You play it really good, but you lose flow every now and then. Your fingers try too hard to hit some notes. Once you feel it, then it would sound perfect. It's already almost there.
Globally as un-catchable as clouds can be ; very sensitive.
Some unattended notes and rythmes, I guess even by the artist... But if it may shock at first, it then magically gets back in the mood and I beleive that's where the artist soul is able to make a song sounding even better.
I don't get why people compare to the original. I think he plays it beutifully and if he played exactly like the original it would have been nice, but maybe boring. He plays like he wants it and i think that is great. A musician have to play their own style and what they want themself. Others don't have to influence on their styles.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Wow you suck in comparison to the original and others out there. What the heck is the point of learning by ear when there are free copies of the sheet music on the web... -_-
talent of what? butchering a perfectly good song? He obviously has a talent for playing by ear but the end result is shit? im just trying to say what is the point of saying that you learn by ear when your music sounds awful? Now if he could play it well, that's a different story...
you need to shut up douche you cant appericite talent like his. and dude i think that any one that has your talent is blessed like shit you are amazing
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
i appreciate the talent but im just saying what good is the talent if its products are shit... you are an idiot. If you think that the music from this video sounds good than you must be mentally retarded...
None of you retards get my point... I like the song too. Yes its a good melody. The problem is that it sounds like garbage. Yea I agree he "dont wants to be the componist," but he shows that he cannot play it(everyday). This video only shows him trying to play it and that he needs to practice a lot more.
im not trying to flame u, but one of the most fundamental techniques in music is keeping a constant tempo. it is very obvious that when you play there is a choppy/jerky/swinging feeling. just work on keeping the tempo, tap ur foot or get a metronome.
regardless, i envy ur ability to play this by ear. not many people have this ability, so don't waste it!
i think you played to fast it makes me feel unrelaxed a few dropped notes is no problem
I hear but don`t care!
you must train your fingers more to make them streatchy
now you fingers are made of wood. you`ll notice you sound will get better you are oke but work your timing more en try to variate whit the pressure on the keyboard you are not a carpenter you play piano good?
I`m dutch so we complain a lot keep doing your shizzel we like it!
ok, after listening to philip glass work related to truman show and muse's song I can say that they are really similar to carly's song, perhaps carly commando was a great fan of muse and had just watched the truman movie and got inspired :)
it's kind of like muse, but if it's ripping off anything it's 'Truman Sleeps' and 'Rasing the Sail' by Philip Glass on the soundtrack of The Truman Show, when I first heard this song I was sure I heard it in a movie, and that's why. But Philip Glass is a great composer, so if Carly Comando didn't realize she did, or hadn't seen The Truman Show she came up with something great
It doesn't rip off Muse but parts of the song are really similar to the intro of New Born, but i only hear it when i play the song myself, don't really hear it otherwise
you're awesome...I just started working on figuring out this piece by heart....so this is definitely an inspiration....thank goodness she did the piece in A minor!! LOL!!!...
Hi, thank you all for the great comments. I as 16 when I made this video. The music in the binder is my collection of video game music and some classical. I can read music just fine, I just can't sight read it very fast.
good song. some thngs tho. those dont look like hands of a 13 year old. i know. i am 13 and play piano. and that binder what is it? does it have notes? i thought u only played by ear... o well. good song. i play by ear too.
i learned guitar on my own but when i took lessons im almost euroboy style now, im learning this song on guiatar, i bet if u have a piano at home u could probably learn howt o play it, if u learn where the notes r and learn to read music than u could download/buy the sheet music from her myspace page and learn it
You don't need lessons. I am self taught. I have only sat at a piano 6 times totaling maybe 3 hours of playing and I am already starting to pick it up. I'm thirteen, by the way.
the only thing i didnt like about the original piece, as awesome as it is, is that it didnt have any sort of build up to it, but rather started out at its peak. i love the way you added a sort of intro to allow it to take off, great work
Jeff, the intro is so brilliant Your playing is very fluent. The sounds of your piano are so very natural. I also learn music through ear and tone which has been giving a gift to me. keep an open ear and the good inspirational work. Thank you....
Agreed, the intro was amazing, I have probably listened to this song over a hundred times and bought the sheet music to learn it myself and I must say that the intro you added was worthy of being part of a cinematic score.
Carly said it is 7 pages long on her myspace. As you notice I did not turn the pages or even touch the binder with music. Besides, I can't sightread to save my life. I really wish I could.
good job, i think you did a perfect job. i dont know if you played it too fast, considering that dont play piano, but i must say i really enjoyed listening to you play.
what chords was the intro?
