@IlGattonero13 I agree with you and your description of the Deller version. But there is something devastating about the perfection of the Scholl. I suppose they are both magnificent in their own way.
I love this song and I collect many versions of it, but this is the most beautiful and haunting recording I have ever heard of "Flow my tears. Just in time for Fall.
I just noticed the opening phrase is almost identical to JS Bach's Komm Suesser Tod... I know that Bach studied the Italians... did he also study the English?
Or maybe those two descending motives, ending on the leading tone, were a commonly accepted opening theme for these sorrowful arias?
And also, Scholl, as always, sings like an angel.
@b0ttomzone Interesting musings. "...did he also study the English?"
I must say I'm delightfully surprised to see a theme from Dowland turning up in a piece by Bach, but I'm not well enough versed in Bach's musical influences to decide if I *should* be all that surprised.
Bach of course, like Picasso, like Shakespeare, took whatever he could use from other artists.
Just starting to explore singing Dowland's music myself. I really like your attention to particular words i.e. 'sighs' 'groans' 'hell." I'm thinking of staring the "Hark!" verse strongly for this reason, like a full mezzoforte. Would welcome any thoughts :)
Perfect, undoubtly a good one, but in a way too "perfect" in the sense of tightness, strictness, too cold also...can't surpass, I"m sorry Alfred Deller's early versions (circa 1954-60).Well, it's just my humble opinion...
I just discovered this guy. Where has he been all my life? I listen to him and imagine myself soaking in a tub with candles everywere drinking a glass of wine. He has the most soothing voice.
I got mine on art song central (just type in flow my tears art song to google)... It doesnt sound right on a piano though, it needs a guitar/lute or harpsichord
Scholl is probably my favourite countertenor and I think this song is lovely - but typically gloomy for John Dowland! I have posted a version of me singing it - if anyone wants to listen and tell me if you think I am any good at this kind of singing I would appreciate it.
Hey! I know this! at least, a Dutch version "Mijn ziele treur" (My soul's sorrow)
You can find it by searching for "mijn ziele treur" on youtube. you will find a movie that starts with an old fashioned version of the Dutch national anthem, followed by this song.
I really like Andreas Scholl's interpretation of this piece. His voice has a very pure sound that I enjoy hearing. I wish he would pronounce "Deprived" with 3 syllables in this song. But I am not an authority on this piece, it is just what I am expecting to hear..
@pianoman1812.... The technique that Andreas Scholl use to sing is merely Technical singing, called FALSETTO is a TECHNIQUE used by ALL singers when appropriate and by countertenors most of the time.
FALSETTO is a voice production technique for singing high notes. It uses only part of the vocal cords plus the resonant spaces in the head and neck.
@pianoman1812 These days, no singer is deliberately castrated in the cause of music but there are a few endocrinological castrati whose physiology gives them the same combination of high voice and powerful projection as the 18th century castrati.
wow, this is really nice. I have to feature a Weep, o Mine eyes ( John Bennet) that was developed from this song in my choral lit class. like it alot.
My music history teacher once asked me to improvise on this for the class, but apparently my improvisation wasnt "jazzy" enough for him...as much as i love to play jazz, this tune is just too perfect in its own general feel
hi everyone, i was really turned onto dowland by the sting cd, but i notice that people say that his renditions don't exactly do dowland's music justice, could someone possibly post a message with one or two singers who sing in a traditional male vocal range who perform dowland?? thanks very much....
ps i can't believe a man can sing this way so beautifully!!!
The countertenor voice has become something of a cliche in "today's" early music. It takes the combination of Andreas Scholl & Dowland at his best to remind us how beautifully expressive it can be.
@BubCar2 Cliché? How so? It is a voice type which has been used/performed/however you want to say it, for centuries. There just happen to be a lot more good and great countertenors now, and more are recording, than in the past era of the rediscovery of early music.
