@fleis2sluo Good luck, friend. I took a few of the Taiwanese supplementary classes at 國立臺灣師範大學 and all I could say was "...yeah, I'll just stick to mandarin."
Chinese back then only studied and knew their own dialect .When the Qing government fell scholars centralised Mandarin to become the standard language of all its people even for those who live on other countries (Malaysia, Singapore, ROC (Taiwan)
I'm not sure how many Chinese dialects there are but there are few umbrella groups to note like Hainanese, Guangdong (Cantonese, Hakka, Taishanese, Singling, Teochew) Fujian( Amoy Hokkien, Southern Minna(hokkien), Hokchiu, Hokchia), Wu dialect (Shanghainese, Suzhounese, Hangzhou,etc ), Northerner( Beijing Mandarin, other mandarin types). Did you know chairman Mao Zeong spoke in his dialect Xiang dialect and ChiangKaishek spoke Wu dialect
Is this Taiwanese or is this Cantonese? Because it sounds beautiful. And I listened to it like 3 times and it doesnt really sound like Cantonese, but it doesn't sound Taiwanese either :P
I agree with fishiie, this song is gorgeous in Taiwanese. I only speak Mandarin, but I love this song nonetheless. I would have to say it's my favorite off this CD.
Taiwanese is like.. a native language. What the old people speak, basically. Young people nowadays (mostly those outside Taiwan) don't know how to speak it
@fishiiie A) its not a native language... its from china im taiwanese i know B) its not spoken by just old ppl the ppl near the southern area of taiwan, even the middle area spoke it too and they r really good at it im ok aint that good but im gonna teach my kid no matter what 3) this song is awesome
@MintyButterfly i meant use taiwanese in general... can someone tell me what the difference between taiwanese and mandarin is?? i heard that its traditional (taiwanese) but isn't cantonese also traditional??? i'm confused.... o.O
Holy, I don't understand a word but this is freaking awesome
libiiaf 1 month ago
lol...i feel proud that i understand this song!!! go taiwan!!!!
Flautist286456 3 months ago
i wanna learn but my father don't wan teach me!!!Can only learn a little frm 娱乐百分百....:P
shugoshugo12 5 months ago
I love this song! It's beastie! <3 Ella Chen :D
BgirlMickie 6 months ago
i wanna learn taiwanese so badly D: the language sounds epic ;P
fleis2sluo 8 months ago
@fleis2sluo Good luck, friend. I took a few of the Taiwanese supplementary classes at 國立臺灣師範大學 and all I could say was "...yeah, I'll just stick to mandarin."
VermisM 6 months ago
Comment removed
TheDrugsIsInMyHeart 10 months ago
I am never, ever, EVER going to forgive my mom for not teaching me to speak Taiwanese as I was growing up.
Janishta 10 months ago 3
Chinese back then only studied and knew their own dialect .When the Qing government fell scholars centralised Mandarin to become the standard language of all its people even for those who live on other countries (Malaysia, Singapore, ROC (Taiwan)
zeiitgeist 10 months ago
I'm not sure how many Chinese dialects there are but there are few umbrella groups to note like Hainanese, Guangdong (Cantonese, Hakka, Taishanese, Singling, Teochew) Fujian( Amoy Hokkien, Southern Minna(hokkien), Hokchiu, Hokchia), Wu dialect (Shanghainese, Suzhounese, Hangzhou,etc ), Northerner( Beijing Mandarin, other mandarin types). Did you know chairman Mao Zeong spoke in his dialect Xiang dialect and ChiangKaishek spoke Wu dialect
zeiitgeist 10 months ago
Is this Taiwanese or is this Cantonese? Because it sounds beautiful. And I listened to it like 3 times and it doesnt really sound like Cantonese, but it doesn't sound Taiwanese either :P
MySungminOppa 11 months ago 3
@MySungminOppa its the southern minnan dialect of fujian (hokkien) however this variation is taiwanese (hokkien mixed with mandarin) i think.
zeiitgeist 10 months ago
@MySungminOppa
Its taiwanese...i know bcuz i speak hokkien
Flautist286456 3 months ago
i love how taiwanese sounds so similar to cantonese, but it's so different at the same time! :D
HungryLitoBookWormxP 1 year ago
I agree with fishiie, this song is gorgeous in Taiwanese. I only speak Mandarin, but I love this song nonetheless. I would have to say it's my favorite off this CD.
Wagscion 1 year ago
I agree with fishiie, this song is so gorgeous in Taiwanese. I really loved how they did it. =)
Wagscion 1 year ago
oh~ so that''s why i can't understand this song...because it's in taiwanese...
i was like: this sounds strange. but now i get it. it's a very beautiful song.
superseoul11 1 year ago 2
they make taiwanese sound so beautiful!!
xixlxyxsxtx 1 year ago
Comment removed
RyoheiMilKz 1 year ago
most taiwanese natives speak taiwanese or at least understand it.
because people still speak it occasionally on talk shows and the older generations blabber away in taiwanese.
ThePinklimeade 1 year ago 11
<3 this song. beautiful (:
sassygirlsweet99 1 year ago
Taiwanese is like.. a native language. What the old people speak, basically. Young people nowadays (mostly those outside Taiwan) don't know how to speak it
This song is sooooooooo beautiful in taiwanese :)
fishiiie 1 year ago 21
howeryu 1 year ago
@howeryu
derived* from china
howeryu 1 year ago
it's a pretty song, but i think i'd like it better if it was less "modern"-ish...i get it, it's the style, but that's just my opinion...
MicrobeObliteratorMo 1 year ago
does S.H.E ever use taiwanese when speaking?? usually they just speak in mandarin right??
MintyButterfly 1 year ago
@MintyButterfly i meant use taiwanese in general... can someone tell me what the difference between taiwanese and mandarin is?? i heard that its traditional (taiwanese) but isn't cantonese also traditional??? i'm confused.... o.O
MintyButterfly 1 year ago
@MintyButterfly
Cantonese is traditional for all Chinese. Taiwanses is traditional for Taiwanese cuz most of the Taiwanses are come from the same ancestor.
cheliesy 1 year ago
@cheliesy Mandrin is traditional for all Chinese... Cantonese is for people who lives in Hong Kong
superangelstar14 1 year ago
Comment removed
cheliesy 1 year ago
@MintyButterfly
They do not taiwanses generally. I don't know if they use it at home.
cheliesy 1 year ago
they have really good taiwanese
desssireee 1 year ago
it is a good song although i dont understand the lyrics.
JaneChen89 1 year ago