Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (184)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • David Tennant will always be my favourite Doctor in Doctor Who folks & he will also be yours as,well though hes the best Doctor ever & he will never be forgotten I bet we all look forward to seeing him at the Doctor Who 50th Anniversary in 2013 November wont that be great folks.

  • I love both Tennant and Smith. I feel like Matt brings a certain... whimsicalness(?) to the doctor. I think it makes for a more fun doctor, and I can appriciate the value of that.

  • I like Matt smith way better than the last guy

  • plus he's too young and silly and seems immature like all the time. I mean occasionally, fine, but 24/7, no

    ok I'm done )

  • no. 10, David tennant will alwaaays be the best

    matt smith's a'right he's just too...jokey. you wouldn't really think he's a 900 year old time lord and he never seems serious! it starts to get annoying! and he doesn't pull off the charm so well...maybe cus, he looks like a girl! :P I mean he's really funny but doctor who isn't a comedy!

  • I loved David Tennant as the Doctor, But I also love Matt Smith's Doctor!!!

  • I wonder how they'll bring David Tennant back in 2013

  • @Sleezy42 There is the alternative him in petes world.

  • i think that david was better that matt because matt never did that thing of never kill anybody although I must say I like matts Bow ties are cool line LOLOLOLOL XDDXDXDXD

  • @TheFionstein The Doctor has always indirectly killed someone in one way or another.

  • Hey don't steel david's text! LOL XDXDXDXD

  • Fake

  • matt smith is a good doctor, i love him.

    but then ppl are faithful to different doctors

    

  • David is superb. His Doctor was a dream, a wonderfull one. He will be forever in my heart.

  • what's the song name?

  • David Will Be Back In 2013 which is good news

  • @Hellboys2ndBro How will they be bringing him back? Do you know?

  • @Hellboys2ndBro Where did you find this out? Why? I know it is the 50th Anniversary, but we don't even know for sure if Matt Smith will remain til' 2013 (he hasn't said he is or isn't, but there are rumors flying around he will remain for that half a century of DW episode and then fly away himself)

  • love the music !

  • River Song can't be used for very long, because we know she survives well and unharmed into the Library. Putting her in danger or using her in any capacity other than to visit in a safe place (like her home) would be a false sense of danger (unless they use equally ridiculous means of resurrecting her as they did the master, which would further fail to suspend disbelief).

  • Matt Smith isn't old enough to be The Doctor, he's more like a 1st year medical student.

    Doctor Who was a Grandfather figure,

    Then later more of an Uncle figure,

    but to give the role to someone so young will I think lose the show many many fans.

  • You haven't seen enough of his performance to judge yet. From what Steven Moffat has said about him, he sounds like he's going to be a very inriguing prospect from Doctor Who. Good luck Matt.

  • My original Doctor was Tom Baker, But David brought me back to the fold big time. whilst I understand an actors needs to broaden their experience. I feel nothing but disdain for the new Doctor (and it's not Matt Smith's fault)

    Originally the Doctor was meant to be of an age where he would be a Grandfather or favourite uncle (agewise) but this is just wrong in my book. Far far too young.

  • Doctor Who is a series with an important central character, who is a cultural icon. Getting the right actor to play the Doctor is far more important than getting an experienced actor. Look at the talent that the show has brought through, like Noel Clarke, John Barrowman, Carey Mulligan. Look where they are now. If you don't try, you'll never know. Steven's tried. Will he succeed? There's only one way to find out... Not long now ... 21 days and counting!

  • I'm going to miss david :(

    although I still can't wait to see what matt will be like

  • man i love aivd tennant he's the reason i started watching doctor who :(

  • I will watch the new series and give it a chance but i'm gonna miss david. he brouht life to the character

  • Any actor that would follow David would have to be either insane or completely overconfident.... Maybe both.

    Simon Pegg would have been the only person I can think of that could pull it off.... But alas we have some weird looking virtually unknown dude. With a new head writer and this new weird looking kid....Dr Who viewership will drop. Mark my words... He will only last one season.

  • OI!

    GIVE HIM A CHANCE!

  • Okay, seriously.

    I was doubtful too at first.

    But give him a chance!

