Zakir Naik - Few Mathematical Contradictions in the Bible

[GZUS96]

Can this guy please hire someone to talk for him, he sound like he has ceriblepaulsy.

[rainindesert1]

Dr.Zakir thanks for making me reading bible

[Lobotaru]

Yeah, its the links. If you want links to the articles, send me a personal message and I'll reply to that. Otherwise, do a web search for "has the quran changed with time?" on yahoo. The facebook article at the top of the search highlights a bunch of them.

[Lobotaru]

There are several articles on the subject matter of the Quran's origins. However, everytime I try to show a link here it gives me an error message when I try to post it.

[a4finger]

that does sounds like an error but i think it is actually possible thusly,

Special relativity basikly says that the faster an object travels, the slower time flows for it. So if you say put a father whos 30 with a 1 year old son on a rocket and have it orbit the earth for say 40 years at speeds comparable to the speed of light, like .9c, then only a year or something (its not hard to calculte) will pass for the father with 40 years passing for the son and the father will be younger thn the son

[Lobotaru]

Allah is said to preserve the Quran in Surah 15:9; 41:41-42;[33] 85:21-22; 56:77-78[34] and later the words of Allah are said to be unalterable: "there is none that can alter the Words (and Decrees) of Allah..."[35] and "...none can change His Words..."[36] Let's stop here for a moment. If the Quran is true, then what Allah inspires cannot change, and cannot be corrupted. So we ask the obvious question: are the Torah and the Gospels said to be inspired? According to Quran, yes.

[Lobotaru]

The problem is that in the Qu'ran, Mohammad never refers to the Torah or the Bible as corrupted. According to Sura 3:3, he states that the Torah and Bible were in fact the word of God.

Surahs 3:7, 21, 23, 48, 84, 65, 93, 184, 199; 4:44, 51, 136; 5:15, 43-49, 57-59, 66-69, 113; 6:91, 154; 10:37; 11:17; 16:43; 17:2; 20:133; 21:7, 33; 23:49; 26:196; 32:23; 41:42-45; 46:10-12; 54:43; 57:27; 80:11-16; and 87:18-19 all confirm, rather than repudiate the Torah and Gospels.

[marcelcol69]

but GOD says that the jews and christians were lead astray.

it even desribes why!!

obviously either leadership or the scriptues or both have been corrupted because of their theologies.

At the time it was the catholic church and the rabbis

[hoddie54]

@Lobotaru well, God says the "Injeel" or"the Torah" which speifically mean the uncorrupt version. The bible that is known today is not the Injeel we speak of.

[Lobotaru]

@hoddie54

The Torah is not the Bible. Part of the Torah is in the Bible. However, when you speak of corruption, I presume you mean textual corruption. The Torah of today is supported by the Dead Sea Scrolls. However, if you mean corruption as in changing over time as language and culture change, then all three books, even the Quran, have been fundamentally altered by time. Textual evidence from the 7th century shows the current Quran to be different than the original.

[hoddie54]

@Lobotaru

1. I never said they're the same book. They're 2 seperate examples. Sorry if you mis-understood.

2. The Qur'an has NEVER been altered. Please show me this "evidence" you speak of...

[StopSpamming1]

Hahaha, this so funny.

Try calculating inheritance according to the Koran. It's a huge mess.

Allah has 1000 or 50000 days to one human.

Don't throw stones inside a glass house.

[MuBa21]

We have lol. And it all adds to 1.

People tend do screw up with the counting when some ppl are decluded in different situations when it comes to inheritance.

[hoddie54]

@StopSpamming1 Well, it is to show an extent of something...but if you still disagree. The word"Yaum" can mean day or period of time. so if you examine the verses(it isn't just refering to God's day), you'll find there is no contradiction.

[StopSpamming1]

@hoddie54

You are right. And if humans correct the Koran, there is no contradiction. I agree. But I would expect a perfect, clear and precise statement from a god.

[dhella1]

As of today there are more than 300 different version of bibles exist today! The funny thing is all of them portending their bible is the right one which come from Jesus!

[DoctorXTV]

Both books are full of shit !!

