as much as this video is bias, im taught maya in uni as its industry standard, then i put what i learnt into blender and found it easier to use blender in most aspects, even its layout. but we all have our own opinion, its more to do with the artist than the program, tho if you know how to make the most of more than one program your laughing.
3ds max is overpriced and sometimes underestimated. Both are phenomenal programs but 3ds max uses the same old mainstream interface. Blender mixes it up, tons of shortcuts, you barely need to click. 1 vote for blender here.
Top and bottom is they are both awesome programs capable of unbelievable stuff, I prefer Blender as I`ve found it easier to pick up the techniques. Although when I tried max it was an older version, probs 10x better now than it was but Ill be sticking to blender thank you..and thanks to team at blender.org..love you guys ;)
it all depends on the artist, just cause you buy a 1000 dollar program or can afford it , doesnt mean you can make 1000 dollar picture, it might be the best program but does it come with the skills?
As an artist who uses Blender, I will say that this video is very biased. You should use examples from both programs that are similar/even in quality and then compare.
Either side will say their program of choice is better by default, but that doesn't really solve anything. In all honesty, we should probably be comparing the rendering engines since that's what this video seems to be about. In that case, it's a tie.
All the images in this video could be made by either software. It comes down to modelling and texturing, and there's nothing advanced about these images. A true comparison can be made with fluid and smoke simulations as well as hair shading and rendering.
I love Blender and use it every day. I will never use another program for 3D modelling as it looks now. But this movie is a joke. You picked the worst from 3DS Max and the best from Blender. Max is a great software. Which it of course "has" to be since it cost quite a bit of money compared to Blender which is free.
STUPID VIDEO! I bet you typed "shitty 3D max images" to get them, both programs has their goods and bads, its up to the artist to make a the difference.
Blender wins by far. Now if we can have something with the awesomeness of Blender that's easier to use then I will just die of awesomeness. Wait, I would live long enough to njoy it. Then I would die of awesomeness.
Each package has it's pros and cons but in the end - what it all boils down to is workflow. How long will it take to achieve the results you want. Again that all depends on how proficient you are with the product vs how well engineered the package is.
Max was the standard for many years but the tides are turning. Blender is developing much faster and is easier to use than Max. Max cost $2800 while Blender is free.
I think it also has to do alot with the artist i have seen some amazing things come out of blender artists that would rival some of the best 3ds max artists.
The author compares the beautifully madeworks created in Blender 3D to work with an obviously inferior quality, which are created in 3ds Max. A similar comparison can cook and against Blender.
I like the Blender, I use it with pleasure, but this movie outright false, so my vote against it!
If you have the option to do maya or blender, always do maya because when getting a job, employers would rather see that you are experienced with a very expensive high-end program rather than a free program. Blender is still really good and you can make amazing things with it but it's all about pricing these days
Blender is getting exponentially better. There will be a day I believe when it meets or beats the best of the best on all levels. If everyone donated a few dollars then everyone could have a tool that comparatively would cost thousands.
@JohnnyForehead Sir it is already at par with major 3d softwares like max and maya when it comes to modelling , custom rigging and animation . it just need a few more features like Max's CAT automated rigging system , a proper event based particle system , something like Maya's paint effects and better connectivity with programs like Zbrush and Vue
ok i am not sure i know blender is free and the graphics look much better but i want good graphics and i heard 3ds max was good but i watched sintel and that also blew my mind so in your guys oppinions what should i get ?!?!?!?!?!!?!?!?!?!
