Katharine McPhee, Over It, Seattle, Mother's Day 2007

[nothlithawk777]

This is just a crap song. Check out her singing Mary Jane at this same concert. Amazing what a good song can do.

[tiklemeangi]

well she did sing good on american idol. so im sure its just this performance tat she didnt do as good as she can

[tlw5016]

she's so pretty.

[alejandrosanzii]

There iZ a game called Chrono Cross, which haZ a very unique way of "talking" for every one of itZ characterZ. One of them (Harle) speakZ thiZ way, I guess I liked it. It waZ tediuoZ at the beginning, yeZ, but then I got uZed to it and it became very fun. =)

[alejandrosanzii]

She juZt can't hit thoZe high noteZ when she iZ singing live.. Why? Why? Why? I really LOVE thiZ song, but.. Dammit *goeZ back to listen studio version again* ¬¬

[tanzenzual]

dont you know singing live its not the same as in the studio... cuz in the studio you do it over and over again... live its more complicated.. and she didt it very well

[alejandrosanzii]

Of courZe I know, becauZe I'm a singer, too.. And I know that if I can't sing a song properly, I better shut up to avoid commentZ like theZe.

[alejandrosanzii]

...besideZ, if you think she did it "very well", juZt liZten to 1:39 and/or 2:35, simply unacceptable for a song which iZ great becauZe of itZ high noteZ.

[tanzenzual]

well u are right in those details.. but checkout over it acoustic... its also live and youll see.. what she does

[frankareno]

I listen to this song over and over again :)....I simply love Kat!

[groucho3710]

Well now that we know your eyes and ears don't work, what's left?

[cupcakes92182]

I'm sorry I'm not as big as a KAT fan as you are, but people have their opinions. I respect your opinon. There's no need to get smart mouth on me. There's other performances I like of her much more.

[groucho3710]

Actually I thought I was replying to someone else. I haven't a clue how my post got where it did. And I am usually remarkably restrained compared to the negative posters who can't find anything good to say about her so why on earth are they even bothering to watch her videos? That makes me tired and always will. If I can't stand something I just turn it off.

[lovePaula07]

she sounds amazing live.love u Kat and the outfit

[Esmeralda6891]

Mariah's live perfomances don't always sound good

[allstardancer136]

i love her so much i think she should of won not taylor he sucks

[jpillmouse]

YAY! She Rox!!

[cheezmunky]

She's still got all her old bad voice habits from Idol. And she's got a really shakey falsetto. She needs to build up her lower register and work her way up. But look at that outfit! Yowza!

[ivydagamer4life]

amazing kat! i adore her so much.. and i really love this song <3

[briewong]

This is HORRIBLE.

[purrtypinky]

i noe ryt...live songs always sound horrible!!

[groucho3710]

Nobody sings anything flawlessly live. She's singing with a track, just doing her own lead vocals. And she sounds well within her range to me. In addition, we're getting the sound from a camera phone most likely, and filtered through Youtube, so it's hardly going to be utter perfection.

[niati]

I hate that artisits can sing on the record, but don't sound even remotely good live! I like katherine but....

[groucho3710]

Are you kidding me? At least she can sing without needing studio magic to make it sound like she can stay on key and not sound like Donald Duck. She's at her best without all that stuff.

[niati]

She sounded fantastic on American idol. Mary Jane sounded great too. But changing to her falsetto in Over It was very rough. I think that artists shoudl stick to recording songs that they can sing flawlesssly LIVE! Or, they should not perform them live ever, and just have it be a CD track. I like er, I even voted for her a times, I just think that she should record sonmgs within her range.

[J0NES]

Beautiful