@rimidalvetarak "Japan learned about folding process from China" i rest my case. From the book the samurai, by Stephen Turnbull page 140 "the first (yamato soldier) swords... were straight... also the so called "korean swords" with a ring base... with a shape of an animal on the base" the Dong dinasty introduced to Japan the "horse Slaugher sword" (斩马刀) in the X century.
@msalazarx Yes. Perhaps you meant "Song" dynasty, not "Dong". It is this Sword from Song dynasty China that I was talking about. If I am not mistaken there is even a term used by the Japanese regarding these Chinese swords..... Chokuto.
It would not be a surprise that first Yamato soldier using "Korean" style sword which remembering back in that time, Korean was a colony of China in which Korea pays tribute to China and receive Chinese culture, incl. Chinese sword.
Wow I am more interesed with the "hate" posts than the actual video here. I am surprised so many people forgot that these are just sparring/competition/kumite and whatnot. Chill out...
Most Gumdo dojang claim that Samurai originated in Korea under the name Samurang - not true. Korea has never had Samurai or any bodies of men practising sword art.
Katana was based on Chinese saber (dao?) - not necessarily true. First sword in Japan was straight bladed more like Jian. cont...
Corea has no samurai. She lacks what Japan has always had - a cultured body of men, superbly trained in both mind and body, the soldier and scholar in one, who held to a high ideal of loyalty, patriotism, and sacrifice for country.
hwarang history was a lie →watch?v=VtZ2lYKDHA8
Please do not steal a soul of Japanese with a samurai.
and korean please stop making a fantasy myth newly .
@saburaix Everybdy knows that samurai are not Korean, and Koreans adapted budo arts since WWII Also evewrybody knows Japanese adapted Chinese culture like confusionism, indian buddism, and the katana is based in the chinese sabre before the samura in 500 AC so. Every culture takes something from others, thats cultural evolution. But that does not mean that we cant practice a good will torunament between all arts to make fiennds and share understanding from martial arts arround the world.
@saburaix Everybdy knows that samurai are not Korean, and Koreans adapted budo arts since WWII Also evewrybody knows Japanese adapted Chinese culture like confusionism, indian buddism, and the katana is based in the chinese sabre before the samura in 500 AC so. Every culture takes something from others, thats cultural evolution. But that does not mean that we cant practice a good will torunament between all arts to make fiennds and share understanding from martial arts arround the world.
Korean began to plagiarize the Japanese martial arts from the late 20th century. Korean martial arts is nothing to the history of Korea. Individual martial arts was not developed in the Joseon Dynasty(Korea).
Taekwondo plagiarized the Shotokan Karate. Tang Soo Do plagiarized Gojyuryu Karate. Haidong Gumdo and Kumdo plagiarized Kenjutsu and Kendo. Hapkido plagiarized the Daitoryu Jujutsu and Aikido. Yudo plagiarized Judo. Hwa Rang Do is not historical martial arts. Hwa Rang was dancer.
@unkeihokusai Everybdy knows that samurai are not Korean, and Koreans adapted budo arts since WWII Also evewrybody knows Japanese adapted Chinese culture like confusionism, indian buddism concepts in budo, and the katana is based in the chinese sabre since 500 BC. Even the firsts horses the samurai used, came from Korea!. So, that does not mean that we cant practice a good will torunament between all arts to make fiennds and share understanding from martial arts arround the world.
@taihuu25go Everybdy knows that samurai are not Korean, and Koreans adapted budo arts since WWII Also evewrybody knows Japanese adapted Chinese culture like confusionism, indian buddism concepts in budo, and the katana is based in the chinese sabre since 500 BC. Even the first horses in Japan, came from Korea!. So, that does not mean that we cant practice a good will torunament between all arts to make fiennds and share understanding from martial arts arround the world.
cont... Japan learned about folding process from China but they perfected the method "in house" after fighting Emishi.
In fact, the curvature of Katana was more based on Emishi swords.
Having said all these, can people with Kendo and Gumdo backgrounds respectively enagage in friendly spar? - Yes, they can.
rimidalvetarak 2 weeks ago
@rimidalvetarak "Japan learned about folding process from China" i rest my case. From the book the samurai, by Stephen Turnbull page 140 "the first (yamato soldier) swords... were straight... also the so called "korean swords" with a ring base... with a shape of an animal on the base" the Dong dinasty introduced to Japan the "horse Slaugher sword" (斩马刀) in the X century.
msalazarx 2 weeks ago
@msalazarx Yes. Perhaps you meant "Song" dynasty, not "Dong". It is this Sword from Song dynasty China that I was talking about. If I am not mistaken there is even a term used by the Japanese regarding these Chinese swords..... Chokuto.
It would not be a surprise that first Yamato soldier using "Korean" style sword which remembering back in that time, Korean was a colony of China in which Korea pays tribute to China and receive Chinese culture, incl. Chinese sword.
rimidalvetarak 2 weeks ago
Wow I am more interesed with the "hate" posts than the actual video here. I am surprised so many people forgot that these are just sparring/competition/kumite and whatnot. Chill out...
Most Gumdo dojang claim that Samurai originated in Korea under the name Samurang - not true. Korea has never had Samurai or any bodies of men practising sword art.
Katana was based on Chinese saber (dao?) - not necessarily true. First sword in Japan was straight bladed more like Jian. cont...
rimidalvetarak 2 weeks ago
japanese copy korean swordsfighting
japantruthify001 2 months ago
@japantruthify001 what do you mean?
skymadder 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
To all of you of the whole world.
Komdo is stupid sports in imitation of Japanese old KENdo of Korea.
Please stop it immediately if you learn Komdo now.