@MrHalofreak01 hear me man!:D 3d max is 3gb and more blender is i dont know maybe(100mb-500mb) just for think:) im 3d max artist and i know power of 3dmax...its much better than blender! 3d max with vray,rayfire,fumefx,afterburn,dreamscape(plugins) are facking awsome.just trust me or you can finde more information in google:) and gays i get 3d max for freeeee:D:D and all plugins that just i said:)
@ManFrom3D what are the websites just tell me on my channel so no one else can hear if its a secret but if its not ok to tell me nevermind then i will look into something else and thnx for you guys who helped me out! :)
@ManFrom3D Sir that means you have never used blender . Max is powerful nobody is questioning that , but the point is that blender being a free software has come very close to what these big programs can achieve . If you are a startup animation studio blender is the best choice for you . Vray is also available for blender , the community is working hard on adding fluid dynamics to Blender , so the need of fumeFx will be met in the near future , Blender will have all the features of max & maya
@Galavya41 its not my statement about that max is much powerful or fast and e.t.c professional artists prefer max and maya...i think your are blender artist and you want to defend blender:D right? if you want to get 3dmax just tell me i will help you as i can:)
@ManFrom3D Quiet the contrary friend, I am a max user. I use blender only for personal projects . I think professional artist would prefer Blender or Lightwave as Max and Maya are way too expensive for an artist but Yes professional Studios do prefer Maya over all other software and thats not because Maya is more " powerful" but simply because Maya and to a lesser extent Max fits into the production pipeline better e;i it connects better with other software like zbrush
@Galavya41 i have zbrush:) (i get it for free:DXD) so i think every person has his favorite program:) my favorites are 3dmax and zbrush i think you can do whatever with this two programs.
@MrHalofreak01 Blenders interface and workflow can be very quick and provide a fast workflow, and the V-Ray renderer (and octane as well) are supported commercial renderers. There are also free HQ renderers for Blender such as LuxRender (Similar to Maxwell for 3DS Max)
3DS Max has more plugins such as Realflow, Krakatoa, FumeFX, Other rendering engines etc... that are all great if your willing to spend $1000's on them for commercial use. If you can get them free, great.
@MrHalofreak01 Get blender , its free , its just as good as max or maya . Good animation depends on you the artist and not the software , just make sure you get enough Books & training DVDs so that the learning the software becomes a little easier.But if you want to learn Animation and story telling , well then taking a course is a better idea, you can also take a course online with Animation Mentor
fuck! a person who do'nt know the 2 programs very well(like me) can surly tell blender is more awesome from the pictures and it's free! oh yeah bitch ! bite me!
you're comparing Blender with VRAY-plugin vs 3DS max without 'VRAY plugin'. V-ray plugin makes it more realistic. Do you still think Blender is better when you watch this video? /watch?v=JveJxQrKC_U ;-)
Yo utilizo blender y no me podria comparar con algunos de esos resultados. Depende de quien lo utilize le saldrán mejor o peor. Por eso opino que estas comparaciones no son aceptables al 100%. Lo que se puede hacer para llegar a una buena conclusion es un modelo complicado, que el resultado visual del renderizado sea el mismo y ver cuanto tardan en renderizar. Un amigo me dijo que si queria saber cuan potente era mi procesador que lo pusiera a renderizar. Y ademas blender puede crear juegos(+1).
Fuck off Cheater....I am using 3ds max for almost 3 years and I bet you I can create photo real renders using max. You just put the crap in 3dsmax section calling it a final render? I donot criticize or promote any software coz I knw Softwares doesn't matters but it's the Artist's creativity that matters a lot.
I'm a blender user, but why the hell did you show those low resolution noob renders from 3Ds Max ? 3Ds Max is better than Blender in some ways and Blender is better than 3Ds Max in some ways.. You made it look like 3Ds Max sucks...
Really? Slap a bunch of simple and even low quality Max renders alongside some of the better Blender renders and call it a comparison? Tools are tools but dishonest information like this really doesn't help anyone.
Blender wins, and that is for this reason. You can do the same things you can do in 3ds max only easier or less easier. and blender is free so you can get it how when and where you want.
Blender 3DS Max 1000 times better! Cycles with Blender 2.61 and modifiers, Python Scripts, Post Production, Video Editing, sculpting, etc. Game Engine. etc.. the beauty is that makes this wonderfully! 3DS Max throw it in the bucket;)
Mansses774, vc ta errado cara. Pesquise mais, estude mais, e vai ver que os dois programas são muito bons. Seu video foi injusto, pois vangloriou o Blender, e deixo o Max como uma coisa amadora, mas quem ja viu "Matrix: Reloaded" sabe que não é bem assim, todos os efeitos foram feitos em Max.
