She may have not executed this song perfectly, but this song really complimented her voice. When I heard this live, I fell in love with her (as a fangirl), and this song.
Throughout her stay on the show she was always lacking in the vocal department but with this performance I can look past that. Perfect song for her, I really enjoyed this.
Randy is just a jerk.....he never liked her. All I can say is that Carmen has just released a new CD and to Randy..."eat your heart out!" This girl can sing!! As Gladys Knight said...she was on the brink in this...well listen to her new CD....and you'll see that Carmen has arrived.
I think she actually sounds good with this! Indeed she was out of tune in some spots in the verse, but no big deal; the chorus was good!! :D Blah Randy never liked her that's why he was so harsh here!
Oh come on people, give the girl a break! She was only 17 when she was on the show. I think she did a great job! It wasn't her best performance but she did a good job. :0) Keep going Carmen!
I love her
1brohudson 3 months ago
She may have not executed this song perfectly, but this song really complimented her voice. When I heard this live, I fell in love with her (as a fangirl), and this song.
dopehope 6 months ago
Throughout her stay on the show she was always lacking in the vocal department but with this performance I can look past that. Perfect song for her, I really enjoyed this.
scabbedwings44 1 year ago
Randy is just a jerk.....he never liked her. All I can say is that Carmen has just released a new CD and to Randy..."eat your heart out!" This girl can sing!! As Gladys Knight said...she was on the brink in this...well listen to her new CD....and you'll see that Carmen has arrived.
larkpraise 1 year ago
Veem como canta bem parece um rouxinol
698icerman 1 year ago
the lower parts of the song sound really dead but she sounded good at the high parts
is she really 17 here? people back then look old!
im 16 and she looks atleast 20 to me
Bernerker 1 year ago
@Bernerker I'm pretty sure Carmen was just 16 during the taping of the show.
She does country music now, I believe.
tejil27 1 month ago
I think she actually sounds good with this! Indeed she was out of tune in some spots in the verse, but no big deal; the chorus was good!! :D Blah Randy never liked her that's why he was so harsh here!
elpelozzz 1 year ago
Oh come on people, give the girl a break! She was only 17 when she was on the show. I think she did a great job! It wasn't her best performance but she did a good job. :0) Keep going Carmen!
ladycop1220 1 year ago
I agree w/ Simon. This was a pretty good performance.
ThatsSoKirby 1 year ago 3
her voice doesn't suck. it just sounds bad on this song. but she really knows how to perform if you watch.
xxkmlsmpxx 1 year ago
OMG she really sucks!! Girl how did you come so far anyway? your voice sucks!
xx1Rachel1xx 1 year ago
its not 1994....what's with the makeup... haha. she sucked
ryababe24 2 years ago
She's not the best vocalist in the world, and she was a little pitchy in this song, but somehow I like her!
Emerald19633 2 years ago 8