Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (248)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I think Mad World song have been perfect here, just like Dom in Gears of war 3.. R.I.P Fred

  • To everyone who says JK went to far with the deaths of beloved characters:

    THAT WAS THE POINT! She said so herself, the second half of Deathly Hallows is a WAR movie. NOt everyone lives! Makes it more of an impact to the audience when their favorite characters die! I think she was a genius for killing off more than one! It made me cry and it was brilliant!

  • Why Lupin and Tonks look like flat+ pancakes lol

    But no really this is sad.

  • thumbs up if you think this is the saddest scean ever

  • How can voldamort say Harry should feel ashemed I mean Harry said it him self in deathly hallows part1 he didn't want any one to die for him in nevilles speech he said that Fred lupin and tonks didn't die in vain they died trying to save enasint people from voldamort and his death eaters they died trying to make both worlds safe for muggles witches and wizards Fred is a hero and will be in our hearts for ever

  • Voldemort pretty much saved George's ass. When Voldemort was whispering she stop attacking him as his wand flew away. She was also trying to do a killing curse. R.I.P. fred

  • Any1 else know that Ron was supposed to die hmmmm

  • @awsome556 i know ron was supposed to die

  • i cant breathe from crying!

  • @19abbaa I pity you.

  • I had to keep skipping the creepy voldemort whispers because I feel like that + Fred's death is too much for one video D<

  • The masochim attacked me. Seeing this, makes me cry like there's no tomorrow. R.I.P. Fred, we love you<3

  • Amazing quality, thankyou for uploading this, it's the saddest moment in the film for me :'(

  • In my case when I saw the fifth movie I just stopped watching harry potter, because i think it was to dark for me and by seeing that JK R just killed fred...like Sk8erDude3325 said, its just too far, and i tough that killing sirius was also too far he was my f*cking favorite character! so by seeing a scene like this...i'm just glad I abandonned Harry potter.

  • @19abbaa One of the many thing why I'm PROUD of JK Rowling: She was never really scared of killing characters.

    It would've been way too perfect if no one died.

  • @TheBelieberDiaries yeah you're right but the only 2 characters i care about are sirius and fred. harry potter would have been one of my favorite movie series if they were alive at the end but i understand your point.

  • too many dead !!!!!

  • No NO NOOOO! D: WHY

  • dear fred,

    i miss it when you'd finish the other half of my sentence.

    -george.

  • Who are the people at 2:28?

  • Why Fred? Why, J.K. Rowling, why? Why not Percy, no-one really liked him!

  • Too far jk Rowling. TOO FUKING FAR :((((

  • 2:19 one of the patil twins is deatb?! :'(

  • I'm a guy and I got teary eyed

  • Didn't cry a single tear, I didn't understand much of it. :l

  • @Flipray2009

    It's actually quite better in the book. The movies didn't give characters justice.

  • I HAVE to fastforward through this scene. I don't like getting my heart re-broken. :'(

  • Voldemort has sunken lower than gravity can pull us. Dx

  • I cant stop crying! R.I.P Fred x

  • Crying my eyes out!!! :'(

  • The tears wont STOP flowing!!!! stop crying me! stop crying me!! oh dammit my books wet...!! ='(

  • i just read Fred's death in the book i am crying more than ever </3

  • Voldemort you so bad!

  • Yo it dosent show how Fred,Tonks and Lupin accualy died

  • @animevampire161 so what they still did!!!!! *crying*

  • @cutekittens6 ya it says how they died in the book

  • The actor playing Fred was asleep when they shot this scene haha :)

  • :'(((((((

  • it should have charlie! no one cares about charlie! well then again he helped harry and hermoine with norbert. okay then it should have been bill no one... oh yeah he got married. okay then Percy! No one cared about that, oh yeah he fought with fred and made sure his body was safe. well maybe it should have been draco! no on cares... ugh fangirls. well who should have died in his place then? draco's other friend goyle/zabbini?

  • who was the person dead that was next to prof trelawney and that one chick

  • One of thoes twins died not fred and george but thoes girls

  • @krrboo Have you read the books? Neither of the Patil twins died, and Fred did die as a matter of fact.

  • @krrboo  no it was pavarti's friend Lavender Brown

  • *cries so much*

  • LUPIN nooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!