[killjack123]

haha christians men are not man enough 2 accept the errors in the bible. instead they think being highly illogical will help them. simple thing is Jesus cannot b God. and ur God is 1+1+1=1 right? i mean where is ur brains dear christians!?how can ur gods book have errors? n then inspite of knowing how can u believe it? worship GOD. who created, not the creation! a GOD cannot come into his own Creation!

[786mansoor786]

one proof to all christains that the quran is truly word of god is that it is memorizable unlike the bible. it cant be proven wrong wither only misinterpreted. however thsi christainn proffessor proved that the bible has undeniable errors

[jamshed231]

@pankupappu

32:5 He rules (all) affairs from the heavens to the earth: in the end will (all affairs) go up to Him, on a Day, the space whereof will be (as) a thousand years of your reckoning.

The angels and the spirit ascend unto him in a Day the measure whereof is (as) fifty thousand years:

both are different verses referring to different things one verse talking abt affairs on earth one is talking about angels and spirit where is contradiction?

[love4christx77]

When the two verses are compared, 1 Chronicles 21:5 says that All Israel had one million one hundred thousand men who drew the sword . But 2 Samuel says, And there were in Israel eight hundred thousand valiant men who drew the sword It could be that the author of 2 Samuel was indicating the number of seasoned veterans or valiant men, while the author of 1 Chronicles was numbering any man who drew the sword, not just the valiant ones.

[love4christx77]

its only the king james version of the bible that has 22and 42 it a typo look in any other bible he is 22in 2kings 8:26 and in 2chronicels 22:2

[DYXH0RN]

he talks to fast

And he thinks he is smart by letting us think he knows all the books out of his head whats not the case

[killjack123]

lol oh really dyxhorn..lol i mean how can u b soooo stupid 2 say that.. go check it urself! haha !i can understand when a persons mouth is shut , 2 defend theirselves they have 2 talk shit.. =]

but no criticizing i want 2 show u the right way. rest.. ur grown up.. u shud b able 2 do the ryt decision.make a lil sense .if u kno ur book is wrong , arent u man enough 2 admit it?n b intelligent enough 2 follow the ryt path.. sry 4 bein rude but comon..plz reseach!

[DYXH0RN]

go kiss buts 5 times a day

[mijking2k7]

huh what kinda response is that?

[outllawz]

he is a well educated man, not like the learned man of christianity, who dont even know the bible, but yet follow blind belief, mistakes, contraditions

just ask your self, can gods wordconatin mistakes, lies, mathematical errors

and the answer is NO

[JerkwaterJones]

This is "Allaht" of crap.

[pigapumbu]

Are there any mathematical contradictions in the quran? maybe relating to how property is split up after someone dies? I am now sure. Perhaps I ought to check it up and see if it all adds to 1.

[love4christx77]

its only the king james version of the bible that has 22and 42 it a typo look in any other bible he is 22in 2kings 8:26 and in 2chronicels 22:2

[pankupappu]

OK, every thing agreed about what you told about bible. Tell me what is the duration of Allah's one day, as writen in Koran? 10,000 or 50000.

[killjack123]

brother. dont listen 2 ur non muslim friends.. bout islam n dont follow the media. get a copy of Quran in english from a 'good msulim'. u will get 2 kno wat it means. i mean c , Gods book CANNOT have a mistake. how can u believe in it then. i mean i aint critisizing , ma duty is just 2 help u understand the ryt path. plz do! show me any 1 mistake in Quran. just research bout it.. u should know more about the religion. dun believe frnds and media.takecare ..frnd..

[randomteen314]

How is ANY other religious text different? The Quran for instance isn't free from contradictions either, and if this is just nit-picking facts on a scientific level, it shows that these texts aren't supposed to be taken on a literal basis, but a metaphorical basis, but then it is up to personal context and evaluation, possibly taking away from what is actually meant. All religions are the same on these ambitious and delusional grounds. It's not god, it's all too human.

