A Perfect Circle Judith Live @ Rock on the Range 2011

[DropShotDixon502]

i dont see what all the negative drama about apc being the headliner was about. they blew a7x out of the water.

[kmedina419]

I want the back drop... Was amazing show to the least

[snicklefritz7861]

I WAS THERE! FRONT N CENTER!



[sebastian16w]

this was a kick ass concert, I will be there every year

[EricAntonik]

I wish Paz and Troy Van Leeuwen were still in the band. That line-up was something real special.

[TaOpOcLmjk462]

oh thats right the jus didnt close with judith

[TaOpOcLmjk462]

u guys sure this is rrontr

[RocktheRange2208]

@TaOpOcLmjk462 Yes it is @ Rock on the Range. I recorded it and was there...

[mapavlikify]

@TaOpOcLmjk462 Absolutely sure, I was there too. Only time they played it during the general tour, not counting the mini tour on west coast. Felt really happy to get to see it even though they didn't play By and Down at this show.

[dusty42482]

Now why in the fuck did they not play this in atlanta or Kanrocksas!!! Bullshit we got stuck with a bunch of eMotive bullshit. Who the hell wants to hear that when the original stuff kicks so much ass!!!! No Judith, no Blue, a dumb remix of 3 Libras, that in itself is worth cock punches to each band member

[46andT00L]

@dusty42482

I'm just going to give you the benefit of the doubt, laugh, and hope this "setlist wish" is your idea of a joke. Hahahahaha, too funny. Hoping for weak attempts at playing "Judith" over well orchestrated covers from eMotive and a righteous-ass performance of the All Main Courses Mix of 'Libras...I lol'd.

Please tell me this is sarcasm directed at most closed-minded, dipshit APC fans XD

[dusty42482]

@46andT00L

The only covers on Emotive worth playing are Imagine, Passive, and War Drums. You might think they are "well orchestrated" but they suck. The melody for the original 3 Libras kills the remix version and the music is not near as powerful. So I want to hear APC's original compositions and that make me a dipshit fan? The joke is you sir.

[46andT00L]

@dusty42482

Friedl's drum work on "What's Going On" and "People Are People" is absolutely top notch. "When The Levee Breaks" and "Gimme Gimme Gimme" both brought Maynard into his element vocally. "Annihilation" and "Fiddle and the Drum" were perfect aesthetic openers/closers. So no, I don't think "Imagine" is the only cover on eMotive worth playing. By the way, "Passive" and "Counting..." aren't covers; those are originals, sir.

[Siamiesedreams]

@46andTOOL WELL SAID!!! Love it all! Minor thing, "Passive" actually derived from a song that MJK wrote with Trent Reznor in their project called Tapeworm. The song was originally titled "Vacant". So it's borderline a cover because it was written by both Rez and MJK, yet it was never released and I'm sure it sounds different from the original. As for @dusty42482, uh....I'm just gonna shake my head. Pity.

[Siamiesedreams]

@46andTOOL WELL SAID!!! Love it all! Minor thing, "Passive" actually derived from a song that MJK wrote with Trent Reznor in their project called Tapeworm. The song was originally titled "Vacant". So it's borderline a cover because it was written by both Rez and MJK, yet it was never released and I'm sure it sounds different from the original. As for @dusty42482, uh....I'm just gonna shake my head. Pity.

[46andT00L]

@Siamiesedreams

You're right about it being a borderline cover, I just like to consider it an original :) "Vacant" has such a raw feel to it. Shame it was never released, but the videos I've seen from the Mer De Noms & 13th Step tours sure do sound nice. Thanks for being an advocate of accurate information. Peace, brother.

[46andT00L]

@dusty42482

P.S. - "...and that make me a dipshit fan?"

I never said that. You simply inferred it :] Thanks anyway, haha.

And I certainly hope I am "the joke". What's the point to life if you can't laugh at yourself?

[pinkzeppelin421]

Really pissed they didnt play this and alot of other stuff when i saw them in St. Paul. They could have put on a way better show and handed the crowd dog turds and dick-taters

[16bmorgan]

I was bummed when they did not play this the other night in atlanta but they were fucking awesome

[rickythegreat462]

man i wish they played this song on the other shows of this tour

[GaryLeeLeviErvin10]

they were amazing that night i was going crazy when they played

[nolson4062]

I like to think I sound this good when I sing this song on Guitar Hero!

[CBJackets07]

Maynerd is the best song writer I have ever seen!

[543567432678321789]

@CBJackets07 Ha, try Billy Howerdel

[NJP609]

@543567432678321789 Maynard revamped judith after he first saw what billy had for it so far, he changed it to make it about his mother, so basically maynard rewrote the whole song lyrically

[NJP609]

Maynard revamped judith after he first saw what billy had for it so far, he changed it to make it about his mother, so basically maynard rewrote the whole song lyrically

[deeroni9577]

 A Perfect performance!!thanx!

[BuriedAlive7x]

Man i love this band>>>APC!!

[TheMofo666]

These guys were amazing!! the rain made the show fuckin crazy lookin