Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (198)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Really good.

  • thats a wrap everyone good job

  • Wonderful job all, just beautiful, you did well here!

  • Really nice cover. Sonya and Shuie did a great job with the backing tracks. Really well done! What is y'all's recording setup?

  • Absolutely perfect!! What a field day for us all!! :)

    xo Paula xo

  • Excellent Gil.... sounds real good!

  • Great job, awesome cover Gil, Sonya and Shuie! A timeless tune and you guys did an amazing job

  • SWEET!

  • Very Nice Gil

    Thanks For Sharing

    Keep Smiling.

  • Be there or be square!

  • How many fricken times Gil did I tell you about Add &fmt=18. Never. Hey you are great as always.

  • Loved it Gil. Thank you! You had me strumming along with you up here in T.O. Very exciting news 'Buffalo Springfield' playing at 'The Bridge School concert in Oct. 2010.

  • You done a great job with this song and you have the voice for this song as well. I love this song and do it in my band as well its one of the greatest song ever recorded.

  • Dam good job on this song dude...I like ther back up too

  • Nice cover of a great song

  • Hi Gil,

    nice playing very beautiful sound,great music.

    Can you explain in a short clip,the strumming and slam down from the song "For what its Worth".

    Its the E and A you play there?

    When you hit the low string i almost got it,need another clue.

    Thanks mate.

  • Hi Gil,

    nice playing very beautiful sound,great music.

    Can you explain in a short clip,the strumming and slam down from the song "For what its Worth".

    When you hit the low string,i need another clue

    Thanks mate.

  • gil i am definitely a fan dude that was nice

  • A Song to End ALL Wars.

    Thank you so much for sharing...

    As-salaam-alaikum. (Peace unto you)

    Namaste (The light in me; honors the light in you)

  • fantastic!!

  • Beautifully played. Beautifully sung. You interpreted the song in a very clear and faithful way.

    Thanks.

  • wow 1 of the best covers ive heard n along time nice job my good sir

  • wonderful.....fan from India

  • Luv d sounds, carry on bro

  • Brilliant Gil !!!!!

    5******

    Thanks for sharing

    Keep Smiling

  • lovely to come back to ..where have sonia and shuie gone...??

    great cover Gil ..fantastic harmonies too ...;0)

  • Wow! You are very good! You have an excellent voice!

  • You, my good sir have a talent!

  • Usually cover versions suck but I think this sounds ok

  • You fucking raped the song :O

  • nice job . .when I do this song solo acoustic I let it ride right into 'After The Gold Rush" . . I goota vid session comin' up . . maybe I'll put it on there too just so you'll can see how cool those two songs sound together . . notwithstanding my horrible rendition there of . . .

  • very nice job folks

  • Very nice job! I remember when the original came out, and this is every bit as good as that. Kudos!

  • nice job...

  • AMAZING, AMAZING, AMAZING !!

  • Great work! I think you turn up the original too much as the song comes to the and. But otherwise really good.

    I suppose you wouldn't have anything to hold against me if I used 80 seconds of your piece for a little homemade-documentary I'm doing.

    You will be fulli quoted and linked to. The fact is that I really wonted that song and your version is the BEST I found that WMG (Warner Media Group) doesn't consider its copyright.

    Of course 5 out of 5.

    cheers

  • Very good job...well done!

  • very good.

  • Nice dude, Really gd 5 stars!

  • Excellent!!!! Well sung mate -good backing track as well very professional.

  • Excelente mi amigo!!!!!!!

  • What a great song and an exellent job on it!

    Great groove.

  • are you sitting on the toilet? stop whats that sound, everybody look whats going down...It's a turd.. I figured it out.

  • great job ty

  • muito bom

    BRASIL

  • Well done.

  • This is a great cover Gil

    5*****

    Thanks for sharing

    Keep Smiling

  • Great Cover!.5 Stars!.Thanks Man!.

  • classic ....and classically covered

  • damned good done !

  • 19.999 views!! Blooming Heck!

    Bet you're thrilled with the veiwing figures, Gil.

  • great 5/5

  • so nice

  • great cover mate! 5/5

    cheers from aus

  • very sweet. kudos.

  • outstanding job man

    10/10

  • 10/10 for sure bud excellent job!

  • I dont know if im the only one that thinks this but you look like a mid-aged johnny cash. and that was awesome man great job 5/5

  • just magic, great effort by all.

  • superb just superb

  • What a wonderful cover!!! YOU'RE REALLY GREAT!!!

  • etwas langsamer aber sonst ganz gut

  • nice job

  • one the best covers ever

  • Wow she really got the electric sounding like the original on this (but better). :)

    Good job everyone. 5 stars.

  • this is an amazing cover for an amazing song... can't get any better i don't think.

    nice one mate

  • Great

  • wow great job thanks

  • i found this guy on chordie. This is a REALLY good cover 5/5

  • This sounds so amazing!!!

  • Add &fmt=18 to the end of the URL to listen in high quality. It will sound even better.

  • Thanks so much for reminding everyone. I did give a link in the description but am never sure if anyone actually takes the time to click it. The &fmt=18 version totally opens up the sound and reveals what a great job misspopanoche did.

