Hopefully I can help clarify this....This guy IS a bass. He may sound like a baritone compared to some of the lower guys, but the lowest here was an Eb2, which sounded quite easy for him. The range of a typical bass goes down to E2. This guy fits in that range and slightly lower, so he's definitely a bass.
Now guys like Tim Riley are in a range known as Basso Profundo, or "deep bass". They are gifted and in the cases of Tim Riley and London Parris, they were taught techniques for good tone.
@GamingDrummer89 Just because someone isn't a Basso Profundo doesn't make him a baritone. Maybe compared to a deep bass he sounds like a baritone, but the guy here is still a bass. Specifically, he's not a Basso Profundo, but rather a normal Bass.
Being able to hit a low note and carry a tune is two different things, JD, George, or most any bass singer, never did their best singing when they were trying to see how low they could go. Most just sound like they are coughing up phlegm and a bull frog in mating season has more tone. Greg does ok. You ever notice that Stuban of the Oaks only drops down when it fits the tune.
I do sing bass and I am sorry but that sounds like more of a baritone that has a decent vocal range. Real bass singers such as J.D. Sumner or Ray Reese of The Kingsmen are bass singers. But very good song.
I'm sure this young talented bass singer would appreciate some of my favorite bass singers, Jimmy Jones from Harmonizing Four, Dickey Freeman from The Fairfield Four, and Jimmy Ricks of The Ravens.
Thanks for sharing this good video with everyone.
As a professional bass singer myself in an ' a cappella' group from Canada called The Essentials, I can tell you that this guy IS a bass.
He's comfortable hitting a low Eb with nice resonance in this video which is a full tone lower than the "definition" of a bass singer (someone who can hit at least a low F).
Not every song has to be sung by a bass at the very bottom of their range. :)
Yeah, this guy is more like a baratone. I'm a baratone and i can match his range very easily. He is singing a bass harmony, but if it was a real bass singer it would probably actually be an octave lower
I can sing BASS better than that ! Even though I have never sang in a Quartet as a BASS, I sang bass in a choir @ Church ! and I used to reach Low E/F , 2 steps below the BASS G B D F A staff !
Many of you have it right. I'm a bass singer in a quartet and those notes are not hard but it's more fun singing in baritone and even tenor at times. I stick with bass on Gospel songs but enjoy other ranges on others. That was one of the great things about George Younce--he could also sing beautifully in the upper registers if he wanted.
yes! Great bass....if anyone does not like it, try to sing bass your own self! Not all basses are easily understood, he is, and that is a true compliment in the singing world! Nice/smooth/melodic voice!
i dn' ge some comments, i talked tosome music guy at my church and he said you don't have to go low as Tim Riley,JD, George or any of those bass legends, you'll just have to be able to hit certain notes, i think its like 3 notes before the low C (do,re,mi,"fa",sol,la,si,do) . Correct me if im wrong.
@ramey58 well idk then, this guy a pretty good jobs on high notes, he makes them look as if they were low, anyways the point is that he is good, even tough he doesn't hit low notes in this video, he still sings good.
no he doesn't stink at all. Let us not compare credentials... This is gospel music and he has a uniique voice and carries the bass well. Of course it may not please you, but it does me - and I trust the One for whom it si ssung as well. Peace,
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
All I can say is, this guy stinks. After hearing all the great bass singers over the years, how can you people say this is awsome? He is not even in a low register and he is singing sharp. JD, George, Herman, London, Big Chief, Tim Riley, now they were awsome. I don't mean to be ugly, but this guy can't sing.
This guy has a strangley high timbre but he isn't half bad... I really liked his ability to maintain a stable voice if nothing else.. And he managed to add one good low note in there! Not bad man 4.5/5
As JD would say does it matter? The man is singing for the Lord and he is passable. as for George, Rex Nelon ect great man in their own catagory! However, the bass for Ernie Haase and SS he is good. time to enjoy those who now sing. We can enjoy the old guys here on Youtube and with the gaither videos.
Great bass.I have a christian site that has just started. It's free and anyone wanting to chat with other christians let me know and I will tell you where to go???
It is a mistake to think that any bass who can not hit a double-low C is no good.
I love to be entertained by JD (I listened to him over 50 years), but he could never blend into the harmony of a group like this guy. I'll take this guy any day over those guys who sing with the mic burried in their mouths and sound like a truck backfire.
You are kidding, aren't you? The man who could nail a G below staff, who was a figure with Elvis, the Blackwoods, the Stamps? You say he couldn't blend? Do you have peanut butter in your ears?
LOL that was freakin hellarious...and ur right..I'm a huge JD fan and i will agree some of the stuff he hit does not sound all that great once u get past a certain lowness but he could blend with a mule taking a dump. If ur elvis' right hand man and he picks u....then ur the best there is, was, and will ever BE!