Une voix extraordinaire, d'une pureté, d'une justesse et d'une amplitude émotionnelle extraordinaire. Non seulement beau, mais merveilleusement inspiré ! Merci.
the most touching, the most beautiful and most sad piece of music i ever heard. seriously. i cant stop listening again and again... and again. sick for it. just ordered the the songbook and will learn to play the lute part on guitar. the voice of anderas scholl is divine. a genius simply. lasultanica, your postings are fantastic. thank you! greetings from munich, germany
the BEST countertenor in the world, perhaps in all history. any my most favorite song of all. so perfectly sad, yet so perfectly beautiful. dowland + scholl = beyond words.
this is totally beautiful. this song sounds good with a female singer but a male voice has more resonance and is bolder...i just think this is how the song was intended to be.
I can't get over this voice - thanks to you and to civileso! Brings back memories of another fantastically pure singer whose life, unfortunately, had ended in tragedy. Golden. C.
I haven't heard this in years... love singing in harmony to it, so beautiful <3
Cardien18 4 days ago
SEMPLICEMENTE PERFETTO!!! UNA DOLCEZZA INFINITA!!! FANTASTICO
cvocale 3 months ago
A bard after my own heart.
Possatboi 3 months ago
Divine!
douskara 4 months ago
Sublime.
songersogner 5 months ago
Quelle merveille ! Il est exceptionnel.
satharnful 6 months ago
This is amazing
DarkNshY 6 months ago
yes, I almost remember, I must have lived as a trouveur singer/lute player in a previous life
btw it was much better a life than this one...
ottavva 6 months ago
This is exquisite music and an amazing countertenor.
MsCSCG 7 months ago
Beautiful :)
hannahtripp 8 months ago
This is so sad!!! T_T
batain 10 months ago
So...sad and beautiful.
Emman27running 11 months ago 2
I'm singing this song for contest. <3
V0CALVIRTU0S0 11 months ago
See Alfred Deller's version at the Salomesslave site on You Tube.
TheJbach 1 year ago
A bit quick.... see Deller!
TheJbach 1 year ago
Scholl has flawless technique, but I prefer Alfred Deller's version, which is slower, graver, more knowing, subtle and moving.
IlGattonero13 1 year ago 2
@IlGattonero13 I agree with you and your description of the Deller version. But there is something devastating about the perfection of the Scholl. I suppose they are both magnificent in their own way.
Bouncybon 8 months ago
Lutenist is marvellous as well.
angietihi 1 year ago 2
This is one of the best version's of Flow my Tears so far. Tone and pitch is perfect , absolutely perfect !
saintandrews84 1 year ago 8
what a wandeful...
wally63100 1 year ago 3
what a beautiful voice! tresure of the earth.
yugottachance 1 year ago 4
:o so mesmerizing! I wasn't much of a fan of countertenor singing. But this singer sounds..... lovely!
funkycatglasses01 1 year ago
La musica è arte.....scorrete mie lacrime....dove il nero uccello della notte la triste infamia di lei canta, ....
ciccacarmen1 1 year ago
@ciccacarmen1
Che bello l'italiano! These words sing - even without Dowland's and Scholl's mastery :)
voltamore 1 year ago
Обалдеть!
pondeflouers 1 year ago
Is this guy a castrati?
zorlac86 1 year ago
@zorlac86
shurluful 1 year ago
MOST CERTAINLY NOT A CASTRATI
shurluful 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I love this song and I collect different versions of it, but this is the most beautiful and haunting recording I have ever heard of this song.
gibshillpics 1 year ago
I love this song and I collect many versions of it, but this is the most beautiful and haunting recording I have ever heard of "Flow my tears. Just in time for Fall.
gibshillpics 1 year ago
I can't stop crying...
GothamWriter91 1 year ago 5
is this really falsetto??@_@ it sounds natural
aravis123 1 year ago
Sounds BEAUTIFUL...thank for sharing this (:
MaksimLevinskyMusic 1 year ago
I love Andreas Scholl and his voice!!!!
siervadedios1 1 year ago 2
Il y a eu Alfred Deller. Il y a depuis qq années, quand même, Andreas Scholl.
Simplement merci...
