Added: 3 years ago
From: WickedofEden
Views: 32,039
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (238)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Went to school with this lass. You knew she was good but crikey!!! Thats amazing.. Last time I seen her she was doing her acting school and checking my groceries. It's a dman good story her life.

  • jemma rix is better

  • @TheSeanCrawl totally

  • Amanda Harrison is phenomenal. she is definitly right after Idina Menzel.

  • Amanda is one of the best singers ever. Great voice. Great Elphaba. :)

  • Love Amanda's voice.

  • This was utterly amazing! I love her voice! But, I don't want to judge her on voice alone. There is more to musical theartre than just voice. I am sure she is nothing short of brilliant, but she did a couple of expressions that bothered me. I am not big on comparing, so I won't. I just want to see more.

  • @Sasoriscarecrow I saw Amanda play Elphaba twice and she was phenomenal :) Very talented

  • haven't heard anyone sing so well before! She's the best Elphaba for sure by a LONG SHOT. She has a full voice, pace, amazing control and feel of the song.

    I've see other Elphaba's just shout this song.

  • En Fuego!!!!

  • She is one Elphaba after Idina Menzel who could make me shiver. Really good one. Idina is the best, but she is damn close to Idina :)

  • I'm not denying Amanda is not great... or was great... she definitely was not the same after melbourne when Wicked came to Sydney.

    But lots of people say she has a technically great voice... but if she did, she would not have developed vocal nodules by belting her face off.

  • why is it that all of the girls who play Elphaba a girl who is supposed to be ugly are all sexy

  • Amanda: Amazing stage presence and great quality actress/singer

    Patrice: Little powerhouse. Strong and amazing voice and good actress.

    Jemma: A good mix of both above

    My point is, they are all amazing, but each in their own way.

  • I was fortunate enough to see Amanda play Elphaba last year in sydney, and I gotta say she was absolutely brilliant. There is something about her... She's Elphaba through and through. It's terrible she had to stop.

  • such a technically brilliant voice. and an AMAZING stage presence!

  • Jemma is sooooooo Much BETTER!!!

  • @scottywrong21 Ive seen both and actually, Amanda is better by far. Especially when you hear them in the theatre - youtube is heaps different.

  • amanda harrison should play elphaba in the wicked movie!

  • She's incredible!!!

  • she is a good elphaba but i like idina menzel more. :) <3

  • @kewlmusicbabe73 Well no one can really beat her lol

  • @aussyangel this is true. ahaha.

  • She's so good... Which production was she in? Because if she's British, she's AMAZING at having an American accent! ;)

  • @broadwayluvr33 She was in the Australian company...she had to stop because she had a lot of throat and vocal issues while in......

  • really nice voice but wish she had more grit its to nice for me

  • hehe...she has funny teeth

    lol

    She's got a lovely voice and very good characterization.

  • her acting is forced and contrived. it kinda takes away from the performance.

  • It seems forced and contrived because she's performing this song the way she would in the show. Acting is much more exaggerated in the theatre than it is in TV/film; it has to be so that the audience can actually see and understand what's going on on stage. When translated to other media it seems over-the-top. That's why.

  • amanda harrison is pretty good. but jemma rix will always be my favourite elphie :)

  • I completely agree. I loved Jemma Rix's performance.

  • @snowangel21111 she came back too the musical recently.

  • No she didn't... Her last show was like mid October

  • I wish Amanda would come back to perform... I know that Jemma Rix is amazing too, but... Amanda is always going to be my favorite. I'd love to see her in the show again. After all, she was my first Elphaba and part of the reason I fell in love with the musical ^^

  • Amanda was absent for the last few months of the Melbourne season as she was having surgery on her throat.

  • I think all of us Wicked fans agree that Idina is incredible and mean no disrespect when we say that Amanda Harrison is better ... but ... Amanda Harrison is better. I didn't think anyone could be better, but she is. My goodness, what a voice!!!!!

  • I remember when I first saw Wicked with Amanda and heard her singing, I thought it was an absolute priveledge to be sitting in the audience listening to her.

  • oh. my. gosh. Amanda is amazing!!! I was speechless! =]

  • Saw wicked sat night with Jemma as Elphaba, she's very good but no-one beats amanda, I have seen her perform twice and she was utterly sublime. Wicked is the best musical ever!

  • I think that Amanda should try and get on Broadway like Kerry did, because I think she has the most convincing American accent out of the two of them, since the Aussie cast made it standard for all of them to have one.

