Charlie Brooker's Screenwipe: Question Time.

[pockthehairy]

there is deaf initely no audio

[Idlevice]

Rather than listening to the song and liking it, I am now of course going to purchase it on the basis that I've not heard a fucking note of it. Makes perfect sense.

[ImahGoer]

Copyright can suck my dick.

[notsotupelohoney]

I think it's important to keep it up. It shows just how stupid this issue has become. Fifty-three seconds is going to break someone's pocketbook? Whoever did this deserves to lose a lot of money.

[gabiotta]

Fuck copyright.

[Xenctuary]

SILENCE

[rickyoswald]

uh, wtf bbc?

[LAnonHubbard]

Just take the video down FFS and stop wasting everyone's time.

[steveigog]

I dont want to be a dickhead but why keep it up?

[thejb1978]

yeah man

[ServantOfAllah0264]

This is unfair

[mellowNdark]

YAWN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[smpowis]

Yes, let's block the audio on a clip that isn't even a minute long, because everyone who so much as listens to this video from 1000 miles will become a scum-sucking leech for being that little bit more happier in a world full of dreary, money-grabbing fuckwits working just that little bit harder to make your lives miserable. Access Industries, you're a bunch of pricks - good day.

[superwin930]

FFFFFFFFFFUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU­UUU

WHY?

[SillyIrishPenguin]

Why not take the whole fucking video down anyway? Who's going to sit through a section of a comedic show with no sound?

[Beccar217]

FUCK FUCKING FUCK!!!

[bonnie43uk]

the audio works ok on my laptop, .. Charlie Brookers point was well made and extremely funny.. in fact, probably the funniest thing I've ever heard in my life.

[rbfett]

Instead of complaining here go to the WMG site. Click contact on the left side, and have at it. Pretty easy site to find. dub dub dub wmg and that dot com thingy. Flood them with hate male...probably will not make a difference, but it will at least annoy them, and it's certainly better than just screaming about it on YouTube.

[rbfett]

@rbfett LOL Hate Mail even....I'm an idiot, but don't you all be. Go have some fun yelling at a big cooperation for real.

[xXjessiexnimXx]

can you not just subtitle it? or will they get you on that too? "ohh, noo! you can't type any more! we've copywrited that! ... and freedom of speach"

[kiSHness]

Wow, this is terrible. I was looking for this on YouTube so I could share it. The soundtrack is what makes this segment so hilarious.

[sonnyjimslim]

Whey hey the bankers have taken away the music, what dya want next, our souls

[ignoranttwat]

ACE OV SPAYDZduhduhduhACE OV SPAYDZ!!!!

[lordpharris]

Parody is fair use isn't it?

[mankillsquare]

Come on, we've all heard Ace Of Spades before

[Probablyacowtbh]

brb stealing more albums to make up for this raped vid. Up yours, WMG.

[VincentBrooke1]

WMG = Weapon of Mass Greed...

[845mrm]

@053bss Dickhead

[jackhartcup]

thus why people illegally download everything

[4TehLulz]

@jackhartcup Yeah, because everything isn't free, that's why people steal stuff. Shit, you must be a goddamn philosopher.

[jackhartcup]

@4TehLulz really should change my user name

[sheepeasy]

This reminds of Charlie Brookers comments on the aspirational TV episode..

Wmg... FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFUUUUUUUU­UUUUUUUUCCCCKKK OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF

[morrismagic08]

Not authorised? Iv pay'd my TV licence you greedy money grabing capitalist FUCKS!! what more do you want?

[Transpersonals]

"This video contains an audio track that has not been authorized by all copyright holders. The audio has been disabled" it's someones job to be a cunt. There are cunts and there are people. The cunts have to have shit jobs that pay well. Oh well, we'll live in a cuntless world someday. I hope. I'm a signed musician, but I'm skint because I give my music away, and I don't give a fuck, cos I'm not a cunt.

[tommusthecountryman]

@Transpersonals You can't see me, but I'm raising my fist. :)

[LessthanJake14]

This video contains traces of fair use policy and must therefore be removed from this content-generating website. Instead of asking you to reupload it without the track, we've decided to use illegitimate actions to fuck your content up the rectum without any lube. More about anal-slamming policies here.

[antcuth85]

fuck it you know. ill just download it. atleast on youtube you can get the hits, but now you will get nothing!! man cant keep me down, the net always finds away!