Kerlerot 1 year ago
I just noticed the opening phrase is almost identical to JS Bach's Komm Suesser Tod... I know that Bach studied the Italians... did he also study the English?
Or maybe those two descending motives, ending on the leading tone, were a commonly accepted opening theme for these sorrowful arias?
And also, Scholl, as always, sings like an angel.
b0ttomzone 1 year ago
@b0ttomzone Interesting musings. "...did he also study the English?"
I must say I'm delightfully surprised to see a theme from Dowland turning up in a piece by Bach, but I'm not well enough versed in Bach's musical influences to decide if I *should* be all that surprised.
Bach of course, like Picasso, like Shakespeare, took whatever he could use from other artists.
polymath7 1 year ago
Just starting to explore singing Dowland's music myself. I really like your attention to particular words i.e. 'sighs' 'groans' 'hell." I'm thinking of staring the "Hark!" verse strongly for this reason, like a full mezzoforte. Would welcome any thoughts :)
Sammygirl7466 1 year ago
He is quite in a class of his own. There is no sense of effort or strain in his singing and his voice sounds so pure and ethereal.
zutal0rs 1 year ago
Thank you lasultancia!
rozalia67 1 year ago
In which CD can I find this song?
rozalia67 1 year ago 4
@rozalia67 "English Folksongs & Lute Songs"
(sorry, i was wrong)
lasultanica 1 year ago
Comment removed
KP1215MM3000 1 year ago
What a voice....
What a peformance...
What a music...
rozalia67 1 year ago
you put the "k" in "darkness" in the wrong spot. And there's only one "e" in "darkness".
KiptaviusFuzz 1 year ago
Melancholy and beautiful.
AngryLurikeen 1 year ago
Perfect, undoubtly a good one, but in a way too "perfect" in the sense of tightness, strictness, too cold also...can't surpass, I"m sorry Alfred Deller's early versions (circa 1954-60).Well, it's just my humble opinion...
HeartnSoul99 1 year ago
btw it's "exiled for ever let me mourn" anything else doesnt make sense! or what does "exlide" mean?
Singvoll 1 year ago
btw it's "exiled for ever let me mourne" anything else doesn't make sense...
Singvoll 1 year ago
Scholl has been given a great gift and he is obviously making good use of it. What a wonderful performer!
bernard1422 1 year ago 3
Magnifiques musique et interprétation. Quelle musicalité !
Jude616 1 year ago
This is a thing of supreme beauty.
SpaceCaptainDaddy 1 year ago 3
He has such a gentle voice (-__-)
Cardien18 1 year ago
Absolument merveilleux, la meilleure version de flow my tears existante !! Je me régale et je l'écoute en boucle ! jardinsdecalude
jardinsdecalude 1 year ago 19
Bravissimo !
melisilus 1 year ago
@jardinsdecalude szkoda Francuzie,że Cię nie rozumiem,ale jednak widzę,że masz starodawnie cudną tkliwość duszy...
KP1215MM3000 1 year ago
ya grusu=((((((((((( mne ochen nravitsa
emeraude7 1 year ago
Superb.
PlutonianBum 1 year ago 4
well, this is actually in F sharp minor
newFranzFerencLiszt 1 year ago
Both Scholl's and Lesne's interpretations are just wonderful and very moving! Bravi! But I prefer Lesne's version a bit more.
serenaluce 2 years ago
The best kontratenor I've ever heard-the Balsam one to my soul.
KP1215MM3000 2 years ago 33
exactly the same for mine too!!!!!
rosovavoda 2 years ago
He is nice..what about Jaroussky? You think he is one big commercial?
chorister88 1 year ago
Comment removed
KP1215MM3000 2 years ago
I would love to sing this one day .......
saintandrews84 2 years ago
che bello! splendido...
outsider950 2 years ago 2
muy bien
dani1978el 2 years ago 2
The perfect misicians for that wonderful piece .
macasoprano 2 years ago 3
like sweeping silk over a childs cheeks
DarkNshY 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
creepy
playpetergriffin 2 years ago
oh yes it is
DarkNshY 2 years ago
beautiful
superb
chas5131 2 years ago
Just the best...