Please comment to discuss

[Fullmetalliod]

he kinda has to nit pick , you can't prove god existing or not...similar to a kids invisible friend. the only way is to show that the religion is bad is to prove the book has flaws therefore the book could not be the direct word of a perfect god, because a direct god would not have flaws in his word. the only thing this really proves is that the bible is not the direct word of god ... it might have been before man messed it up, but not now.

[Fullmetalliod]

continuation of last comment ...

or a different conclusion is that the god is not perfect and the book is the direct word of a flawed god

this logic can be used for any religion that there god is perfect, and whose word has contradictions.

[randomteen314]

I agree with most of what you say, it makes sense . . .but I'm kinda lost to what your point it is, no offense. . what I'm arguing is that Dr. Naik is very biased and promotes Islam as the one true religion while the logic he is using to undermine other religions can be inturn used to disqualify his. I'm saying ultimately all religions and their claims are equal invalid, in this imperfect and imprecise sense, be it Christianity, Islam, Judaism, etc.

[positron66]

There is no contradiction in the original manuscript. The copy is just copy and not original autographs. Read Sura 10:94 are you greater than Muhammad to interpret the scripture? Speak like a great fool.

[ptica11]

positron66, yes i am greater they your petty muhammad or allah

[0utworlder]

Try this

w w w dot chick dot com fwd slash information fwd slash religions fwd slash islam fwd slash word_god2.asp

[shakaz01]

obvious he cant read properly because his very first mathematical contradiction is wrong. because the king who begin to reign is not the son of the king who had died, but of another king. he is so keen on finding contradiction when there is none. how foolish.

[sami6108]

have a nice sleep at night.

ur mind will be fresh.

than start 2 finding contradiction of bible.

n there will be no illusion that the bible is not word of god n it has more than 1000 contradiction.

[shakaz01]

get a life.

[Fullmetalliod]

that's fine but just cuz he is wrong the first time does not make him wrong all the time ...i looked that one up to cuz that was insane

[randomteen314]

I agree with most of what you say, it makes sense . . .but I'm kinda lost to what your point it is, no offense. . what I'm arguing is that Dr. Naik is very biased and promotes Islam as the one true religion while the logic he is using to undermine other religions can be inturn used to disqualify his. I'm saying ultimately all religions and their claims are equal invalid, in this imperfect and imprecise sense, be it Christianity, Islam, Judaism, etc.

[baetores]

What a nervous guy. He's blinking his eyes so often and he sounds so full of unrest while he is hard to understand with his heavy accent. I can't bear to watch it for more than a minute, even though the contents may be right.

[dreadedqb]

and so remain ignorant

[zubaer23]

The title should have been thousands of contradictions in the bible.

[ZEboria]

zubaer23 the comment above u is for rowsdowersavesus

[maxwelle103]

in addition, a marriage taken place more than oh say, more than a couple of centuries, i mean more than not 100 years 200 years, 400 years, but 1400 years ago, the traditions and culture is strictly vastly different than it is now. Just a few decades in recent years US culture changes like crazy for instance, the Alcohol prohibition act, by us law. It was illegal to drink in the united states. this law, happens to be Allah's law then and now.

[Benszymanskiisright]

Hey, you know it sais in the quran that non muslims have 7 intestine, it also says god made Adam 90 feet tall - Both are proven scientificaly rong. Oh yeah did I mention that there is historical evidence that Mohamed maried a 6 year old and had sex with her when she was 9, he was around 50. Filthy pedo!

[maxwelle103]

Another moron. First quote it where it says in the Holy Quran about that non muslims have 7 intenstines and He made Adam 90 feet tall. Second, Girls go faster than boys, scientific fact. After a girl goes through puberty some very early, they are able to bear children. Second, if God were to tell you to marry someone who you were hesitant to marry will you say yes or no? Thirdly, The last Prophest SAW, marriage to Ayesha was a blessed marriage with the blessing of Ayeshas, who? Ayeshas Father.

[Islamonator]

"Do they consider the Quran (with care). Had it been from any other than Allah. They would surely have found therein many a discrepancy" (Holy Quran 4:82)

[ttatiova]

DID YOU KNOW?

The famous verse relating the Trinity [1 John 5:7] has been thrown out of the Bible (RSV) as a fabrication!!