I grew up on JD, George Younce, Harold Reid, Herman Harper, Noel Fox. I'm a bass singer myself, in the same league as this One Accord guy, and neither he nor I have the chops those guys had!
Yeah....I sing bass on a few songs...mostly lead and baratone in our group...not really a bass singer. I wish I was but im not. Man Herman harpar was just amazing man..he could get lower than richard sturban...What happened to him??
Herman Harper left the Oaks in the late 60s, a couple of years after Duane Allen took over for Smitty Gatlin. Noel Fox replaced him. He went to work for an agency in Nashville, booking the Oaks and other acts, and eventually opened The Harper Agency, which is still one of the biggest in gospel music.
He was a Baptist deacon and a backup singer on Nashville recording sessions for years, and died in 1993.
ah man that stinks...didn't know all that. Man with his talent he coulda sang for anyone he wanted!....guess thats not what he wanted to do. Man what i'd give to have a voice like his! thanks for info brother!
You goitta remember that back in those days, unless you were the Blackwoods, Stamps or the Statesmen, you couldn't make a living in Gospel music -- you lived on what you got, or you had a 'day job', which most of them did. For example, I won't name the group, but the tenor for one of the most successful acts in Gospel music in the 60s and 70s had a professional photography business.
forgot to add -- I never met him, but he was my all-time favorite low-sounding bass singer. George Younce and I were friends, and I'd say he was the best soloist I ever heard who sang in the bass range. But Herman Harper could nail the low notes like nobody except JD.
I enjoyed your video, Very Good! If you like you can find my video on " YouTube" under Wayne Weberpal. I also have a Music CD on EBay under "Mansion Over the Hilltop". Best wishes, Wayne Weberpal
your name suits you well american"pride". always something better out there and you have the answers. Gospel singing should be different than worldly singing. We should not judge christian singers based on talent, looks, etc. Anyone who lifts the name of Jesus in song should be applauded and encouraged. I love the critics too but we need more singers proclaiming the good news more often. Go forth One Accord!
i was expecting a bass guitar solo -.- this is still epic XD
razorhedz 3 months ago
Please just show the music. Thank you.
fine1fine1 8 months ago
Hopefully I can help clarify this....This guy IS a bass. He may sound like a baritone compared to some of the lower guys, but the lowest here was an Eb2, which sounded quite easy for him. The range of a typical bass goes down to E2. This guy fits in that range and slightly lower, so he's definitely a bass.
Now guys like Tim Riley are in a range known as Basso Profundo, or "deep bass". They are gifted and in the cases of Tim Riley and London Parris, they were taught techniques for good tone.
GamingDrummer89 9 months ago
@GamingDrummer89 Just because someone isn't a Basso Profundo doesn't make him a baritone. Maybe compared to a deep bass he sounds like a baritone, but the guy here is still a bass. Specifically, he's not a Basso Profundo, but rather a normal Bass.
GamingDrummer89 9 months ago
That's like hearing a tenor sing an F5 and saying that since he isn't singing the highest note there is, that he's not a tenor.
AtariMaxiToriyama 9 months ago
Being able to hit a low note and carry a tune is two different things, JD, George, or most any bass singer, never did their best singing when they were trying to see how low they could go. Most just sound like they are coughing up phlegm and a bull frog in mating season has more tone. Greg does ok. You ever notice that Stuban of the Oaks only drops down when it fits the tune.
billybobaz11 10 months ago
I do sing bass and I am sorry but that sounds like more of a baritone that has a decent vocal range. Real bass singers such as J.D. Sumner or Ray Reese of The Kingsmen are bass singers. But very good song.
Southerngent0426 11 months ago
Nice group, and a really good bass singer.
Good diction!
I'm sure this young talented bass singer would appreciate some of my favorite bass singers, Jimmy Jones from Harmonizing Four, Dickey Freeman from The Fairfield Four, and Jimmy Ricks of The Ravens.
Thanks for sharing this good video with everyone.
allaboutrecords 11 months ago
fairfield four got the hardest bass u cud ever hear. dis one is more baritone
kyatkraker 1 year ago
sounds like a baritone with a cold.
popeclan03 1 year ago
Sounds like a baratone with a cold. Tim Riley is a bass.
popeclan03 1 year ago
As a professional bass singer myself in an ' a cappella' group from Canada called The Essentials, I can tell you that this guy IS a bass.
He's comfortable hitting a low Eb with nice resonance in this video which is a full tone lower than the "definition" of a bass singer (someone who can hit at least a low F).