MrMagnificat 2 years ago
I just discovered this guy. Where has he been all my life? I listen to him and imagine myself soaking in a tub with candles everywere drinking a glass of wine. He has the most soothing voice.
jennyrebekah 2 years ago 5
Just beautiful.....
adehmark 2 years ago
This is awesome!
MisterNumber6 2 years ago
A wonderful piece in Old English poetic prose - with a voice like milk and honey for the ears - absolutely superb!
RoyalSnowbird 2 years ago 3
Anyone know where to get some sheet muic for this? (Just like a voice + piano version)
SquallPwnLife 2 years ago
I got mine on art song central (just type in flow my tears art song to google)... It doesnt sound right on a piano though, it needs a guitar/lute or harpsichord
AnimaMiaPerdona 2 years ago
Oh My GOD,,,, Those are two ANGELS, Dowland, and Scholl. The lute is wonderful too. Thank's for sharing..... Is Amazing Beutiful.
DAVID.....
bachgod 2 years ago 2
Supernal
Kveldssang 2 years ago
Excellent performance! Bravo!
wolkowy1 2 years ago 3
habe das Lied in der Interpretation mit dieser
perfekten Stimme so nicht gehört,für mich bis jetzt die schonste,
Bernadette
maiggy81 2 years ago
Great John Dowland¡¡¡¡
Beautiful voice,Andreas...¡¡¡
xtrememusic6 2 years ago 2
Bellísimo, very nice.
garcilaso1971 2 years ago
Excellent. J. D. himself would have applauded this wonderful effort...
songblam 2 years ago 2
This is a very beautiful song, I like it a lot. Thanks for sharing it.
OlivianBREDA 2 years ago
I came to hear his voice because of Gregg Prichard from BGT.He has an amazing voice too!!!
zerobox10 2 years ago
This is sweet, I need to find more music like this
Achbar 2 years ago
sublime voice!!!
avatarprimus 2 years ago
che veramente marvigliosa
LOLADAMUSICA 2 years ago
Now that's the nicest timbre to a countertenor voice that I have heard.
Lovely! <3
hotqueekboi 2 years ago 3
Scholl is probably my favourite countertenor and I think this song is lovely - but typically gloomy for John Dowland! I have posted a version of me singing it - if anyone wants to listen and tell me if you think I am any good at this kind of singing I would appreciate it.
oliveranthonyrowland 2 years ago
that is the ancient lyric i found, dear : )
put yours here, if you want : )))))))
lasultanica 2 years ago
I guess "darnesse" lost its "k" )
kozzzh 2 years ago
thank you kozzzh ! ;-) very kind.
lasultanica 2 years ago
¿?
lasultanica 2 years ago
That took my breath away. Simply perfect! Thank You for adding this song. :)
Aradeia 2 years ago 2
I recommend English Lute Songs to you by Robin Blaze (Counter Tenor) and Elizabeth Kenny...
sylersky 2 years ago
thank you : )
lasultanica 2 years ago
Stunning.
RowanFortuneWood 2 years ago
I wish I could sing like that, sends tingles down my spine.
mrmartinmartin 2 years ago
Hey! I know this! at least, a Dutch version "Mijn ziele treur" (My soul's sorrow)
You can find it by searching for "mijn ziele treur" on youtube. you will find a movie that starts with an old fashioned version of the Dutch national anthem, followed by this song.
DeHeld8 2 years ago
How sweet music !!!!!!!!!!!!
SilkBoxer 3 years ago 2
Amazing... I can't dry my tears...
Athrael999 3 years ago 2
This song speaks for me.
Cardien18 3 years ago 2
Como puede que no dijera Cicerón en las Fidípicas, el que no llora no mama.
1956MARIBEL 3 years ago
I really like Andreas Scholl's interpretation of this piece. His voice has a very pure sound that I enjoy hearing. I wish he would pronounce "Deprived" with 3 syllables in this song. But I am not an authority on this piece, it is just what I am expecting to hear..
gifu1960 3 years ago
It's what Dowland expected to hear!
