Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (181)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • If don't compare it to the album, it sounds great: if you listen to it and presume that it was meant to sound like this (which it may well have been) that it sounds totally fine.

  • Comment removed

  • Qtip definitely holds up well compared to the record version. MNDR sounds just terrible. If she was singing this in a karaoke bar I'd have thrown something. Brittney, Rhianna and other 'babes' get a break is because they are sold as plastic music. There is no reason Mark Ronson should be recording with people who can't sing.

  • @ifpr534 fuck you ,she sound perfect for this song... !!

  • si es una cancion francesa, que habla de desplular y degollar una Alondra

    gentille allouette .............. hahha , y es de niños que enseñanaza

  • Wow she sounds great on the album but terrible in this! some people just can't sing live I guess, that or her voice is synthesized. Man that was a horrible performance all in all (QTip did ok though), wouldn't have done them any favors, luckily the sound sounded great on the radio.

  • She sounds somewhat not as bad for the second half of the song.

  • beck was fresh in his day i agree,odelay was fab.

  • Ronson is a breathe of fresh air!! Like a new Beck. Music in 2011 is stale and lifeless, I blame that fuckin evil cunt Simon Cowell in ruining new music!! The guy is a total prick!! Cowell wouldnt know good music if it came up and sucked his big tits!!

  • @coltsuperocean10 what did cowell said about Mark Ronson? i love the guy his album is brilliant! bought, went to see him and the Business Int'l and it was woooorth it!

  • I think Q-Tip manged to salvage a bit of this performance!

  • I would like to be deaf

  • @naacho0880 careful what you wish for - you might just get it

  • q tip reminds me at steve urkel

  • she isnt gr8 but iv heard far worse. the music vid is fuking deadly do:)

  • Comment removed

  • Fuck it's a young deirdre barlow.

  • This is a fantastic live performance. I actually saw this before I heard the single and just fell in love with the song.

  • @y0uthagainstfacism no you didn't.

  • @anddyx Yes I did. I don't listen to the radio. However, I saw this on Jonathan Ross. Then downloaded the single.

  • @y0uthagainstfacism I don't believe you.

  • @anddyx ...wow.

  • i actually think she sounds pretty good, her voice is different, perfect for the song

  • she's out of the pitch sometimes

  • Blimey - Sue Pollard's aged well!

  • check out my version of the bike song?? or.. not/..

    xxxx

  • Anyone bitching about MNDR's voice should try performing live while sick so we can toss rotton eggs at you behind the safety of a screen.

  • @AlbeeSquareMall how do you know she was sick?

  • @sandysnowbeard Good call, that's an assumtion but after hearing her other performances (this song and others) it sounds like her throat is stressed/unusually gravelly here so I hear it as singing with a cold. Plus her normally energetic presense is missing.

  • its good how mark ronson is unique of what he does.

  • fail awesome fail only q-tip owns

  • Comment removed

  • Mark Ronson | Kelis @ Puerto Giesing - Munich --> 10|19|10

    we we we puerto - giesing . de

  • Mark Ronson | Kelis @ Puerto Giesing - Munich --> 10|19|10

    go to FB (puertogiesing)

  • Q-tip is great live :D

  • @KFUNK100 have you ever seen him live?...and yea hes freakin awsome

  • @melara111193 no ive never seen live, i was saying hes good here :) sorry

  • People you can clearly hear in her voice that she is sick. Like someone said before the show must go on! I have alot of respect for her for pulling it through even though she was sick. I can hear it all in her throat. I like MNDR and I have seen them b4 and she sounded fine. She just wasn't 100% during this performance

  • I didnt know olive from 'on the buses' sang.

  • wow this songs shit live

  • hah the female singer looks way older here D:

  • shes much better on jools holland

  • is it me or this girl's got little control over her voice? or maybe she's got stressed..

  • i think this song is genius. i don't understand it but i luv it lool :D

  • mark and q-tip were great, but mndr..damn girl get it together..

  • I'm no fan boy, this was the first I heard of MNDR but she has a good voice. Half of these people don't know what they're talking about it. It's live, get over it.

  • not as good as live i think

  • she aint no gd live

  • ~Whos the business then?

  • q-tip is still great-!

  • her voice is so bad she sounds ok on the video (:s

  • After Reg Verney left on the Buses Olive reinvented herself as quirky pop chick

  • I really don't think her voice is as bad as some people are making out, she's pithcy in places- but i've seen rihanna and others on jonathan ross and they were not only pitchy but off key. Give the girl a break!

  • @torifuentes yeah, it fits her alternative style....and at least this song is not overflowing with autotune

  • @torifuentes have you already heard kate perry o myle cyrus in a live concert, is the worst thing i ever hear in my life, that is whe you realice that they are only prefrebicated products, only to make fast money, you need a very educated ear to apreciate good music, and good voice too, like this

  • @torifuentes yeah i think she was just nervous. she held it together pretty well.

  • @torifuentes I love how u have to put down one artist in order to hype up another...real classy :)

  • when it's live that girl sings awfull it's bad i'm sorry but the CD song is great!