Not every song has to be sung by a bass at the very bottom of their range. :)
Peace,
Jo3
theessentialsvideos 1 year ago
Bass singer? Not at all.....Listen to Richard Sterban or Tim Riley
mreddiemush 1 year ago
@mreddiemush dont forget harold reed
n4sir804 1 year ago
Bass? My mother sings lower.....listen to Richard Sterban or Tim Riley
mreddiemush 1 year ago
he's not bass
landoblu 1 year ago
hey,.,.,do u have a minus one of that music
jovanetlyn93 1 year ago
what a bass that he has. let's use our talent even in a simple voice like his. use it for the glory of God..GBU all..
justrayn 1 year ago
It doesn't really matter who sings better or not, and if u like his voice, its all about glorifying God! Thats my 2 cents!
tcssball9 1 year ago
he sings in the same range as jeremy lile and everyone thinks he's one on the best basses out there.
lowluvver 1 year ago
@lowluvver 2 words jd sumner
bball708 1 year ago
Yeah, this guy is more like a baratone. I'm a baratone and i can match his range very easily. He is singing a bass harmony, but if it was a real bass singer it would probably actually be an octave lower
bishops0258 1 year ago
@bishops0258 Funny since he doesn't sing any harmony in the entire song.
bandit90z 1 year ago
I can sing BASS better than that ! Even though I have never sang in a Quartet as a BASS, I sang bass in a choir @ Church ! and I used to reach Low E/F , 2 steps below the BASS G B D F A staff !
dutchyboy66 1 year ago
im a baritone and all this solo is in my range
xcryin911 1 year ago
Many of you have it right. I'm a bass singer in a quartet and those notes are not hard but it's more fun singing in baritone and even tenor at times. I stick with bass on Gospel songs but enjoy other ranges on others. That was one of the great things about George Younce--he could also sing beautifully in the upper registers if he wanted.
ramey58 1 year ago
Yes the bass singer is a smooth singer but i have to say tim riley is much better but the bass singer is still
4291992 1 year ago
well there arent many people that you can compare with tim riley
Scsibut 1 year ago
yes! Great bass....if anyone does not like it, try to sing bass your own self! Not all basses are easily understood, he is, and that is a true compliment in the singing world! Nice/smooth/melodic voice!
smcrone77871 2 years ago 9
Very good. I really enjoyed it. Thanks for posting.
greytemp 2 years ago
Amen...I really thank God coz am not what I was...
Akefe1 2 years ago
i dn' ge some comments, i talked tosome music guy at my church and he said you don't have to go low as Tim Riley,JD, George or any of those bass legends, you'll just have to be able to hit certain notes, i think its like 3 notes before the low C (do,re,mi,"fa",sol,la,si,do) . Correct me if im wrong.
chipojo2008 2 years ago
@chipojo2008 Bass is defined as two octaves below middle C. The ones you mentioned and myself at times are three octaves below that.
ramey58 1 year ago
@ramey58 well idk then, this guy a pretty good jobs on high notes, he makes them look as if they were low, anyways the point is that he is good, even tough he doesn't hit low notes in this video, he still sings good.
chipojo2008 1 year ago
@chipojo2008 Yes, he's a fantastic baritone who can also dip into the bass range. Nothing wrong with that.
ramey58 1 year ago
I think awesome was the wrong word. Good maybe but not quiet awesome. Atleast he's singing for the lord.
hiddencharges 2 years ago
no he doesn't stink at all. Let us not compare credentials... This is gospel music and he has a uniique voice and carries the bass well. Of course it may not please you, but it does me - and I trust the One for whom it si ssung as well. Peace,
deborahsuewho 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
All I can say is, this guy stinks. After hearing all the great bass singers over the years, how can you people say this is awsome? He is not even in a low register and he is singing sharp. JD, George, Herman, London, Big Chief, Tim Riley, now they were awsome. I don't mean to be ugly, but this guy can't sing.
firefighter2745 2 years ago
Comment removed
obeyyourchad 2 years ago
sure - not in the same class as JD or George, but stll a nice-to-listen-to voice.
crmc9999 2 years ago
This guy has a strangley high timbre but he isn't half bad... I really liked his ability to maintain a stable voice if nothing else.. And he managed to add one good low note in there! Not bad man 4.5/5
victoryopop 2 years ago
gorgeous bass voice, enjoy it.
cde123cde 2 years ago
Nice Video, Check out my videos too, if you have some time you can check it out and rate and comment. Thank You and God Bless !!!
samorage 2 years ago
A nice song from this awesome quartet. Thumbs up to the bass singer. God bless you
bycors 3 years ago 7
solid bass, very solid,
trombonedemon 3 years ago
As JD would say does it matter? The man is singing for the Lord and he is passable. as for George, Rex Nelon ect great man in their own catagory! However, the bass for Ernie Haase and SS he is good. time to enjoy those who now sing. We can enjoy the old guys here on Youtube and with the gaither videos.
kyldy 3 years ago
Great bass.I have a christian site that has just started. It's free and anyone wanting to chat with other christians let me know and I will tell you where to go???
