Death to False Metal pt. 1

[lrsgamer23]

your version of metal and not-metal contradicts itself. 1:56 huge breakdown and you call it not-metal?

[VitalSigns1]

Motley's Crue's second album is 100% heavy metal, and it's better than a lot of the bands you listed in your "true" metal section.

[SkygroundQ]

@VitalSigns1 Motley Crue was Rock n Roll... not metal

[VitalSigns1]

@SkygroundQ I'm a metalhead and I'm telling you you're wrong. Shout at the Devil is classic heavy metal. If you can't hear that you're deaf.

[brucedickinsonWARD]

fucking poosers defending his poosers bands assholes!!! realy,realy hate that emo pússy´´s pazuzu take care of you loosers

[opop12able]

I Don't know why ?

honestly , I love the not metal :D

[ohmygodimonfire12]

The Black Dahlia Murder are not metal. Wow, I think they probably are. In fact there are about seven fucking hundred bands on this list that are metal. Trivium? Slipknot? All Shall Perish? And if your argument is ''they are metalcore not metal'' then please die. Metalcore is an offshoot of metal.

[Metalcore623]

@ohmygodimonfire12 slipknot is not metalcore

[ohmygodimonfire12]

@Metalcore623 I know, I was just trying to make a point that many of the bands in this idiots 'false metal' category are classified as metalcore.

[TheEmeraldRitual]

@ohmygodimonfire12

Agreed, Black Dahlia Murder are true.

But however, Slipknot are nu metal, trivium and ASP are metalcore.

Not a fan of any but I actually liked 1 song by TBDM!

[danmarder1]

I'm not saying they are good either, but they are metal

[danmarder1]

Cradle of Filth really aren't false metal. Otherwise I agree.

[lunarstrain235]

whats the name of the Ghoul song?

[BAKSLYDERmusic]

LMFAO @ your "Real Metal"

[juano271824]

POS CHIMBA LOKO QUE PUBLIQUE ESTO ES ORGULLO del metal estoy mamao de ver chinos maricas con entubados y tenis(creyendose los mas metal....)cansado del puta metalcore y sus derivados que se pudran emos punkemos rockemos y el resto de mier....ODIO EL PINCHE DEATHCORE como ellos lo bautizaron .....no hay respeto por el METAL....

[myserus]

Comparas cualquier cosa y te quedaste en el tiempo. No coincido una mierda con este video. Slipknot puesto al mismo nivel que Motley Crue, y al mismo tiempo poniendolo a nivel de Hatebreed y Throwdown? :S

Todo lo que no sea thrash o death metal no es metal? estas equivocado

[SanguineBullet667]

i agree with this video, this retarded new 'metal' isn't even metal. it's glorified pessimistic side of the scene trend.

[battlep0t]

I, the listener will decide what's real and what's fake metal for myself. I don't need a bunch of bellends on youtube to do it for me.

[remnant24]

@battlep0t And yet, you clicked the link to a video that does just that.

[DocLocc]

Does it matter which band is "real" metal and which is not? I like real metal, but e.g. Trivium or Limp Bizkit are great bands, too.

[SmokescreenAbyss]

3:30 R.I.P \m/

[GoGoVengo]

generally real metal is more restrained in feeling and about fantasy themes and complex stories which rise and fall throughout the album.

[Kiki3141592]

Now in Japan, Heavy Metal is toooooo old and Metal fans are toooo stupid, so many people are saying. First time I denied, but I searched and I found many many movies "Death to false metal", and now I can't deny that "Metal fans are stupid".

After all many metal fans are continue to attacking their dislike bands. Maybe you're pleasure to make these movies, but HEAVY METAL disappear, maybe!

[Kiki3141592]

Cradle of Filth is false??　Hahaha! Crazy!

I'm MEGADETH fan too, and I know MEGADETH's album "Risk", "The world needs a hero" etc.

Why are you ignored recently MEGADETH's song??? For example "Prince of Darkness", "Ecstasy", "The scorpion", etc..

Your picked up MEGADETH'S newest song is "Symphony of Destruction"! This song is about 20 years old song!!

Maybe people who made these movie don't like real MEGADETH!! SO SAD!!

