@Justapackking not sure, i like each of these songs, but jose's is kind of more peacefull, i guess this is more similar with original, each of them have its own magic
HEY Guys!! I am a young singer/songwriter called Kelsey Conroy from theUK. I am trying t get my muscheard wit a promotional fund of £0 so I am left to spam!- SORRY! Please "thumbs up" this comment to help get my music seen!- would be so greatfull if you did! Have a great day! p.s CHECK OUT my Ellie Goulding cover of "Guns and Horses" Thanks! From Kelsey! x x
jose gonzales already covered it in this style so it wasn't particularly good. and the singing just wasn't as good.
surprisingly the guitar was actually pretty nice, but i don't think it fits the song as well as the simpler gonzales one - in this song it was a little too upbeat and "strummy". it almost sounded folkish. when this song should sound a lot more subdued and gentle imo.
it would have been a good cover if it wasn't a copy of gonzales, but he already did it better.
i think its a really good version of the song. i saw jose gonzales performing this song, and it was amazing but i do like ellie gouldings version! its pretty good and i love her voice!
you ever see those people who always think they're so awesome by saying things like "The original was the best..this just sucks" kind of trash? Most of them have massive egos, and I'll bet my nuts they think they're original at most they do. The Knife, the first..was an awesome electronic tune steeped in meaning that one can not only dance to, but feel. Jose, slowed it down, and intensified the feeling factor. Ellie, delivered the same as Jose..with a little added feminine comfort. ALL GREAT!
Jose gonzalez all the way, original is not particularly my taste-no offense just my opinion, n this version is just... There's no fuckin feel in it or passion... Sorry ellie x
if i haven't heard jose gonzalez's version i'd say this is perfect. but it takes 2'nd place then.. but her cover is beautiful in it's own way. she's got an amazing voice and that's really something these days. anyways, the point is- great cover.
Personally i feel this is the best verse for a few reasons. Firstly it beats the original as i feel,even though i like all versions musically, i feel it didnt match the lyric. Secondly it beats jose's as even though the guitar is sublime in it, i feel it is too monotonous and can get boring hence why this is the best as the composition matches the words and also her voice is amazing. Lastly because i have the biggest crush known to man on Ellie :P
@DavidWilsonization check out the version by Jose Gonzales, the original suuuucks! Ellie is good but I think Jose is much better. I wanna know what you think :)
i'm sorry but i prefer Ellie to Jose its just something about her voice the tone its like perfection. but that's my option boy are way good don't hate or compare :)
Jose Gonzalez smashes this I'm afraid, the dynamic he plays around with is much nicer, this seems pretty monotone. Seems like shes just ripped his version tbh especially with the doubled up vocals in the chorus
@bcwilde in some ways his can be better, i mean, ellie did hers live, and is what i think the most beautiful live singer that has ever lived, where as jozes' wasn't live and it was edited, as you can see from the corners of the video, im sure it definitaly isnt all that autotune shit with him, but whos saying it isnt? still great song. :)
Jose Gonzalez smashes this I'm afraid, the dynamic he plays around with is much nicer, this seems pretty monotone. Seems like shes just ripped his version tbh especially with the doubled up vocals in the chorus
@bcwilde I agree with you. This version is good, but it's pretty much just her covering this song in the style of Jose Gonzalez. He totally changed the feel of the song, for the better.
@AngelBeeps I agree. My favourite version will always be the original by The Knife, but very closely followed by this. I much prefer it to Jose Gonzales
@ConallA lolwut? Mate, do your research before saying such stupid things.
A simple wikipedia search on Jose Gonzales under the 'Singles' section of the article reads "Heartbeats (The Knife cover)" (January 9, 2006) #9 UK, #66 AUS" The Knife released it in 2001. Now tell me Retard, cow can a song that came out in 2001 be a cover of a song that came out in 2006. You're an idiot.
I haven't listened to this for weeks and weeks. Now I do and it makes me cry... I'm not sure why. It reminds me of the man I love, and how amazing it is to be with him... I just wish he loved me back I guess :/
Great:)
tomf2201 3 days ago
She looks really hot in this picture lol XD
DarkFragGamers 4 days ago
Really, quite good that.
WillJRogers123 5 days ago
Bah, I just came.
w0000dpecker 1 week ago
This is the most beautiful cover of a cover i have ever heard <3
BeccaW9 1 week ago in playlist Liked videos 2
For those asking! I put another download link on the information bar, take a look. RIP Megaupload :(
Enjoy music! ;)
strawberryfields4you 2 weeks ago
Sweet!
