don't know how i gonna react when i discover that MY father is famous mass murder. i think i would be ashamed & humbled 4 being a child or even born by a mass murder.
i hate all of those nazis who had damaged the whole world. even nowadays people still suffer from the 2nd world war. FUCK HITLER! FUCK GöTH & all the others
@Pmtmr i have watched some of your videos. i wanted to know what makes someone have such a perspective. a lot of your information is wrong. 1 - hitler did attack civilians, especially in the battle of london which is why he lost that battle. 2 - vietnam was fought via guerilla warfare, they were supplied by the soviets and had no military installations to bomb. (cold war). 3 - you've never provided unbiased proof as to 'jewish crimes'. your an interesting guy.
@Pmtmr who's tried to infiltrate? who counts as 'one of them'? zac efron?scarlett johansson? when you say when the masses rise up? do you mean the holocaust? the suez crisis? the six day war? the spanish inquisition?
if everyone in the world hates each other, than no one is safe. how do you protect yourself?
@Pmtmr huh.. so if i convert to Judaism, I'll be safe? cause from what you've said being a jew doesn't sound so bad. their rich and they control the world.
@Pmtmr but what's the point of it? why do they do it? why would people stage this such an elaborate plot for nothing? if the jews are doing it, why aren't others?
anyways you still haven't answered my earlier questions. have you always believed this or did you start believing at some sort of turning point in your life?
@Pmtmr but if that's the case then their all sending out really mixed messages. The Koch's are libertarians and are for big business. Anthony Weiner is a democratic senator whose for abortion, green energy and regulating the private sector (especially the oil industry). if all these jews are in some giant plot together why are they opposing each other so much? why did they let obama become president? what's the point of this giant conspiracy of jews anyways?
@Pmtmr at this point there a so many more powerful families out there that are non jewish, the KOCH's who fund AFP and other "grass roots" movements to prevent cap n trade policies and green house gas emission legislation, the KOCH's make over a 100 billion dollars every year. the BUSH family, father and son both president! not to mention all the CHINESE family's out there that have major fortunes! its not just jews that control the world. expand your sight..
@Pmtmr logic can often be subject to perception. your 'logic' is based on a name change, no longer outwardly practicing which i doubt you have definitive proof of. naming their kids jewish names? there are tons of non jews with names like sarah, noah and adam.
just a few general questions though, how old are you and when did you start these 'discoveries'? and .. are you a neo nazi or some sort of revisionist historian?
@Pmtmr truman was angry with the jews. where does it say they're jewish? ok, who are these behind the scenes people? like actual names of these jews that "rule the world" how can people look beyond the surface if there's only the surface? you get what i'm saying? where is the proof of in all this? how do you know, where is the documentation to what your saying? seriously the most dangerous jewish person i can think of is steve jobs and how bad is he? hello ipod, iphone, macs, conspiracy..? NO!
@Pmtmr if jews did rule the world than why are so many of them dying? has there even been a jewish president of america? most people in power aren't even jewish, there some form of christianity. why would jews even be in some secret plot to control the world?
@Pmtmr criminal cabal? interesting. why were these jewish people never caught? but anyways, i think the film is interesting and it's nice that you replied without being repugnant and hatefully, it makes be have a little more faith in people.
@Pmtmr people died. while those people were dying other people did nothing. yes, the jewish people died of typhus and starvation, did the Germans die of those things? Did they die the way the jews died? The Germans put Jews in concentration camps and that we have proof of. No one deserves to be treated the way the Jews were treated.
A jewish propaganda movie.....AGAIN! Note the camp and how far it is from Amon's "villa"! Yet, they say that he shot camp inmates from his villa balcony. He would need a 50000x10 rifle scope! They never even film from the balcony towards the camp to show you the outlook! Why not?! Another thing.....Helen cries all the time but no tears! I know that she is old but is she really that dried out? I do feel bad for Monika....She has to listen to all this propaganda crap and don't know what to think!