BesACB 3 years ago
several notes in his throat have an uncanny mysterious sound...
Lohengrin 3 years ago 2
@Lohengrin I noticed that as well, it's very beautiful, strange, and in a sense, somewhat castrati like. Or should be. Don't you think?
pianoman1812 1 year ago
@pianoman1812.... The technique that Andreas Scholl use to sing is merely Technical singing, called FALSETTO is a TECHNIQUE used by ALL singers when appropriate and by countertenors most of the time.
FALSETTO is a voice production technique for singing high notes. It uses only part of the vocal cords plus the resonant spaces in the head and neck.
LeaBruggen 1 year ago
@pianoman1812 These days, no singer is deliberately castrated in the cause of music but there are a few endocrinological castrati whose physiology gives them the same combination of high voice and powerful projection as the 18th century castrati.
LeaBruggen 1 year ago
Such a beautiful piece about darkness, sadness,mourning, no light and hell. Thats music !
saintandrews84 3 years ago
今まで聞いた中で一番良い。chinpolomalu.
chinpolomalu 3 years ago
Semjante bellza y claidad vocal solamente puede ser cantada por un hombre!
Aguanten los contratenores!
SupermartinR 3 years ago
The man is a vocal machine
bushcrap2019 3 years ago
Incredible! This is sung by a man?
But it's really beautiful!
TreckZT 3 years ago
yeah, andreas scholl is a man, he is in the picture, amazing voice
WeziElliott 3 years ago 2
to jest dopiero śpiew !!
pirx0 3 years ago
This is wonderful, but I will always prefer Deller's interpretation.
/watch?v=r_aR3cOUYm8&feature=related
humbucker1000 3 years ago
Beautiful!!!!
cymro89 3 years ago
This is so beautiful in it's sadness, I too now have tears in my eyes.....
BytomGirl 3 years ago 2
oh! now my tears flow too :-)... Wunderschön!
Jakobus2007 3 years ago 5
beautiful
Cardien18 3 years ago 4
such clarity and perfection! Sigh....
o0butterflyweaver0o 3 years ago 4
I did not know this interpretation by A. Scholl.
Wonderful. I love it.
Thank you.
Sofilajiraf 3 years ago
wow, this is really nice. I have to feature a Weep, o Mine eyes ( John Bennet) that was developed from this song in my choral lit class. like it alot.
bngwal20 3 years ago
I love Andreas Scholl. He has a wonderfully strong, masculine tone. I would love to see him as Nerone in L'incoronazione di Poppea. He is dead sexy!
coloraturakae 3 years ago 2
it sings an angel...
rosovavoda 3 years ago
Scholl Vs Sting .....
I know which I prefer
lostatsea775 3 years ago 5
@lostatsea775 Scholl, of course, though both are fine musicians.
sophelet 1 year ago
this makes me happier each time i listen to it
tenebrousllama 3 years ago 2
My music history teacher once asked me to improvise on this for the class, but apparently my improvisation wasnt "jazzy" enough for him...as much as i love to play jazz, this tune is just too perfect in its own general feel
marvinkmooneyoz 3 years ago
fantastic masterpiece
ibnfahlan 3 years ago
great.
hundingwelser 3 years ago
this is simply beautiful..the music,the voice,the combination...i could really let my tears flow to the sounds of this.
i just adore the way he sings..
beautiful..
muzicarka 3 years ago 5
hi everyone, i was really turned onto dowland by the sting cd, but i notice that people say that his renditions don't exactly do dowland's music justice, could someone possibly post a message with one or two singers who sing in a traditional male vocal range who perform dowland?? thanks very much....
ps i can't believe a man can sing this way so beautifully!!!
thoyo 3 years ago
@thoyo This is a traditional male range...but perhaps you mean baritone?
sophelet 1 year ago
The countertenor voice has become something of a cliche in "today's" early music. It takes the combination of Andreas Scholl & Dowland at his best to remind us how beautifully expressive it can be.