  • IM IN THIS SCENE!! i was an extra in the film!! im at 2:14 im the loner!!! got such a fright when i first saw da film cus like im in it!! :) prudest day of my life!!

  • NOT FRED ANYONE BUT FRED

  • Oh god, stop crying, stop crying, just stop crying *gives up and keeps crying*

  • <3

  • how dare you deatheaters how dare you.

  • i cried when remus lupin and nimphadora tonks died TOT

  • LUPIN!!!!!! NNNNNNNNNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

  • i cried harder at lupin and tonks

  • @EnchantedTower Yeah he did when he saw Tonks and Lupin

  • how come they did not show freds death in deleted senes

  • When I saw Fred, I was THIS close to crying.......then I saw Tonks and Lupin and that's when I gave up ;(

  • @MaemiSaemiNaemi13 i know same :( and there hands were touching too ! :(

  • They should've really made this longer, but it was really sweet when I heard about Oliver breaking down over seeing his brother even pretend to be dead. I loved Fred! I just can't imagine George without Fred, it just doesn't make sense! And Tonks, too! Augh, why do all my favourite characters off things have to go and die!!

  • thsi movie was the worst harry potter ever

  • @hflgoulart your the biggest faggot ever.

  • @DeltaTeamClan so as you....no... You're probably worse---- What I said was truth...the "magic" of harry pottter died on this movie...alto of main char died.... and the "horro" as grown

  • When I read this I bawled. But when I actually saw it, I felt sick. Not in a bad way, I think this scene was perfect. But it was FRED! I didn't want him to die, but it was him or Luna. I love them both:'(

    Also, if they were going to keep Luna in the end, couldn't we have at least got end-game Luneville??? Unfair.

  • FRIGGN WHYYYY WHYYY FRED WHY COULDENT IT BEEN BILL OR PERCY OR CHARLIE!!!WHY!!!!??!!!

  • @AuroraDee99 Originally the one who die will be Ron.

  • no matter how many times i watch this i always cry

  • WHY COULDN'T HAVE BEEN PERCY THEN I WOULDN'T HAVE CARED well i would care but it wouldn't be sad like freds death i love all the weasleys

  • i just cried again, this scene. No :'(

  • how come they did not shoe freds death in deleted senes

  • i can tip fred and george had tricked voldemort into death

  • They shot it at an angle that George's misshapen ear wasn't visible.

  • Fred's death was soo sad and upsetting :(

  • :( Man, Harry didn't even shed a tear. How Disrespectful. Their all doing it to help him.

  • @EnchantedTower After the shot of Lupin's and Tonks' bodies, look to the left on Harry face. You can see a tear near the right side of his mouth.

  • @CwapThePlatinumOne I think that's sweat.

  • I wonder what would happen if one very smart Hogwarts student brought a gun to school. I mean, after all, Harry Potter does take place in recent times.

  • Snape died?

  • Gegen diese Gänsehautstimme im Orginal, hätte Voldemort in der deutschen Syncronisation auch gleich ganz normal reden können^^

  • this is so sad. :(

  • NOOOOOOOOOO thups up if you like remus lupin and tonks

  • James Phelps tweeted that the Weasley who was disarmed was not Fred but George.

  • "You have fought valiantly..." this line will not get out of my head till the day that i die :P

  • :( ;(.

  • at 0.20 that could be fred just before he was killed or george, who was saved from death because of voldemort's call to retreat.

  • in a way i'm kinda glad that they didn't make a huge scene about fred's death. i know it was hard for oliver to do and it was really genuinely hurting him and that's why the scene was so short but either way i think i may have thrown myself off a cliff if it was any longer.

  • @sophmeister303 what do you mean it was hard for oliver what happened and why is the scene so short?x

  • @MegaMissymee i mean it was hard for liver to see his brother dead. it made him think of what it would be like if his brother died and it got him really upset between takes. they were planning on doing 12 takes so it would be longer but because he getting quite distressed they decided to have just a few making the scene shorter.

