Added: 4 years ago
From: housebytheriver
Views: 424,421
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (185)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • faggy

  • Im gonna have to watch this later...i really don't understand it yet.

  • @TheCasu305 Look up the story of Tsoora Shah. It'll help you understand it.

  • great ! and the video is great as well!

  • the video. =\

  • My God.... the song itself is such a strong statement.... the video is freaking stunning. no one brings it out quite like Sinead eh??

  • i like the song

  • OMG what was she thinking when she made this video???? If my face could turn Blue for her it would!

  • Wow,Great Song.

  • comenteme o suscribete !!!

  • A scream a shout far in the distance Maybe the first or second floor Curtains colouring the windows Never see behind closed doors A silent siege behind politeness Domestic harmony for show Lost in the mirage of a marriage Outside a world she'll never know And as I see through the real you I'm falling Straight into A Thousand broken Mirrors I can't hide And outside the bright lights Can't hide the pain inside And I've broken a thousand mirrors Now it's time
  • Loving her children with a passion

    Protecting them at any cost

    Taking the only course of action

    There's no more bridges left to cross

    Who are the ones that are the guilty?

    Who are the ones that bear the scar?

    We must not leave our sisters bleeding

    We sing this song for Tsoora Shah

  • Comment removed

  • the uglyest video for the prettyest song!!!!

  • 14 people have broken 10000 mirrors ;)

  • Tuhle písničku zbožňuji išinetku i Asian Dub foundation ! ..:)

  • this song tells the tale of Tsoora Shah, who was accused of murdering her husband, after he had beaten and humiliated her for years.

    "Who are the ones that are the guilty? / Who are the ones that bear the scar? / We must not leave our sisters bleeding / We sing this song for Tsoora Shah"

  • @solelimh i guess that's what it says on wiki but that doesn't make it fact--so just guitar or is he contributing keys or layers synths and percussion

  • This is a great video, maybe you people don't get it. As an Indian I truly get it... the director has done his research!

  • Ed O'Brien plays on this...right?

  • I don't care what she interpits the videos to look like she got the music right AND YOU KNOW IT one of the best and spiritual albums i've ever owned COLLABORATIONS by SINEAD O'CONNOR, YEAH THE VIDEO DOESN'T MATCH THE FIERCENESS OF THE SONG BUT IT'S ALL GOOD take another listen to the album MAKE ANOTHER ONE LIKE THIS PLEASE SINEAD

  • comprendre et entendre sinead est top au moins il y a 1 message

  • I Had no idea Sinead had a musical evolution so ... particular! What's that sound, Dub? Trip Hop? Whatever it is, I like it. Is really original!

  • мелодия просто убийственная..,,кто такую мог придумать в  наше время,только гений.Необычное исполнение на высшем уровне.

  • elle est plus que magnifique... du bon son et sa belle voix pfiou suis transportée !!!

  • Sinead Is no Princess She's a Queen This is a Warning To All Only Mostly It's Directed To India To Stop Killing Your Daughters
  • It's

    Quite Astounding

    How

    So Few

    Know

    What

    She's

    Saying

  • lo kurwa, dobra nuta

    LEGIA rlz

  • super sinnead .je t adore depuis 25 ans .la plus belle voix et quel talent

  • big ears...

  • beautifull song, PRELEPA PESMA!!

  • And as I see through the real you

    I'm falling straight into

    A thousand broken Mirrors

    I can't hide

    And outside the bright lights

    Can't hide the pain inside

    And I've broken a thousand mirrors

    Now it's time

  • Sinead O`Connor

  • Sinead O'connor singing in the Massive Attack ?

  • @Szodomma ?????? First: Sinéad O'Connor is a singer, she's a solo artist but likes to cooperate to other artists. Second: Massive Attack? Yes, she had some songs with them, but didn't join. But this song still belongs to Asian Dub Fundation...

  • MERAVIGLIOSA!

  • pozdrav za lelq,OBI4AM TE TI SI MI EDNO OT NAI CENNITE NE6TA!!!!!!

