I was there with my best bud, it was awesome! :)) But someone in the mosh pit got hurt super bad and they had to call an emergency Helicopter to life-lite them to the hospital. Me and my friends had backstage thingies and went and got all their autographs and told them how cool they were and talked to them. It was fun! :D
Idiots!!! The songs were not written FOR Carah. She just happened to be the singer at the time. Sisely can't sing them because she sucks. She doesn't have the range. She screams when she can't hit the notes which you'll find alot of on Poision. Couldn't cut it as a Pussycat Doll and can't cut it with STG. Bring back Carah. They'll never be as good as they can without her. Oh, you ever notice how Chad covers his head in interviews ever since Carah's departure....what's up with that?
Ive seen STG 4 times so far,and I Love what Carah brought to the band. We are Pilots will never be for Sisely, but Season of Poison will never be for Carah. In saying that though, I dont agree with Siselys Style for this song. What people forget though, is that Sisely was STGs first choice for female singer, Carah was second originally. Shes doing an ok job atm, second album s incredible.
She probably looks uncomfortable bcuz she knows ppl don't like her, and she knows that everyone's going to think carah was way better. on these songs, yes carah was better. bcuz these songs were written for carah. it's almost like when a band does a cover of someone elses's music. most ppl like the original better bcuz it was written for the original band. yes, i personally do miss carah, but i think sisely's doing a fairly good job, in all due respect. carah wanted to leave. period, the end.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
i have tickets to the detroit show this sunday, but after watching this, im scared that treasure will disappoint. i agree with the other posts that she does have big shoes to fill. i guess ill give it a shot and go, but for now im gonna pop open itunes and listen to stg with carah singing dont cry out.
... I'm really upset. The atmosphere of STG is extremely different without Carah. I'm not trying to say I'm not giving Sisely a chance... but she's really blowing it with a presence like this.
ive seen carah preform on numerous accounts and carah has a much stronger voice and can blow the fish right out of the water, sissely is only able to hold the same A line threw out every pitch im sorry bud but your wrong
just not the same without carah,
still great band though,
going to see them in three days in tulsa OK
AaronAnthrax 1 year ago
I was there with my best bud, it was awesome! :)) But someone in the mosh pit got hurt super bad and they had to call an emergency Helicopter to life-lite them to the hospital. Me and my friends had backstage thingies and went and got all their autographs and told them how cool they were and talked to them. It was fun! :D
KyRiE654 2 years ago
Idiots!!! The songs were not written FOR Carah. She just happened to be the singer at the time. Sisely can't sing them because she sucks. She doesn't have the range. She screams when she can't hit the notes which you'll find alot of on Poision. Couldn't cut it as a Pussycat Doll and can't cut it with STG. Bring back Carah. They'll never be as good as they can without her. Oh, you ever notice how Chad covers his head in interviews ever since Carah's departure....what's up with that?
sammy5279 2 years ago
fuck.. why is everyone such a dipshit? just like the band or not.
wretchedmixshow 3 years ago 2
Dude: You cant get much more flat than that...she sucks! Carah was way better, even if she did dance like Elaine from Seinfeld.
fyicary 3 years ago
I'd like to see you get up there and rock out like she did.
KyRiE654 2 years ago
i thought she did a great job live. there's not really a huge difference between the two anyway...
tyrone258 3 years ago
Ive seen STG 4 times so far,and I Love what Carah brought to the band. We are Pilots will never be for Sisely, but Season of Poison will never be for Carah. In saying that though, I dont agree with Siselys Style for this song. What people forget though, is that Sisely was STGs first choice for female singer, Carah was second originally. Shes doing an ok job atm, second album s incredible.
Still Miss Carah though :(
ckb87 3 years ago 2
Carah wasn't that great live with this song either, they both scream into the microphone and don't even sing it!
jennibee83 3 years ago
She probably looks uncomfortable bcuz she knows ppl don't like her, and she knows that everyone's going to think carah was way better. on these songs, yes carah was better. bcuz these songs were written for carah. it's almost like when a band does a cover of someone elses's music. most ppl like the original better bcuz it was written for the original band. yes, i personally do miss carah, but i think sisely's doing a fairly good job, in all due respect. carah wanted to leave. period, the end.
yisaPOO 3 years ago
I swear, you Carah fangirls are way too fucking bitchy, somebody call the waaambulance.
Kelsosbitch 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
and to think... i almost drove from boise to see this bullshit.
shortsmurf07 3 years ago
Hey man shiny toy guns was ok but the rest of the bands rocked
billylily7 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i have tickets to the detroit show this sunday, but after watching this, im scared that treasure will disappoint. i agree with the other posts that she does have big shoes to fill. i guess ill give it a shot and go, but for now im gonna pop open itunes and listen to stg with carah singing dont cry out.
dagoodness11 3 years ago
Shit, she fucking SUCKS...her voice is terrible. It sounds like lame kareoke...
And none of this, "well she's singing live" bullshit because Carah sang AMAZING live, moving around like crazy, and out of breathe...
Her (Sisely) prescence alone makes me wanna gag...
Imaginary114 3 years ago
... I'm really upset. The atmosphere of STG is extremely different without Carah. I'm not trying to say I'm not giving Sisely a chance... but she's really blowing it with a presence like this.
RabbitsBunnyLittle 3 years ago
she fucking sucks.
immoonligh7 3 years ago
she looks uncomfortable,
as if she doesn't know what shes doing
if she wants the respect of stg fans,
i think her live performances should be better than this
they'll get grilled when they come over to the uk if they carry on like this
obzz1 3 years ago
I couldn't agree more...she has some huge shoes to fill...
Imaginary114 3 years ago
hmmmm i missed this show
but seeing this video, sisely doesnt suck as bad as everyone was saying she did
i still prefer carah way way more tho
SWF18 3 years ago
Carah had better legs :P
Shalalaforever 3 years ago
SHE FUCKING SUCKS. fuck her.
shimmr88 3 years ago
haha I 2nd that...
Imaginary114 3 years ago
This is Pathetic. You lost me STG.
Bestfriendkev 3 years ago
you and me both...
Imaginary114 3 years ago
Sisely had a great live atmosphere, and her voice works very well on Don't Cry Out. I was happy with it.
shadowkhas 3 years ago 3
In person Sisely rocked the place. She's pretty good. And it's way too hot when she plays bass!
toddcnoker 3 years ago 5
this is very true!
tyrone258 3 years ago
lucky bastard!
i was at this show.
further back.
not to mention your camera can actually record sound...
sisely was pretty good but carah is definitely irreplacable
failurexxinxxstereo 3 years ago
wow it can't get any worse then this! beyond failure is what this is
xblondie90 3 years ago
What? Are you serious?
Enuf3 3 years ago
xblondie90, you need to hear Carah's live shows to compare . Sisely is stronger and has much better pitch. Although I love carah too!
alsodsotmfan 3 years ago
ive seen carah preform on numerous accounts and carah has a much stronger voice and can blow the fish right out of the water, sissely is only able to hold the same A line threw out every pitch im sorry bud but your wrong
xblondie90 3 years ago
wow, maybe i'd have to see it in person...but sisely seems terrible.
mickylaren 3 years ago