Mickayish 2 weeks ago
Need a new download link since megaupload got punked =(
sasafraser 2 weeks ago
@sasafraser I've just put a new link, enjoy! :)
strawberryfields4you 2 weeks ago
hmm...nah the Knife´s live version of this is still better.
Falloutcookingshow 3 weeks ago 4
Sorry but the spirit of the Knife has been totally lost
zaie91 3 weeks ago
@zaie91 i know.. but its a differnet spirit. and i think thy are of equal worth.... personally =/
unfuckingavailable 2 weeks ago
who is that?
genowhirl 3 weeks ago in playlist ownage
@genowhirl ellie goulding... thats why it says at the top ellie goulding- heartbeats...
shewasonly15 3 weeks ago
i can't stand the woman at the beginning
silverfoxzzz 1 month ago
2001like:)
MaurikaCAE 1 month ago
Her voice is orgasmic!!
Samuraislash600 1 month ago 2
is this better than joses one?
Justapackking 1 month ago
@Justapackking not sure, i like each of these songs, but jose's is kind of more peacefull, i guess this is more similar with original, each of them have its own magic
polostor 1 month ago
60 people are TONE-DEAF.
manmictash 1 month ago
Lol, Megaupload link in the description.
harreh91 1 month ago 4
I love this version!
rosieemilymusic 1 month ago
I even liked it when she sang "Satellite". Anyway U.A. need any more proof? Thought not...;)
SuperZerodotcom 2 months ago
There's a male voice in the background for those not using earphones atm.
SuperZerodotcom 2 months ago
@SuperZerodotcom do I need headphones to hear it ? lol.
MakissTV 1 month ago
@MakissTV some do...U? prolly not ;)
SuperZerodotcom 1 month ago
@SuperZerodotcom got studio monitors haha
MakissTV 1 month ago
@MakissTV LoL
SuperZerodotcom 1 month ago
You guys are aware of the fact this is in one take right? Like Kind of Blue with Miles Davis (he was a true genius...and the answer is turqoise)!
SuperZerodotcom 2 months ago
Lina...I liked you. Keep the 480...I'm not angry with you (anymore).
SuperZerodotcom 2 months ago 2
wow. this is amazing. i love her she's my favorite female singer. for sure
Chiavarii 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
HEY Guys!! I am a young singer/songwriter called Kelsey Conroy from theUK. I am trying t get my muscheard wit a promotional fund of £0 so I am left to spam!- SORRY! Please "thumbs up" this comment to help get my music seen!- would be so greatfull if you did! Have a great day! p.s CHECK OUT my Ellie Goulding cover of "Guns and Horses" Thanks! From Kelsey! x x
KelseyConroyx 2 months ago
Oh my god.
Harryhamlyn 2 months ago
The Knife gave pattern, but what Jose Gonzales made of this is just briliant.
I've no more to say!
thor1202 2 months ago 2
Lovebal :D
hamajuggle 2 months ago
Respect the original, none of the other cover matters.
asutn 2 months ago
this and jose gonzalez, wow
helenc121 2 months ago
Sen-fucking-sational
RickyHigham123 3 months ago in playlist Liked videos
nothing like Jose Gonzale's song
TGIJoshy 3 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
YouTube.com
/watch?v=4SknBY37dVg
ROCK VERSION ^^
LaurieBuchananMusic 3 months ago
The original is still the best. All these acoustic versions just sound like buskers having a go.
AlbertBundy 3 months ago 3
Vraiment pas mal la reprise de José Gonzalès en version acoustique
mrtcuni 3 months ago
jose gonzales already covered it in this style so it wasn't particularly good. and the singing just wasn't as good.
surprisingly the guitar was actually pretty nice, but i don't think it fits the song as well as the simpler gonzales one - in this song it was a little too upbeat and "strummy". it almost sounded folkish. when this song should sound a lot more subdued and gentle imo.
it would have been a good cover if it wasn't a copy of gonzales, but he already did it better.
dm9910 3 months ago
i think its a really good version of the song. i saw jose gonzales performing this song, and it was amazing but i do like ellie gouldings version! its pretty good and i love her voice!
startbeingyoung 3 months ago 2
you ever see those people who always think they're so awesome by saying things like "The original was the best..this just sucks" kind of trash? Most of them have massive egos, and I'll bet my nuts they think they're original at most they do. The Knife, the first..was an awesome electronic tune steeped in meaning that one can not only dance to, but feel. Jose, slowed it down, and intensified the feeling factor. Ellie, delivered the same as Jose..with a little added feminine comfort. ALL GREAT!