[ZPDUDE87]

how is the black dahlia murder not metal?

[itsdrpepper567]

@ZPDUDE87 i was thinking the same thing along with all shall perish and hatebreed

[ZPDUDE87]

@itsdrpepper567 well hatebreeds more of a hardcore band but yea i know what you mean.

[hurerz]

PLAYLIST PLEASE!

[corrosivetrip]

wow 7:35 the biggest, most pathetic ass pussies ive ever seen, and thats sayin somethin. how do ppl fucking let themselves get like that?!

[WolfeSergio]

The title of the video is "Death to False Metal" but in the video the transitions are "Real metal", and "Not metal" two different things. Yes, some of those bands aren't death metal, but that doesn't mean they aren't metal, No disrespect intended.

[xmetalfuckingcorex]

the only bands i would say shouldnt be on your not metal list are the black dahlia murder, job for a cowboy (their newer stuff is death metal) and hatebreed

[VitalSigns1]

@xmetalfuckingcorex You're a retard. Those bands are all just about as false as you can get.

[xmetalfuckingcorex]

@VitalSigns1 well i just feel sorry that your definition of metal is so narrow. youre missing out on alot of good shit man.

[VitalSigns1]

@xmetalfuckingcorex I assure you, I'm not. It's not like I haven't tried those bands. To think that I'm missing out on anything is laughable.

[nymetalhead89]

I agree with your list except one thing man i think cradle of filth is metal and i enjoy listening to them i am sick of these idiot kids who think nu metal and "core" is metal

[cckeach7]

OK..I'm almost 50 and have always loved hard rock/heavy metal. I agree with most of the picks (Poison is decidely UNMETAL), in some cases the audio clips do not sound that much different from one another, though it's obvious that some of the false metal bands appearance is much more commercially appealing (read: SANIIZED)...

[cckeach7]

@cckeach7 I mean SANITIZED...

[CaesarAugustus27]

where the fuck is metallica????????

[WFHRt]

Dices que Motley Crue y Poison no son bandas de heavy metal ¿tu sabes que cojones es el glam metal o que?

[TheMusicThrasher]

@WFHRt Cuando dicen metal falso, se refieren al metal malo, y Poison y Motley Crue son bastante malos. MC menos pero solo por Dr. Feelgood. Poison se pueden ir a morir en un hoyo.

[SpaceNTimeForADime]

@WFHRt Glam metal está más relacionado con el hard rock, en realidad no son bandas de metal, más parecido a las bandas de rock.

[koivandon]

I don't understand why Mötley Crüe's even on this list. They've never claimed to be anything else than Rock'n'Roll. I won't argue about anything else (not because I necessarily agree, but mainly because I don't care), but since the video is named "death to false metal" it seems incredibly stupid to even put them in this type of comparison. (I guess the same goes for Poison, but face it: no one likes Poison enough to stand up for 'em)

[miloraca]

No 1 poser band is SLIPKNOT!!!!!! they really suck shit! checkout a band called EVILE thrash metal at its best!

[EverxOpeningxFlower]

@miloraca Check out Vektor. That is imo the best new wave of thrash metal band.

[TheLuvablerogue]

I am seeing a trend here.....young boys with nice hair are not Metal...I would agree that a lot of these shitty bands the kids are listening to are posers.

[halfbackofthecentury]

I like every time i die and hatebreed. But they're hardcore and punk, which is why they have breakdowns.

[kiba4443]

Darkest Hour kicks ass. Kris Norris is amazing

[philold09]

they're all metal.......EXECEPT YOU motley crue......face it people the modern metal is here step up or fuck off

[EverxOpeningxFlower]

@philold09 Modern metal rules! Bands like Obscura, Detonation, Vektor, Suicidal Angels, Exile, Violator, Hexen, Hellcommand etc. The list is endless. But the bands on the false list here are not metal. Especially Bullet for my valentine and Avenged Sevenfold.

[McRabbid9]

Where's Pantera?

[kingcahoj]

@McRabbid9

you need to watch the "extremely overrated metal bands" video for them.

[thecrouchpouch]

i like the message this vid sends, but u only picked old bands as examples of real metal bands? and i think you could have found better bands to troll on than bleeding through.