And I suggest to learn KENdo.
"KEN" of "KENdo" is a meaning called the swords, and "the DO" is a meaning called the ways.
"kom" of Komdo does not have a meaning at all.
Japanese Bushido and keen mind is included in "KENdo".
There is mind to respect the enemy even if it is an enemy.
Please learn "KENdo" if I want to train true Bushido mind.
poke9520 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Please watch this video.
watch?v=uQ5zOKB3yzw
It is plagiarism from Japan that Kumdo/Gumdo is traditional martial arts in Korea 1000years or more.
enushisama 5 months ago
wtf, this's no Kendo. this's two apes fighting each other with bamboo stick. lol
bibibi8888 5 months ago
@bibibi8888 to critique and make fun of others is easy.
msalazarx 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
朝鮮王朝實録：The Annals of the choson Dynasty (The True Record of the Korean Dynasty)…
【June 11, 1480】矧惟國人, 不慣槍劍, 專業弓矢, 爲禦敵之備
The people were not accustomed to use of sword or spear, defended from enemies only by archery...
【October 13, 1592】上敎政院曰“我國絶無劒手”
The king said “There was no swordman in our country at all”...
【July 11, 1594】我國自古劍術不傳
There has not been descendent any swordplay from ancient time in our country...
enushisama 6 months ago
Comment removed
enushisama 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Korea has no samurai.....
TheGodFatherBlasta 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
武藝圖譜通志Muye Dobo Tongji (1790) : Comprehensive Illustrated Manual of Martial Arts in Korea .
[ It is an official document at a Korean Dynasty, written by The Korean King order in the 18th century ]
國練兵之制三軍練于郊，衛士練于禁苑，其禁苑練兵盛自 光廟朝，然止弓矢一技而已如槍劍法技，既未之聞焉，
Archery was the only martial art that had been practiced by Korean soldiers. They have no skills of sword or spear fighting.
enushisama 7 months ago
William Elliot Griffis, Corea the Hermit Nation,
Corea has no samurai. She lacks what Japan has always had - a cultured body of men, superbly trained in both mind and body, the soldier and scholar in one, who held to a high ideal of loyalty, patriotism, and sacrifice for country.
hwarang history was a lie →watch?v=VtZ2lYKDHA8
Please do not steal a soul of Japanese with a samurai.
and korean please stop making a fantasy myth newly .
saburaix 7 months ago
@saburaix Everybdy knows that samurai are not Korean, and Koreans adapted budo arts since WWII Also evewrybody knows Japanese adapted Chinese culture like confusionism, indian buddism, and the katana is based in the chinese sabre before the samura in 500 AC so. Every culture takes something from others, thats cultural evolution. But that does not mean that we cant practice a good will torunament between all arts to make fiennds and share understanding from martial arts arround the world.
msalazarx 5 months ago
@saburaix Everybdy knows that samurai are not Korean, and Koreans adapted budo arts since WWII Also evewrybody knows Japanese adapted Chinese culture like confusionism, indian buddism, and the katana is based in the chinese sabre before the samura in 500 AC so. Every culture takes something from others, thats cultural evolution. But that does not mean that we cant practice a good will torunament between all arts to make fiennds and share understanding from martial arts arround the world.
msalazarx 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Korean plagiarized the Samurai, Katana, Japanese martial arts and Japanese tea celemony.
/watch?v=FaOCQ9AQyP0
unkeihokusai 7 months ago
Korean began to plagiarize the Japanese martial arts from the late 20th century. Korean martial arts is nothing to the history of Korea. Individual martial arts was not developed in the Joseon Dynasty(Korea).
Taekwondo plagiarized the Shotokan Karate. Tang Soo Do plagiarized Gojyuryu Karate. Haidong Gumdo and Kumdo plagiarized Kenjutsu and Kendo. Hapkido plagiarized the Daitoryu Jujutsu and Aikido. Yudo plagiarized Judo. Hwa Rang Do is not historical martial arts. Hwa Rang was dancer.
unkeihokusai 7 months ago
@unkeihokusai Everybdy knows that samurai are not Korean, and Koreans adapted budo arts since WWII Also evewrybody knows Japanese adapted Chinese culture like confusionism, indian buddism concepts in budo, and the katana is based in the chinese sabre since 500 BC. Even the firsts horses the samurai used, came from Korea!. So, that does not mean that we cant practice a good will torunament between all arts to make fiennds and share understanding from martial arts arround the world.
msalazarx 5 months ago
Haidong Gumdo no es las artes marciales.
La base de Haidong Gumdo es la película del Samurai japonesa.
En otros términos Haidong Gumdo es Tate (escena de la lucha) en la película.
Por favor miras el video del torneo mundial de Haidong Gumdo.
Haidong Gumdo no tiene el boxeando como kendo.
En Haidong Gumdo, sólo la belleza del propon se compite para.
taihuu25go 7 months ago
@taihuu25go Everybdy knows that samurai are not Korean, and Koreans adapted budo arts since WWII Also evewrybody knows Japanese adapted Chinese culture like confusionism, indian buddism concepts in budo, and the katana is based in the chinese sabre since 500 BC. Even the first horses in Japan, came from Korea!. So, that does not mean that we cant practice a good will torunament between all arts to make fiennds and share understanding from martial arts arround the world.
msalazarx 5 months ago
Es una de las dos escuelas de viveros sino me equivoco... Por que no invitanron a las demas =P?
gonzalosamurai 8 months ago
Ouch los dos últimos 2 puntos entraron bien agusto X3
sanriuk 1 year ago
Woooww cuando fue o que onda? que escuela de Haidong Gumdo participo?
sanriuk 1 year ago