Personally, I prefer softer voices than this as I believe it suits Mulan better. This is why I prefer the song in Cantonese than in my Mother language of Mandarin or than in Japanese.
I'm sorry; I have really not been impressed by any of the Japanese dubs of the Mulan songs. The rhythm works a lot better than in Honor To Us All, but this time it's the singer :I I'm retarded at critiquing music, but it's like there's parts in the chorus where she holds the same sound when she should be varying it a little. The Lea Salonga version is still my favorite, but Coco Lee did a great job in the Mandarin one, too.
@anythingnew that's weird, because those languages in fact sound different, use completely different sounds... I don't speak any of them and I'm from Europe and I can tell the difference.
Their pretty similar dude seeming as they are all asian langauges of course they are going to sound the same. Stop trying to differeitiate between asians.. asians should be united now none of this I'm this asian or I'm this kinda asian YOUR ALL THE FUCKING SAME!!
@Dimitri0809 wat the hell are u saying? Of couse there are different asians. what if ur white and someone told u all caucasians are the same? THEY'RE OBVIOUSLY DIFFERENT. a French person and a German person are completely different. why dont u go back to educate urself before making a fool of urself here.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
this version sucks!! the japanese language is broken and stupid and japanese women are trashy whores. this song is so much better in arabic and mandarin
@bigman1171 I think the only reason you left that comment was to prove to us all that you are a fantastic troll, and also to prove you're a flaming racist against japanese people. Well, I think we got the message.
Why don't we all thumbs his comment down to show how much we hate him? He'll probably enjoy it.
@bigman1171 Well the floor is certainly yours. After all, I'm SURE you've been to Japan twice, studied Japanese for three years and took a complete Rosetta Stone course like I did, right?
I think once you've done all of those things you can start talking. For now, I'd keep my mouth shut.
@bigman1171 what the hell do you know about japanese people? i've met some japanese people before and they're the nicest people ever. at least they respect others which is something you seem to lack.
il giapponese è molto simile all'italiano xD
PazzaLaCapa 1 week ago
beautifullll<3
larki12 2 weeks ago
She sounds too old in japanese!!But it's still a beautiful song
Machiruda59 3 weeks ago 2
with this scene alone, i would have said it was set in japan XD
lawrencealcantara 3 weeks ago
WOW!! Sounds WAY better than the English version!! :D
m1hoffman 1 month ago
LOVE ! French fan :)
VahineTahiti212 1 month ago
My fave version
PolishCutie93 1 month ago
Lovely! I love and can now sing both reflections in English and Japanese
nickie083100 1 month ago
In the language it's supposed to be in :)
leodemi23 1 month ago
@leodemi23 No its supposed to be chinese, because they are in china.
MissEbbAndersson 1 month ago 8
the only word I truly understood was mizu (water) but i had memorized the lyrics in english so i sung along anyway
LightNeko01 1 month ago
I really want to learn Japanese. At first it was simply because of anime, but now the more I hear it, the more beautiful I find the language.
SombreroNinja1 1 month ago 6
Maybe I've been listening to too much jpop but Japanese sounds way more smoother to my ears, even though I understand the Chinese version...
TheSilviepie 1 month ago 4
japanese is so beautiful :) wish i knew it
TheJeneye 2 months ago 5
this is definitely really good but I still prefer the english with Lea Salonga
ferrari250tr 2 months ago
Japanese sounds better than chinese too many stops and pauses with manderin.
Dimitri0809 2 months ago 3
Personally, I prefer softer voices than this as I believe it suits Mulan better. This is why I prefer the song in Cantonese than in my Mother language of Mandarin or than in Japanese.
CIairvoyance 3 months ago
omg i got chills, seriously.
visceraViSAGE 3 months ago
I'm sorry; I have really not been impressed by any of the Japanese dubs of the Mulan songs. The rhythm works a lot better than in Honor To Us All, but this time it's the singer :I I'm retarded at critiquing music, but it's like there's parts in the chorus where she holds the same sound when she should be varying it a little. The Lea Salonga version is still my favorite, but Coco Lee did a great job in the Mandarin one, too.
smallhadroncollider 3 months ago
@smallhadroncollider Chinese, Mandarin, Cantonese, Japanese, all sound same to me.
anythingnew 3 months ago
@anythingnew that's weird, because those languages in fact sound different, use completely different sounds... I don't speak any of them and I'm from Europe and I can tell the difference.