[willjonesuk]

Go here for the undestroyed version V7O65dk3SeQ#t=0m47s

[SeanAKnox]

How incredibly annoying. Fuck you, copyright... Greedy money grabbing bastards.

[gamerunknown]

@SeanAKnox

Read it in Brooker's accent

[noklarok]

fuck you warner group music, i am going to try and avoid buying ANY of your music

[chrisjoneschrisjones]

capitalism rocks!

[MrMorgansgoat]

WMG SUCK MY COCK

[LordCustard]

Looks like this section needs a WAAAmbulance.

[beastatlay]

"This video contains an audio track that has not been authorised by all copyright holders. The audio has been disabled."

Great strategy, record companies. There's absolutely no way that I'm now going to log on to Mininova or TheBox to get a torrent of the entire 30 minute show now that you've stopped me from watching a 53 second clip.

Well done. Award yourselves another gold record and line of cocaine.

[tvandbeermakehomergo]

copyright claims like this will be worse in a few moths time when MP's put through the digital econermy bill - designed for the fatcats!

[oscarelgy]

'not been authorised by all copyright holders' ?

somebody is biting the hands that feed them

[atomicbreaker]

Whoever disabled the audio should die!!!

[DainBramageStudios]

no thanks!

[rickrenny]

why?

[Lazzars]

those evil bastard, leaving my the video but taking the audio. totally makes the video pointless doesn't it. i think that's where the copyright protection guys are going now, just taunt us because we can't do anything to stop them. evil evil evil

[alltat]

Except just reposting it elsewhere.

[magicadd]

this is a featured video, yet it's got no audio because they disabled it....makes sense...

[prnorth]

this seriously sucks arse

[metalebd]

This video contains an audio track that has not been authorised by dipshit fuckstick copyright holders. The fucking audio has been disabled rendering this video completely fucking useless. For more about copyright visit WMG's stupid fucking website and call them stupid cunts.

[razaz03]

here here!

listen when this man speaks!!

[urzzz13]

@metalebd To fucking right mate, all this copyright bullshit is pathetic

[Boardy1846]

@metalebd

Are you Charlie Brooker???

[killalmostwise]

@metalebd and the fact that it's a BBC programme makes it even more ridiculous....we've already paid for it!!!

[mmmzeitgeisty11]

@metalebd took ur advice, it turns out the phrase 'stupid cunts' is copyrighted and now im being sued

[Razza1091]

@metalebd Said like Charlie Brooker himself :)

[ChickenMOOO]

@metalebd YOU ARE KING.

[wixy20071]

@metalebd HAHAHAH! :D

[MistressQ]

Oh great, WMG is even fucking with Screenwipe now *headdesk*

[053bss]

CAPITALISM IS KILLING MUSIC

[1brettsnyder]

not capitalism. but it is dying

[psychodave0]

yeah, being able to fund the vast amount of money music costs to make is totally killing it. The government should just decide what good music is for us. It's nothing to do with outdated business models, people who expect things for free, and bad copyright law.

[yellowcougar18]

@053bss

Capitalism is at the centre of music, always has been, so it created the music first. The fact that music is dying means that Capitalism has failed.

[temporaldisplacement]

@yellowcougar18 lol, sex 1st, then capitalism ...does this mean sex has failed. HA! in your face; people you ever get laid!

[ignoranttwat]

@yellowcougar18

I know you wrote this 9 months ago, but...really?

[yellowcougar18]

@ignoranttwat Well look at the recent demise of Guitar Hero, DJ Hero and other music based games.

Capitalism takes everything to be a product. Whether it is human life, or creative output, such as music. What this means is record companies want to make money off of music, by targeting demographics. Think how Elvis was promoted. He had an image, and he could not veer outside of that image. For example, in a movie role his character was to hit a woman, yet Elvis, would not do it.

[yellowcougar18]

@yellowcougar18 The reason being he could not seperate actor Elvis from real Elvis, and knew this would tick off his fans. If fans get angry, they wouldn't pay to see or listen to him. He also would not die on film, because it upset his mother so much the one time he did in a film.

Anyway, Capitalism is killing music. Why? Because they only see demographics, not actual talent. Shows like XFactor and "Insert Country" Idol are creating cookie cutter singers. Good music id dying.

[ignoranttwat]

@ignoranttwat

...rather it means that Capitalism has succeed in making a commodified, consumable version of music, devoid of any sort of intellectual or artistic merit. Capitalism is consuming us all.