  • this is magic :D

  • she's so beautiful I love her so much... thank you for your music sinead

  • not forgetting ed o'brien proving guitar

  • @guilaumekabum

    hahaha, yeah :)

  • @guilaumekabum

    i think she's beautiful when she's bald.

    most people don't look good without hair.

  • beautiful song enjoy this song

  • @guilaumekabum

    who cares? does that affect her singing?

  • ouais t'as raison Bert ! bises

  • Qu'est ce que vous voulez que je vous dise?...c'est bon...c'est un mélange de genres qui va bien!....et entendre cette voix ça file toujours le frisson!

  • What album is this song on?

  • @NewYork17 Enemy of the enemy

  • @floyde91 Thanks

  • WTF?! that was reallyy sttuopidddd..... but awesome at the same time.

  • 2:53 "Mommy, the singing lady is scaring me." lol

  • wow collaborated with this too??? thanks sinead!!!!! I LOVE U 2 PIECES

  • is this video takin the piss?? Good song mix tho....

  • everything is awesome...video also :)

  • I love this song

  • Amazing vocal plus music of soul equal Oustanding song:) Thanks for sharing:)

  • She has nice eyes.

  • wtf.....song is really nice...but video???? go to he||

  • she was so hot when she was younger

  • wtf @ video???

  • Beautiful song, beautiful voice, embarrassingly stupid video.

  • excuse me, but who do you think she's presenting the 1000 mirrors? people, of course. so, video's just fine.

  • @jaredbradford the video puts the budget in low bugdet...

  • @jaredbradford LOL écoute et regarde ça fait + de 20 ans quel chante 

  • @jaredbradford

    Are You retarded

  • @iAsteroidPlanetSmash Not in the least. But, based on your limited grasp of language, you clearly are. Grow up, child.

  • @jaredbradford The video is referencing the tragic real life events that inspired the song.

  • @jaredbradford i am not quite sure how you can understand the beauty/meaning of the song and then say the video is embarrassing. it is a perfect representation of what she is saying through the song.... really you dont see that???

  • @InfiniteSpiral112358 It has nothing to do with "not seeing" anything. I can assure you, I see what's meant to be seen. I think the song, lyrics, and her voice are stunning. This is a poor video, no question about that. It doesn't do the song justice.

  • @jaredbradford well i guess we are going to have to agree to disagree. this song addresses all of the emotions, confusion, pain and unspoken rules of not speaking about a truly dysfunctional to even abusive family life. at first they encourage her to speak/be herself, and they happily dance along happily (keeping up charade) but as it starts to become evident that she is speaking of what it is taboo to speak of they become more and more disapproving and judgmental ...(cont)

  • @jaredbradford (cont 2) and instead of being encouraging they stop listening and some even become angry, and then all goes dark (she is silenced again) and she mouths "what happened" not only to her "happy family" but also to represent the painful confusion of growing up in a family like that. it may be simple but the video definitely shows the song's meaning.

  • @InfiniteSpiral112358 I didn't need an explanation. I get the concept. I just think it didn't work. As I said, beautiful song, message, lyrics and, of course, brilliant voice. I just think the video failed in its attempt. Just my opinion - no big deal that we disagree. :)

  • @jaredbradford well as i said, to me the video shows and represent all of the thinks that are wrong within a family that is dysfunctional and/or abusive. i do understand that this IS MY interpretation of the video and i am sure that Sinead would want all of us to get from it what we need/want to get from it. i will not argue about your opinion of the video any further, because there is no reason. and to be clear i was NOT insinuating that you "jut didnt get it" or anything. (cont)

  • @jaredbradford (cont 2) you absolutely have the right to your opinion... i do apologize if i made you feel insulted or any such thing. and i have no problem with us agreeing to disagree. i have to say that i respect your responses being clear and non insulting, as that is mostly what happens in anonymous internet sites. i thank you for being someone who can have a differing opinion and yet instead of being rude or insulting you disagreed with integrity. thank you.

