of hmong does not go back to china is because of the communist that push the hmong down to lao, The hmong fought the chinese for about 100 years They shed blood sweats and tears. lost love one. In Laos the hmong were nobody live up in the mountain peacefully and worried free. They would rather remember the good times then the bad. I Studied hmong history so if there's any other things you need to know im here bro. i hope that answer your question though.
thankx. but in china that over 100 of year ago, look now hmong in laos they don't wat to live there any more they been try to fine a way out to thai n to the thir country usa. it look like now in china hmong people r more free than in laos. n i think laos is a bad place for hmong cus i been hear hmong kill hmong alot of time there. plus we look more chinese n china is where our older came from.
Yeah you are right. The hmong would rather come over to the US because here the hmong are someone, and since the chinese are more civilize now so communist or somewhat over thrown by the goverment. but we do look alot like the chinese because we are chinese and i have a lot of respect for our ancestors. You are right too that lao is a bad place for us hmongs. well nice talking to you and you take care my brother.
Yes Hmong are not Han Hmong are Hmong not chinese han this one hmong person kept arguing with me telling me oh hmong is chinese I said no hmong is hmong and chinese is chinese. We are not Han. He even said dude do you know what is chinese. I said yes I sure do Im pretty sure I know what the difference is and what it is to be chinese, Do you know what Being hmong is? He didn't replied back to me lol ahah type in hmong china travel it will pop up lol
Maybe he was talking Nationality wise. Nationality wise, you are of whatever citizenship or host country you live in. However, you still are Hmong by ethnic identity as long as you still: a.) speak your language b.) wear your clothes and c.) keep the traditions.
You see, that right there is what makes Hmong, Hmong. But, not for long though. See, Hmong survived as long as we did because we refused to bow down. Nationality wise, you are Chinese because you have no other country. However, Hmong will insist they are not, especially Hmong that moved to SE Asia. Hmong in Laos are the "raw" Hmong that never accepted imperial rule.
But this will die off quickly with the new generation that can't even speak Hmong anymore...
@hmonguru What do you mean not for long, it's been a while now and we are still just Hmong never was Chinese. Of course Hmong would never bow down we are Hmong and remain Hmong, were not Hmong and then claim that were something else that's just a disgrace being ashamed of what you are and claim other race. That's like calling a Samoan a black person, they aren't black they are Pacific Islanders.
I mean that Hmong is going extinct if things don't change drastically. Hmong are assimilating to their host cultures and most of the younger folks today don't even know how to speak properly, let alone know about their history or culture. By the end of this century, it's likely to be extinct if things don't change.
@hmonguru That is true that most younger folks here are forgetting their cultures, but that is wrong for one point. It is wrong because the younger ones lack discipline no one is out there to teach these youngers or be commited to teaching them developing and help them learn our culture traditions. If there isn't anyone commited to teach us youngers of course we wouldn't know if we didn't go school to learn english we wouldn't know how to read or speak english. Hmong will live on.
Yes, that's true. And that's my point. Hmong culture is family oriented and is taught from parent to child and family to child. If the family system breaks down and the parents don't teach the children, then guess what? The culture dies. That's exactly what's happening. Hmong in a clinical environment doesn't work, because Hmong is a living culture. You can only apply what you learn if you live it. You can't learn it from a book.
@hmonguru Family system breaks down? No your looking at it wrong doesn't matter if the family breaks down or not if the father or mother is committed to teaching them about our traditions they would I've seen many family that has break down problems, they still know the tradition. My uncle pass away before my cousin was born, now my cousin know how to hit the drum and all other tradition. just because family break down doesn't mean you can't learn, that's just ignorant thinking that way.
@hmonguru Books? Of course we can write it down in books and able to teach younger generations from the book people who think it's a waste of time reading from book or writing down from book doesn't work, how can I say this (lazy). We were all able to educate ourselves here in America and learn most of their traditions. Most of their traditions we didn't learn it from books like Christmas, but then we still celebrated it right? or Thanksgiving like what we just had.