FISTMASTERRR 4 months ago
the intro sounds like something from halo.....correction the whole song dose
TheAvengedsevenfan6 5 months ago
You play it really good, but you lose flow every now and then. Your fingers try too hard to hit some notes. Once you feel it, then it would sound perfect. It's already almost there.
EazyL0ve 1 year ago
amazing intro for this all over covers just stick to the original thing but that was really good
bombfuckinhadston 1 year ago
dude epic....the intro was soooooo calming....and if you really learn that without any sheets.....then seriously you have some talent =))))
zeromanthebest 1 year ago
Do you know how many girls you can get by playing this piece? Well played, superbly played.
afsdhfilsahr48742wyf 1 year ago
gave me loads of goose pimples...thanks!
jstb0b 1 year ago
That was really good how
Sakuragurl3636 1 year ago
fantastic song and a very good piano player!!
silvio84s 1 year ago
I love the intro! you're so good! Especially for playing this by ear! I wish i could play by ear soo bad
kiwidoll2321 2 years ago
omg that was amazing!!! i love this song
mimi95606 2 years ago
amazing
rauninove 2 years ago
holy crap that was really good its touching and relaxing keep playing :)
evilmonkiesshow 2 years ago
The start bit is very enya-like. Great :)
adamswapitshop 2 years ago
wow it made me smile cuz this song bring hope thats what i think
greenlollipopandred 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Are you sure you isnt god????
Hdyberg 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Are you sure you isnt retarded????
JTheory41 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Are you sure you isnt retarded????
JTheory41 2 years ago
es maravillosa esta melodia, no se pero al escucharla siento una mezcla extraña de sentimientos, espectácular Carly.
patokitas 2 years ago
that epic intro was AWSOME
Riccio7213 2 years ago 11
MAN!!YOur so GOOD!!!Its kinda touching when u play and relaxing...5/5
Range5skill 2 years ago
this is cool and relaxing
osvas23 2 years ago
REALLY GOOD. 5/5!
EngelBros 2 years ago
touching,awesome and relaxing, deserves a 5* from me
TuskenRaider80 2 years ago
Its touching :')
TheGreat778 2 years ago 3
Globally as un-catchable as clouds can be ; very sensitive.
Some unattended notes and rythmes, I guess even by the artist... But if it may shock at first, it then magically gets back in the mood and I beleive that's where the artist soul is able to make a song sounding even better.
Very nice, THX.
dZastreux 2 years ago
heavenly!
lawgracekid 2 years ago
Great
af4029 3 years ago
Well done impressed =D
nsr180 3 years ago
thats great gj!
boyakasha88 3 years ago
Wow, you are talented. You gave me the courage to convert songs I like into piano. Thank you.
Rufftyroff 3 years ago
It's she of course ;)
And she plays beautiful songs.
TomytoNTF 3 years ago
SIMPSONS ! :D
Keviniscloud 3 years ago
lol -.-
tibiaxatao 3 years ago
I don't get why people compare to the original. I think he plays it beutifully and if he played exactly like the original it would have been nice, but maybe boring. He plays like he wants it and i think that is great. A musician have to play their own style and what they want themself. Others don't have to influence on their styles.
rasm5574 3 years ago
nice
guywithaface 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Wow you suck in comparison to the original and others out there. What the heck is the point of learning by ear when there are free copies of the sheet music on the web... -_-
ps790xps790 3 years ago
it shows talent
Aeon135 3 years ago 3
talent of what? butchering a perfectly good song? He obviously has a talent for playing by ear but the end result is shit? im just trying to say what is the point of saying that you learn by ear when your music sounds awful? Now if he could play it well, that's a different story...
ps790xps790 3 years ago
learnin a song by ear is very hard, and i think he did well considering that
stop being ignorent and just go to another vid
Aeon135 3 years ago 2
you need to shut up douche you cant appericite talent like his. and dude i think that any one that has your talent is blessed like shit you are amazing
SufferFool 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i appreciate the talent but im just saying what good is the talent if its products are shit... you are an idiot. If you think that the music from this video sounds good than you must be mentally retarded...
ps790xps790 3 years ago
what do you assholes speak of? He likes the song, and he like to play it, and i understand why. its a good melodie!!