  • @InfiniteSpiral112358 Likewise - thanks for being civil! You're right - doesn't happen often online!

  • She sang, sings and will sing by her soul, and its amazing voice Her soul conductor! I admire it already much, it is a lot of years)))

  • she has the best voice in the world!

  • zelo lepo nekateri pač so rojeni zvezniki

  • good song..good lyrics

  • She is a genie of hope a redemption

  • wow, great song!! never heard it before, but i adore sinead. her voice is a true gift.

  • cool song, shit video

  • agreed...

  • awesome voice..

  • I'm sort of curious...why was someone's comment of "Kick ass video" rated down? If you're elitist to the point that you find his language offensive, I think there's no hope for you. Good video at any rate.

  • OMG. i'ts fantastic to see ed o'brien and sinéad doing a song together.

  • WOW. Sinead always amazes me! Too bad that Americans never gave her the respect that she deserves!

  • I had never seen this vid before. Sinéad is so cool. I love her stuff.

  • This video is pure genius.

  • Sinead makes me proud to be irish

  • iyyk, dans etmeyin lan!

  • Please indian family, stop dancing on you chairs...

  • ...amazing voice......so powerfull...i'm really glad for this video, cause i used to search it a lot....thank you very much...

  • I am spellbound with her (voice)!!!

  • love!

  • I Love This Woman!!!

  • bassline !

  • ou yeassss...

    tu tu tu tuu  ♫

  • Greatsong!

  • struggling

  • lovely:)

  • maximális tolerancia! van mit tanulnunk...

  • i love this video and her music

  • i love this song and music and shinead you're the best and i love you!!!

  • It is impossible to remain indifferent to hear the songs of Sinéad. Touch the soul, make us reflect, protest, express, verbalize the actions. Thank you for your music, for your voice, for your strength and courage. I hope that one day it can assist here in Brazil.

  • Uwielbiam ten kawalek, pelna zajebioza !! :D

  • I love this song and video!

  • Sinead jest WIELKA.

  • I love the way no matter what Sinead is singing she never loses her Irish accent!

  • Asian Dub Foundation !!!

  • jó zene, kata-kingának való:D

  • not a good video but a good song. what is this song about anyway?

  • A women serving life for killing her abusive husband

  • really? i should work on my english...thank u.

  • I was looking for this song for many years, I'm glad I finally found it. She's so underrated!

  • OMG at 0:57 I nearly died laughing :D

  • LMAO! so did i ! :L!

  • beautiful

  • How interesting / ironic to mis-understand the message the video was trying to express.

    "A silent siege behind politeness,

    Domestic harmony for show.

    Lost in the mirage of a marriage,

    Outside a world she'll never know."

    Google Tsoora (Zoora's) name as suggested by butteslmao & you may understand why there is a 'domestic / home-made' feel to the vid. Or perhaps not. Anyone familiar with ADF music/gigs & political activity will be more than aware that they champion those with little or no voice.

  • I can't believe what I saw. They didn't spent one dollar to make this clip. It looks like a home-made video! Horrible clip for an awesome song.

    (( Eu não acredito no que eu acabei de ver. Eles não gastaram um dólar para fazer esse clipe. Parece um video caseiro! Clipe horrível de uma música incrível. ))

  • I beg to differ. The focus is on the message. Sinéad feels and means every word, never ceases to amaze me. The video is very cool.

  • @howardlol It's deliberate. It's supposed to look homemade. The song is about a victim of domestic abuse who wasn't allowed to leave the home who eventually likked her husband. The whole facade of politeness and happiness when people visit; "A silent siege behind politeness,Domestic harmony for show.

    Lost in the mirage of a marriage, Outside a world she'll never know." I think the video fits the song perfectly.

  • @howardlol ...and that should have said 'killed her husband' not likked! ;)

  • the stupid video totally ruins the whole song, it was 1000 millions times better when when I first listened it on the radio.

  • Es tan bella.!

  • Great voice.I love the facts from which the song was inspired.

  • i don't get this video. so odd.