"For there are three that bear record in heaven, the Father, the Word, and the Holy Ghost: and these three are one." [1 John 5:7]

[rowsdowersavesus]

When even a moron like Dr. Zakir Naik can point out the problems with the bible, christianity is in a lot of trouble

[PathTooIslam]

that "moron" is a doctor and you wouldnt last a second with him,

[rowsdowersavesus]

I am aware that he is a medical doctor, and he is a moron.

[PathTooIslam]

not really, he is correcting "bible scholars" as if they were little children so i dont think so!

[rowsdowersavesus]

bible scholars are children in adult bodies, as are quranic scholars. Any human with a developed brain who studies for a few hours can debunk any religion

[PathTooIslam]

LOOOOl, you are a tiny tiny creator and a tv-atheist!do you have any idea that hundreds and hundredz of tv atheist (like yourself) have become MUSLIMS after studying islam??

[rowsdowersavesus]

hundreds and hundreds? Maybe a few. There are also a lot of muslims becoming atheists-in the west, it's almost certain that more of you come to our side than vice versa. Most of your converts are christians, though Islam is not converting many

[PathTooIslam]

you are deaf dumb and blind!you see what you want to see!muslims are leaving there religion because they are weak people in our religion too,our quran warned us that this time would come when disbelivers and christians would run TO islam and muslims away from islam!

[rowsdowersavesus]

it's always been like this. People will always switch religions-however, Islam is losing people with regards to conversions. Islam only is growing because of births.

[PathTooIslam]

LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL!!!ar­e you serious???are you serious??? =)))

[rowsdowersavesus]

I'm not only serious, but right

[PathTooIslam]

this is the way it is with tv-atheist, they think that they´re right without knowing a single thing about religion!STUDY ISLAM and we´ll talk!i christianity better then most christians and i know the principals of atheism!and they are, if george carlin is atheist i am too ; ))

[rowsdowersavesus]

I have studied Islam. It doesn't make any more sense than christianity.

[PathTooIslam]

explain what doesnt make sense, and dont just run to a anti-islamic website and steal info!

[rowsdowersavesus]

If it makes no sense, how can I explain it?

None of it makes sense. Sorry.

[ZEboria]

Then there is no sense in your words-wait did that make sense, oh yeah i forgot u can't comprehend sense,sorry was that a fact?...I make no sense u say? then how did u figure that out?

[ileftislam2]

Naik was issued an open challange by faithfreedom. org to debate and prove that the koran is the word of god as told to mohamad by the angle gabriel.

naik has REFUSED to accept this challange because he is shit scared of faithfreedom dot org

He knows that his half truths and lies will be exposed for what they realy are.

He is shitting his pants ,too scared to debate islam with another moslem.

naiks agruements are ripped to pieces on that site.

Has anyone seen a bigger clown than naik

[saigoal1]

u see this is the problem with ppl like u. y dont u state exactly what zakir naik has said. zakir naik dus not want to have a WRITTEN debate. he wants to have an open debate in front of EVERYONE in broad daylight.and guess wah ali sina said to that?NO.infact to this day he hasnt even had one AUDIO DEBATE.dont give us ur shite.y dont u debate him live?becoz u dnt have ur computer to hide behind.

[rowsdowersavesus]

Kent Hovind is pretty close.

[hexagonmoose]

What is he saying? Can't catch a word. Subtitles or something?

[peaceofminds]

Peace be upon you All...

Are you people aware about the International Peace Conference going on in Mumbai from 23rd Nov to 2nd Dec? During the Q&A session (after the lecture by Dr. Zakir Naik on the topic Concept of God on 24th Nov 2007), a non-muslim sister posed a question and after having it answered by Dr. Zakir Naik, Guess what happened??

Allahu Akbar -- she pronounced the Shahada and became a muslimah.

Watch at peace tv and youtubeislam dot com

[mrfarraj1]

this is clap is taken from a debate between dr zakir and a bible scholar and u can watch the whole debate her in you tube just type "the bible and the quran in the light of sceince" it is not like somebodys pasted muslims just wanna attack christianty because this has been always ur job. if u don't believe me just look here in youtube we are always in the defence position and they are the ones who being attacked

[earthmessage]

how strange...

they get together to study so called "bible contradictions" and they think it's "funny"

they even clap at his jest.