[rollthelosingdice]

OVERKILL!!!!

[rollthelosingdice]

slipknot is annoying

[Curmudgeonistic]

This is based on what now??... (other than the uploader's opinions!)

[8582roy]

motley crue is defetly not metal but i rather have that around that fuking metal core stupid shit

[MrTomservo85]

Oh man haha 38 year olds post youtube videos now. This is awesome.

[SpaceNTimeForADime]

@MrTomservo85 How would a 38 year old now about all the modern bi curious metalcore bands?

[umega5]

So what, just because people who are metal in there own way, a way not of your own, you have to hate on them. now how is that right, thats just a ignorant man way of being himself or just trying to get attention, are you a Christian preacher(while we are ignorant attention whores) Thats just not metal. metal is the coming together of "rejects" and other people in that same demographic.

so what if some bands do the logical thing and sacrifice some hardcoreness for the sake of not sounding like

[umega5]

@umega5 a bunch of retarded screaming skinhead and sound like good, valuable artist who are worth listening to and albums are worth buying cause you might find something new or special in its own way that is Worth the time it takes to listen to it.

AND WHO THE FUCK HAS EVER CONSIDERED LINKIN PARK AS METAL, FUCK THE HUMAN RACE HERES TO ALL OF HUMANITY DIEING TOMORROW.

[TheBloodyBassist]

the black dahlia murder not metal? strange i wonder what they did wrong

[Amyisretarded]

Don't forget Slayer and Testament! Classic bands :)

[horrorluvr]

This dude thinks he has the market cornered on what is and isn't Metal....I'd be willing to bet he's close to 40.

[Wytchfinde]

@horrorluvr

At least he's not a poseur acting "elitist" by aligning himself with mainstream garbage and pap.

[SwirlyBrokenHearts]

haha you LAMEOID! you think this crap means anything? does it ever occur to you thet genuine "metalheads" dont make videos like this? its because we are too cool to care! go back to precious gaydus priest lmao enjoy worn out heyday tattered out of fasion "leather meta"l! well anything thrash metal, im pretty "down" with black and death metal but i dont over obsess about it, pretty fun and sad at the same time to see people like you HillProxwhatev make bias shit like this, have a great day. :D

[Mistressofhell666]

teach them posers whats metal and whats not lol MALLCORE MUST DIE

[Mistressofhell666]

you have awsome taste

[TheTruMetal]

Iron Maiden and Judas Priest are not true metal...

They're mainstream, how can they be metal?

[DeathToRealMetal]

@TheTruMetal mainstream doesn't change you from being metal.bands like priest and maiden paved the way for metal.its fine if a metal band reaches high success.what wrong with that?if your favorite band went platnium witht their next album would you stop listening to them?if so your not a true fan.you should want bands you like getting noticed and succeeding.fame is only a bad thing when they start changing because of it.they stop writing music because it what they love but to get money.

[Wytchfinde]

@DeathToRealMetal

Exactly----metal is innate in its art form, popularity is not a prime measure of what metal is or is not.

Everyone has heard of (at least) Black Sabbath and they are popular, and metal. Mortem is a dark death band and has a underground cult following, but they are still metal regardless.

[hmfvunit]

FUCK YOU FOR DISSING MOTLEY CRUE!

[kgrind99]

I love how Metal is about respect but when it comes to other heavier bands that OTHER PEOPLE call metal you disrespect it! I love and listen to both "Real Metal", "metal" and "Hardcore" and its all basically heavy shit! Hardcore can learn from metal and metal can learn from hardcore! Don't be jealous that 20 year old kids can shred or out blast your favorite Swedish viking black satanic REAL METAL band.

[kgrind99]

I love how Metal is about respect but when it comes to other heavier bands that OTHER PEOPLE call metal you disrespect it! I love and listen to both "Real Metal", "metal" and "Hardcore" and its all basically heavy shit! Hardcore can learn from metal and metal can learn from hardcore! Don't be jealous that 20 year old kids can shred or out blast your favorite Swedish viking black satanic REAL METAL band.

[FearlessSpinner]

KREATOR !!!!!



