Added: 3 years ago
From: 2dannyc89
Views: 12,610
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (36)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Notable que se hayan atrevido a tocar esta canción en un país donde estaban todos vigilados por los terroristas de la CIA. Nixon culiao, genocida asqueroso.

  • great song. very rock and roll for s&g. i do think it would fit on the album tho, definitely no less than a "baby driver" or "keep the customer satisfied". But still BOTW is such a great album, its hard to argue any different song choices. like i said, great song.

  • lyrics anyone?

  • Would they sing now "Gaddafi Si Obama No"? Bob Dylan was right... The times they are a-changing.

  • There's a reason this song didn't make the album. Thank God for someone with common sense.

  • Paul Simon now acknowledges that Garfunkel was right to insist that this not go on the "Bridge" album.

  • @leon723

    Who the f ist Garfunkel?

  • Brilliant! I've been dying to hear this. Man I wish it wouldvd made the album. Missed classic.

  • @ohfoolishworkerbee I think the same way as you do :)

  • @ohfoolishworkerbee From what I read, it was a pivotal dispute between Paul and Art. This nearly ended up on "Bridge", but Art and (I think) the producers insisted

    it would minimize the perennial sales strength of the album. Many probably

    wouldn't argue.  But it's a great number. Big staple in the live '69-'70 shows.

  • I find it hard to believe they would break up over this song, as I've sometimes read. It's actually pretty lightweight.

  • @mtopper66 I read their biography, and it seems they broke up mainly because they both started to have other interests (as in trying out newer sounds and also Art's acting career).

  • I would have found to so much harder to like them if they had put this song out.

  • As I heard it, Art and closer advisors vetoed Paul's intentions to include this

    on the "Bridge" album, claiming it would

    threaten the album's future saleability,

    making it less perennial. Guess they were right...!

  • This track just proves that you can have all the musical ability in the world and still be an idiot.

  • @Kickingit06 This post shows you can write and still be an idiot.

  • Thanks for posting. When I saw them (quite a few times) they were absolutely non-political. This is a nice surprise.

  • Nice collection of rare tracks. Do you have the full album of this concert, because I've only been able to find half of it.

  • Dommage quelle soit sortie sur l'album.

    Elle est trop bien

  • excellent !

  • who is singing ? Paul only or both ? It is a great song.

  • Just paul, apparently art didnt like the politics of the song and wanted nothing to do with it.

  • @2dannyc89 No, he didn't like the easy way to bring that message across, he agreed with the message, but thought that this wasn't the type of music S&G were all about.

  • @CheezzHeat I can see why he felt that way. This sounds like Jerry Lee Lewis.

  • Always enjoy to the rock and roll songs by Paul Simon.

  • I forgot!!! THANKS YET AGAIN & BLESSINGS!!

  • Great sound quality, and what a jaunty and terrific song!! I love the demo version of "Feuilles-O" & I think both would have added unique and varied textures to what is already as fave an album as I can think of. I'll be curious to hear if "Groundhog" would've been worth it too. I know my mom had the Peter Yarrow album ("Peter") it's on, and I heard it as a kid, but I can't really recall it at all. I look forward to hearing it again. What is your opinion of the extra BOTW songs? Blessings!

  • cool song

  • This is amazing. You really got a rare find here. Paul dumped the song with Art's suggestion from the Bridge album.

  • My mom told me she was at this concert. She went to Oxford

  • Oh that must have been something. I met someone who told me that he saw Simon and Garfunkel in concert. It was just two voices and a guitar.

  • I just read an old interview from Rolling Stone with Paul Simon, and he says that Grafunkel didn't want to release this song and that he wanted to do "a Bach chorale thing" instead.

  • has anyone heard the Bach chorale that they didn't release?

  • Well, American Tune is based on Bach Chorale. I think u mean Feuilles-O which was released on a re-released bridge over troubled water album.

  • Art put a traditional song called feuilles o with a Bach song on his solo album. the lyrics were by his then-wife, Linda Grossman

  • thanks for the info. Yeah, I knew that some of the chords in American Tune was based on a Bach chorale. My music teacher told us that! :)

    I've heard the rereleased Feuilles-O song too. I guess I was thinking that the song was actually going to sound like a Bach Chorale.

  • yeah just look up ART Grafunkel Feuilles-Oh/Do Spacemen Pass Dead Sould On Their Way To The Moon and you'll get the whole thing. i uploaded the osng on to youtube the other day.

  • Wow

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more