  • Not a problem(I figure this will help them with other videos too). Anyway, I agree, it seems like they did well in the production category. You did a really good job too, which is a lot coming from such a picky audiophile such as myself. I think you added just enough of your own sound too it while still keeping the songs original feeling and emotion.

  • @g6120s Hi Gil,

    nice playing very beautiful sound,great music.

    Can you explain in a short clip,the strumming and slam down from the song "For what its Worth".

    Its the E and A you play there?

    When you hit the low string i almost got it,need another clue.

    Thanks mate.

  • woah what a difference

  • fuken awesome cover man !! real talent

  • hey man you played that perfect and it sounded great, 5 stars

  • That's really great man, I love that song, and you played it perfectly 5 stars

  • This one really deserved a comment: BLOODY WELL DONE!!!! I love the song and remember the day I first heard it at Monterey Pop. This really does it Justice. Good cover!

  • Pro all the way!!

  • In general, I never listen to covers on youtube. But I have to say, this one is really amazing! Well done.

  • Hey thanks for listening! They did a fantastic job adding to my solo acoustic recording!

    Check out our other collab I have posted as a video response to this one. Cheers, Gil

  • Yeah! Wicked Gil, I love this one!

  • well done! great cover :D

  • awesome!

  • Well done!

    It´s totally amazing. Is it made without postproduction?

    However, much better than original.

  • Awesome cover of a great song!

  • amazing

  • wow at first i didn't think it would be that good but good job

  • great job man and an amazing tune. Historic!!!

  • i can hear this again and again and again :)i love it

  • bellisimo!! five stars!!!

  • Awesome sound, great harmony.

    This Rox

    5*****s

  • bella rappresentazione!

    Giuliano

  • That was brilliant!!

    5 stars...(wish I could give it more)

    Cheers,

    Shane

  • Loved it, loved it, loved it, and I liked it, too!

    Aegan

  • Thanks, Gil.

  • complimenti ciao amico

  • Very Cool, Gil and friends. Enjoyed this very much. Classic song that you treated with respect. Your own, but still very true to the original.

  • good !!!!*****

  • Totally awesome, i mean it, this is fantastic. the harmonies and music work so well and this is a great tribute.

  • I love this song, well done job mate!

  • Excellent Gil.Thank You!.*****!.

  • That is really great, but how did you get your video in my subscription box?

    I don't aprreciate that, a lot of people are doing that to me. You are great though.

  • Stopped, looked & listened to this extremely exquisite tribute!! Love your talent to peaces!!! Paula

  • Great Cover People!!!!!

  • That was very nice music & vocals 5 *****..Marc Jones-Vocalist..Los Angeles,U.S.A.

  • Honors for this video (2)

    #27 - Most Discussed (This Week) - Music - United Kingdom

    #36 - Top Rated (This Week) - Music - United Kingdom

  • ho bro that was good. 55555

  • Gil, Sonya,Shuie, '' Great cover, Awesome tribute'', for 'Dewey Martin' (RIP)...Thank You!

  • Excellent Gil, You have much talent!

  • Fantastic!!!

    Grandma Mary

  • Sonja&Shuie, hope I got the names right

    Yeah, Bbufflow Springfields sound were

    terrific, I'm a big fan of Neil Young, although the complete band, well, each person of the group, did amazing work on their own. Thanks for you video. Silviogold

  • A really fine collab. Glad to see there are still folks out there trying to keep the true spirit and intention of Youtube going.

  • I actually spent about three weeks one time obsessing about an accompaniment for this song on one Guitar

    ( trying to incorporate the drum pattern and hint at the lead line and harmonic rakes).

    What I'm really trying to say is that I LOVE this song!

    Brilliant collaboration folk's! (Thanks for the share BigBen)

  • Very well done. One of my favorite songs of all time.

  • Gil thats a jam up collab.sounds great;peace[Freddie]

  • wow this is cool i know this song-...awesome

    good vid-.....really great

    greets

    ender

  • A song for the ages from a song master for all times...truly a classic...three thumgs up!

  • Great playing and singing

    All round song five*****

  • Great guitar playing my friend and a lovely vocal performance 5*s from me :-)

    Mark....

  • Honors for this video (8)

    #65 - Most Discussed (Today) - United Kingdom

    #9 - Most Discussed (Today) - Music - United Kingdom

    #77 - Most Discussed (Today) - Music

    #36 - Most Discussed (This Week) - Music - United Kingdom

    #36 - Top Favorited (Today) - Music - United Kingdom

    #76 - Top Rated (Today) - United Kingdom

    #14 - Top Rated (Today) - Music - United Kingdom

    #45 - Top Rated (This Week) - Music - United Kingdom

  • This is lovely ! 5***** Thanks for sharing . Keep Smiling

  • excellent job on this tune . thanks to bflat for the share . i give you five stars

  • aweesome job

  • Gil, Sonya, and Shuie...

    Excellent effort on this timeless classic!

    Gartel

  • Thanks Gartel..

    Gil sings it great, doesn't he?