[Mulitfrog]

@ignoranttwat Based on your name, all your comments are invalid. Way to go

[SlimeTron5000]

@Mulitfrog Takes me to know one

[Mulitfrog]

@SlimeTron5000 Trolls trolling trolls.

[SlimeTron5000]

@Mulitfrog keyboard?

[killazofjo]

@053bss Capitalism is killing everything

except capitalism of course, that would be silly

[AphoticCosmos]

@053bss Nah, capitalism is killing Charlie Brooker. Just as bad.

[tommusthecountryman]

@053bss I got my dancing shoes ready to dance on the music industry's grave, to music that was made with passion and artistry instead of money.

[2gentrs]

@053bss IDIOT

[053bss]

@2gentrs Step from behind your computer screen and say that.

[Plantman67]

@053bss Wouldn't say that - I would say whiny bastards are killing music.

[Howieeeeex]

@053bss More than just music...

[jackm24111859]

@053bss It's not capitalism thats killing music but government protection of capitalism thats killing music.

[soupalex]

@053bss Home taping is skill in music!

[Snow8Man975]

Copyright bastards!

[666rocko]

oohh yeah lets ruin youtube for everyone

[yair20]

youtube is becoming shit innit? no audio, what a bloody joke.

where are we, china?

[COTDEATH]

PUBE SALAD

[monkeyboy85]

one day soon I hope the Itunes servers and everything required to bring it back get put in a truck that accidentally falls off a cliff. off topic I know, lmao

[DJEdSaunders]

WMG = CUNTS

[vikingmog]

WMG fucking musical nazi BASTARDS

[mittens50]

FUCK YOU WMG

[XtraMinty14]

We should upload every goddamn video thats had the audio removed or taken down because of copyright. That will show WMG and all the other bastards out there. I don't care if I get IP banned or such, ill just get behind over 9000 proxies. You big corporations have declared war on the internet. You cannot possibly win

Also, the game

[nameshaveallbeenused]

fucks sake

when are they going to slap some itunes advert at the bottom and put the audio back on like with pretty much every single other video

[Deathugee]

oh just FUCK OFF WMG!!!!!

[squigian]

'not been authorised by all copyright holders'...

Look, WMG, we're not stupid. Everyone here hates you already so there's no point hiding your pettiness.

[Nomis90000]

poor show wmg

[rustybeamer]

Soundtrack to this clip available by searching this site for "Charlie Brookers Screenwipe S1E1P2"..............Clip is 10.10 in total....the bit you're after is appx 1 min in.

[countevil]

wtf they removed the sound track. Might asw well take the whole thing down as that was crucial to the joke.

[AirportMonkey]

Fuck you WMG

[BigWoodyAllen]

BBC : Brown's Barbaric Control

[FollicleMiracle]

Barry Shitpeas: That was like amaaaaazing that was like soooo good. That is like theeeee best acronym like wow like that is just amaaaaazing..

[voltage17121712]

Errr, what?

[clyrenternal]

i like boobies

[tomdragontattoo]

erm... all copyrightholders? that'll be just the one then... the pissing bbc... i pay you fuckers, stop being fucking dicks

[tvcrunkfool]

yeah i do pay my tv liscence for a reason

[87bri]

its not the BBC's fault its whoever owned the song that played with the video

[Perki]

It's not the BBC's fault you tit.

[Hellotheres]

It's probably actually been disabled automatically, by mistkae. if the guy petitions it, he'll get his audio back.

[MarxBakuninMe]

Isn't this a BBC show? Don't we pay for their channels? Didn't we pay for the . . . erm, copyright of the song?

[dannymc18eire]

But we didn't pay for it to be broadcast to the world for free.

[MarxBakuninMe]

Yeah, well, it'd be nice if the Beeb could keep these episodes on the iPlayer for a bit longer.

[ximono]

FUKC THE ANCIENT COPYRIGHT LAWS

[Perki]

FUUUUUUUUUUUUUU-

[richie2291]

Reading the comments below people aren't too sure who's to blame for this so i'm just going to have stick a big FUCK YOU to whoever is responsible and hope they read this comment and the others that correspond with mine.

[imhallowarren]

Fuck copyright

[dunstanofgreen]

cunts

[Heatliex24]

WTF?!? FUCK WMG

[Anonymous1986]

Fuck WMG, gonna have to torrent to make up for this

[joepickard]

WMG can get fucked, they're like the Goldman Sachs of Youtube

[sanguinus]

Mmm... well technically WMG don't hold the rights to the soundtrack of this video. The music was licenced by Endemol, and therefore WMG can't step in and start submitting claims of ownership over the material.