Kofeina19 3 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@Kofeina19
Their pretty similar dude seeming as they are all asian langauges of course they are going to sound the same. Stop trying to differeitiate between asians.. asians should be united now none of this I'm this asian or I'm this kinda asian YOUR ALL THE FUCKING SAME!!
Dimitri0809 2 months ago
@Dimitri0809 poor trolling is poor.
Kofeina19 2 months ago 3
@Dimitri0809 wat the hell are u saying? Of couse there are different asians. what if ur white and someone told u all caucasians are the same? THEY'RE OBVIOUSLY DIFFERENT. a French person and a German person are completely different. why dont u go back to educate urself before making a fool of urself here.
TheGinghamDress 2 months ago 10
@Dimitri0809 The same way all whites are the same. Go say that in UK. Let's see your fingers get chopped off.
fevimaster 2 months ago
@Dimitri0809 cant tell if trolling or completely stupid..........
DragonFox84 2 months ago
@anythingnew WHAT? All sounds different. They all speak different
MsArielle13 3 months ago
I wonder whats it feels like for a japanese person to watch a japanese dub of an american movie taking place in china......
XOcutie901 3 months ago 5
@XOcutie901 ...normal XD
lawrencealcantara620 3 months ago
@lawrencealcantara620 haha so tru! XD
XOcutie901 3 months ago
whos th singer for th japanese version ???! anyone knows ??
RisingFahrenheit 3 months ago
@RisingFahrenheit Eri Ito.
FJKowz 2 months ago
I will try to like this video 100 times before lunch
Nunziohotpants 4 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this version sucks!! the japanese language is broken and stupid and japanese women are trashy whores. this song is so much better in arabic and mandarin
bigman1171 4 months ago
@bigman1171 I think the only reason you left that comment was to prove to us all that you are a fantastic troll, and also to prove you're a flaming racist against japanese people. Well, I think we got the message.
Why don't we all thumbs his comment down to show how much we hate him? He'll probably enjoy it.
AmayaHinageshi 4 months ago
@bigman1171 Well the floor is certainly yours. After all, I'm SURE you've been to Japan twice, studied Japanese for three years and took a complete Rosetta Stone course like I did, right?
I think once you've done all of those things you can start talking. For now, I'd keep my mouth shut.
ZessXX 4 months ago 2
@bigman1171 what the hell do you know about japanese people? i've met some japanese people before and they're the nicest people ever. at least they respect others which is something you seem to lack.
jade45631 4 months ago 2
@pikajutsu in internet
Bluecat444444 4 months ago
it just sounds right to me in japanese
sailorscoobygirl04 5 months ago 116
@sailorscoobygirl04 LOL It's like a Dynasty Warriors game with Japanese dub
anythingnew 3 months ago
@sailorscoobygirl04 It sounds even more fitting in chinese :3
TheFawkes12 3 weeks ago
@sailorscoobygirl04 but they're chinese
Urukins 4 days ago
Agh, so nice!! Great seiyuu/voice actress too!! So great. ;D
AH... BUT... I can't find the Japanese version of this movie ANYWHERE. >____<" WHERE DO I FIND IT?!
PikaJutsu 5 months ago
so powerful
jeight 5 months ago
I got chills down my spine. Amazing!
(I'd love to hear the Christina Aguilera version sung by Utada Hikaru, btw)
SailorSaturn1994 5 months ago 2
such a beautiful voice!! this japanese version is really pretty :) kisses from Portugal
RitaPortugirl 5 months ago
Does itou eri does the speaking voice too ?
charguigou 6 months ago
Is the singer's name Itou Eri, by any chance? Wiki says that she's Mulan's singing voice in the Japanese version... not sure if it's true.
Whoever the singer is, she sure does a great job! =]
(And if it's really Eri you might wanna find more of her songs here in Youtube to enjoy... haha)
AYYX 11 months ago 60
@AYYX
In the official Japanese version Mulan is Mayumi Suzuki...but you're welcome to prove me wrong!
noslipgrip89 4 months ago
@noslipgrip89 I think Mayumi-さん did the voice (dubbing), while Eri-さん did the singing. So absolutely nothing wrong with what you'd said. =)
AYYX 4 months ago