Carly Smithson American Idol Glendale 2008 Heart

[ksluvscs]

Agreed. She should have won or AT LEAST been top 2 with David Cook.

[jackson4socks]

I love the tone of her voice. Amazing! she should have won.

[cbotten106]

Carly is amazing. I agree.

[bleedingxlove3]

i wanted her to be at least in top 3.

[DooDaht]

her and michael should have been in the top 4.

[rdushir]

the top 4 should have been david a david c carly and syesha with michael at 5

[PinkLoverSammy]

what are those things on her hand? anyone? is it because she's allergic to metal??

[rdushir]

I think it's just gloves to go with the look

[rockmusiclover16]

she is good but i think david archuleta is way better.

[countrySTAR06]

God Dman she can sing her ass off

[hottyMcl]

amazing

[RequiemLacrimosa]

she needs to start singing the song in a lower key, if you pay attention there are several parts of the song where she scratches up her throat. If she keeps that up, by the end of the tour she won't have a voice.

[absolutjared]

shut up, idiot.

judging's over. she's a star already.

[bgrulzz]

Crazy amazing! :P

i love Carly!

Cant wait to buy her album!

[rdushir]

there are moments in this when she totoally reminds me of irish melissa mcghee

[rdushir]

how is it she didn't win!?!?!?

[philippineMJfan]

her hair looks gorgeous!! she definitely rocks! and i agree, she could take the whole tour on her own!!

go carly!! take care of that voice of yours!! you're amazing! :)

[bregieirofernandes]

this girl is bloody brilliant.

[puupposka]

what is that song she sings before Crazy on you starts? Or is it part of the song? lol? :D

Anyways, absolultely AMAZING!!

And lol, is she wearing leather pants :D ??

[sweetersacrifice]

Part of song.

[puupposka]

thanks!

[HopelessPursuit]

amazing! i love her!

[starstruk4DC]

The Irish girl rocks!!

[hottyMcl]

freaking crazy good thats what this is

[hottyMcl]

WOW FREAKIN AMAZING

[cbotten106]

Take care of your voice Carly! What a crazy set she chose.

[countrySTAR06]

damn those pants are really tight lol

[irishsweethearttx]

Haha, countrySTAR06,

If you a guy, I bet you like them! :P AHAHA!

Im kidding. She looks fabulous.

[countrySTAR06]

lol well im a chick. and i dont think i could EVER wear those pants. how the hell do you even breathe??

[irishsweethearttx]

Haha, really? I'd totally wear the whole outfit. I love her style. And, it's easy to breathe because they are fake leather. :d

[irishsweethearttx]

Shes absolutely gorgeous, her hair looks fabuloous, and her singing is flawless! :D

[katharinelover]

By the way..it looks like you had awesome seats!

What row were you on?

[sweetersacrifice]

Row 26

[katharinelover]

AHHHHHHHHH!

I freaking LOVE Carly!

Can't wait to see her on August 17th in Charlotteeeeee!

:)

[veruccasalt07]

Carly is amazing!!

[Danaref]

wow!

[StacyKeiblerFan1]

She is gorgeous