[pippynip]

Licenced by Endemol yeah, but for TV, not youtube.

Then again I don't know much about the whole licencing process.

[myloverisbillmurray]

wot a waste of fucking time, id rather have been rick roled

[7584695]

FUCK YOU YOUTUBE AND WMG

[LovelyBill]

Oh you've got to be fucking kidding me youtube. Is Lemmy really kicking off about this?

[pippynip]

No, artists don't really have much of a say in how their music is used AFAIK. Most likely it's the record company.

[rustybeamer]

To see this clip with sound then search for 'Charlie Brookers Screenwipe S1E1P2'. It's a minute or so into the clip. The only way this one will be copyrighted is if someone comments on it.....oh crap

[OgleCorp]

Cheers man.

[Edward306]

this is crap

why?

[BigOrang10]

Greedy fuck copyright causing more problems than it solves. Copyright for music has grown into anachronistic, excessive bullshit that the vast majority of private citizens and businesses are better off without.

[thegoodcocklife]

This is taking copyright to the extreme, i mean a 53 second clip of motorhead, how is that stealing music?

[harshbutfair1]

Deaf people are laughing now!

[GenericInsect1979]

How the fuck can warner music group copyright this vid? It isn't even music.

[Soundfrequency]

If we don't watch here we'll just watch it somewhere else!

You can't stop us all!

[theredtinkerbell]

Shut the fuck up WMG, you twats.

[JackGlands]

Up yours WMG!

[LovelyBill]

Up YOUR WMG.

[JackGlands]

Oh dear oh dear.

[LovelyBill]

Sorry, I couldn't resist.

[choclitrayn]

Fucking copyright, fuck you

[AlexMikic852]

oh yeah cause watching the video without audio is actually better than just seeing a black screen with sound. ..... not. at least ive got my audio preview down here, i might as well re-invent the sound to waste time like you've wasted mine already!

[haydenhaydenhayden]

Yeah Warner, remember your a friggin economic entity, not a person too!

[blueminerva]

Wow, this is making me want to go and spend money on official, licensed Warner music.

*stifling laughter*

[CallumR56]

Load of fucking little piss-weasels. We paid our licence fee for that!...well, not just that, but Screenwipe is the only watch-able thing on the Beeb.

[PrivateCustard]

Yep, that confirms what I already knew.

Warner are a bunch of festering cockblisters that really need to sort their fucking lives out.

But they can keep Madonna.........less of that cunt is always a plus!

[danspare]

wtf

this was one of the best videos man

cunts, what harm is it to you?

[sortedm]

Warner doesnt own this video!

Maybe some of the music perhaps, but even then the beeb would have used it under license and I pay my damn license fee :(

Fuck Warner and fuck the US music industry.

[boffyb]

None of my videos have been authorised by Warner, I demand you mute them all immediately!

[Perki]

For fuck's sake Warner.

[vortexguyz934]

Get a fucking grip Warner, you stupid cunts! Stop ruining youtube!!

[VivaZweiFan]

how about you black out the screen too you fucking WMG cocks!

[Lazyguy22]

But the song was in the original show and was presumably paid for by the BBC.

Fucking Warner.

[ahdkaw]

Hold on, this is BBC production, so I have every right to listen and watch this, I pay my TV licence.

[SaqibAKAScarface0786]

Warner can fuck themselves.

[xproblematique]

Fuck Warner.

[comaninezero]

wmg need to suck a dick

[cloudstrife90110]

death to WMG!!

[soulofshiver]

Death to WMG!

[lollylopz0r]

love how they synced the song to the intro/zoom shots of the speakers on the panel! :D fantastic!

[vitalogy]

hilarious

[LazersFromJimmy]

ken livingstone and ken clarke on the same show! I'd watch that even without the motorhead intro. Although its mostly shit with shit no-name speakers talking about shit boring things and 'what we should do about iraqistan' and dimbleby moves on when it gets interesting. And the public are depressing cunts.

[Brenho]

here fuckin here

[Tehmolez]

No. They added a gutair sound to theme tune

[manladyyasser]

lol, they always wanted to appeal to the younger audience.

I wonder what the response would be if the BBC actually ran this intro just the once?