Im so happy to find out that this hmong man still speaks and have the same accent as us hmong in the united states if i ever do visit china i need to chat wit this guy since so far all the videos i seen I cant understand the other hmong chinese but except this man im so happy
Miao has 3 big dialects in China, Eastern Middle, and Western, all hmong languages white hmong, and green hmong etc are sub dialects of the western dialect of Miao. So yes white hmong is part of western dialect, but so is green hmong. Did I make sense?
tis good to know that there are still Hmong who speak the white dialect in China. I was begining to think that this dialect only exist outside of China.
awesome.. [=
ChillXionger 1 year ago
Aww...should have let him talk on. Wanted to hear.
Rymaaaa 1 year ago
This is a real Hmong man. He speaks western Hmong Dialect and play the Ncas the way Hmong westerners play.
jeffxeemwang 1 year ago
i don't know why hmong people still want to go to laos whan we can go back to our real country in china.
realthin3 2 years ago
@realthin3 The reason why alot of hmong does not go back to china is because of the communist that push the hmong down to lao, The hmong fought the chinese for about 100 years They shed blood sweats and tears. lost love one. In Laos the hmong were nobody live up in the mountain peacefully and worried free. They would rather remember the good times then the bad. I Studied hmong history so if there's any other things you need to know im here bro. i hope that answer your question though.
asianmanMLK 2 years ago
thankx. but in china that over 100 of year ago, look now hmong in laos they don't wat to live there any more they been try to fine a way out to thai n to the thir country usa. it look like now in china hmong people r more free than in laos. n i think laos is a bad place for hmong cus i been hear hmong kill hmong alot of time there. plus we look more chinese n china is where our older came from.
realthin3 2 years ago
Yeah you are right. The hmong would rather come over to the US because here the hmong are someone, and since the chinese are more civilize now so communist or somewhat over thrown by the goverment. but we do look alot like the chinese because we are chinese and i have a lot of respect for our ancestors. You are right too that lao is a bad place for us hmongs. well nice talking to you and you take care my brother.
asianmanMLK 2 years ago
Actually Chinese are Han. Hmong are Hmong-Mong,Miao,etc...
But stay rooted... :)
neverforever1984 2 years ago
Thanks for the corredtion sister. I appreciated it.
asianmanMLK 2 years ago
sure-no prob.
neverforever1984 1 year ago
@neverforever1984
Yes Hmong are not Han Hmong are Hmong not chinese han this one hmong person kept arguing with me telling me oh hmong is chinese I said no hmong is hmong and chinese is chinese. We are not Han. He even said dude do you know what is chinese. I said yes I sure do Im pretty sure I know what the difference is and what it is to be chinese, Do you know what Being hmong is? He didn't replied back to me lol ahah type in hmong china travel it will pop up lol
kevinhawj13 1 year ago
@kevinhawj13
Maybe he was talking Nationality wise. Nationality wise, you are of whatever citizenship or host country you live in. However, you still are Hmong by ethnic identity as long as you still: a.) speak your language b.) wear your clothes and c.) keep the traditions.
hmonguru 1 year ago
@hmonguru No way Hmong is never considered to be Chinese we are different. Even if we did live in China that doesn't mean were Chinese.
kevinhawj13 1 year ago
@kevinhawj13
You see, that right there is what makes Hmong, Hmong. But, not for long though. See, Hmong survived as long as we did because we refused to bow down. Nationality wise, you are Chinese because you have no other country. However, Hmong will insist they are not, especially Hmong that moved to SE Asia. Hmong in Laos are the "raw" Hmong that never accepted imperial rule.
But this will die off quickly with the new generation that can't even speak Hmong anymore...
hmonguru 1 year ago
@hmonguru What do you mean not for long, it's been a while now and we are still just Hmong never was Chinese. Of course Hmong would never bow down we are Hmong and remain Hmong, were not Hmong and then claim that were something else that's just a disgrace being ashamed of what you are and claim other race. That's like calling a Samoan a black person, they aren't black they are Pacific Islanders.
kevinhawj13 1 year ago
@kevinhawj13
I mean that Hmong is going extinct if things don't change drastically. Hmong are assimilating to their host cultures and most of the younger folks today don't even know how to speak properly, let alone know about their history or culture. By the end of this century, it's likely to be extinct if things don't change.