  • definately the best elphaba!!

    i saw this show a week ago

    AMAZING!!

  • she's so awesome :)

  • OMG she is brilliant what a voice!! I watched it last friday but she wasnt there but the understudy Jenna Rix was also brilliant....I wanna watch it again!! =)

    LUV WICKED AUSTRALIA!!

  • AYE!

    I want an Australian Cast Recording sooooooo baaaad.

    Bloody Amazing! Amanda - I LOVE YOU!!

  • AMAZING!!! Best Elphaba since Idina! Did you see she didn't take a breath in between "with me" and "and I'll stand there with the wizard"? BRAVO!!!

  • she's great but idena is still the best ever!

  • her mum is my old office lady at school and she went to the same school at me.

    :)

  • Oh my god, I wanna fly to Sydney right now! That was amazing!

  • when are we getting an Australian Cast Recording of Wicked Dammit!?

  • If you think this chick is good, see carrie manolakos shes FUCKING amazing, the BEST elphaba

  • WHAT ABOUT IDENA!

  • r u for real! She holds no candal to so many elphaba's

  • amazing!

  • Best Elphaba ever, agreed?

  • Best Elphaba EVER. Agreed!

  • SO, amazing, so much better in the actual show, but she is truly incredible,! And such a dork, at the end with the arm swing and the beg stupid grin. She's like "hey they like me! that's so cool"

  • She is such a good Elphaba her and Kerry Elis are the best ones, When i saw Amanda in wicked her voice was so strong the other times i went i only got the under study she was rely good to but Amanda wow she's amazing.

  • She just does it so effortless... Amazing

  • i saw her in may, her voice cracked in defying gravity but she was amazing.

  • she is soooooooooooooooooooooo amazing!!! she holds those notes out so good!

  • Wow do they always use an american accent in the australian Wicked? or is that just amanda?

  • They all use the accent (As in the entire cast & all that play Elphaba)

  • i like this, but jemma rix's interpretation better.

  • Holy Crap!!!!

    Thats incredible!!!!

  • she sings this song so well!!

    truely and amazing performer!!

    she is an excellent elphie!!

    :)

  • amazing

    Love Amanda, she is the best elphaba, way better than all of the others

  • That is a stupid bias comment. She is not better than anyone else, just different, with different strengths and weaknesses. Please, think before you post such close minded comments.

  • she is one of my favorite elphabas, her voice is so pure and beautiful

  • i love her voice. i love idina as elphie but you can just hear that her voice is about to explode out of the throat whereas amanda just pumps out the high notes with ease. shes awesome. got tickets to th last show and am rediculously excited.

  • Amazing :)

  • She is AMAZING!

  • She's a great Elphaba.

  • She's great because even though she has to sing in an American voice, she also sort of australianises it with her gestures. That helps to make her unique

  • OMG i was just about to post the same thing!!!

  • she leaves all the rest for dead/ i have the origanal cast soundtrack and she sings way better than idina. my mum got me surprise tickets to see it in melbourne, and i really hope i get to meet her and lucy :D. shes deffinatly the BEST elphaba, no questions

  • i went to melbourne twice and i met rob mills.

    he was awesome.

  • great stuff amanda!! well done

  • When she 1st sang this song, I was completely shocked and amazed! Once she performed Defying Gravity, I was completely speechless! Too bad I only saw her during Act 1. Jemma replaced her in Act 2.

  • I think I was there too! :):)

  • isaw amanda on easter saturday

    she was great

    best elphaba

  • amazing

  • best elphaba ever! leaves all the rest for dead!

  • @Jarren987654321 Exept for Idena 

  • @Jarren987654321 shes good but not as good as jemma rix

  • @Jarren987654321 Apart from Rachel Tucker. :-)

  • I saw Amanda at both the Friday and Sunday night shows last night and she was fantastic!!!

  • cool! :) amanda's awesome!

  • she and teal are very similar styles. they are brilliant singers

  • Has anyone seen Amanda at Wicked as of late....cause all im hearing is people seeing Jemma...so yeah i dont know wats goin on?!

    If anyone has seen her in the last month? how good is she now?

  • no amanda is definately elphaba currently in australia i saw her 4 days ago n she was the best eva

  • i know she is...but i just havent seen much of her i have been 6 times and seen Jemma 5...thats just why i was wondering if she was sick or wat

  • very simply sung, but its nice to hear an elphie sing it, and not riff it....:-)

  • exactly!!!!!

