Encore une petite lyrique qui se prend pour une grande colorature!!! Pas même en mesure de battre correctement son trille... Et de placer son ré conclusif! Une charmante Juliette ne fait pas automatiquement une grande Elvira. N'est pas Ruth Ann Swenson qui veut.
Very pretty soprano, with a good technique. but the voice is not leggiero coloratura. Her coloratura is better than Anna Netrebko, though. But no way to compare with Diana Damrau!
@sutherlandfan64 thank you for comparing her with Joan. Joan started her B$R*ILL*IANT career not in early age as Callas, so I hope Nino will blossom in 5 years.
@sutherlandfan64 Of course she isn't. But then what? If you are not Joan you should not sing this? Joan is dead so we should bury the opera completely?
Nary a trill in sight -- she didn't even try to fake it. And the strain on the high notes. I'm not impressed with her in the coloratura bel canto repertoire. She should stick to Mimi and Musetta. Florez may agree with me, he looks like he is half-asleep.
@songbirdwatcher I miss the trills, too. And, I could do without the scream up to the final high note. With so many comments mentioning Sutherland, I'd also like to add that Sills was also fabulous in this role, with impeccable technique and glorious trills. All in all, though, Machaidze is certainly an improvement over Netrebko.
How you can't love her She is a like a creamer and suger in your coffee,plus her beaty,her personality and her magic voices.I love her.
MsSandtime 1 week ago
One of the best contemporary Elviras, better than Netrebko, but her diction is not good.
For example "or sembri la aaaaaa si all'altar"?
Tosycyzkiewicy 3 weeks ago
Meravigliosa!!!
TheValeriaValeri 1 month ago 2
Comment removed
feblik 2 months ago
ma.. c'è qualche problema nell'orchestra a @4:04?
jovi1715 2 months ago
@jovi1715 soltanto? ahahahahahah
lei è molto generoso/a!
bodiloto 1 day ago
I have only recently come to know her and that amazing voice. I hate this opera but may have to reconsider with all these gorgeous arias she sings.
chucknyc123 3 months ago 2
She is simply the Best!!!
KussKuss100 3 months ago
Nino Machaidse singt weitaus besser als Netrebko-die Stimme ist koloratur-und
höhensicherer---tolle Bühnenpräsens-eine echte Konkurenz für Anna Netrebko!!!
MultiZahl 3 months ago 2
her Lucia in Brussels was the best I ever saw....all in all, including imperfections
savoirgai 4 months ago
This lady isn't even 30 yet. Amazing potential! Not the sharpest final high note, but a "scream"? I think not.
lginpdx 4 months ago 3
Encore une petite lyrique qui se prend pour une grande colorature!!! Pas même en mesure de battre correctement son trille... Et de placer son ré conclusif! Une charmante Juliette ne fait pas automatiquement une grande Elvira. N'est pas Ruth Ann Swenson qui veut.
BEVER29 5 months ago
Joan was pretty good, but would have been better if she had not had her consonants removed so early in her life.
MrHbc3 6 months ago
lovely!
OperaLoverL 6 months ago
Nino Machaidze meravigliosa e brava. Taf289
taf289 7 months ago
BRAVA
mariloly38 7 months ago
Very pretty soprano, with a good technique. but the voice is not leggiero coloratura. Her coloratura is better than Anna Netrebko, though. But no way to compare with Diana Damrau!
Cissy97 8 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
bellissima voce,brava
GijuaTaz 8 months ago
Nino Machaidze!!!
GijuaTaz 8 months ago
well...umm... she ain't Joan!!!!!!!!!
sutherlandfan64 10 months ago
@sutherlandfan64 thank you for comparing her with Joan. Joan started her B$R*ILL*IANT career not in early age as Callas, so I hope Nino will blossom in 5 years.
zurriussII 8 months ago
@sutherlandfan64 Of course she isn't. But then what? If you are not Joan you should not sing this? Joan is dead so we should bury the opera completely?
martello79 7 months ago
Una preciosura y con una voz maravillosa. Adorable.
alragarp 10 months ago 2
OH MY GOD!!WHAT IS THE MATTER WITH THE CHOIR???
dulCISSIMA1 10 months ago
il coro è terrificante.....
denissettantotto 1 year ago
@denissettantotto il coro ?
E come trova l'orchestra?...
bodiloto 2 months ago
Giovanissima,bella,una bellissima voce,brava Machaidze!
bodiloto 1 year ago
love this singer
wwwgggrrrttt 1 year ago
Insomma...manca di morbidezza e di reale leggiadria nella coloratura. Però, decorosissima!
leprincebeaumont 1 year ago
SUPREME!!! CAN'T WAIT FOR RECEIVING MY ORDER OF IT!!!
dougebraga 1 year ago
Un peu aigre,mais chanté avec goût.
abracadabranque 1 year ago
Fantastic!!!
KikkoBankikko 1 year ago
Maravilhosa!!!
DrFernandoBicudo 1 year ago
Really, without someone specialized in this repertoire, this music can be extraordinarily boring...
foropera 1 year ago
@foropera agree
BlackCrowNavajo 11 months ago
OMG SHE IS GREAT!!!!!! can you upload more please?
dvedas2 1 year ago
OMG SHE IS GREAT!!!!!
can you upload more please???
dvedas2 1 year ago
She is the winner of Leyla Gencer Voice competition , on of the best ... i am looking forward to see her in Turkey again and again
FeryalFun 1 year ago
Simply Fantastic Nino!!!!!!!!!!!
I love this singer! she is so beautiful and so great!!!
Thank you for upload this video. can you upload more of this production please.
bestmantheworld 1 year ago
Comment removed
bestmantheworld 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Oh dear, looks like a real lack luster performance!!
devampa 1 year ago
Oh dear, looks like a real lack luster performance!!
devampa 1 year ago
Oh dear, looks like a real lack luster performance!!
devampa 1 year ago
Nary a trill in sight -- she didn't even try to fake it. And the strain on the high notes. I'm not impressed with her in the coloratura bel canto repertoire. She should stick to Mimi and Musetta. Florez may agree with me, he looks like he is half-asleep.
songbirdwatcher 1 year ago 2
@songbirdwatcher I miss the trills, too. And, I could do without the scream up to the final high note. With so many comments mentioning Sutherland, I'd also like to add that Sills was also fabulous in this role, with impeccable technique and glorious trills. All in all, though, Machaidze is certainly an improvement over Netrebko.
AiTaiwandeRen 5 months ago