I wonder,what exactly is learned from this horror by reducing people to monsters or saints?Who knows how any of us would behave given unlimited power while knowing you would be killed if you questioned your situation?Wouldn't it be much more educational to look at this as a "cautionary tale" of what we ALL are capable of, given the right time and place.If you don't think this man's behavior is in you,as well,you're obviously not very understanding of human nature.
iM SORRY BUT SHUT THE FUCK UP. YOUR TAKING A PISS. THIS MAN WAS BRUTAL BEFORE HE GOT HIS UNIFORM. HE TOOK HIS OWN INSECURITIES AND HATRED OUT BY KILLING , KILLING, KILLING.
Well, I'm sorry too, but I just don't see the world in black and white terms, the way you apparently do. Life is not like a fairy tale, my friend. There is no good guy and bad guy.We are all good, and we are all bad.Once you come to understand that, you will realize that Hitler was just a man,like you or I, who was given an opportunity to use his gifts for the good or ill, and chose the latter....just a sad,weak little man desperate for attention and respect...That's the dull reality, my friend
I really am sorry now. It's been awhile since I wrote that comment,and i forgot it was about one of Hitler's henchman.That said, the same still applies to Mr Goeth.
Hitler was disturbed. He had medical problems and events in his life made him unstable. He drove two of his lovers to suicide and endorsed a theology that killed 18 million people. Hitler took a piss. Plain and simple and his subjects let him. Their were nazis who didnt share hitlers sentiments like the one who saved Wladek Szpilman from starvation. Or Oscar Schindler himself. Dont justify somebody becuz of their conditions. Goeth was a beast who was given the power to kill indisriminately
You seem to be inferring that I am condoning their behavior by trying to understand it. Far from it.Hitler and Goeth were already living unfulfilled lives when, through circumstances, they were allowed to indulge their pedestrian fantasies of power and control. Let's face it, none of us are immune from feeling angry and cruel, from time to time.You do yourself a disservice by not trying to imagine yourself in that time,in the same circumstance.Think, 1920-40 Germany, not 2010 America.
Regarding the 2 men who tried to save the Jews-they obviously were of a higher moral character than Hitler and Goeth.Because, for us Westerners, it is so hard to believe this happened in modern history, we want to make it this grandiose war between good and evil.Sorry, it's just a testament to how vile humans can be.Sorry, kiddo, that's just the sad reality.
BTW-I agree with you that the drugs he was taking towards the end of the war, escalated his already pronounced gradual paranoia and erratic behavior,making a horrific situation, even worse.
@tet43 That is nothing short of crap. To say that Goeth was anything short of a monster is pure dillusion. Knowing that he shot the prisoners for sport from his balcony is horrific. Yes, many Germans went along because they were afraid and in denial, but leading a concentration camp and taking such perverse pleasure in it is the act of a monster.
@herrrob14 Your comment makes it quite clear that you need simple explanations to complex situations and questions.You apparently live in a world where there are absolutes to any question.You'll have to forgive me ,but I'm no longer 5, and can understand the nuance and inconsistencies in human behavior.Just once I would like to witness one of you in the same position as those you dehumanize,and see how sanctimonmious you were then.
@tet43 Erwin Rommel. Nazi general in their African campaigns. He and his troops were never found to have committed war crimes of any kind, and blatantly disobeyed orders to execute POWs, Jews, and other civilians that were coming down the pipeline. He had far more power than Goeth ever did.
@tet43 You mean, if you don't enjoy killing people, are a sadistic psycho and have no value of life, you are not very understanding? That was the most dumb thing i've ever heard. With power comes responsabbility as they say, good people would have come up with a way to save jews, and minimize the deaths...... psychopaths with no empathy becomes like this pathetic excuse for a human.
@Invocati I'm afraid you are so completely invested in a world where people are either good or evil, that you have misunderstood my more nuanced point, which is that HUMANS can be very cruel and animalistic,given the right set of circumstances.Goeth obviously loved his child, so he was not devoid of empathy for her pain.How do you explain that?
@tet43 Not at all. I'm very well aware of greyzones and this is not it.
He had no empathy for her at all. He only cared about himself, and since he was lonely, as with the jewish maid in the movie, he wanted some kind of company.