    And also, this isn't just some new head writer they found on the street: IT'S STEVEN BLOODY MOFFAT. You might recognize his name from episodes such as Blink, The Empty Child, and The Silence in the Library.

    Also see: the Fifth Doctor. Tom Baker was a harder act to follow than even David Tennant is, but somehow Peter Davison managed it.

  • I do believe Simon Pegg could have been a decent doctor, but to see whether he would be better than Matt Smith, I think we needa give him a bit more time.

    Believe me, I thought Christopher was amazing and David was also great, I thought they were almost equal in their own personalities and great acting, not sure about Matt though, just doesn't seem like he can compare to those two.

  • I dont think that the doctor will be able to be a lady killer anymore. But I trust in their choice.

  • why did you quote yourself in your own video hahaha...

  • new guy loks like a fag

  • Give him a chance o.O

  • no he's is too young and doesn't fit the roll as much as david RIP 10th docto.u will be missed dearly :'(

  • You're acting like those people who thought WTF about Peter Davison, who was after Tom Baker. Peter was only 29..when he took on the role... and people thought hes too young and stuff.. BUT he turned out to be a legend!

  • I agree with you till a point. when Baker left I was upset...But Davison turned out to be my second favorite Doctor (until Chris and David took on the role)

    That being said. I don't like the look of this new kid and his acting is very one dimensional in what I have seen him in. You are going to replace one of the most popular Doctors since Tom Baker with this moonfaced kid? Who are making these decisions?

  • i agree

  • David shall not be forgotten...EVER

  • no he will not

  • ill bet theyll doa tsubasa thing and only tell us his real name when it ends

  • I don't think it would be a good idea to give his name out, then it changes the whole point of the character, he is anonymous, but also represents the good in everyone of us.

  • yeah which means well find out when its all over like on his final deathbed or something

  • We shouldn't ever find out, he probably doesn't even have a name lol, the writers never bothered to give him a name =/

    It's just a plot device. There is no name

  • master ha d aname

    i cant for the life ov me remember what it is because i never really cared about him

    and as son as you hear it you know hes going to die

  • Trust me, they'll never kill off the Doctor :D

  • when the serie is over

    i think hes at his second last regeneration

    but itd be awsome if something like his daughter took ove rthe tardis happened

  • @c0nt3g0

    He has no limit, the Master did, but they rewrote that in the new series, they can't end the show because of a stupid plot device, they will create a loophole to allow him to keep living.

    And no that would suck if she took over the show, it wouldn't be Doctor Who anymore, and she isn't a character built to last more than an episode.

  • In the Dark Path he was called Koschei.

  • they left her story with an obvious to be continued

    they would'vejust killed her off if that were the case

    and yeah theyre limited to 6 i think it was and the dr had his limit doubled mean he has 12 lives and now hes on his 11th

  • Maybe, but they will come with a loophole to somehow give him more lives, cause they cant end the show just like that.

  • "just like that"

    its obvious that when he comes to his last life hes going to use it wisely

  • have you got a copy of the dark path? ive been after that for years. hes also called koschei in face of the enemy.

  • Nope, don't sorry

  • the masters real name is koschei and the doctor was known as theta sigma (first mention of theta sigma is in the making of dr who 1973 and also in the armageddon factor he is called theet by Drax)

  • OMG that made me cry David Tennant will be my Doctor and i will never forget him I wish he would keep play The Doctor

  • David Tennant is a great actor and His doctor who was the best of all times!!!!

  • you are gay and no he's not.

  • Your gay and your wrong :D

  • I'm sorry but doctor who needs EYEBROWS!

  • i'm not watching it when matt smith is the doctor. im not trying to be childish but nobody can be as good as david tennant and i think he was the best doctor.

  • he actually is the best doctor ever and even though matt smith isn't as good i have seen his acting and he is good enough to be a really really good doctor hes actually really good and i do understand why stefen moffat chose him now search up matt smith and check out his acting he has all the qualitys

  • u need to stop thinking of the doctors as the same character think o fthem like presidants u have u faveourite but that doesnt men u cant give the new guy a chance before u start moving to another country

  • Dont judge a book by it cover well in this case dont judge a preson by his cover.