Fora que não adianta nada o programa ser o melhor do mundo, se o usuário não souber usar, e usar bem, pois apenas decorar passos, não faz um bom dançarino.
Quem postou este vídeo ridículo agiu de má fé. Colocou imagens infantis para o Max e imagens bem feitas por último, que na verdade o 3D Max consegue fazer a mais de 10 anos!!!
Dont forget to compare prices :P i used max for ages but recently been swapping to blender to create my own game to save on a comercial license love some of the features
I think that 90% of users and companies can use Blender for what they need to do. Fact is as always free products are seen in a bad way just because they're even without trying them.
Well, i'm giving Blender its chance 'cause you see they put a lot of effort and, more important, love/passion in their work..also all the students etc. should learn Blender instead of cracking 3DS Max.
P.s. anyway this video is just dumb, you chose great Blender images and shitty 3DS Max ones on purpose. not fair
eu uso só o 3d max, nunca usei e nem sei mexer no blender e jamais quero aprender a mexer no blender. Mas dizer que blender é melhor que max é burrice, pois o software 3d mais usado no mundo é o 3dmax e é bem caro, enquanto que o blender é de graça. Na realidade eu prefiro em primeiro lugar 3d max, depois cinema 4d e depois maya, o blender fica logo depois desses que falei,
@cineastaAmadorx que preconceito, só porque é gratis aushauhsuahu, mas eu entendo. Uso o 3ds Max e sei mexer no blender, mas comparar programas é idiotice, todos os programas tem basicamente as mesmas ferramentas e finalidades, vai do gosto de cada um
@cineastaAmadorx Acho melhor aprender a mexer no blender antes de falar qualquer coisa.... Claro que o 3DS Max é pago e talz, tem mais recursos... Mas o 3DS Max faz jogos? Esculpe? Não? Ah... você precisa comprar pelo menos 3 programas pra fazer esses tipos de coisas... ZBrush pra esculpir e Unity/UDK pra criar um jogo....
Você só esqueceu de um importante detalhe, o código do game criado no blender é aberto para qualquer um mexer. Sem falar que a maioria das empresas utilizam maya e max. Gosto do blender e sou usuário, porém em questão de estabilidade minha preferência é maya.
@marcelomoraification É possível criar um .exe sem expor o código do jogo, também, se não estou enganado, é possível criar outros tipos de executáveis nele, sem expor o .blend.
@Pedru000 Então, eu não tenho ciência se realmente da para gerar um executável. O melhor motor de jogo bom para criar jogos é a Unity 3d e UDK. Ambos bem documentados na medida do possível. Até hoje eu vi um jogo bom feito em blender , uma replica do mario galaxy. Se for verdade isso que você está falando, realmente vale a pena. Abs...
Exactly. Blender is very good since it's very simple to use and it's in constant evolution, and it has the advantage of not costing the same as a 2nd hand scooter. But 3DS Max is much more advanced and has more powerful render engine.
@youdontknowxpand There are good render engines available for Blender, such as LuxRender, Octane, V-Ray, Yafaray and now Cycles (still early development)
For example, I am sure a few of those blender ones had to be LuxRender or Yafaray... Blender Internal cannot do those
Ah cara, sério... Blender possui excelentes ferramentas sim, no entanto cara, não tem nem como comparar rrs... o Blender tem 27MB o instalador (funciona somente em um sistema 32bit, mas com modo de compatibilidade com 64bit).
O 3ds Max possui 2 instaladores de 3GB cada (um pra 32 e outro pra 64 bits)... olha só o tamanho da diferença... logo, vc conclui que o 3ds Max tem recursos mais avançados e precisos... muito mais recursos... até o maya é melhor.
blender and 3DS max are pretty much the same cause there both 3D engine's and sure one has a different than the other and viceversa but they will do all the same thing some time you see better renders in 3DS max than in blender and viceversa personally i use maya cause they have good set of tools to animate and blender might be good in modeling and 3DS might have better specular maps and stuff but they do all the same thing
i use both 3d max and blender. i honestly like blender better but still, the 3d max pictures are made by noobs and the blender pictures are pros. this video is not very fair. Both are wins!
