Added: 1 year ago
From: citioflights
Views: 11,551
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (17)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I always liked the Jess Roden (Band) version. What has happened to him?

  • lyric¡¡¡

  • Baby, take off your dress ..,. Yes, YES, YES. But I left my hat on ... the ultimate slow-motion, striptease-him-until-he-scream­s. And, yeah, I gave him reason to live.

  • Joe Cocker turned this into a big flashy wall of sound song-and-dance number. It sounds OK, but this version is how I think it should be played - it's supposed to sound like it's one man, one bottle of whiskey and one woman. He's singing it to the woman, not the stadium, and that makes this a beautiful, intimate song instead of a raspy voice shouting it to the world.

  • @MrRastaVibrations i agree cept randy looks liek a bit of a goober :) in the nicest possible way

  • This version is so much more ironic, which is totally lost in the Joe Cocker version! The way Randy sings it  is hilarious! Joe is a great singer but he can't pull off the irony intended here!

  • God, he sounds as boring as he does on Family Guy, and this is not some teenager. I am a 70s/80s child yet Randy's voice is annoying.  I prefer Joe's version. Randy should stick to composing.

  • @cjs33139 You know what's annoying?It's people who focus on the irrelevant,like his voice{Dylan's and Lennon's are so great},and not the writing.Keep watching American Idol and Family Guy.You're truly in Who Gives a Shit What You Say territory.

  • Much better than Cats, I'd listen again and again! :)

  • Awwww, thanks post person!!

  • really lame imagery, but a great song

  • Thanks citioflights. Job well done. You know what love is. Just discovered Etta James' version of this a moment ago, which is bad ass, but Randy's is still my favorite. Randy Newman's original is the most adult version of a very adult song. Cocker's version is lightweight fluff by comparison.

  • It seems that the only thing Joe Cocker did with the song was replacing the piano by brass instruments....It's Newman who should be known for the song, not Cocker

  • I do love this song. Thanks Randy for writing it.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more