  • what happens at 0:20?? Xx

  • Who knew? As we saw in Sorcerer's Stone, Fred was like," I'm only jokin' I am fred!" He didn't knew that later in his life he would die a tragic death in the war. He made the most out of his life, making fun and laughter. He could have done more things, but SCREW the War! >:(

  • There's so much in this scene and the last two movies that anyone who hasn't read the books would brush off or not understand. Parvati and Trelawney crying over Lavender for example, Percy's sudden return, Tonks and Lupin's relationship [and Teddy] and so much more.

  • @xangryyemmiix158 True that. It makes me glad I've read the books.

  • you have no idea how much i cried at this when i was watching the movie:'(

  • That voice freakin creeps me out

  • Poor Freddie and definitely poor Ron my dad read the books and he told me what happened to Fred before the movie was in theaters

  • I bawl every time I watch this:'(

  • Freeeeeed :'( Why Rowling? WHY?!

  • It may have been best for impact to take out Fred's death, but I still feel as though true fans would have appreciated it in much more.

  • It's just a movie, he's not actually dead. It's just a movie, he's not actually dead.... *breaks down in tears*

  • @XxOhSnapItsSofixX thats what i said to myself about snape, but im still crying

  • *sobs* This damn part always gets to me!

  • I cried when Fred died :'(

  • @74hungergames74 me too!!!

  • @74hungergames74 i did when lupin fred and snape died :(

  • at 2:58 did it show sirius black and one teacher dead man i thought those two died in order of the phoenix

  • @fatcookiesftw it shows tonks and lupin who both died at the battle at hogwarts

  • @koddaver1 Awww lupin died

  • @fatcookiesftw That's Tonks and Lupin -_-

  • Voldemort's voice sounds seductive, dontcha think?

  • @PopLuverGal that is cind of loosing yourself I never thought of it that way

  • I feel really bad for George. Since theyre identical twins, its liike losing half of yourself

  • @alex25314 I was wrong it was goblid of fire

  • @alex25134 no not goblid of fire order of the phinex

  • @alex25134 it was a fake file she's a smart gal to make on and put it at the cort place in the order of the phinex.

  • @Alex25134 agustus rockwood it tells you that shes dead in the goblit of fire but it turns out she isn't.

  • Voldemort's voice so terrible :( and ı'm crying !!

    google translate terk :(

  • Oh yeah they said in a interview that it was to much anxiety for Oliver ( George ) to watch his bro pretend to die, they said that the original plan was to show Fred's death.

  • Who kills Fred?????? I know it's just acting and I know for a fact that he fell asleep while they were filming this but I still can't help but crying every time I see this!!!!!!!!! I love the weasley twins!!!!! R.I.P Fred

  • @alex25134 he was killed by an exploding wall.

  • @alex25134 Was Bellatrix

  • @alex25134 i read the book and i think it was that blonde guy in the minstry. y'know the one who telling the undercover ron that his office was raining. im not 100% on that, so dont go completely by me

  • you can tell mr. weasley could barely look at fred. seeing ron kneel down n mr weasley just looking away from it all.

  • @cooleymovies you mean Percy? Yeah, he was a terrible son until the battle of Hogwarts. J.K.R says that she kills of people so that Harry and readers experiences loss. A lot of her relatives died, so I guess she wanted to transfer her pain of them dying to Harry. Though, I agree with you, why did she have to kill off such significant and good people? Like Fred, Dobby, and Sirius?

  • @Arulez12348 For that exact reason likely. Why kill characters that no one cares about if you're trying to get your readers to experience loss?

  • @4everlilbrunette1996 yeah, and Dobby, and tortured the Longbottoms into insanity, and Sirius was a brother, or cousin or something because Bellatrix was on his family tree, and her last name used to be Black, right?

  • jk rowling i hate you why did you have to kill fred i understand someone needed to go why not the one that worked for the ministry no one liked him

  • . R.I.P. Remus and Tonks. )':

    Poor Teddy. He'll be like his godfather, never having met his parents. But he'll be raised by people who'll love him.

  • Lupin was killed by Dolohov and Tonks was killed by Bellatrix. I hate Death Eaters :( they're always killing someone!!

  • @Arulez12348 I like Bellatrix as a charater, she's awesome. But its horrible that she killed Sirius. And Tonks! Her own niece! :'(

  • @Arulez12348

    Ya Sadly They are Ugh!

  • I'm bawling my eyes out :'(

  • I like it to hear voldemorts scary voice!!