  • galifray is dead but clue the master is coming back and on the last of the time lords he said he will only stop when theres a new galifrey in the hevens THINK

  • Galilfary not dead its in that time thing blarg

  • cant wait!!!!!

  • that was sweet. = )

  • In my opinion, I don't think Smith will be able to fill the shoes Tennant has left for him.

  • well considering matt smith has bigger feet i doubt he could.

    But anyway, it's gonna be a hell of a ride, can't wait, at least the 10th gets to see gallifrey before he regenerates.

  • what do you mean he gets to gallifrey? theyre gonna show gallifrey in the next series?

  • Gallifrey is coming back.

    Remember what the african woman said in planet of the dead, "It is returning through the dark" not him, IT, meaning gallifrey is returning.

    After waters of mars you will see it, it returns.

  • how can u tell u havent even seen a full season of the 11th dr. give me strength

  • That remains to be seen. Remember, People thought once that Tom Baker had a challenge in taking over after Jon Pertwee and Tom is the favorate of everyone. And that is how the show in itself has lasted since 1963. It teaches us not to be afraid of change.

  • I know, I was just stating that he better have as good adventures as Tennant.

  • nither do i tennant and ecelsten were the best the worst one yet was probibly urrrrrrrrr the 1st one cause he is shit and and old fogy

  • Ok, I know this may be an obvious question but...Have you WATCHED the originals?

  • shouldnt he have said "they break my HEARTS" not heart?

  • yer but that which woman preson on one of the eps stop one of his hearts and he said how can u live with one heart

  • good point thankyou

  • gosh, this video sounds like a funeral procession song for david. we will see him again in some other show. right now, he is hosting masterpiece contemporary. and we can all get our fix of david right here on youtube with all the movies and shows he has done previously.

  • Good lord, people, just because you think he LOOKS like a Cullen, that doesn't mean he's going to ACT like one. His Doctor certainly looks and dresses more like a professor than any silly Cullen.

    Darthnexus: what is the music you used here? I know I've heard it in the series somewhere but can't place it...it's goooooorgeous :D

  • Cullen!!!!!

    never mention the docter and *cough cullen cough cough* in the same sentance >:(

    damn emo vamps need to be slayed (by buffy maby :D)

  • The music is called the lone dalek it is on series 1 album

  • Totally not looking forawrd to the new Doctor. I agree, he looks like a Cullen, an that's not in any way good. David Tennant was the best, I just started watching the Doctor Who series BECAUSE of him. Farewell, David. Tee hee, Barty Crouch Jr.

  • The new doctor looks like a Cullen.

    Just saying, its almost putting me off from wanting to see the new episodes.

  • just to let people know that david is returning to doctor who in 2013 for a 50th aniversary show,i dont know if it is a one of,i dont know how he comes back,or what the plot is,he said it at an awards things,he is and will always be the best doctor who in my eyes no one can replace him,he will be missed for many many years to come,who knows if the viewing figures drop they might offer him loads of cash to return,like they did to ross kemp in eastenders..stranger things have happened...........

  • bullshit, Baker beats tennant hands down. I don't understand why they started casting younger people to be the doctor.

  • David Tennant brought something new to the word Sci-Fi, he was possibly yhe best Doctor Who EVER, he will be missed, but not offending him, he was a fool to give up being the Doctor. David Tennant is amazing at acting.

  • David will always be the one and only doctor to me. Him and maybe Tom Baker, but no one has, or ever will, play the doctor like David did. Truly brilliant.

  • I just realised, I've been so excited about a new Doctor stepping up to the plate and wondering how the regeneration will happen, that I didn't stop and think about one really important thing... I'm really gonna miss David Tennant's Tenth Doctor.

  • i love david tennant as the doctor. he is brilliant and it'll be sooo sad to see him go.

    WHY does the new doctor have NO eyebrows??

  • Thank you for this lovely tribute to David. In David's early interviews you could hear the excitement in his voice to have landed the role he was born to play brilliantly!! Big fan of both Dr Who and David Tennant. Thanks to David too for keeping Dr Who alive for me. I was 9 when the first episode was aired and William Hartnell graced our screens, I hid behind the sofa/cushions to watch! I hope to still be watching when I am 99! Still hiding behind sofa and cushions. (daleks/cybermen) lol :)

  • I have been watching Dr. Who since I was a child. I well remember William Hartnell, the first Dr. Who. He had been my favourite, but, for me David Tennant is and always will be THE Dr Who I love the most. I will really miss him, he gave he role character and believability, appealed to a wide audience and I really hoped he would change his mind and stay with the role. It will never be the same, for me, when he leaves. Good luck David for the future, perhaps one day you will return, Who knows?!