Blender=Maya+3Ds Max+Mudbox+After Effects+Final Cut+V-Ray/ Renderman(ok, Renderman is a stretch, but cycles is pretty sweet).
Oh, and it is open source, and free.
But how much of this is how well you knew textures in the program and how much was the actual program. Also, isn't 3ds max's renderer just crap? I have heard that a lot of people use external renderers for it (though some people use yafaray in Blender- even though the render is pretty good, and the new Cycles is even better). I use
@GeekinsteinTutorials ok thats just bullshit XD After Effects??? have you ever even used after effects!? it cant be compared to blender they are completely different.
@GeekinsteinTutorials umm..they are COMPETELY different. After Effects doesn't even do 3d! sure you can motion track a 3d a object but i geuss thats it :/ . But can you key out a green screen in blender? How about use masking layers so you can have effects like this?/watch?v=84Fm353GuQ8 and im talking about editing REAL footage you have taken with a REAL camera. How about slowing down real life clips more than 30fps should allow with frame blending and plugins like twixtor??? AE is video editing
@GeekinsteinTutorials Nope, it can do Keying but you cant really edit a 1 hour long video in blender lets be honest, and you can do motion tracking with after effects, u need like boujou or whatver to motion track with blender.
@123tejas You can edit full length films in the video sequencer. You can track in the movie clip editor {tomato branch} You can mask (compositor). I am sure someone has made a plugin to slow down the frame rate. And, if you dont know how to use the compositor, you can always use images as planes. You can do anything After Effects can, it just might be a little harder.
@123tejas Color correction yes, i don't know if there is a way to create DVD menu- but Blender is open source, so if enough people wanted it, it would happen. This is part of the reason why I want more people using Blender, it makes the program better.
Blender 3d will be releasing a new system that does not limit you to 3 or 4 sided polygons. I am sure it will be a bit weak the first year or so but it is close to done! Other thinks to look at, Ocean, Dynamic Paint, Motion tracking, new Unwrap tools, a new cycles render engine (you still have the old one too), reworked boolean tools, and a new remesh tools. All this is in the current version or at at least the SVN version (downloadable no compiling required at graphical). BTW this film SUCKS.
@xomagick calm down, i said my comment 3months ago. Also, im just gonna say yh blender can do a lot of stuff but it isnt as good at it as specialised softwares. Yh you can do some decent effects with it but in After Effects its a lot easier, less time consuming and easier to make look better than what you can make with blender. Im not talking about ''changing frame rate'' im talking about frame blending like Twixtor for after Effects. Blender is not some kind of ULTIMATE SOFTWARE XD
How much is After effects? How much is Blender? You go pay all that money for a program that is a one trick pony I'll use blender and create great videos, games, animations, 3d art work, 2d artwork and work with a dedicated community striving to make it better and make me better.
@Leadman1989 After Effects is better at videos editting tho, sorry but its true. Blender isnt just like some god of programming. Most people use blender with after effects.
For the price it better be good at what it does. But don't worry you'll be paying 200$+ for plugins to help it do extras. Blender does everything I need it to do comparably and free. Oh and if I want a plug in bad enough I can code it myself and put out there for everyone to enjoy. The COMMUNITY is one of the best parts. Tutorials, help, inspiration, and friendly competition is everywhere.
I AGREE read most of the comments around you including the one that I wrote that wasn't directed at you. We believe in blender and don't think that people have to make ill-representative videos to support it. No body's raging at you just defending the software we prefer, and trying to convince others that it's good as well, but everyone has they're preferred software to each his own.
@Leadman1989 The price is what started me on it, but now I have MAYA (student version), (and it is great) but the program itself is what makes me use it. I like how everything is in one package and I don't have to render out everything separately and composite it in AE.