@Invocati I see that you are very youing.One day you will come up against a reality that you've never had to deal with, and you will make choices based on emotion, not rote facts. You will then be able to truly test your idea of yourself and the world.This happened to me, and fortunately I made the more evolved choice.Since then, I never judge what another man does with his life,because i realize we are never asked to tap into, or undersatand the darker aspects of ouselves until one day, we are.
amon goeth was just trying to save lives in the future by killing the jews then,he didnt kill enough,look at what the jews are doing to russian and ukranian girls now their kidnapping them and forcing them into slavery,read a book called mcmafia,look at the jews who shoot unarmed kids in palestine,the jews are horrible wicked people badly inclined towards life they should all be executed
just goes to show you people are people ,no matter who you are ,what hate can do to people ,and how they get there ,how do these things happin?I think Greed ,and weakness play a big part on both sides of the coin.
Wait what? i thought Helen Hirsch was his personal servant-maid thingy ????? cuz in schindlers list Amon Goeths maid lady is Helen Hirsch and she was or is still alive when they shot that film cuz shes at the end.....im confused.....
In the beginning of the documentary Monika says that her grandmother often mentioned "the two Helenas" who worked as slaves for Amon Goeth: an older one who, I suppose, is already dead, and the lady who participates in the documentary, who was around 14 when she was sent to Plaszow. There, Goeth changed her name to Susanna, because he didn't want to have the hassle of having to clarify to whom he was referring to.
yeh ur right about helen Hirsch, coz she is at the end of sxhindlers list, the real helen hirsch. I just read an article about Amon Goth & it said that Goth chnaged her name to Susanna, coz there was to maids called helen which he had. hope that clears the confusion coz i was too when i heard that lol
I've just watched the movie. and here is what I have to say: amon goeth's daughter is not as ordinary as they pretend in the movie. she's the daughter of a muss murder. so I do NOT believe that she's different from her father. in fact, if there were another world war, this woman would act like her father. that's the only logical way to explain why so many sons and daughters of died nazis are supporting the neo-nazi movement in Germany.
Yeah I saw this movie when it aired and Monika never knew about her father because her grandmother kept her away from him. And once monika learned the terrible truth, I'm sure she lives with the shame everyday.
I just watched it today, Dec 10... at the PBS channel (13, NY) It's a very nice documentary. You could buy the film from PBS. Try to Google "Inheritance Holocaust"... it'll lead you there.
don't know how i gonna react when i discover that MY father is famous mass murder. i think i would be ashamed & humbled 4 being a child or even born by a mass murder.
i hate all of those nazis who had damaged the whole world. even nowadays people still suffer from the 2nd world war. FUCK HITLER! FUCK GöTH & all the others
mistertrailerpark1 9 months ago
@Pmtmr i have watched some of your videos. i wanted to know what makes someone have such a perspective. a lot of your information is wrong. 1 - hitler did attack civilians, especially in the battle of london which is why he lost that battle. 2 - vietnam was fought via guerilla warfare, they were supplied by the soviets and had no military installations to bomb. (cold war). 3 - you've never provided unbiased proof as to 'jewish crimes'. your an interesting guy.
1lastsoldier 1 year ago
@Pmtmr who's tried to infiltrate? who counts as 'one of them'? zac efron?scarlett johansson? when you say when the masses rise up? do you mean the holocaust? the suez crisis? the six day war? the spanish inquisition?
if everyone in the world hates each other, than no one is safe. how do you protect yourself?
1lastsoldier 1 year ago
@Pmtmr huh.. so if i convert to Judaism, I'll be safe? cause from what you've said being a jew doesn't sound so bad. their rich and they control the world.
1lastsoldier 1 year ago
@Pmtmr but what's the point of it? why do they do it? why would people stage this such an elaborate plot for nothing? if the jews are doing it, why aren't others?
anyways you still haven't answered my earlier questions. have you always believed this or did you start believing at some sort of turning point in your life?