[dawe707]

that's why i hate those ridiculous close-minded true metalheads... false metal ftw.!

[MrMetallicMentality]

Oh, I see. Inaudible vocals, small fan base and lyrics that don't make sense is what makes metal metal. Okay, I was mistaken, I thought metal was a genre based around loud distorted guitars, emphatic rhythms, dense bass-and-drum sounds, and vigorous vocal styles...could be wrong though.

[DNOMYTE]

had me up until Motley Crue and Poison

[Caiolambofgod]

???

hilltoprocks = new fag

[HenryChing93]

Napalm Death is grindcore,but they are great.

[ididit4fun]

Iced Earth \m/ ....so wait. if it's not power metal or thrash metal, it's not metal at all?

[DNOMYTE]

You had me up until Motley Crue not being metal...they most definitely were on their first two albums. Poison is hard rock btw they never claimed to be metal.

[MrTsikoulatas]

this video sucks!who are you to judge real metal you asshole?xD

[HarvesterOfMisery]

You sir... are a poser. Pull your head out of your ass, yes there are bands that suck ass on this list but theyre on both sides of your metal and not metal list

[HarvesterOfMisery]

You sir... are a poser.

[1SHOWNOMERCY]

KREATOR RULES

[JaaniVan]

Great job dude!Awesome photo of Celtic Frost!

[OfficialFever]

New metal are try hards trying to imitate Thrash, Death, Black, Metal it's pretty sad ! hahaha

[TheSwagganator]

For about half of this video, I was thinking, "WOW, this guy is retarded"

But then I realized the titles came before the bands, not after.

[QuatuorMortis]

This is really funny. According to hilltoprocks, POSERS=Real Metal, while real bands not concerned about their image=Not Metal.

[xxchimakaraxx]

I hope you guys know those bands are keeping metal alive, sure maybe their not doing it the same way to old guys did, I started listening to stuff like deathcore/metalcore, then I started finding out about guys like Cannibal Corpse, Nile, Dying Fetus etc, if there never were any new innovations to metal music, then "real" metal probably wouldn't be alive right now

[blacksabbath0909]

Check out the new thrash metal band Diamond Plate, there coming out with a new album in 2011 and are signed to earache

[jaimedadestroyer]

bury your dead is not even metal

[corybiro]

NAPALM DEATH HAVE NO LEADS,,NOT METAL,,,GRIND

[corybiro]

NAPALM DEATH R NOT METAL,,,THEY ARE THE GRIND FATHERS,

[corybiro]

I ALMOST THOUGHT U SAID GHOUL WAS FAKE,,I WAS READY TO KILL YA,,LMFAO,,KIDDIN,,,GHOUL ARE THE SHIT MAN.,SICK BAND REMIND ME ALOT OF CARCASS,,,GOOD CARCASS

[McMinnManiac]

some of the bands who "are not "and "are " don't say who they are ...Was Black Dahlia Murdurs considered "Not Metal"? Then Celtic Frosted Flakes is is hank sherman metal because he was on MFs first and second albums??

[hiimtre]

hey man, i was wondering, since you made this a long time ago, have u changed ur mind about any of the bands u mentioned??? personally, uve listed some of my favorite bands on both sides...

[skerpunky]

what was that band after KORN on 4:18 ?

[V15h0u5]

Who was that at 1:58?

[mooshon9]

hilltoprocks,you sir,are an asshole

[NuMetalification]

Let me get this straight; a band is only "real metal" if it's a classic metal band or an obnoxiously shitty death metal band? KoRn and Slipknot are in the heavier section of a subgenre known as "nu metal". Whether or not you like it, it's still metal. Linkin Park sucks ass and Limp Bizkit is one of the worst bands ever but I still like them. I hate Linkin Park. Other than that, I completely agree. Job for a Cowboy fucking sucks.

[cloudrenibo]

@NuMetalification no NUmetal are metal at all. Those so called metal bands are a disgrace and should not be mixed up with metal.

[fangt00th]

poison was never trying to be metal, poison just fucking sucks

[McMinnManiac]

@fangt00th I look at it like is it "Party Rock" like van Halen or "Metal" Starting with Priest and Maiden Venom etc

[arrbejebus]

If opinions are fact this guy's a cunt.