@Leadman1989 I am saying that even though I have the option of using MAYA, i still use Blender. This shows that price has no real influence in my program choice.
That's what I thought you were going for, just worded a little confusingly. Lol, I agree. Which ever program an artist chooses they should be comfortable with and confident in their skill to use it that is (almost) all ways the determining factor for quality of work.
@123arskas I know that I was vigorously defending Blender before, and I still prefer it, but if you like 3DS Max, and it does what you need it to, then use it, and make amazing art.
its about the user tbh, you can get some one who is crap at max but good at blender and vice-versa but blender wins hands down because its free and is just as good as max and is almost as good as z brush with the new 2.5
@benjamin98ish lol blender is just as powerful as max, let me guess ur a max user? i usto use it but i like blender better faster work flow however maya is slightly better for animating.
VEIO É OBVIO QUE BLENDER GANHAAAAA..TEM GRAFICOS BILHOES DE VEZES MELHOR Q MAX KKKKK HEHEHE :D JOINHA''
xabimba 1 day ago
231 no les gusta blender
EberlolikonHeldersxD 2 days ago
i rather use blender cause its free and open source
superbungabunga 3 days ago
as much as this video is bias, im taught maya in uni as its industry standard, then i put what i learnt into blender and found it easier to use blender in most aspects, even its layout. but we all have our own opinion, its more to do with the artist than the program, tho if you know how to make the most of more than one program your laughing.
blipblipblur 4 days ago
3ds Max is much better. Blizzard team working with that
MrGhosTRideRrR 4 days ago
3ds max is overpriced and sometimes underestimated. Both are phenomenal programs but 3ds max uses the same old mainstream interface. Blender mixes it up, tons of shortcuts, you barely need to click. 1 vote for blender here.
iRoxproductions 1 week ago
Top and bottom is they are both awesome programs capable of unbelievable stuff, I prefer Blender as I`ve found it easier to pick up the techniques. Although when I tried max it was an older version, probs 10x better now than it was but Ill be sticking to blender thank you..and thanks to team at blender.org..love you guys ;)
tonyc3d 1 week ago
Wow all of blender photos like real life , who make it ? me hahahahahahahah no just kidding
2137860 1 week ago
it all depends on the artist, just cause you buy a 1000 dollar program or can afford it , doesnt mean you can make 1000 dollar picture, it might be the best program but does it come with the skills?
superbungabunga 1 week ago 3
I love Blender
natchasilp1 1 week ago
the only reason blender is better than my 3ds max is because my 3ds max is 5 years old and i can't afford a new version
so blender wins on affordability, it's a really nice prog too btw
Quindal 1 week ago
As an artist who uses Blender, I will say that this video is very biased. You should use examples from both programs that are similar/even in quality and then compare.
Either side will say their program of choice is better by default, but that doesn't really solve anything. In all honesty, we should probably be comparing the rendering engines since that's what this video seems to be about. In that case, it's a tie.
RealEpicFX 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
houghtob1234 2 weeks ago
Bad 3dmax`s examples! It`s like comparing Bentley paper-sketch with real Citroen car.
sergeysan1 2 weeks ago
i use blender. i made a desk.
TheNat2341 2 weeks ago
Is cycles better than Vray?
LemonadeCinema 3 weeks ago
@LemonadeCinema Not yet, but it is getting there.
GeekinsteinTutorials 1 week ago
it not the resources that count, its the way you spend it ....
syah143 3 weeks ago
All the images in this video could be made by either software. It comes down to modelling and texturing, and there's nothing advanced about these images. A true comparison can be made with fluid and smoke simulations as well as hair shading and rendering.
3DanielW 3 weeks ago
1:22
dualsword222 3 weeks ago
I love Blender and use it every day. I will never use another program for 3D modelling as it looks now. But this movie is a joke. You picked the worst from 3DS Max and the best from Blender. Max is a great software. Which it of course "has" to be since it cost quite a bit of money compared to Blender which is free.