BubCar2 3 years ago 2
Damn straight! David James is amazing as well. One of my favorite counter tenors
cuckthefardinals 3 years ago
@BubCar2 Cliché? How so? It is a voice type which has been used/performed/however you want to say it, for centuries. There just happen to be a lot more good and great countertenors now, and more are recording, than in the past era of the rediscovery of early music.
sophelet 1 year ago
This is utterly beautiful..
joe983 3 years ago 2
same thing here
shambach 3 years ago
SO GOOD! I do not like the type of voice very much but here I must admit that it's just DIAMOND!!!
jhvorotin 3 years ago
Andreas Scholl his voice is always beautiful:) Listen to 'O Jesu, Nomen Dulce'. His voice is idd a diamond<3:D
gehaktmolen 3 years ago 2
Une voix extraordinaire, d'une pureté, d'une justesse et d'une amplitude émotionnelle extraordinaire. Non seulement beau, mais merveilleusement inspiré ! Merci.
hanterkant 3 years ago
the most touching, the most beautiful and most sad piece of music i ever heard. seriously. i cant stop listening again and again... and again. sick for it. just ordered the the songbook and will learn to play the lute part on guitar. the voice of anderas scholl is divine. a genius simply. lasultanica, your postings are fantastic. thank you! greetings from munich, germany
Davidoff73 3 years ago
you are welcome, david : )
lasultanica 3 years ago
Beautiful beyond words.
zeldalicious 3 years ago
Exquisite.
His voice overwhelms me with its beauty and perfection... yet such sadness breaks my heart!
xXxSocorroDovesxXx 3 years ago
the BEST countertenor in the world, perhaps in all history. any my most favorite song of all. so perfectly sad, yet so perfectly beautiful. dowland + scholl = beyond words.
hexc0de 3 years ago 4
I did upload a guy with soprano voice, just write: Russian Farinelli
puppieluv101 3 years ago
My favourite piece...
How deep,how sensual...how beautiful.
Thank you
ArbiterElegantium 3 years ago
se oye demasiado bajo, de no ser asi le habria dado la maxima puntuacion
jewish1972 3 years ago
could you please post barbara bonney's rendition of this song?
asisecanta 3 years ago
I have, search for it!
tararep 3 years ago
supongo q ya la viste, pero la tienes en el canal de tararep. la subió hace un mes. saludicos : )
lasultanica 3 years ago
When I hear him,my tears beginn to flow too..
rosovavoda 3 years ago 9
This was Philip K. Dick's favourite song.
montymike 3 years ago
one of the great songs in all of history, beautifully sung and played
nohpiano 3 years ago 2
this is totally beautiful. this song sounds good with a female singer but a male voice has more resonance and is bolder...i just think this is how the song was intended to be.
sirmattbelios 4 years ago
beautiful song, beautiful voice!
ShoshanaYisraela 4 years ago
i did not really love renaissance music so much,but scholl made me love it,marvellous!thanks for uploading!
wujingcdh 4 years ago
Ah, my favorite song from the moment I heard it. Those renaissance composers really knew how to evoke the affections of humanity.
lambicframbroise 4 years ago 2
This voice heals and brings you from death!!!
PadreAcaJoca 4 years ago 4
I can't get over this voice - thanks to you and to civileso! Brings back memories of another fantastically pure singer whose life, unfortunately, had ended in tragedy. Golden. C.
chiaroscurofx 4 years ago 2
i could have been as good as him if my voice were trained, i have a countertenor pitch too
jewish1972 3 years ago
you could have been, but you are not.
so...
emalag999 3 years ago
no, a pity.
jewish1972 3 years ago
No one does Dowland good like Scholl..
"Hark! You shadows that in darkness dwell..."
Sublimity.
civileso 4 years ago 3
:))))
Your voice is really beautiful too dear Eser btw:)
BachLoveNat 4 years ago 2
Thanks dear:) So kind of you..
civileso 4 years ago
my tears .... to John Dowland....
Beautiful song ....
Thank you dear Andreas!
BachLoveNat 4 years ago 2