  • o cmon.. i dont want some pretty boy posing to be the infinitely knowing doctor :'(

    well i dont know bout the rest of yall.. but im gonna miss David

  • i think hes going to be amazing! but david will always be my fav....we'll just have to see

  • I was not happy about Matt taking over.  But after seeing an interview with him, I've lightened up a lot. He's not David, but he'll be fine

  • Matt Smith does not look very doctor-y

  • if you've seen his pics for doctor who in character he looks very perfect for the job

  • till i see his performance, i cannot say, but david tennant is the best looking doctor for teh job

  • meh, david tennant was my first doctor and will always be my favourite doctor

  • the should have picked someone older

  • They should have picked Mark Gatiss, not that 13 year old.

  • Oh were you in the audition? I think not. Give him a chance.

  • but every time he regenerates he gets younger

  • Incorrect :p

  • crap it was crap

  • well when the doctor does change into matt smith, they open up a new door to bring rose and david tennant back into the series at some point since there wont be 2 look alikes now

    heres to hoping

  • goodbye tennet :(

    hello emo bastard >:(

    honestly the was the casting derector high when matt smith walked in for an interview?

  • i actually REALLY wanted James Nesbit to be the doctor:/

    ahhh welll

  • Karen Gillan is confirmed as the new companion. Great two people i don't know filling my fav tv spot

  • Wow this music gets me everytime !!!

    and associated to david's depart of the show, wow I'm in tears ...

    Thank you for this magnificent tribute !!!!

    And Thank you David for being such an amzing, sparking, clever, wonderfull, lovely, molto bene, fantastic ... Doctor !!!!

  • He looks like a spazz

  • What music begins at the one-minute mark? It makes my heart drop every time.

  • I liked the rumor that john simm was the next doctor better, at least hes coming back for davids last ep so thats something I supose

    great vid

  • I have to admit, I choked up a little at the bit where Ten is riding in the balloon with the First Doctor's speech as the voiceover! So powerful and really connected all the Doctor's incarnations.

  • he isnt the next dr john simm is its gonna be mad as

  • love the bit were the first doctor says he's famous speech

    really makes the video really powerful

    David was a brilliant doctor and you r my dr

  • matt smith is really ugly

  • matt smith is going to be brilliant! steven moffat casted him so i know hes going to be really good.

  • just coz im right u throw a spacker lame!

  • LOL!

  • spoilers for what exactly?

  • The Eleventh Doctor Revealed

  • love the bit were the first doctor says he's famous speech.

    really makes the video really powerful

  • Oh and by the way.. if you watched Doctor who from the very beginning--- the console room would change time after time with each Doctor. So um yeah it's been ongoing since the 60s.

  • Meh Doctors come and go, I have to agree, but this was a nice tribute. Peter Davison will forever be the best Doctor ever, as well as Patrick Troughton and Jon Pertwee. The new Doctors can't even compare to those guys. Sorry, but it's true. But David was brilliant as the tenth Doctor. and I am willing to give Matt a try... Tom Baker was a goofy looking Doctor, but no one cared- why should looks matter???

  • Actually Tom B aker is he number one most popular Doctor, followed by David Tennant

  • I agree with u.David was a brilliant doctor.

  • this made me cry... however i am holding onto the fact the human doc is still out there

  • Davids not even left yet , whats the point of making this ? uploading it after his left yeah , but not before ! .

    " Good Grief " as Jon Pertwee would say .

  • y do u always have to be a dick:!?!

  • they cant change the tardis look the chameleon circut got destroyed its always gonna look like that! i dont want david to go he's the best doctor ever and to be replaced by that silly bastard is so stupid

  • WHO THE HELL RATED THIS +1??? SILLY BASTARD????? YES YOU ARE MATe!"

  • Goodbye david. You were the greatest DR. You are my hero.