  • wow omg im shocked at mndr terrible singing :-( after hearing this song on sum music channle i was like praticly in love with her but after watching this eww lol but omg i cant stop listening to this song not this version though lol i must be laced with audio heroin or somthing lol im addicted lol

  • wow, mndr is sooo bad live... :(

  • wow, mndr is sooo bad live... :(

  • Oh my god she's soooooo bad!She did a good job on the studio version,but Mark Ronson should fire her and hire another girl to sing the live version...

  • The girl from MNDR annoys me so much! One of many indie-schmindie idiots who thinks charisma comes in clothes from Urban Outfitters, big glasses and an affected vocal.

  • I LOVE this song - it's my FAVOURITE! But 1:08 her voice is TERRIBLE :S

  • Q-Tip, Mark and the band are great, but wtf is up with Amanda's voice? It was so good on the studio version!

  • I like Mark Ronson but this is the worse thing he's ever done.Crap.

  • if i was a guy i would make love to her because of her voice :) xxx

  • She has a bad live voice but the song is good.

  • I think she sounded pritty good and she obviously is or else Mark Ronson wouldent of chose her too sing the song and i think hes knows more about music than the people commenting on youtube :)

  • @millsymo1234 lol u put me in my place lol fair doos i really hope she was just having a bad day because im becomming a fan lol she ounds good in her other stuff too just even u have to admit she was god awfull there

  • A bit of echo and she would have sounded fine ;-/

  • 3:54 mark ronson is fuckin his keyboard xD

  • I can imagine Kate Pierson from the B-52's singing her part

  • This is 80s flamboyance like I haven't seen since I was a kid. Love it.

  • The girl cant sing but still a great song!

  • 1:07 AAAAAHHHHHH she cant sing!!!!!!!!

  • @gastonHamburg holy fuck i was waiting for this and ur right loool

  • Q-tip is still amazing

  • She sounds like an Xfactor reject who was put just for entertainment (e.g Jedward)

  • This made me a bit sad.. really liked the girl before i watched this -_- she was so awsum in the studio version! but this is pretty bad actually :( Mark Ronson is great though :>

  • Mr mark WONSON!!

  • @wiz2b08 haha epic ;D

  • she aint that good live

    love this song

    im liking the piano in this version

  • The girls is not a brilliant singer but really the song is just amazing. Who cares, just give us a beat , a melody , good rap and let the girl sing (as best as she can :) )

  • q tip is who kanye west wishes he was.

  • @TokinBloke so true!

  • she sounds fine to me

  • MR MARK WONSON

  • @MACfoo16 hahah ;P

  • Q tip brilliant girl not so good

  • Q-tip's outfit is awesome :]

  • live, the girl is horrible! but on cd she sounds brilliant! I love mark ronson!

  • wow she sounds horrible! everyone else delivers a great show though

  • I´ve got the same sensation ...since my first time, i´ve got the necesity and the sensation to listen an listen again this song! its the best! i need more i hope that mark could make songs better that one if it possible!!!! its the most cool song of the all that you can find actually, its imaginative, incredible, espectacular etc etc...

  • q- tip awsome live, mndr should be should be illegal to listen to

  • its a mixing problem. also its very very hard to perform such a rythmn live.

  • Songs like this are super hard to do live.. This unfortunately sounds horrible compared to the video. Amanda sounds horrible.. Qtip is good though.

  • There proper shite live !

  • Q tip is good live... her, um not so much. she sings completly wrong tone and her mouth looks weird when she sings

  • @Jaystis Thank you xx

  • can he kick it? yes he can

  • I like this song. Does anyone know what's the girl name? Thank you xx

  • @dayanalove18 amanda warner aka MNDR

  • @Marillion90 Thank you xx

  • actually quite crappy live

  • This live version is crapish... she ruins it

  • i think she sounds okay? is that wrong o.O

  • I disagree that her voice is crap, it's unique. It reminds me that it isn't just the same synthed bullshit you get nowadays

  • @piggy978 I agree piggy. Maybe she should have used autotune and then people would love it. MNDR is the fucking shit. I love her.

  • Think she had a cold?

  • I fucking love this song but it's a shame the girl sounds crap live. Q-tip is ok live though :P

  • @Tubularm8 Correction, she sounds bad here yes but I didn't know she had food poisoning here, no wonder she sounds bad so I take back what I said :)

  • Her voice is crap ! So are her looks.

  • amazing music! but that girl is so annoying

  • Ya can't do POP LIVE, it ends up POOP. Mark Ronsons music is great for radio, parties & catwalks, etc, etc...

  • love the song, q tip sounds a bit different live. still like the song though.

  • In the offical video the look much better :D

  • She is butterz and can't sing :)

  • That woman cannot sing live for shit and she looks fucking stupid i did like this song

  • @sugarsweetcandyman Agreed !

  • mndr is okay......