  • she could play galinda too

  • sounds like she came right off of a CD.....flawless. I LOVE her.

  • i cant stop watching this video!! SO good. i love it! ...and her.

  • know every word off by heart 2 this show by the way best elphaba eva

  • i know i'll probably never go to australia..but i would love to see her!!she's an amazing singer!!:D..hot too!

  • brilliance like none other!!

  • omg amanda is soooo amazing! shes my idol, she sings the song so great, best elphaba ever!

  • Wicked is touring the US again and I just went to the opening show in my city a couple of days ago. I'd thought I loved Idina to death until I saw Donna Vivino as Elphaba. She doesn't have as much publicity as the others but anyone who has heard her sing will agree with me that she's up there among the best. I'm planning on going again before the cast leaves but I have precisely the same dilemma. I don't wanna get the standby.

  • Amanda is the best Elphaba out of all i wreckon, and Lucy is the best Glinda :D

    i have seen the shows 3 times and im going again soon and these girls are just amazing.

    i would really like to get them for the next time I go...so does anyone know how i know who im getting because i don't want to get the stand-bys.

    thanks.

    xx

  • you never know its only if there sick but i have scene Jemma which is amanda's standby and i'd say shes better than her.

  • okay thanks.

    lol nah i don't think jemmas better :P

    Amanda and Lucy are the best for the part i think..

    lol

  • Ok well dont go on a saturday matinee Jemma does all of them, i think, well she does alot cos its usually Amandas performace off.

  • She kind of reminds me of Geena Davis

  • Would it be sacrilege to say I prefer Amanda to Indina?

  • i thought she was wearing a gum shield at first but her teeth are lovely she's kind of a cross between hillary swank and jennifer garner?

  • SHES FUCKING AMAZING!

    and shes so beautiful.

    i want her teeth and her facee.

  • her teeth annoy me =P

    but she's amazing

  • This will sound strange but I adore her teeth. It adds to the slightly exotic beauty of Elphaba. She's meant to look different and I think Amanda, being the talented, beautiful woman she is, fits the bill perfectly. ^_^

  • Her mouth looks like Melissa George's.

    imo.

    I still haven't seen amanda :'(

    I've seen Jemma & Patrice but no amanda.

  • You've got to, she is simply amazing!

  • Yeah me too. I saw both Jemma and Patrice and was impressed with both, but was disappointed not to see Amanda at either show :(. Couldn't believe how different Jemma and Patrice were in their interpretations though - I thought they would be so rehearsed they would be identical! I was really impressed by how differently they played the parts.

  • Each fill in has been told to do it differently, they dont have the same voice so they can't be the same. Eachs fill in has to be other wise there is no point in changing people

  • she is great but i just cant get over those huge teeth!

  • i love amanda!

  • God she's good.

    Can't wait to see WICKED again.

    :)

    i wish i could sing :P

  • she is abosolutely stunning!!

    she is soo amazing!!

    when i saw her live i got shivers down my spine!!

  • this is absolutley AMAZING!!!

    melbourne has the BEST actors!!

  • Amanda Harrison is Bloody Awesome! she looks so a lot like Hilary Swank lol

  • She is AMAZING.

    I don't know why, but she reminds me soo much of Katherine Heigel :P

    Seriously though; All the best Elphabas aren't in my country, not fair haha :P

  • she acts like a dream

  • Isn't Amanda Harrison and Lucy Durack just amazing! They are both so beautiful!You won't find a better Elphaba and Glinda!Amanda belts out an amazing voice.She can not only sing but she can act!It's an amazing show costing 18 MILLION dollars to put it on! It's worth it!The sets amazing!No wonder costing 18 million dollars!Amanda Harrison is amazing!The girls are so beautiful together!Great stage partners!

  • Amanda is great, but Kerry Ellis owns The Wizard and I. Amanda makes mistakes & tries too hard, Kerry doesn't :P Idina tries too hard aswell.... But seriously, Amanda and Lucy are the best pair currently in Wicked, the other Glinda's are fat...

  • I got SO. MANY. shivers when I saw this live! Especially the belting at the end - the choreography and lighting were so great and really added to the impact of that last section when she stood centre stage and just belted right up to the back of the theatre! Everything about this production was SO professional - and Amanda is just ... so thrilling ... the whole cast was incredible! Ahhh theatre ...

