At Seventeen

[Whalekiller4life]

ha i agree, to hot for this song

[Malocosa]

Ha, the preview pic had me thinking it was Audrina Patridge. Like she'd be singing lyrics "like ugly duckling girls like me..." LOL

[WakkoXtreme]

she could sing this song wile doing a gang-bang porn , would be great = D

[jarofants1]

Better chance for this girl in the porn industry she can't sing. Like to see her in a porn film though.

[simysam]

@LovelyYTRocks How does she look like a slut? Haha, she doesn't. How could you say shit never happened to her? Do you know her personally? Didn't think so. You have no idea what could have happened to her, anyone can feel that they aren't pretty enough, and as a huge fan of hers, I say she does have passion AND soul. Maybe not in this song, but you can't judge an artist on one bad performance.

[loneone01]

i don't know... it's like if aretha franklin sang a song about battling anorexia... the message is lost :P

[ReminiscenceS2]

she seems as if she's acting...

[Tonidoesit]

she has nooo clue

[Dedeurklink]

wtf is wrong with the guitarplayer? he just can't?

[jovialduke]

aside from the context of her looking like a floozy she can't sing for shit. it's that whispery, whiny excuse for singing that passes these days.

[geebeeman1]

@jovialduke  I totally agree on your comment! This girl can't sing!!!!!!!!

[threewheelsbetter]

girls like her back in the day stole all the dick from janis ian

[smokeytripper]

@threewheelsbetter

Lmao! I love your comment, it's so true. Hot dog down a hallway? More like, a pebble down the Panama Canal

[LovelyYTRocks]

She looks like a fucking slut. No wonder she can't sing this song. Shit never happened to her. She has no soul. She has no PASSION.

[xbears3304]

What are all you people talking about? She's too good looking to sing that song? It's not like she wrote it and is sending YOU a message about her life. Take it for what it is; a hot chick doing a cover of a song way before her time. BRAVO

[toneythetigerrr]

MEAN PEOPLE...PREVIOUS COMMENTS...REALLY? WHAT HAVE YOU VENTURED LATELY?

[426Feather]

Love her. :)

[FredericaBimble]

It's a bit hard to listen to this when the singer doesn't know what it actually feels like to be that person.

[fxtrader92]

@FredericaBimble That's what I was thinking. Here's a stunningly beautiful girl who's singing of being an ugly duckling.

I'm guessing someone really messed up her mind when she was younger to plant that belief in her head. Some beautiful women do believe their ugly.

[FredericaBimble]

@fxtrader92 - That is so very true but this young lady is simply singing it because that is what the producers and directors of the show picked out for her. In her case, it's nothing "personal" which makes it even more incongruous.

[tony00165]

Can't help making comparisons can you!.....A sweet girl but the quiet intensity of janis Ian can't be bettered..Even Celine Dion doesn't do it justice. Listen closely to the words and you feel as if someone has been reading your mail and this song was written about YOU!

[GodisLove1934]

In my opinion she is too good looking to sing this song

[Gatsby999888]

She's good. But actually too beautiful for the song to have full impact. Although I suppose anyone can have these inadequate feelings inside no matter outward appearance.

[suushi10]

She's not that bad, is she? I am satisfied enough with her performance.....

[IheartVolleyball1]

haa i lovee her.. and i thinkk she actually sounded good... so dont like be all hobo-ish and say she sounded gay :(

[crabtrap]

all fluff no stuff

[imprezton]

She has no right to perorm this song. She has never experienced the gutwrenching loneliness and rejection these words convey. Pitch is horrific, too.

[fxtrader92]

@imprezton You don't know her history so can't say what she FEELS in her heart. Some beautiful girls believe their ugly - abuse, etc.

[VanillaRice24]

She does seem forced. Also, learn how to play a guitar. Much more impressive. A lot of people can "just" sing.

[Youtoo2128]

Wow she sucked! That was awful! Dificult to watch.

[rollzvalle]

wow... a new version... i like it... :)

[jap102189]

WHAT!? Song is totally butchered! and this bitch is whp the song reffers to!!!! maybe she was trying to get a pity vote making us she thought she had a complex.. pft! Suck on that! alalalalal!

[qxw66]

u pretty

[wiwq]

she herself is "beuty queen" HOW THE HELL SHE DARES TO MOCK THIS SONG?

[mollkatles]

@wiwq - do you mean like how some mock the way English is spoken and spelled? Is that kind of mocking you are referring to?

[saadddd4]

exhausting. Butchered!

[duckmanx88]

just terrible/ butchered

[jonboy7777]

she suks

[kwickenbe]

This sounds a lot better than what passes as music today

[karenegross]

i don't think so. yes, it does sound a bit weird when she says "those of us with ravaged faces", but I think the song works for anyone who ever felt awkward, left out, or FELT ugly- a lot of pretty girls have low self esteem. She gives the right amount of vulnerability for this to work.

[bobmax59]

bravo miss,and +

[Blooberry95]

GO CANADIANS!

[jamanaha]

For some odd reason, I want tacos.

[IheartVolleyball1]

@jamanaha

LOLOLOLOLLLL I LAUGHEDD SOOO HARDD AT THATTT LMFAOOO TACOS <33

[cAnEmArU]

@jamanaha hahahahahahahaha xDDDD

[gabbyrandomm01]

I MET HER YESTERDAY! ♥♥♥

[ilovewheatiesbiatch]

not badddd

[hennerz16]

I think she is doing far more better without the title of canadian idol.

[charmerci]

It's such a powerful song - but each time she sings, "...ugly girls like me..." well...a switch comes on and says, "no way!"

[hannaremnant]

She's so pretty that it's hard for me to believe her emotion in this song, but I guess I'm being a little superficial.

[tdwp0920]

who won this season, cause she should have won by a landslide>

[WOWTODAZ]

wow canadian girl!

[kentuckythursday]

one of the best canadian idol performances ever! love it!

[skipper8257]

Great song with such a cutie singing it.

[hunnykay]

God I loved her... she puts sooo much into her music too, I mean she seemed so affected by this song...the power behind it... soo great

[scince220]

In my opinion... The best voice ever on CI.

[anime2192]

such a stunning girl

stunning voice

stunning song

[antoniodcz]

why isn't this singer more famous, this is a beautiful version of a classic song.

[asinnis]

Her cd is coming out soon. Her first single is getting radio play now its a cover of "Sunshine on my shoulders"

[munkiimonster]

seriously? or is that just a rumour?

[silverwolf9399]

i saw the song on itunes

[moonshinegirl420]

it's true, same with her song tug of war- it's actualy another cover as well, and also the name of her C.D. It has been in stores since Sept 30th

[perfectestperson]

tug of war is not a cover. sunshine on my shoulders was the only cover on the album. :)

[moonshinegirl420]

Oh haha, I thought it was a cover song too

thanks :)

[mtchair4me]

A very haunting interpretation of the piece. I like it.