  • "We sing this song for Tsoora Shah" Google her name.

    Everyone's all happy to go along and pretend nothing is going on but when asked to speak out nobody wants to.

  • Some people don't have a voice. It's covered by the lies of others. Very few would speak when asked, but those people are over looked. Miss invisible me.

  • she has got beautiful voice! and she is not an ordinery singer neither a person. you know what? it could be great: Sinead and Bjork singing a song!

  • Ohhh yeah! Totally agree!

  • It's Time.

  • MAGNIFICO

    sinead sei un bocciuolo a very little bocciuolo

  • ...e la cosa bella é che lo é stata per venti e più anni. E come lo é stata. Quite possibly the ultimate diva, nessuna come lei.

  • It's not often to contemporary music - to have such expression while singing, just like Sinead O'Connor. She thinks about words she sings. And she's not singing about pity things. I love "Feel so different" too.

  • Szeretem! :)

  • Nem vagy ezzel egyedül. :)

  • ezt kinek válaszoltad?

  • Sembra la canzone adatta per uno striptease..se volete evitare infarti non usatela per tali fini!

  • Ricorda alla mia memoria una serata soddisfacente, in cui i protagonisti, me e il piccolo Edi che del suddetto gruppo mi fece invaghire anche grazie alla sua convincente arte persuasoria

  • Her voice is as sexy as she is

  • The the indian guy in the blue shirt is the oompa loompa from Willy Wonka.

  • she's got great voice, big respect for her from Poland!

  • stop fucking argue about arabic countries, covering their hairs its just a matter of culture, they are like us, have a travel down there and have a look before commenting....

  • It is a brilliant song and video.

  • Everyone should pay attention to Sinead's eyes when she watches the dancers.

    This is exactly the kind of videos you don't see on mtv. A fucking good short movie. And every link with the music (and the song) is just perfect.

  • You are right. And this video is just great.

  • Than explain me, why do that three person the cumba-jajas and the "dance" in the chair. It doesnt mean anything. And I'm sure that black guy is the husband of the girl and he is not indian.

    By the way.. look at the arabian countries and see how women supressed and abused.

    I just dont agree with this video. I like the song a lot. But the video is too underground.

  • First "the dancers" are not understanding the meaning of the song but then after the name "Zoora Shah" falls everything is clear and they feel unpleasant.

    And it is not about being indian or whatever.

  • @Zatikaaa

    lol there is no black guy in the video. he's just a bald south asian.

  • Yes, this video is quite disappointing. I dont really understand why the hell is it so interesting that she is with an indian family. Zhey could have done this ever so much better.

  • How about thinking a little bit more about the meaning of this song, and then judging the video?

    The thing about India is, that it is a country in which women are surpressed more than in many other countries.

  • What a ridiculous music video - they start by egging her on to sing and in the end they all look like they just want her to shut up - and what was with the "chair bop" those 3 were doing near the start - compared to the mood of those song it looked comical. Shame, coz the song is so good...

  • Mate, check out who's Zoora Shah.

  • I think it's the third floor.

  • i wanted to see this video four yrs ago, now i think it's so much inferior than the song... asian dub foundation has better videos though, i guess we can imagine a better visualization of this song on our own...

  • This features Ed OBrien from Radiohead on guitar!

  • i know. i love ed o'brien!

  • Heartbreaking - reduced me to tears this did.

  • Go on Sínead and ADF!

  • i love sinead :D

  • i love her 2 - wellcome 2 the club ;-)

    she's just amazing

  • Video much inferior to a great song, which is making the mood for a beautiful external.

  • this is an Mucc song. Anybody does know the real the japanese name this song? I've downloaded the album but the songs writen by kanjis.

    thanks

  • What? isn't this Asian Dub Foundation and Sinead O'Conner????

  • Sorry I've mixed up the songs^^~

  • you don't know?

  • i love the facts from which the song was inspired..

  • i love this song!

  • amazing, just amazing

  • Such an odd little video :)

    But I love this song!