Wheres the problem.. he dont wants to be like the componist, he just shows that he can play it. good job btw
MickeyCollena 3 years ago
None of you retards get my point... I like the song too. Yes its a good melody. The problem is that it sounds like garbage. Yea I agree he "dont wants to be the componist," but he shows that he cannot play it(everyday). This video only shows him trying to play it and that he needs to practice a lot more.
ps790xps790 3 years ago
If you look at Carly's myspace, you'll see she herself plays by ear.
thisismystory15 3 years ago
Yea but she plays it well...
ps790xps790 3 years ago
she? not he?
olkogolek 3 years ago
man
tibiaxatao 3 years ago
en la mano derecha cuando ace do si la, cn sexta es re re# mi, el ace otra cosa y suena raro nose si lo percibis
rodrigodeportes 3 years ago
im not trying to flame u, but one of the most fundamental techniques in music is keeping a constant tempo. it is very obvious that when you play there is a choppy/jerky/swinging feeling. just work on keeping the tempo, tap ur foot or get a metronome.
regardless, i envy ur ability to play this by ear. not many people have this ability, so don't waste it!
asianx13oy 3 years ago 8
i think you played to fast it makes me feel unrelaxed a few dropped notes is no problem
I hear but don`t care!
you must train your fingers more to make them streatchy
now you fingers are made of wood. you`ll notice you sound will get better you are oke but work your timing more en try to variate whit the pressure on the keyboard you are not a carpenter you play piano good?
I`m dutch so we complain a lot keep doing your shizzel we like it!
losjos 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
My god ??? what are you doind to this music ??
You had a nice start, but then... oh my...
I'm sorry, you need to practice.
shaoranhongkong 3 years ago
your a fag
SilverMTzion 3 years ago
i agree his playing brings shame to carly commando's excellent original
ps790xps790 3 years ago
thats awesome =)
iCheat222 3 years ago
Simply amazing-
Katie.
KahDeex 3 years ago
So perfect!!!!
drizzith0 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
sounds like shit kill yourself
zo0m14 3 years ago
ok, after listening to philip glass work related to truman show and muse's song I can say that they are really similar to carly's song, perhaps carly commando was a great fan of muse and had just watched the truman movie and got inspired :)
zik667 3 years ago
Mammamia tutto fuori tempo e pure le note sbagliate...
jacopotore1 3 years ago
abouslety PERFECET not to slow not to fast 5 stars
jareth198 3 years ago
this is great good job xD
xtermanater 3 years ago
for any abusers, at least he tryed, this is very good and i rate it 5/5. a talented person with a taste for sad music :'),
i do think this song is sad.
13yroldmodder 3 years ago
i love this song!!! its like the remix one!!! hahhaha but i like it!!!
thegrand13 3 years ago
i like them songs!!!1
thegrand13 3 years ago
this is among the best piano peformences ive seen
colomadri55 3 years ago 2
Great !!
kingsaru33 3 years ago
fn great
luciusbarbus 3 years ago
doesnt even looks like hes playing o.o
ToNyBaLlin93 3 years ago
AAMZING!
alwera12 3 years ago
it's kind of like muse, but if it's ripping off anything it's 'Truman Sleeps' and 'Rasing the Sail' by Philip Glass on the soundtrack of The Truman Show, when I first heard this song I was sure I heard it in a movie, and that's why. But Philip Glass is a great composer, so if Carly Comando didn't realize she did, or hadn't seen The Truman Show she came up with something great
ziggyleb 3 years ago
i completely agree, at first i was looking for this piece in the soundtrack for the Truman show
recrenton 3 years ago
GREAT!!!!
Nemkrisz 3 years ago
great song...shame it rips off muse - new born
Greendude01 3 years ago
how does it rip off muse?
prove it with a song from them
zik667 3 years ago
It doesn't rip off Muse but parts of the song are really similar to the intro of New Born, but i only hear it when i play the song myself, don't really hear it otherwise
VelmennaNinja 3 years ago
This is tantamount to graffiti. carly I'm sure, plays this with some passion which comes from her parameters of experience. You can't duplicate it.
Jubeisan1 3 years ago
It's rare that a cover of any music surpasses the emotion, passion, what have you, of the original. Every musician is different.
BUT that doesn't automatically make the cover any less incredible in its own right.
69, I think you did an awesome job :).
pocketsfull 3 years ago
im 13 and i wana start learning this! can you help? chords or something?
IceBellz 3 years ago
consejo:levantas mucho los dedos...
diesolfami 3 years ago
consejo: no des consejos
siriuse 3 years ago
very nice play......nba 4 ever:P
mhtsoukos1234 3 years ago
you're awesome...I just started working on figuring out this piece by heart....so this is definitely an inspiration....thank goodness she did the piece in A minor!! LOL!!!...
bpresley3 3 years ago
where perfect music happens
XVirusDetectedX 3 years ago 4
Hi, thank you all for the great comments. I as 16 when I made this video. The music in the binder is my collection of video game music and some classical. I can read music just fine, I just can't sight read it very fast.