  • the video was pretty good, the new doctor is so ugly ,david was the best and will alwaays be the best

  • UM... david tennant is a scranw necky git with a face thatd make a stone gargoyle run for miles! (cracks fingers) :|

  • ill miss david... :'( But even worse there Giving the Tardis a Makeover!!! It will look completly different on the inside and there even Changing the Police Box look slightly!

  • 1:23-i suppose...they break my heart.-cryyy!!! im going to mis david as much as i missed chris. they both were -fantastically brillant- :). bon voyage to two of the awesomest doctors.

  • Welp, there goes the series... :(

  • man, i'm gonna miss david tennant...

  • I never knew much about the 9th doctor, ididnt understand how he regenerated or anything like that.

  • Rose looked in to the heart of the TARDIS and absorbs the time vortex which was killing her, the Doctor (9) kisses her and absorbing the vortex from Rose but he has to regenerate because it was killing him too.

    you shoul really watch series 1. Christopher Eccleston was the best (actually a tie with me).

  • i meant the one before cristopher, the 8th doctor i mean....

  • oh (good!)

  • that was pretty good, but i didnt see any spoilers...

  • this video is brilliant

    the music is really moving

  • colin baker was my lease fav doctor

  • one thing I will miss is Doctor 10 nice buns that means his ass looks fine

  • looks like the final nail in the coffin of my tolerance for the new series

  • her's an idea watch the show and see what the guy is like before you judge him

  • no way am I waiting one and a half years. that said I'll probably watch it anyway

  • i argee

    everyone is going to compare him to david tennant which is wrong because every doctor is different

    matt smith has got a hard job to convince people he is good enough for the roll of the doctor without the added pressure of being compared

  • good video :]

  • Aw damn. I wasn't even sad about David Tennant leaving but you managed to make me tear up! :(

    I know I'm going to cry when he does regenerate now, even though I'm really excited about Matt Smith and think he'll make an excellent Doctor. <3

  • David was the best!

  • The music is called "Lone Dalek"

  • he does look like herman munster, but I think he'll be good or Moffat wouldn't have cast him as The Doctor, The Doctor is supposed to look weird and odd, David tennant was just too picture perfect.

  • that was touching. what is the music?

  • Get a grip.

  • I will miss david=C

    He was awesome because he was funny, awesome, and wore awesome clothes! Matt looks more...serious and his outfit looks like a mixture of the 9th doctor(i forgot his name) and David's

  • Christoppher Ecceclston

    I have seen Matt in a cupple of films where he was fantastic in his role and I think his got a great sens of humor but I don't think he is gonna be as good a Doctor as david and I will miss David a lot cause he is the perfect Doctor but I think Matt is going to do it in his own spicial way and that is great and maby he is what we all need to get over David

  • David Tennant was deffinatly the best Doctor out there...the new one is too young and i dont like his hair,lol....im going to miss the old Doctor.

  • When it was announced that Chris Eccleston was leaving ppl were like.. David who??? remember that? Now he's become the greatest Doctir since Baker. Tom that is. Remember when Tom Baker left ... ppl couldn't get let it go until Davidson stepped up and made it his own? Lest we forget.. Tom Moffat is a brilliant writer. I'm sure he'll guide young Mr. Smith (another irony) into making a classic Doctor. I will miss David...but I am ravenously looking forward to spring 2010.

  • No one can ever be as good as David tennant in my opinion! Love you David :)

  • I'm sure Matt will do a great job too. just give him some time

  • This guy looks like Rocky from the movie "Mask". Hideous and alien looking. Maybe he is from Gallifrey.

  • LOL! ohh yeah.

  • good buy David Tannet

  • Good Buy? Was he on sale?

  • nice one. It's good BYE! Plonker

  • Well, I'm betting they got him cheap, but the resale value, wow!

  • Okay, why did this post here? It makes no sense now.

  • When i first saw him i didn't like him that much, but now i don't think he's that bad a looking doctor.

    Love the Music. Where's it from? sounds familiar

  • Nice video!

  • Hes Fugly :(

    So Diserpointed

  • He's the youngest actor in the role to date. Until they announced him, the youngest had been the fifth Doctor, Peter Davison, who was 29 in 1981....