MrLexanderluther1986 3 months ago
WOW!! shes done this song Justice!! beautiful voice!
ikklehippie 3 months ago
Jose gonzalez all the way, original is not particularly my taste-no offense just my opinion, n this version is just... There's no fuckin feel in it or passion... Sorry ellie x
justhamid 3 months ago
Nice try but imho both the knife and josé gonzales does it better.
matszz 4 months ago
Which ever the original is the best, nothing else.
asutn 4 months ago
Jose Gonzalez version <3
GetStuffed04 4 months ago
put it on 480p, its like a different song <3
boboingthebaggies 4 months ago 184
@boboingthebaggies omg it is!
TheFoxMau5 4 months ago
@boboingthebaggies NO IT'S NOT!!!!!!!!
adamennis999 3 months ago
@boboingthebaggies how do ya do that?
magiller2010 1 month ago
@boboingthebaggies how?
magiller2010 1 week ago
memories<3
alicechan96 4 months ago
amazing <3
PixieJay15 4 months ago 2
i'd say its different to both and its a unique cover she has made it her own
shitcuntmotherfucker 4 months ago
This song is amazing.Every cover is great in its own way.
phillipsqazxsw 4 months ago
this is beautiful
alugavere 4 months ago
i think this captures the essence of both versions because of the female vocals and serene acoustic guitars. all three compliment really well.
ultragabe 4 months ago
if i haven't heard jose gonzalez's version i'd say this is perfect. but it takes 2'nd place then.. but her cover is beautiful in it's own way. she's got an amazing voice and that's really something these days. anyways, the point is- great cover.
kaya2204 4 months ago
The knife version is better . sorry
ztech45 5 months ago 5
The Knife made it, Jose Gonzalez perfected it....this was good, but unecessary.
pomeroy600287 5 months ago
She sounds like a whiny child...doesn't compare to The Knife or Jose...bad show!
TheDobalob 5 months ago
This is more of a cover of Jose Gonzalez's version than it is a cover of the original.
laHeretic 5 months ago 103
@laHeretic EXACTLY.
shobhnaiyer 4 months ago
@laHeretic good, jose's version blows the knife out of the water.
Iey9 3 months ago
@laHeretic I wasn't aware of an original. I always thought it was Joses song.
DuckFolk 1 month ago in playlist Liked videos
she always fucks covers up look at your song she ruined
missuscam 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this song gets me all jolly
TingTungTizzle 5 months ago
Comment removed
TingTungTizzle 5 months ago
this is really good :)
the knife's live version will always be my favorite
TMSreptiles 5 months ago
jose's is good
this is nice and im glad she redid it
The Knife's live version is the best
nonamerify 5 months ago
jose is better but befor this chik was big her tunes were good
shakesmadness 5 months ago
Jose Gonzales is the best cover version, but this is amazing!
Iuk0 5 months ago
I like Ellie's version because I can actually understand the words when she sings them :)
AlexandraKate08 5 months ago
oh yes!
SillyCee3 5 months ago in playlist Liked
it's amazing that this is live :)
LadyIsisXIX 6 months ago
Can iI jsut say I lvoe you ellie goulding and you need to bring out a new album :( (like if you've never got a top comment :/)
Jimbobjojo 6 months ago
Personally i feel this is the best verse for a few reasons. Firstly it beats the original as i feel,even though i like all versions musically, i feel it didnt match the lyric. Secondly it beats jose's as even though the guitar is sublime in it, i feel it is too monotonous and can get boring hence why this is the best as the composition matches the words and also her voice is amazing. Lastly because i have the biggest crush known to man on Ellie :P
DavidWilsonization 6 months ago 4
@DavidWilsonization i meant version on top line
DavidWilsonization 6 months ago
@DavidWilsonization check out the version by Jose Gonzales, the original suuuucks! Ellie is good but I think Jose is much better. I wanna know what you think :)
MrZyrno 6 months ago in playlist More videos from strawberryfields4you
This is so much better than the messed up original, and Jose's more mellow version, for me the guitar made the song, just my opinion
EllBailz 6 months ago in playlist EllBailz's Favorited Videos
This has been flagged as spam show
Hey guys, if any of you are interested in guitar fingerstyle instrumentals, check out my channel, more videos to come :)
EllBailz 6 months ago
BLEUGH!!!!!!!!!!!
blooadong 6 months ago
The cover by Jose Gonzalez is so much better than this crap
milot914 6 months ago
mind is a razor blade :-(
TYLER170304 6 months ago
I'm pretty sure at least half of those views are mine.
scott16021989 6 months ago
although i ADORE the girl from the knife... i like this version better. i think the song is just better suited to acoustic guitar
tragicnotbeautiful 7 months ago
I'm not sure why but this just made me cry.