Thanks,
-Jeff
69e5d9e4 3 years ago 3
Can you tell me where you got the sheet music please?
OurHighSchoolLolTeam 3 years ago
I do not have any sheet music. Sorry.
69e5d9e4 3 years ago
Ok.
OurHighSchoolLolTeam 3 years ago
Very good playing! You certainly got into it as it went on. I used to have a binder like that, but now it's grown to 5! :)
crazypianolady 3 years ago
it sounds like the music dreaming of fiji
SGASGCfan 3 years ago
good song. some thngs tho. those dont look like hands of a 13 year old. i know. i am 13 and play piano. and that binder what is it? does it have notes? i thought u only played by ear... o well. good song. i play by ear too.
marcomexican35 3 years ago
where great pianoists happen
utubefreak6 3 years ago 4
Make A Tourtorial
imaziah 3 years ago
where excellent happens
thehoomizon21 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
nice. i'm not sure but i think u messed up 2 times.
asiandude99 3 years ago
excellent job! way to go!
uncomplientspud 4 years ago 3
god! i want to learn how to play the piano so bad! my hands practically itch to learn how to play but my parents wont pay for the lessons
maxel11 4 years ago 4
i learned guitar on my own but when i took lessons im almost euroboy style now, im learning this song on guiatar, i bet if u have a piano at home u could probably learn howt o play it, if u learn where the notes r and learn to read music than u could download/buy the sheet music from her myspace page and learn it
therealsporadicaarmy 4 years ago
You don't need lessons. I am self taught. I have only sat at a piano 6 times totaling maybe 3 hours of playing and I am already starting to pick it up. I'm thirteen, by the way.
amozoness6 3 years ago
the younger u are the easier it is to learn things so dont feel all special.... sorry if i burst ur bubble little kid
sprghn 3 years ago
does that even look like a kid?
lol
evinty 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
You seem like a rather jealous person. I think I'll just continue to feel special, thank you.
amozoness6 3 years ago
u arrigant fag
joshtwilliams 3 years ago
awesoome do you have the sheet music? if you do, can you send it to me?
LeavingNipPLEs 4 years ago
One of the few who actually did the accents! Fabulous!5/5 ^_^ (I logged in just to praise you =P)
Musicfriyck 4 years ago 4
Thank you very much.
69e5d9e4 4 years ago
I love it, I am trying to learn it but it seems so hard...
darklink945 4 years ago
love this song
jeffweng8 4 years ago
hope u have a good carrer as a pianist cause i love this song!!!!
cbassCORN94 4 years ago
beautiful songs and well played
MEAST2134 4 years ago
this is almost as good as the actual song :) best on youtube by far
bilboman195 4 years ago
the only reason u should not call X-box 360 support is one reason u'll be to dazeld by the Indian Actcent
BlahBohogun 4 years ago
Thank you all for all the comments. It means a lot.
Thanks,
-Jeff
69e5d9e4 4 years ago
beautiful!
okpearce 4 years ago
epic win?
BlahBohogun 4 years ago 2
The intro provided a worthy introduction. You made an epic song have an epic introduction. Congratulations.
batterymesa 4 years ago
NBA
dyingxmonkey 4 years ago 3
the only thing i didnt like about the original piece, as awesome as it is, is that it didnt have any sort of build up to it, but rather started out at its peak. i love the way you added a sort of intro to allow it to take off, great work
pakiprince7135 4 years ago 4
that's awesome, especially considering you learned it by ear! A skill I've been trying to develop for years, but no success :(
sonic13 4 years ago 4
this is the nba commercial song!
LakerForever24 4 years ago 7
Thats the best ive ever seen play this song
Good Work!!!
Smkeybare10 4 years ago 4
best player i have ever seen
spencer7138 4 years ago 4
good work son
Hansomjoe 4 years ago 4
love it, keep up the good work!
dndeee 4 years ago 3
Fucking genius
alapakaba 4 years ago
lol loving the adjective there
brreadd 4 years ago 3
Music
alapakaba 4 years ago 2
OMG!! BRILLIANT!!!!!
Atsuko1992 4 years ago 2
very nice...i cant help but notice the funny way the black keys move when you press them
ippymcbippy 4 years ago 3
2 words. FUCKING BRILLIANT
megadeadpool 4 years ago
Jeff, the intro is so brilliant Your playing is very fluent. The sounds of your piano are so very natural. I also learn music through ear and tone which has been giving a gift to me. keep an open ear and the good inspirational work. Thank you....