  • If anyones interested, the continuous synth melody thats played all the way through was done on a Sequential circuits Prophet 5 synth, program number 32. I should know, I own one. Its the one that you can see propped up behind the singers, although it does shows Mark playing a moderm synth.

  • The way Jonathan says Bang Bang Bang! lol

  • MNDR graduated from my University (NDSU) and her mom is friends with my mom! Based on e-mail I was forwarded, it seems MNDR had food poisoning that day, but of course "The show must go on!" and she performed anyway. What an amazing opportunity, and after seeing this video I found the song on iTunes (US) and have listened at least 15 times already today!! What an awesome song, and MNDR's voice is absolutely fabulous. WAY TO REPRESENT MNDR!!!!!!!

  • @digitseven pfffffffffft. Your some fucking idiot !

  • @SkiLLaChiO Who are you to say I'm an idiot? Can't I have an opinion? You're obviously the idiot if you're acting that way on YouTube... get a life!!

  • stuart zender !

  • i know the song still fresh,but they really need to re-arrange the song for live.

  • what an amazing syncopated* beat, love the xylophone at 0.57. Q Tip is great, his voice reminds me of bits of DeeLite.

    *syncopation includes a variety of rhythms which are in some way unexpected in that they deviate from the strict succession of regularly spaced strong and weak beats in a meter (pulse).

  • Too bad that MNDR sounds terrible live. She often misses her notes and her voice sounds like she has a cold or something. Q-tip and Mark Ronson are great though. I'll stick with the studio version.

  • Great song, but an absolutley awful live performance! Looks and sounds like Dierdre Barlow on the Karoake!!

  • First time I saw this song was on this show. Love it - MNDR is my kinda girl :-)

  • Leave her alone, she's strangely attractive

  • Needs some Horns

  • Superb, MNDR made this live performance great

  • also who is MNDR? i saw an interview with Mark, is she even a singer?

    i heard she was like a 'barbie geek' and works with computers and stuff?

  • @effyjeansxx

    yes, she's a NY- based singer and she creates her own beats with music programs.

  • i suppose her vocals arnt as good as the studio version, but once you get into it, she starts sounding really good

    better than half of the artists these days, they make it sounds good

    raw and quirky,

    propper 80's performace, and no playback for once,

    love mark ronson <3

  • your mad ,this is the best version I have heard, real and quirky

  • mndr live voice it's disappointing compared to the studio one...

  • I know she's saying "here's your silhouette" but it sounds like "bitches in your way"

  • I actually love the studio version of this which is why this was such a massive disappointment.

    Q-Tip was fine, but MNDR was abysmal! I'm really glad this wasn't my first time hearing the song otherwise it would have been DOA. She sounded karaoke at best, out of tune & looks like a joke (one of those singers trying desperately to be so cool and so alternative and looking like a mess as a result).

    Real disappointment....

    Still love the song though!

  • definitely better as the studio version

  • that is one of the worst songs ive ever heard

    she's a terrible singer!

  • her vocals are awful. I normally hate autotune, but in her case please inject a full dose .

  • "Friday night.." was the first time I heard that song and at first I didn't like it but then I listened to it again and again and again... There's something about it. I don't know. And while I prefer the studio version to this one, it still has its charm. MNDR sounds so amateurish, it's actually cool and Q-tip rocks. Plus there's Stu Zender on bass!

    MARK RONSON IS THE SHIT!!!!!!

  • modern pop tends to bore me, but the weird time signature and primitive synths / proggish riff reminds me of late 70's genesis. Air grabbed me the same way in '97 when i saw them on top of the pops. The music video is worth checking out too - tron-esque early 80s aesthetic. About 3.30 in to the music video it's reminiscent of the blockbusters opening credits which amusing, if probably not intentional.

  • @awesa Same with me, the song has kinda grown on me but i still dont think the woman singer deserves a contract though, she has no talent but then again the song probably wouldn't be the same without her.

  • @awesa

    This is so B52's well done Ronson lad!

  • rubbish

  • MNDR WUSSUPPPPPPP!!! She is the business in business intl!

  • Excellent use of the word fricassée in this

  • its a studio record, thats why it sounds shit, i still love it and Amanda Warner

  • Excellent single buys what's with the glasses

  • her performance was good. Bit shaky in places.. but she's good.

  • O-M-G!

    Whats up with MNDR? O.o

  • I love this, i think this performance was really good, wht are all you guys talkin about ? But her glasses look terrible

  • Ive stopped liking this song after watching this. MNDR has ruined it! bitch..

  • This is AWESOME....retro !!!

  • messy

    

  • MARK WONSON! mndr is terrible.

  • i do not see why people are saying she can sing lol. extremely disappointed. the proper song is fine hell she was one of the best things about it but live my god she sucks!

  • i hate her glasses!

  • MNDR kicked it. Absolutely sick - "B-B-B" perfectly performed LIVE. Masterful musicianship. This collection for "Collection" is the real deal.

  • Mark knows good artists , hasn't let me down yet! Love this song,addicted!

  • is this live or mimed on jonathon ross? Mimed and them just playing the record right?

  • i liked her live performance.