  • creepy

    

  • i hav a question.....how did lupin and tonks die???

  • @leacharms101 Duelling Death Eaters.

  • @leacharms101 It isn't mentioned in the books, but J.K.Rowling said in an interview that Remus died first, killed by Dolohov, and then Bellatrix murdered Tonks afterwards :'(

  • Fred is my overall fav character......how could he just die? PS in the book they were trying to kill Fred and then they hit a wall and it fell on him and them they shot him

  • @bscore Nobody shot him in the book...

  • Wait whos the two around 0:22 that died ? *sry kinda a new potterhead n havent seen the complete saga yet :3

  • fred :((

  • It looks like the lights more blue then green, so i don't think that that was fred at 0:20

  • @martyw1712 If the twin we see sitting helpless on the floor is Fred, then they made him die a bit like Sirius who was hit by the killing curse but kept moving for 2-3 seconds before passing away. They bent the rules since that curse kills instantly. That should be him because the spell is green, even though the effect looks more like a disarming spell. If not, it's quite a BIG mistake. Either way, the book is quite another thing. And way better. Fred didn't die cowering.

  • All I hear is George (Oliver) sobbing and it brought tears to my eyes... WHY COULDN'T THEY HAVE PUT THE REAL SCENE IN. I understand the anxiety Oliver was going through... but...

  • I'm glad I've read the book

  • they should have done more the ginny actress cause shes just standing there not doing anything. her brother just died and she akwardly standing there with a blank expression. thats a really intense scene and shes making unbelievable

  • Killing James and Lily - Fair point you need that to get a good book

    Killing Sirius - Woah.. don't see why you had to do that

    Killing Dobby - Hell n'awh :@

    Killing Lupin - You are actually kidding me :((

    Killing Fred - Right that's it! You're actually dead to me JK. Rowling -_-

  • @GeorgieSaysRawr lol i agree. fred was one of the best characters

  • they should have showed how he died!

  • At the theater i bawled my eyes out, fred was my favorite weasly <3

  • I dunno why I keep watching this scene, :c I always end up crying my eyes out.

  • That depressingly sad moment when hogwarts lost the best defense against the dark arts professor they along with his metamorphmagus wife who was 13 years younger than him.

  • dnbstreet fred is the ginger one that died and his twin george was crying his eyes out and same as ron the youngust

  • sorry, *twin

  • wow. the movie without the twins? D:

    Even characters from the very first movies die..

  • @TiannaRox2 I know!

    I wanna cry! D:

  • Gawd, I hate how Ginny is just awkwardly standing in the backgroung while everybody is crying their heart out, even Fleur D: !!!! Book's Ginny where are you?

  • @FlashakaViolet

    Book Ginny=<3

    Movie Ginny= -___-

  • @FlashakaViolet thats what im saying. she kinda ruined the scene for me because it looks just like an actress not knowing what to do

  • @FlashakaViolet She probably doesn't know what to do..

  • @FlashakaViolet But I hated book Ginny to D: *around fifth year to seventh*

  • @FlashakaViolet

    well ever1 acts diffrently when they find out a loved 1 is dead :(

  • sob r.i.p Lupin and Tonks

  • NO!!!! He's not dead.... He just sleeping? YOU UNDERSTAND? HE'S SLEEPING PEOPLE!!!! I CANNOT HANDLE SEEING ONE OF MY BELOVED TWINS DIE!!! THEREFORE HE IS NOT DEAD!!!

    -cries hysterically- He's just sleeping.... He'll wake up......... He's sleeping,

  • I was upset on freds death :( and i felt so bad for ron i saw the movie it was great but upseting

  • @jgibbons221

    i dunno, Avada Kedarva maybe ?

  • how did he die?

  • @jgibbons221 In the book, Fred was killed by an explosion possibly caused by Death Eater Augustus Rookwood.

  • @jgibbons221 wall got blasted apart

  • I can't believe Fred's dead D: and Remus and Tonks ):

  • nnnnnoooooo not fred then its just george

  • Fuck You Voldernmort!!!!!!!!

  • Poor george and the actor that plays him oliver omg I feel bad for both of them his charactor and himself

  • Fred.... Remus.... Tonks.... *sobbing* :'( </3