D.D.T.
missyandmugsy 4 years ago
Thank you for the comment.
-Jeff
69e5d9e4 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
you suck jeff i think your so gay
tomy24274 4 years ago
Yea jeff does suck... well at this song at least
ps790xps790 3 years ago
Agreed, the intro was amazing, I have probably listened to this song over a hundred times and bought the sheet music to learn it myself and I must say that the intro you added was worthy of being part of a cinematic score.
Houdiniwill 4 years ago 7
freaking amazing!!!! i did the same thing when i play the song i add the begginning
SAVExMExJEBUS 4 years ago
Thank you all for the comments.
Appreciate it.
-Jeff
69e5d9e4 4 years ago
this song is so awsome
and this guy makes playing it look easy!!!
good job dude!!
dylan4702 4 years ago
nicely done =)
cheath1705 4 years ago
Nice job. Loosen up your fingers a little more, it sounds a little forced.
ucenigma 4 years ago 2
Awesome! I've been looking all over for the sheet music....
The0Keyboard0Kid 4 years ago
It's available on Comando's website.
MartectX 4 years ago 3
what website?
aggiezak 4 years ago
aaah....you did a great job!
myopinions 4 years ago
nice job!!!! keep on!
Benny133 4 years ago
hey
could you tell me please how to play the left hand of this song?? That would be very nice!
I know how to play the right hand, but I don't succeed in playing the left hand.
Thanks.
finzzzenz 4 years ago
Your intro set this one apart from the rest for me. Job well done.
Bidney99 4 years ago
The intro sounds like a mix between an Enya song and a song from the LOTR OST
dragonforceman7 4 years ago
It's catchy! That's why it's so bloody brilliant.
wallmunky503 4 years ago
even tho it might be easy, it is just simply beautiful... i cant find words for the beauty of this song
LevitatingCups 4 years ago 4
i dont understand how this song gets a spot on a nike commercial
it's not fair
it's so damn easy
beatleb07 4 years ago
forgive them philip glass for their sins! please forgive them!
house25 4 years ago
hey, really nice job, can you send me the sheets please?
Chiwalker 4 years ago
he might not have he has song sheets in front of him.
PvtDoyle 4 years ago
Carly said it is 7 pages long on her myspace. As you notice I did not turn the pages or even touch the binder with music. Besides, I can't sightread to save my life. I really wish I could.
69e5d9e4 4 years ago
Can ANYONE pass on the sheet music?
iZyphyr 4 years ago
SERIOUSLY!!! i really want the sheet music not watch some noob play it
andar650 4 years ago
go to her website and buy it
mothy78 4 years ago
I've been searching forever, thanks!
iZyphyr 4 years ago
the only thing that makes me angry is that i didn't create this song... even though i don't know how to play piano
magn1to 4 years ago 2
is AWESOME really good man
kilmister75 4 years ago
really good
can you send me the partition(sheets) please i really want to play this song
thanks
mirmoleboss 4 years ago
all this done by ear? wow i am highly impressed.
good job, i think you did a perfect job. i dont know if you played it too fast, considering that dont play piano, but i must say i really enjoyed listening to you play.
azntriad 4 years ago
amazing.. i like stuff that is different. covers are boring but a stellar rendition is always welcome.
jesuitprepboy 4 years ago
Can you upload the original partition and give us the links PLEAS ????
Valavatar 4 years ago
holy sm0kes this song rockz and you 2 very nice
DrMabuuse 4 years ago
you played this really good. whatever extras you added in, it was great!
<3
smilesxxx 4 years ago
he impressed me foodcomatose!!
i wish i could play piano like this!!!
dont try to make me angry foodcomatose!...i dont care teeniestatements^^
Tirrany 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
you fa990t ass douche berry. youtube doesn't need garbage like this on it. you're not impressing anyone.
foodcomatose 4 years ago
Wow. Fuck you cunt rag. You are just upset cause you cant even play your skin flute. Just go fall on a knife and stab yourself in the uterus.
At the Poster of this video. Very nice job. Well done mate.
wanchester 4 years ago
love this tune, sheet is available at myspace/carlycommando
L8nitedave 4 years ago
where amazing happens.
itsTheRemedy 4 years ago
lol, you put in cary instead of carly in the "about" section
ggalo14omega 4 years ago
Oh, wow I did not even notice. Thanks.
69e5d9e4 4 years ago