SplinterCell37 7 months ago 2
Wow she sang with such a thick English accent in this song! You almost can't tell her accent in songs like "Starry Eyed"
RavenNightcrawler 7 months ago
I probably love her
jener85 7 months ago
The best version is Jose Gonzales's, but this is alright.
misspriss421 7 months ago 2
Tits or get the fuck off.
MrBickyBurger 7 months ago
@MrBickyBurger So you're telling me you would sit and listen to Katy Perry or Rihanna sing live naked while your ears bleed?
Sup3rMegaNerd 7 months ago
Freakin hell! how lovely :|
sakurakiri21 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Check out Pink vs Ellie Goulding in my Video Section!!!!
djbootox 7 months ago
Prefer jose's version and prefer the knifes to him aswell but she did a decent cover
MrBrennan118118 7 months ago 2
Gosh ! that's beautiful !
SmilemeXD 7 months ago 2
Jose gonzalez version is the best, love it. But I have to admit that this covers is also really speciel. It catches me in a very speciel way.
lunapigen 8 months ago 38
to call for hands of above to lean on
Wouldn't be good enough for me, no. she sings "to call for hands from above"
still a good cover though
kelvbundy 8 months ago 3
Great song by the knife, which in my opinion Jose Gonzalez made even better. This is pretty good too.
lairyleroy87 8 months ago
Soo sehr herzklopfen!
Queen0fLe0n 8 months ago
PERFECTLY BEAUTIFUL
derris 8 months ago
480p sounds way better!
xwilsonza 8 months ago 7
I played this song for like 10 times and every time when it ends I'm still surprised that I was holding my breath for the whole song :o
baronborric 8 months ago 2
nice cover! god job
122olimpia 8 months ago
But Ellie is doing a cover of Joses version, his is the best!
mirwin931 8 months ago
I LOVE YOU ELLIE GOULDING!!!
thefookolhu 8 months ago
I heard a pretty sweet remix of this song. Can search for it on youtube. 'Cosmonaut Grechko edit'.
robmundo 8 months ago
Okay, quit all of the disputes.. Jose and Ellie should just do a duet :)
RahRahZilia 8 months ago 3
i'm sorry but i prefer Ellie to Jose its just something about her voice the tone its like perfection. but that's my option boy are way good don't hate or compare :)
bradleyy2kaii8 8 months ago 3
so beautiful... love it
ImaCrazySceneager 9 months ago
it gives to the original version a real, emotional touch
revengerknight92 9 months ago
A M A Z I N G
magnum4401 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hey please take a listen my song STUPID SUPERSTITIONS would mean a lot! xx
beehdeee 9 months ago
Is there footage of her playing this anywhere? I'd love to see how she plays this and what the other guitarist is doing...
cougarman8 9 months ago 2
Jose Gonzalez smashes this I'm afraid, the dynamic he plays around with is much nicer, this seems pretty monotone. Seems like shes just ripped his version tbh especially with the doubled up vocals in the chorus
bcwilde 9 months ago 2
@bcwilde in some ways his can be better, i mean, ellie did hers live, and is what i think the most beautiful live singer that has ever lived, where as jozes' wasn't live and it was edited, as you can see from the corners of the video, im sure it definitaly isnt all that autotune shit with him, but whos saying it isnt? still great song. :)
TheGeoneon 9 months ago
Jose Gonzalez smashes this I'm afraid, the dynamic he plays around with is much nicer, this seems pretty monotone. Seems like shes just ripped his version tbh especially with the doubled up vocals in the chorus
bcwilde 9 months ago
@bcwilde I agree with you. This version is good, but it's pretty much just her covering this song in the style of Jose Gonzalez. He totally changed the feel of the song, for the better.
anonymouslolxD 9 months ago
My favourite singer and radio station = pure bliss.
EmmaCPhillips1521 9 months ago
Comment removed
ElliotBell2 9 months ago
The Knife's original version will always be the best but this the best cover I've heard.
AngelBeeps 9 months ago 89
@AngelBeeps Jose Gonzalez version of it is pretty special.
Amateratsu21 9 months ago 2
@Amateratsu21 It's pretty good, doesn't have the same charm though, I think the song works best with a female vocalist.