hmonguru 1 year ago
@hmonguru That is true that most younger folks here are forgetting their cultures, but that is wrong for one point. It is wrong because the younger ones lack discipline no one is out there to teach these youngers or be commited to teaching them developing and help them learn our culture traditions. If there isn't anyone commited to teach us youngers of course we wouldn't know if we didn't go school to learn english we wouldn't know how to read or speak english. Hmong will live on.
kevinhawj13 1 year ago
@kevinhawj13
Yes, that's true. And that's my point. Hmong culture is family oriented and is taught from parent to child and family to child. If the family system breaks down and the parents don't teach the children, then guess what? The culture dies. That's exactly what's happening. Hmong in a clinical environment doesn't work, because Hmong is a living culture. You can only apply what you learn if you live it. You can't learn it from a book.
hmonguru 1 year ago
@hmonguru Family system breaks down? No your looking at it wrong doesn't matter if the family breaks down or not if the father or mother is committed to teaching them about our traditions they would I've seen many family that has break down problems, they still know the tradition. My uncle pass away before my cousin was born, now my cousin know how to hit the drum and all other tradition. just because family break down doesn't mean you can't learn, that's just ignorant thinking that way.
kevinhawj13 1 year ago
@hmonguru Books? Of course we can write it down in books and able to teach younger generations from the book people who think it's a waste of time reading from book or writing down from book doesn't work, how can I say this (lazy). We were all able to educate ourselves here in America and learn most of their traditions. Most of their traditions we didn't learn it from books like Christmas, but then we still celebrated it right? or Thanksgiving like what we just had.
kevinhawj13 1 year ago
Im so happy to find out that this hmong man still speaks and have the same accent as us hmong in the united states if i ever do visit china i need to chat wit this guy since so far all the videos i seen I cant understand the other hmong chinese but except this man im so happy
kevinhawj13 2 years ago 2
because you don't speak the eastern dialect... you speak the western dialect
129815 2 years ago
oh for real? well im white is the one in western dialect white? if so thats cool i never really knew
kevinhawj13 2 years ago
did a little research on the language... i guess it could be
129815 2 years ago
Miao has 3 big dialects in China, Eastern Middle, and Western, all hmong languages white hmong, and green hmong etc are sub dialects of the western dialect of Miao. So yes white hmong is part of western dialect, but so is green hmong. Did I make sense?
tsimmeejLi 2 years ago
yeah makes sense to me now thank you. Its great to know about our language dialect. Im hoping to go to china not hoping. WANTING!!
kevinhawj13 2 years ago
wat a way to waste dat dudes time. no sound but some crickets in the backgroud
pimps11 2 years ago
Nice! were did you guys get these movies from? Give me connections!!
KillerXify 2 years ago
next time bring a mic you silly billy goat
peechue 2 years ago
That was pretty loud!
phbakx 2 years ago
i cant hear anything he's making.....
GreyGooseVodka555 3 years ago
tis good to know that there are still Hmong who speak the white dialect in China. I was begining to think that this dialect only exist outside of China.
HmongChaoFa 3 years ago 2
There are still White Hmong living in China. I used to think White Hmong came into existant after the Hmong migrated out of China, but I was wrong.
niamtxiv 2 years ago
wow, white hmong from guangxi, pretty cool.
yajboi303 3 years ago
wow..when was this taken?
mandead10 3 years ago
September 2008
tsimmeejLi 3 years ago
tahts cool...u took them?
mandead10 3 years ago
yog ua tau kuv yuav thod xaav lug nrug koj nyob ti ko. Npaaj nrav ib txuj deb num rua kuv, yuav lug sai sai tom ntej nuad os. :)
Thod koj yees peb moob cov tsoos rig tsho moob xaws tawm ntawd teg lug tsho tuaj peb tau saib! Yog yees tau dluab, xaa xus rua kuv. Muaj sab ua koj tsaug. Xaa dluab zoo tuaj rua kuv kawm quav os.
ENVY YOU!
naaglugyaaj 3 years ago