GustavNils 3 weeks ago
STUPID VIDEO! I bet you typed "shitty 3D max images" to get them, both programs has their goods and bads, its up to the artist to make a the difference.
edukee 3 weeks ago
Blender wins by far. Now if we can have something with the awesomeness of Blender that's easier to use then I will just die of awesomeness. Wait, I would live long enough to njoy it. Then I would die of awesomeness.
FicticiousAnimation 3 weeks ago
the only thing that needs to be compared is render time and working time (workflow)
create the same objects stop the time which you needed to create+render and post the comparison of both objects
dmftt 3 weeks ago
Aaaaaaaaaaannnnnnnnnnnnnnnddddddddddddd the winner is..........BLENDER!!!
MrBadBall 3 weeks ago
There is no program that will make better 3D-content, it's all up to the artist.
There is just 2 reasons to choose a commercial package.
1, Support.
2, More companies uses them in their workflow.
For functionality, it's mostly up to what you prefer. I don't know of any artist that has mastered all the functionality in either package.
fickedy 4 weeks ago
Each package has it's pros and cons but in the end - what it all boils down to is workflow. How long will it take to achieve the results you want. Again that all depends on how proficient you are with the product vs how well engineered the package is.
digitaldetoxx 4 weeks ago
Max was the standard for many years but the tides are turning. Blender is developing much faster and is easier to use than Max. Max cost $2800 while Blender is free.
digitaldetoxx 4 weeks ago
I think it also has to do alot with the artist i have seen some amazing things come out of blender artists that would rival some of the best 3ds max artists.
imtriggerhappy9 1 month ago
OMG People, both are great ok,
If you wan't to get Blender just download it no problems.
If you wan't to get 3d max just freaking torrent download it.(It's piracy for the people who doesn't now what torrents are
MrLaughingbaby 1 month ago
The author compares the beautifully madeworks created in Blender 3D to work with an obviously inferior quality, which are created in 3ds Max. A similar comparison can cook and against Blender.
I like the Blender, I use it with pleasure, but this movie outright false, so my vote against it!
vovchik7ful 1 month ago 29
@vovchik7ful Love blender, but agreed ^^ This is misleading and bs
pas0003 2 weeks ago
@vovchik7ful Very biased.
houghtob1234 2 weeks ago
nice, maya3d is great too
thethinktankchannel 1 month ago
If you have the option to do maya or blender, always do maya because when getting a job, employers would rather see that you are experienced with a very expensive high-end program rather than a free program. Blender is still really good and you can make amazing things with it but it's all about pricing these days
Xemptuous 1 month ago
i like the look of blenders lighting better though
TheCharityGamerz 1 month ago
Blender has grown a lot in the past 4-5 years , and I am happy for it . I will be using blender if and when I start my own studio
Galavya41 1 month ago
Blender is getting exponentially better. There will be a day I believe when it meets or beats the best of the best on all levels. If everyone donated a few dollars then everyone could have a tool that comparatively would cost thousands.
JohnnyForehead 1 month ago
@JohnnyForehead Sir it is already at par with major 3d softwares like max and maya when it comes to modelling , custom rigging and animation . it just need a few more features like Max's CAT automated rigging system , a proper event based particle system , something like Maya's paint effects and better connectivity with programs like Zbrush and Vue
Galavya41 1 month ago
@Galavya41 Couldn't agree more.
JohnnyForehead 1 month ago
This isn't fair, your comparing crappy 3ds max renders to awesome blender ones
AlexDuude 1 month ago
Soi 'Blender head' tambien. Prossima vez uza modelos igual pelo honestidad, ok?
jayjbee 1 month ago
and finaly this video sucks!!! this pictures about 3d max is low quality!!! wtf?! this car is made in 3d max!!!
ManFrom3D 1 month ago
ok i am not sure i know blender is free and the graphics look much better but i want good graphics and i heard 3ds max was good but i watched sintel and that also blew my mind so in your guys oppinions what should i get ?!?!?!?!?!!?!?!?!?!