AngelBeeps 9 months ago
@AngelBeeps I agree. My favourite version will always be the original by The Knife, but very closely followed by this. I much prefer it to Jose Gonzales
spider23000 8 months ago
@AngelBeeps LOL you're kidding me right? Jose Gonzalez has the most sublime cover. I actually prefer it to the original
battlecaps 8 months ago
@battlecaps Nope, not kidding, just a different preference. :p
AngelBeeps 8 months ago
@AngelBeeps Jose Gonzalez's version is better
seanirons 8 months ago 2
@seanirons In your opinion.
AngelBeeps 8 months ago 2
@AngelBeeps No shit sherlock
seanirons 8 months ago
@seanirons
Well I prefer hers. Bite me.
AngelBeeps 8 months ago 6
@AngelBeeps I meant better than the original, but better than hers aswell I spose. And no thanks I'm not sure if you're a man or woman.
seanirons 8 months ago
@AngelBeeps Couldn't agree more :)
80snessEj 8 months ago
@AngelBeeps Couldn't agree with you more.
lexa490 7 months ago
@AngelBeeps The Knife's Version was terrible. That's why it got nowhere.
GeorgeGetsPwned 7 months ago
@GeorgeGetsPwned Cool story bro.
AngelBeeps 7 months ago
@AngelBeeps tell it again.
143mark6275 7 months ago
Comment removed
ConallA 7 months ago
@ConallA lolwut? Mate, do your research before saying such stupid things.
A simple wikipedia search on Jose Gonzales under the 'Singles' section of the article reads "Heartbeats (The Knife cover)" (January 9, 2006) #9 UK, #66 AUS" The Knife released it in 2001. Now tell me Retard, cow can a song that came out in 2001 be a cover of a song that came out in 2006. You're an idiot.
AngelBeeps 7 months ago 3
@ConallA absolute shitlad. what are you talking about? idiot
LateralOPG 7 months ago
@LateralOPG TellingithowitisLAD
ScottBale100 7 months ago
@AngelBeeps Jose Gonzalez's cover will always be the best!
gaellegazou 6 months ago
@gaellegazou Thanks for sharing your opinion, not that I asked for it.
AngelBeeps 6 months ago
@AngelBeeps Who cares if you didnt ask for it. Its youtube. Im pretty sure you will live. And by the way, Ellie Goulding's cover BEATS ALL!!!
adamjamesbond007 6 months ago
@AngelBeeps Heard of Joze Gonzales?
Tmeister111 5 months ago
@Tmeister111 Yup. Not a fan.
AngelBeeps 5 months ago
@AngelBeeps hose gonzales's is defo up there
wagwuam 5 months ago
@AngelBeeps the knife's original version although a good song, is not my music style, i prefer acoustic songs :)
itzbizzee 5 months ago
@itzbizzee Well you have to give them credit, if it weren't for them you wouldn't be listening to this. :3
AngelBeeps 5 months ago
@AngelBeeps yes of course all credit to them i was just saying i prefer jose's
itzbizzee 5 months ago
@AngelBeeps aww, what about Jose's cover? :L
fluffy6596 5 months ago
@AngelBeeps aww, what about Jose's cover? :L
fluffy6596 5 months ago
@fluffy6596 I'm sick of being asked this exact same question every damn week! XD
To all of you who thumbed up my comment, thanks but you have cursed me! D:
Just look through the comments dude, I've answered this like twelve times already. XD
AngelBeeps 5 months ago
@AngelBeeps hahah okay xD
fluffy6596 5 months ago
whats a 480p? :s
Flobbarus 9 months ago
defiantly way better in 480 p
joshichabod 9 months ago
defiantly way better in 480 p
joshichabod 9 months ago
this is amazing
hannahlouwatson 9 months ago
Her voice gives me chills... thinking music.
clareisphit 9 months ago 2
I haven't listened to this for weeks and weeks. Now I do and it makes me cry... I'm not sure why. It reminds me of the man I love, and how amazing it is to be with him... I just wish he loved me back I guess :/
jenziix3 9 months ago
will you marry me ?
Tesco4eva 9 months ago
Not a patch on young José
SurkaLurka 10 months ago
Comment removed
4444de 10 months ago 2
@peacelove090909 No it's a cover.
Sup3rMegaNerd 10 months ago
perfection :D
BlackSwan1610 10 months ago
her voice is perfection
aliceroberts1000 10 months ago
Wow.
MissTwilightHater 10 months ago
i like gonzalez's better, especially with the sony advert video, with the bouncy balls haha? :)
ilovekolx 10 months ago 6
Far better than Gonzalez's cover, but still far from The Knife's original.
neonismyfavorite4444 10 months ago
@neonismyfavorite4444 Seriously? Not bad but absolutely nothing on Jose's version if you ask me..
SRWORKYT 10 months ago 3