  • maybe i'm a little bias, but Amanda is the best Elphaba in the world :)

  • i loooovee heerrr!!!

  • yea i saw bert newton he was ok his voice was kinda annoying and his voice wsnt as strong as robs wouldve been but it was ok cos his part wasnt too big. i agree the cast is amazing! i waited 8months to see it and it was everything i had hoped! i even flew over from nz haha

  • I Totally agree with u mate

  • She's amaaaazing

    I love our cast so much

    Except I'll miss Rob Guest

    Out of interest, anybody seen Bert Newton?

  • Yeah i have, twice. He's okay but he's no Rob Guest. Rip.

  • her and lucy are ..AS GOOD AS KRISTIN AND IDINA not better or worse i saw lucy and amanda live twice and im sure if i saw idina and cheno i wouldnt be able to tell the difference

  • Yeah I just saw Wicked here in LA and our Elphaba is good, but not as good as Amanda. She's as good as Idina. Amazing.

  • Love you Amanda!

  • ahh Amanda :) she's so great! lol i love the facial expression she does at 0:41 :D

  • saw this in melbourne... amanda was brilliant. my favorite person in the musical by far :)

  • Whoa, she's great!

  • okay, can we borrow amanda like we did kerry? she is awesome!!! :)

  • the movie won't be a recording of the show. =.=

  • WITH ME to THE WIZARD in one breath! I thought I was the only one that did that lol!!!!!

  • i think you'll find idina did it first.

  • Umm actually, all Elphaba's have to be able to do it, that is one of the audition requirements!

  • what time on the video does that happen??

  • amanda is amazing the same can be said for lucy durack her co star

  • her last note is perfect. she holds everything in place, pitch, tone... she is really amazing and I saw her live too, so i know it's not fake

  • I saw Wicked on Thursday, it was great! I LOVE Amanda! Her voice and acting is fantastic! I think she should be Elphaba in the movie.

  • movie?? omg do u know i think they should put it on dvd (the broadway show) that would be a top seller i reacon

  • I know! But a Melbourne show :) I've told so many people that...

  • So true, i went and saw it in melbourne it was excellent. :D

  • met her after the show in melbourne a few days ago. she was awesome..

    and looks like hilary swank in real life!

    i agree they totally should do an australian cast recording

  • they have =] My teacher got it for us at the show when we went. It's fantastic

  • really? when we went they said it didn't exist. and so does wikipedia :S

  • I believe they are selling the Original Broadway Cast recording at the show.

  • they are, i'm pretty sure.

    i asked

    i wish they will tho, it will sound amazing XD

  • I think Amanda brings a nice charm to the roll.

  • I think there should be an Australian cast recording of Wicked! And that Wicked needs to come to Adelaide and peforme at the festivel theatre even it's only for 4 weeks you wil be able to get sold out housesi know that for a fact ! Amanda ther's no two way's about it your wickedly Amazing and the same with Lucy ! well really the whole cast ! Rob mills i don't care what any one say about you your just Fantastic and a wicked dancer and would love to see the show again just to see you ! go Wicked

  • lmao - im sure there going to move a multi million dollar set, just to perform in adelaide for 4 weeks. hahahaha.

  • she makes a great elphaba.

    i loved amanda.

  • Saw her on Friday night. She's a fairly conservative Elphaba, but always spot on. Such a charming performer, I hope she stays on for a good long run.

  • I saw the show last Wednesday too (the Matinee)! Amanda was so freaking fantastic!

  • She makes those belted E's sound so effortless!!!! GAH, I love her!

  • Her Defying Gravity was AMAZING live...AMAZIIIING...possibly a little better than Idina (Whom I ADORE).

  • i've never seen her until now, and she's amazing !

  • Amanda is amazing. I saw wicked on wednesday and she was breathtaking. Her voice just soared and she sounded magnificent.

  • i saw her on wednesday as well! how amazing was no good deed! wow. she is incredible!! i love the whole melbourne cast :D

    -kellyanne196

  • Amanda is great but I saw her understudy, Jemma Stevenson, do this song and she blows both Amanda and Idina Menzel totally out of the water!

  • Oh, wow! I love Idina, but after hearing Amanda, phew... I'm sorry but Idina can go on the shelf for a while, hmm, sounds like I'm a prick but I'm so impressed by Amanda