Muslims are such a strange lot

but in the end they just seem angry and negative all the time

[oohaahmaria]

all these contridictions are probably because of the many times its been translated.

BTW, how can anyone understand him anyway geez

[slipknotstonesour555]

thats what you resort to isnt it...? trying to insult him and everything as he just slapped the truth in your face...Quran has been translated many times as well my friend...and not a SINGLE verse is different...you want proof? take ANY copy of the Holy Quran..compare it with ANY other copy in the world...you can even compare it with the 1000 year old Qurans in YOUR MUSEUMS.

[OnlyOneUmmah]

Zakir is a great debator and has a lot to say.

" Paul who never saw Jesus, also admitted that the resurrection was his gospel (II Timothy 2:8): "Remember that Jesus Christ of Seed of David was raised from the dead according to my gospel". He was also the first to declare Jesus the Son of God: Acts 9:20: "And straightway he [Paul] preached Christ in the synagogues, that he is the Son of God."

SO Christianity is not a teaching of Jesus, BUT Paul!

[786usman]

for unbelivers if you dont believe in Allah then cut your hands off becuze it reads Allahs name in arabic, this shows clear proof of the all mighty subhanalah

[allahasucker]

Zakir Naik is biggest liar.

Visit w w w.f a i t h f r e e d o m . o r g

[FahadKhan1988]

awnser faithfreedom . org?

[peaceofminds]

Peace be upon you All...

Are you people aware about the International Peace Conference going on in Mumbai from 23rd Nov to 2nd Dec? During the Q&A session (after the lecture by Dr. Zakir Naik on the topic Concept of God on 24th Nov 2007), a non-muslim sister posed a question and after having it answered by Dr. Zakir Naik, Guess what happened??

Allahu Akbar -- she pronounced the Shahada and became a muslimah.

Watch at peace tv and youtubeislam dot com

[aput75]

Thank you for posting this video. Asslamualikum

[InnocentSinnerDesi]

And christians still follow the same bible because they do not have any choice!

Quran is the alterbative and which the TRUTH... Invite people to the way of thy lord with beautiful preaching and wisdom and argue with them in the best ways... even if u you know only one verse... peace

[IBRAHIMMUSA]

mintos you are so stupid i bet you can't say that to his face you wimp- he is a lion of Islam a great debator and he always speaks the truth! christianity does not exist at all! not mentioned in the bible anywhere, the bible is full of contradictions and lies, things have been taken out to suit the christians - what sad people they are! become a muslim to attain your salvation! say There is no diety (god) excepty Allah and Muhammad is his Messenger - simple!!

[DjJese]

i really pitty you IBRAHIMMUSA.study your religion first then...you are welcome to study our The Bible...and then say whatever you have to say...peace with you

[H591boy]

Your bible has so many contradictions. Therefore, it can never be holy :-) Your bible is man made, not the word from God. With respect I say. YOU come and read Quran. No fathers even fathers can prove to the rest of the world that the Bible is HOLY. Ahmed Deedat & Zakir Naik has CONVINCED them all!

[slipknotstonesour555]

lol they have a new version of the bible every now and then...they make their own adjustments to suit themselves and say this is gods word..haha

[satanicaa]

You are wrong my brother. All the christians who debate Mr. Ahmad Deedat explicitly claim the Bible is the WORD OF GOD. If you wish to say that they are all wrong, there may be bigger problems in the christian people yet (I'm sorry if I have offended you it's not my intention)

[hykhan]

this is a problem with you christians you guyz keep changing your statements, Bible was the word of God thru

prophet Jesus but humans changed it

[Mintos11]

Yak shemazh! My name a Borat! We get together to make sexytime!

[DosFilexicanz]

christians reply with absurd statements from a crappy movie as a response to the real truth about the bible. HHAH im loving it!!!

[warpedmind41]

Sweet vid.