[haichtee]

this scares me; i was looking for weezer

[MICHAEL71475]

finally someone who kinda knows what he's talking about, except for three things, avenged sevenfold, motley crue or poison never tried to be metal a7x is hard rock and crue and poison are glam

[Stupidsquire]

i dont think darkest hour or the black dahlia murder are false metal...

[Holykatzbob]

How do you feel about the next up and coming weezer album's name?

[viletree]

@Holykatzbob hahahahahahahahahaha i was just going to say that,

[revilo59]

Anyone who thinks Underoath is not metal... I dare them to listen to this song and say it again: "Breathing In a new mentality"

[Primebot101]

real metal and not metal sounds completely different

real metal stays true to heavy metal tradition but not metal does not at all

[ratface071394]

Death to STEEL PANTHER, theyre fuckin horrible in comparison to REAL metal

[ratface071394]

Death to STEEL PANTHER, theyre fuckin horrible in comparison to REAL metal

[MetalHead4Life94]

I agree with it all exept Motley Crue cruse is good.

[Wytchfinde]

@MetalHead4Life94

I'd say "Shout at the Devil" is at their most rock/metal.

It's better than the mallcore bands out there, that's for certain.

[MetalHead4Life94]

Hell yea all core sucks ass.Motley Crue & Poison are the only ones on the not metal list i like.But i can totaly understand why they wouldn't be consterd metal.

[guidemetohell]

i can only understand that 'true metalheads' have a complex of inferiority or either feel like metal is declining. Metal is not in bad shape. Metalcore is a subgenre as deathcore is,and if you dont like it you dont listen to it, period. You like heavy metal you like Thrash you like death black folk whatever ,its your choice, but stop this pointless hatred because its ridicolous. Rather you should be just telling the new guys how good old school is!

Opinions are just that, opinions

[guidemetohell]

lol seriously?

this is just sad

death to this 'im an elitist and MY OPINION IS A FACT'

I like and i listen to most band you listed as true, but i can also enjoy some of wich you listed as not metal like Black dhalia,wtf how can you compare it to lickdickshitbiscuit?. Its funny how you all new wave of haters seem to carry the word of truth and label every shit around you.

[andymetaldeth]

you know napalm death would probably hate you for calling them 'real metal' they came out of more of a hardcore punk thing

[MinistryOfProng]

Check out the new Thrash Metal band Savage Messiah, like the song He who laughs last and tell me what you think of them, I like your list, the only artist i liked on your false list was Hatebreed but i can understand why its on the list

[hilltoprocks]

@MinistryOfProng

I've heard of Savage Messiah before, and I think they're pretty good!

[bigstevejames]

@hilltoprocks ER... You could make this easier on yourself by just saying any metal that is marketed to the mainstream sucks... lol \m/

[chaclapa]

DEATH TO FALSE METAL! I FUCKING HATE IT!!!!!

[ViejoNoMeJodazZ]

MOTLEY CRUE??? WTF THEY ARE GREAT \m/

[misterkool20]

@astrip87 it doesnt suck!! and you have some music on the music you like that sounds just like the music you said you hated!

[hilltoprocks]

@misterkool20

You don't make sense dude.

[hilltoprocks]

@astrip87

Hatchet from the Bay Area? If so, those guys are fucking sick! They're one of the better new Thrash Metal bands out there haha.

[hilltoprocks]

@astrip87

I like them all. However, I only like Annihilator's old stuff like "Alice In Hell."

[milos1567890]

How come you are the only person that included power metal bands as real metal , why is power metal hated please anwser me this question .

[hilltoprocks]

@milos1567890

I guess it's "hated" because I'm guessing people don't embrace the high vocals, and that they might not like the lyrical content. Again, that's just my guess.

[misterkool20]

your a fag, you show like 20 seconds of songs you like and like 2 seconds of the so called "not metal"

[xwarlockx69]

you must be a complete tool. if TBDM arent metal then i dont know wat is.

[hilltoprocks]

@xwarlockx69

Then you DON"T know what Metal is hahaha.