1lastsoldier 1 year ago
@Pmtmr but if that's the case then their all sending out really mixed messages. The Koch's are libertarians and are for big business. Anthony Weiner is a democratic senator whose for abortion, green energy and regulating the private sector (especially the oil industry). if all these jews are in some giant plot together why are they opposing each other so much? why did they let obama become president? what's the point of this giant conspiracy of jews anyways?
1lastsoldier 1 year ago
@Pmtmr at this point there a so many more powerful families out there that are non jewish, the KOCH's who fund AFP and other "grass roots" movements to prevent cap n trade policies and green house gas emission legislation, the KOCH's make over a 100 billion dollars every year. the BUSH family, father and son both president! not to mention all the CHINESE family's out there that have major fortunes! its not just jews that control the world. expand your sight..
1lastsoldier 1 year ago
@Pmtmr logic can often be subject to perception. your 'logic' is based on a name change, no longer outwardly practicing which i doubt you have definitive proof of. naming their kids jewish names? there are tons of non jews with names like sarah, noah and adam.
just a few general questions though, how old are you and when did you start these 'discoveries'? and .. are you a neo nazi or some sort of revisionist historian?
1lastsoldier 1 year ago
@Pmtmr truman was angry with the jews. where does it say they're jewish? ok, who are these behind the scenes people? like actual names of these jews that "rule the world" how can people look beyond the surface if there's only the surface? you get what i'm saying? where is the proof of in all this? how do you know, where is the documentation to what your saying? seriously the most dangerous jewish person i can think of is steve jobs and how bad is he? hello ipod, iphone, macs, conspiracy..? NO!
1lastsoldier 1 year ago
@Pmtmr if jews did rule the world than why are so many of them dying? has there even been a jewish president of america? most people in power aren't even jewish, there some form of christianity. why would jews even be in some secret plot to control the world?
1lastsoldier 1 year ago
@Pmtmr criminal cabal? interesting. why were these jewish people never caught? but anyways, i think the film is interesting and it's nice that you replied without being repugnant and hatefully, it makes be have a little more faith in people.
1lastsoldier 1 year ago
@Pmtmr people died. while those people were dying other people did nothing. yes, the jewish people died of typhus and starvation, did the Germans die of those things? Did they die the way the jews died? The Germans put Jews in concentration camps and that we have proof of. No one deserves to be treated the way the Jews were treated.
Look for your humanity.
1lastsoldier 1 year ago
@HansHorstel1 - go away
mikeduplantier 1 year ago
A jewish propaganda movie.....AGAIN! Note the camp and how far it is from Amon's "villa"! Yet, they say that he shot camp inmates from his villa balcony. He would need a 50000x10 rifle scope! They never even film from the balcony towards the camp to show you the outlook! Why not?! Another thing.....Helen cries all the time but no tears! I know that she is old but is she really that dried out? I do feel bad for Monika....She has to listen to all this propaganda crap and don't know what to think!
HansHorstel1 1 year ago
@HansHorstel1 .... doesn't change the fact that the holocaust happened.
1lastsoldier 1 year ago
Even if she was like her Father, do you really think she would admit it?
I have to see this documentary.
mrceebees14 1 year ago
Talk about embarrassing.
mrceebees14 1 year ago
I wonder,what exactly is learned from this horror by reducing people to monsters or saints?Who knows how any of us would behave given unlimited power while knowing you would be killed if you questioned your situation?Wouldn't it be much more educational to look at this as a "cautionary tale" of what we ALL are capable of, given the right time and place.If you don't think this man's behavior is in you,as well,you're obviously not very understanding of human nature.
tet43 2 years ago 4
iM SORRY BUT SHUT THE FUCK UP. YOUR TAKING A PISS. THIS MAN WAS BRUTAL BEFORE HE GOT HIS UNIFORM. HE TOOK HIS OWN INSECURITIES AND HATRED OUT BY KILLING , KILLING, KILLING.