    I always enjoy his stuff

    ~Sonya

  • I agree, I loved it!! You mean to tell me this was all put together by Gil, Sonya, and Shuie? This was increddible, I'd love for you guys to cover my song "Another Angel Will Fall", I can hear you doing a fabulous cover on it, or anyone of my many songs I have posted....You are all that bloody great!!! Mark

  • loved it!!

  • Awesome! Thanks Carol for sharing

  • thanks too bflat this was a awesome share freaking awesome job bro

  • That was fantastic! You all did a super job on this song, it sounded great! Bravo to all involved! ... FrAnK (★★★★★)

    (Thanks Carol (Bflatblues55) for the share)

  • Awesome! Thanks Carol for sharing these great people with us.

  • Sounds great Gil :o)tm *****

  • Thanks Uncle!! Great to hear from you again!!

  • This is wonderful! Thanks Blatblues55 for sharing this with me! Awesome tune! 5*****!

  • Yes it is and Sonya and Shuie did a fantastic job on this!!  Thanks!!!!

  • This is just great !!!!! 5STARS

    Thank you Bflatblues55 for sending.

  • Thanks so much!!

  • Ohhhh.... an all-time fave for sure. Really brings 'round some harsh memories from 'the era' ... those were surely some of my biggest 'growing' years, emotionally.

    BEAUTIFUL PLAYING ALL AROUND. Fabulous vocals.

  • Thanks for sharing this!!!

  • I was a child in 1967 just starting to discover rock music! Thanks for the comment and thanks so much for sharing!!

  • Whoot whoot, Gil, this is an awesome cover.

    If I heard this on the radio, I would have thought it was the original.

    endless starz

    hugs

    Di

  • Thanks so much Di!!

  • That was a really great collab, Gil & Co., and what a powerful song!

  • Yes it is!! One of those timeless classics that marks an era and even trancends it. Thanks so much!

  • Excellent. It's all pretty amazing how close the sound and performace is to the original, but it is still a unique rendtion. My goodness. -Ron

  • Hey Ron, It's quite amazing what you can do via email, isn't it?

    We were so pleased Gil liked it lol - fiddlin' with someones recordings is quite a daunting task at times.

    Whats our collab gonna be then? LOL

    ~Sonya

  • Lets do a Stephen Stills sometime, eh? :o) "Love The One You're With" perhaps, or something else we can all holler a little bit on :o) -Ron

  • Thanks Ron! Sonya and Shuie really did an outstanding job as I knew they would!!

  • Excellent!!!

  • Thanks Jim!! Sonya and Shuie really did an awesome professional job here. You should here the full resolution WAV file. It blew me away. YouTube just cannot do the audio justice.

  • Bufflow Springfield is still

    "heavy", this edition is right on, Neil Young

    isn't ever going to "burn out, nor rust out", as he sometimes' says. Yeah this is a good sounding tune. Silviogold

  • Yeah, I made my reply a #10 for this audio/video, of Buffalo Soringfield, my favorite of the group "is Neil Young", but all the rest of the boys are still right on. I can say "I was there", in there time. Silviogold, got that name given to me from my Angel, from a song by Bob Dylan

  • Silvio has to be one of my favourite Dylan songs!

    Thanks for commenting on our collab!

  • Thnanks silviogold! This was their biggest hit and still remains relevant today. A true classic. I first became a Neil Young fan in 1974 then went back and got all his earlier work. Became a huge Buffalo Springfield fan too.

  • #15 - Most Discussed (Today) - Music

    #68 - Top Favorited (Today) - Music

    #16 - Top Rated (Today) - Music

    #73 - Top Rated (This Week) - Music

  • gil sorry for the delay...:)

    this is so great...you and the gals sound amazing...xx

    5***** and many many more...xx

  • Thanks!! Sonya and Shuie did an amazing job!

  • great

  • Thanks so much!!

  • Outstanding collaboration! I love the song and the way you do it. Endless stars!

    BTW...the video HD is on the bottom right.

  • Thanks a lot!! And thanks for listening in stereo!!

  • Amazing Job as usual my Friend

  • Thanks Sherif!!

  • #14 - Most Discussed (Today) - Music

    #62 - Top Favorited (Today) - Music

    #17 - Top Rated (Today) - Music

    #78 - Top Rated (This Week) - Music

    and well deserved !

  • Thanks Becky!!!

  • I say, that was awfully good all round! ty MissPop, for sharing :)

  • Sonya and Shuie are awesome!!

  • How beautiful. Very beautiful. I admire and congratulate. Thank you

    Alicja

  • Yes it is and all because of Sonya and Shuie's fine work on this!!

  • Wonderful cover Gil...

  • Thanks so much!!

  • that is really cool, to have so much added to your work like that!

  • Thanks! Sonya and Shuie did a masterful job!

  • Bravo! Larry applauding wildly here!

    ★★★★★ & Faved!

    -Larry

  • Thanks Larry!! Appreciate it! I knew you'd like this one!

  • Simply excellent! Oh you guys did so awesome with this! 5*****

  • Thanks so much, Jane!