[xwarlockx69]

@hilltoprocks your just a silly little boy who still thinks thrash is heavy. grow up with the rest of us buddy

[hilltoprocks]

@xwarlockx69

You're a fucking idiot! There are a ton of NEW bands that I find great, and most aren't even Thrash.

[xwarlockx69]

@hilltoprocks who? children of bodem?? die please.

[hilltoprocks]

@xwarlockx69

Decapitated, Ghoul, Impaled, Wintersun, Ensiferum: these are the bands I posted on this video.

As for other great new bands, there are just too many to name. Children of Bodom is okay, but I only like their first four albums; the rest isn't my cup of tea. So why don't you piss off you poser.

[xwarlockx69]

@hilltoprocks decapitated ghoul and impaled are sick but your still a close minded fuck.

[shartdartfart]

i touch myself while listening to slayer because it makes my eyes turn purple and my feet jizz while also worshipping the great gods of metal which is thrash metal bands but not newer bands because they are uneducated unlike me.im educated because i passed preschool but unfortunately i failed kindergarden because it was too hard.but who passes kindergarden anyway? newer metal is bad because its new and old metal is good because its from the 80s.i jack off to megadeth in the basement(my house).

[hilltoprocks]

@shartdartfart

Wow, you have such a great life, don't you? Posting this on every video makes you SOOOO COOOL hahaha.

[shartdartfart]

@hilltoprocks and posting shitty death to false metal videos makes you SOOOO COOOL.

[hilltoprocks]

@shartdartfart

It was for fun SMART ONE!

[S3hnsuch7]

The list is okay, but i darkest hour

IS metal. Black dahlia also could be.

[Slimebeast]

Why do all these nu metal bands look like punk rockers and communists. Makes me throw up.

[theberzerker81]

On the not-metal list, I can agree with all of it, except the newest JFAC and Black Dahlia releases. Black Dahlia has always been total At the Gates/Dissection/Carcass worship, and new JFAC is very Suffocation-like.

[blacksabbath0909]

Awesome list, I do like black dahlia murder though...

[bogoid]

hilltoprocks:

Two things:

First, Motley Crue and Poison are glam rock, idk why you are comparing them to heavy metal bands.

and second and more important, metal is NOT about clothes and being br00tal as servantlol said, some of the real metal bands you listed are so br00tal that actually they make me laugh. Keep that in mind.

Aside from that, most of the real metal bands you listed are good, specially the second half.

Best regards

[servantlol]

There are some deathcore bands that are just soo br00tal tat their music makes me laugh. Meaning they aren't br00tal at all.

[Ryanosaurs]

napalm death isnt metal btw

[Shrieksoftheimpaled1]

Fuck yea! Thanks for showing people what Metal actually is.

[MetalHead510]

I dont give a fuck what anyone says, if it SOUNDS like metal, its fucking metal. some sub genres are obviously better than others but regardless every band listed is a metal band

[sirdorkster]

I have flagged this video as a misleading title. This video should have been called "bands that I like and bands that I don't like."

[CrunchPuff]

@sirdorkster Exactly.

[devildolliarp22]

Most of the bands that you classify as not metal are not even intended to be metal (heavy metal). Some are Metalcore, some Hardcore, some Nu Metal. The fact that one band is famous and you don't like it, it doesn't means it's not real metal. As I can remember, there were no rules in metal; now it's full of people that close their mind to Heavy and Death stuff, leave everything else outside and call everyone poser. Too bad for them =/

[D1rtySanchezZ1]

simply jsut coz u dont like the band dosnt mean there not metal. but i do agree that limp biscut iznt metal

[Beaumain]

The conclusion is, REALMETAL has long hair and grim faces, NOTMETAL has not.

[blacksabbath0909]

Black dahlia murder are pretty good

[razor86thrasher]

dude i dont like slipknot either but i heard danny lilker of nuclear assault once say slipknot was a good band and he one in anthrax

[FaintVideos]

Since when have Linkin Park been classed as metal? You're a fucking idiot.

[AngelOfDeathLEXI]

perfect ensiferum song. :) perfect non metal list too haha :D

[RevylaBreakdawn]

Motley Crue and Poison are good bands and I don't understand why a lot of people think that they're only for posers or "false metal" like you said...