BigBlackWolf89 2 years ago
Well, I'm sorry too, but I just don't see the world in black and white terms, the way you apparently do. Life is not like a fairy tale, my friend. There is no good guy and bad guy.We are all good, and we are all bad.Once you come to understand that, you will realize that Hitler was just a man,like you or I, who was given an opportunity to use his gifts for the good or ill, and chose the latter....just a sad,weak little man desperate for attention and respect...That's the dull reality, my friend
tet43 2 years ago 3
I really am sorry now. It's been awhile since I wrote that comment,and i forgot it was about one of Hitler's henchman.That said, the same still applies to Mr Goeth.
tet43 2 years ago
Hitler was disturbed. He had medical problems and events in his life made him unstable. He drove two of his lovers to suicide and endorsed a theology that killed 18 million people. Hitler took a piss. Plain and simple and his subjects let him. Their were nazis who didnt share hitlers sentiments like the one who saved Wladek Szpilman from starvation. Or Oscar Schindler himself. Dont justify somebody becuz of their conditions. Goeth was a beast who was given the power to kill indisriminately
BigBlackWolf89 2 years ago 3
You seem to be inferring that I am condoning their behavior by trying to understand it. Far from it.Hitler and Goeth were already living unfulfilled lives when, through circumstances, they were allowed to indulge their pedestrian fantasies of power and control. Let's face it, none of us are immune from feeling angry and cruel, from time to time.You do yourself a disservice by not trying to imagine yourself in that time,in the same circumstance.Think, 1920-40 Germany, not 2010 America.
tet43 2 years ago 4
Regarding the 2 men who tried to save the Jews-they obviously were of a higher moral character than Hitler and Goeth.Because, for us Westerners, it is so hard to believe this happened in modern history, we want to make it this grandiose war between good and evil.Sorry, it's just a testament to how vile humans can be.Sorry, kiddo, that's just the sad reality.
tet43 2 years ago
BTW-I agree with you that the drugs he was taking towards the end of the war, escalated his already pronounced gradual paranoia and erratic behavior,making a horrific situation, even worse.
tet43 2 years ago
@tet43
Well said.
sweetsandbloodlust2 2 years ago
@tet43 That is nothing short of crap. To say that Goeth was anything short of a monster is pure dillusion. Knowing that he shot the prisoners for sport from his balcony is horrific. Yes, many Germans went along because they were afraid and in denial, but leading a concentration camp and taking such perverse pleasure in it is the act of a monster.
herrrob14 1 year ago
@herrrob14 Your comment makes it quite clear that you need simple explanations to complex situations and questions.You apparently live in a world where there are absolutes to any question.You'll have to forgive me ,but I'm no longer 5, and can understand the nuance and inconsistencies in human behavior.Just once I would like to witness one of you in the same position as those you dehumanize,and see how sanctimonmious you were then.
tet43 1 year ago
@tet43 Erwin Rommel. Nazi general in their African campaigns. He and his troops were never found to have committed war crimes of any kind, and blatantly disobeyed orders to execute POWs, Jews, and other civilians that were coming down the pipeline. He had far more power than Goeth ever did.
Lupus27 1 year ago
@Lupus27 Sorry, not sure of the point you're trying to make.
tet43 1 year ago
@tet43 You mean, if you don't enjoy killing people, are a sadistic psycho and have no value of life, you are not very understanding? That was the most dumb thing i've ever heard. With power comes responsabbility as they say, good people would have come up with a way to save jews, and minimize the deaths...... psychopaths with no empathy becomes like this pathetic excuse for a human.
Invocati 1 year ago
@Invocati I'm afraid you are so completely invested in a world where people are either good or evil, that you have misunderstood my more nuanced point, which is that HUMANS can be very cruel and animalistic,given the right set of circumstances.Goeth obviously loved his child, so he was not devoid of empathy for her pain.How do you explain that?
tet43 1 year ago
@tet43 Not at all. I'm very well aware of greyzones and this is not it.
He had no empathy for her at all. He only cared about himself, and since he was lonely, as with the jewish maid in the movie, he wanted some kind of company.