That didn't sound right.
heupiedupey 3 years ago
sounds good!
ypsiboi05 3 years ago
hmmm,... for a great bass singer check out the palmetto state quartet
mattoconnor2434 3 years ago
Nicely done!
cvchurch 3 years ago
This guy is a good bass singer.
It is a mistake to think that any bass who can not hit a double-low C is no good.
I love to be entertained by JD (I listened to him over 50 years), but he could never blend into the harmony of a group like this guy. I'll take this guy any day over those guys who sing with the mic burried in their mouths and sound like a truck backfire.
RedRyderVideos 3 years ago
You are kidding, aren't you? The man who could nail a G below staff, who was a figure with Elvis, the Blackwoods, the Stamps? You say he couldn't blend? Do you have peanut butter in your ears?
moproducer 3 years ago
LOL that was freakin hellarious...and ur right..I'm a huge JD fan and i will agree some of the stuff he hit does not sound all that great once u get past a certain lowness but he could blend with a mule taking a dump. If ur elvis' right hand man and he picks u....then ur the best there is, was, and will ever BE!
bigmrclean 3 years ago
I grew up on JD, George Younce, Harold Reid, Herman Harper, Noel Fox. I'm a bass singer myself, in the same league as this One Accord guy, and neither he nor I have the chops those guys had!
moproducer 3 years ago
Yeah....I sing bass on a few songs...mostly lead and baratone in our group...not really a bass singer. I wish I was but im not. Man Herman harpar was just amazing man..he could get lower than richard sturban...What happened to him??
bigmrclean 3 years ago
Herman Harper left the Oaks in the late 60s, a couple of years after Duane Allen took over for Smitty Gatlin. Noel Fox replaced him. He went to work for an agency in Nashville, booking the Oaks and other acts, and eventually opened The Harper Agency, which is still one of the biggest in gospel music.
He was a Baptist deacon and a backup singer on Nashville recording sessions for years, and died in 1993.
moproducer 3 years ago
ah man that stinks...didn't know all that. Man with his talent he coulda sang for anyone he wanted!....guess thats not what he wanted to do. Man what i'd give to have a voice like his! thanks for info brother!
bigmrclean 3 years ago
You goitta remember that back in those days, unless you were the Blackwoods, Stamps or the Statesmen, you couldn't make a living in Gospel music -- you lived on what you got, or you had a 'day job', which most of them did. For example, I won't name the group, but the tenor for one of the most successful acts in Gospel music in the 60s and 70s had a professional photography business.
moproducer 3 years ago
forgot to add -- I never met him, but he was my all-time favorite low-sounding bass singer. George Younce and I were friends, and I'd say he was the best soloist I ever heard who sang in the bass range. But Herman Harper could nail the low notes like nobody except JD.
moproducer 3 years ago
did he have a cold?
Ponymastr 3 years ago
i like this it was really good thanks for sharing
datiez 3 years ago
I enjoyed your video, Very Good! If you like you can find my video on " YouTube" under Wayne Weberpal. I also have a Music CD on EBay under "Mansion Over the Hilltop". Best wishes, Wayne Weberpal
wweberpal 3 years ago
This is pretty cool! (4 stars)
lexovirus 3 years ago
your name suits you well american"pride". always something better out there and you have the answers. Gospel singing should be different than worldly singing. We should not judge christian singers based on talent, looks, etc. Anyone who lifts the name of Jesus in song should be applauded and encouraged. I love the critics too but we need more singers proclaiming the good news more often. Go forth One Accord!
7thetruth8 4 years ago
exactly.....AMEN!
bigmrclean 3 years ago
Good sound. But the performance was a quite stilted. It's a great song but here it had no feeling... No "Oomph!"
As for the bass singer. He has potential that time will bring out. As for this video though, his voice was too bright.
I, myself, sing in a mixed quintet here in Ms, so I know how it can be starting out. One Accord Quartet, good luck in your ministry.
AmericanPride42 4 years ago 2
he is not a bass hes more a baritone bass or low baritone or a high baritone bass good sounding group though
basssinger0051 4 years ago 2
fantastic group and I wish I could start a quartet with that bass. WOW!
cgtdawg4020 4 years ago
Are you actually listening to him???? OK singer, but not a very low bass singer .
simsman1975 4 years ago 2
id like to hear more of this group.what are they called?
steelpole1956 4 years ago
In One Accord Quartet
huvvahuvva 4 years ago
Cool...thank you guys.
theheartbeat44 4 years ago
Nice harmonies.
louthebody 4 years ago