Invocati 1 year ago
@Invocati I see that you are very youing.One day you will come up against a reality that you've never had to deal with, and you will make choices based on emotion, not rote facts. You will then be able to truly test your idea of yourself and the world.This happened to me, and fortunately I made the more evolved choice.Since then, I never judge what another man does with his life,because i realize we are never asked to tap into, or undersatand the darker aspects of ouselves until one day, we are.
tet43 1 year ago 2
amon goeth is in hell
1955porsche 2 years ago
There are no winners in this very sorrowful story.
Hatred endures still today and also those who are the victims on both sides.
havenoneatall 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
amon goeth was just trying to save lives in the future by killing the jews then,he didnt kill enough,look at what the jews are doing to russian and ukranian girls now their kidnapping them and forcing them into slavery,read a book called mcmafia,look at the jews who shoot unarmed kids in palestine,the jews are horrible wicked people badly inclined towards life they should all be executed
lee88614 2 years ago
Interesting. Has anyone seen that documentary about Hitler's relatives?They changed their name and won't even show their face.
jxsilicon9 2 years ago
Would you show your face or admit if you were related to him? I sure as hell wouldn't.
bellaemmamom 2 years ago
Comment removed
sweetsandbloodlust2 2 years ago
@jxsilicon9
I saw that documentary.
sweetsandbloodlust2 2 years ago
just goes to show you people are people ,no matter who you are ,what hate can do to people ,and how they get there ,how do these things happin?I think Greed ,and weakness play a big part on both sides of the coin.
DrewAnti1960 2 years ago
i saw this documentary today
very sad =[
abyan717 2 years ago
Wait what? i thought Helen Hirsch was his personal servant-maid thingy ????? cuz in schindlers list Amon Goeths maid lady is Helen Hirsch and she was or is still alive when they shot that film cuz shes at the end.....im confused.....
mrsbilliejoemargera 2 years ago
In the beginning of the documentary Monika says that her grandmother often mentioned "the two Helenas" who worked as slaves for Amon Goeth: an older one who, I suppose, is already dead, and the lady who participates in the documentary, who was around 14 when she was sent to Plaszow. There, Goeth changed her name to Susanna, because he didn't want to have the hassle of having to clarify to whom he was referring to.
Apozimiosi 2 years ago
yeh ur right about helen Hirsch, coz she is at the end of sxhindlers list, the real helen hirsch. I just read an article about Amon Goth & it said that Goth chnaged her name to Susanna, coz there was to maids called helen which he had. hope that clears the confusion coz i was too when i heard that lol
PlatinumJC 2 years ago
Comment removed
vachtje 3 years ago
What a pathetic comment by stoonka1
bluerosesxxx 3 years ago 2
Comment removed
bluerosesxxx 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I've just watched the movie. and here is what I have to say: amon goeth's daughter is not as ordinary as they pretend in the movie. she's the daughter of a muss murder. so I do NOT believe that she's different from her father. in fact, if there were another world war, this woman would act like her father. that's the only logical way to explain why so many sons and daughters of died nazis are supporting the neo-nazi movement in Germany.
bobhardball 3 years ago
That is a pretty baseless argument mate. Children can be completely different than their parents, so many times. Be logical at least.
Claire1Rogers 3 years ago 20
Yeah I saw this movie when it aired and Monika never knew about her father because her grandmother kept her away from him. And once monika learned the terrible truth, I'm sure she lives with the shame everyday.
FoxyGal18 3 years ago
i want to watch!
abcdefathia 3 years ago
one of the most emotionnal movie I've ever seen.
patsystone69 3 years ago
Where can I get this? I've searched on the entire web but can't find nothing!
I really wanna see this!
Guarnere15 3 years ago
yes, me too.. I want to see it, please help me!
Cockerina86 3 years ago
I just watched it today, Dec 10... at the PBS channel (13, NY) It's a very nice documentary. You could buy the film from PBS. Try to Google "Inheritance Holocaust"... it'll lead you there.
tropset 3 years ago
google "1 third of holocaust"
lictor313 3 years ago
WoW º`º ... i hope she can make disappear that demons because she was only a child, she is a strong woman.
QQTER 3 years ago 3