MrHalofreak01 1 month ago
@MrHalofreak01 hear me man!:D 3d max is 3gb and more blender is i dont know maybe(100mb-500mb) just for think:) im 3d max artist and i know power of 3dmax...its much better than blender! 3d max with vray,rayfire,fumefx,afterburn,dreamscape(plugins) are facking awsome.just trust me or you can finde more information in google:) and gays i get 3d max for freeeee:D:D and all plugins that just i said:)
ManFrom3D 1 month ago
@ManFrom3D ok thnx man but how do you get it for free? i will look into it though
MrHalofreak01 1 month ago
@MrHalofreak01 i know few sites for it:) 3d max 2008,2009,9,2010,2011,2012 32X64bit with crack:D
ManFrom3D 1 month ago
@ManFrom3D what are the websites just tell me on my channel so no one else can hear if its a secret but if its not ok to tell me nevermind then i will look into something else and thnx for you guys who helped me out! :)
MrHalofreak01 1 month ago
@ManFrom3D Sir that means you have never used blender . Max is powerful nobody is questioning that , but the point is that blender being a free software has come very close to what these big programs can achieve . If you are a startup animation studio blender is the best choice for you . Vray is also available for blender , the community is working hard on adding fluid dynamics to Blender , so the need of fumeFx will be met in the near future , Blender will have all the features of max & maya
Galavya41 1 month ago
@Galavya41 its not my statement about that max is much powerful or fast and e.t.c professional artists prefer max and maya...i think your are blender artist and you want to defend blender:D right? if you want to get 3dmax just tell me i will help you as i can:)
ManFrom3D 1 month ago
@ManFrom3D Quiet the contrary friend, I am a max user. I use blender only for personal projects . I think professional artist would prefer Blender or Lightwave as Max and Maya are way too expensive for an artist but Yes professional Studios do prefer Maya over all other software and thats not because Maya is more " powerful" but simply because Maya and to a lesser extent Max fits into the production pipeline better e;i it connects better with other software like zbrush
Galavya41 1 month ago
@Galavya41 i have zbrush:) (i get it for free:DXD) so i think every person has his favorite program:) my favorites are 3dmax and zbrush i think you can do whatever with this two programs.
ManFrom3D 1 month ago
@MrHalofreak01 Blenders interface and workflow can be very quick and provide a fast workflow, and the V-Ray renderer (and octane as well) are supported commercial renderers. There are also free HQ renderers for Blender such as LuxRender (Similar to Maxwell for 3DS Max)
3DS Max has more plugins such as Realflow, Krakatoa, FumeFX, Other rendering engines etc... that are all great if your willing to spend $1000's on them for commercial use. If you can get them free, great.
Ive used both, both good
zeealpal 1 month ago
@MrHalofreak01 Get blender , its free , its just as good as max or maya . Good animation depends on you the artist and not the software , just make sure you get enough Books & training DVDs so that the learning the software becomes a little easier.But if you want to learn Animation and story telling , well then taking a course is a better idea, you can also take a course online with Animation Mentor
Galavya41 1 month ago
HAHAHAH! Such a dump comparison! HAHAHAH
gbrayner 1 month ago
talk about picking the worst images you can find.... jeeeeez
rikuziyi 1 month ago
fuck! a person who do'nt know the 2 programs very well(like me) can surly tell blender is more awesome from the pictures and it's free! oh yeah bitch ! bite me!
illidens 1 month ago
LOL! Its 3DS Max by the way!!
TheRochak123 1 month ago
BLENDER!
Pperr333 1 month ago
lol,you compare low end sofware with high one...3ds max all the way!
bumtaksi 1 month ago
sorry for the spam, but /watch?v=phWZ1c-8uyU&feature=related 0.40 ! and yes it's about the skill of the artist..
ikbenikHD 1 month ago
you're comparing Blender with VRAY-plugin vs 3DS max without 'VRAY plugin'. V-ray plugin makes it more realistic. Do you still think Blender is better when you watch this video? /watch?v=JveJxQrKC_U ;-)
ikbenikHD 1 month ago
Yo utilizo blender y no me podria comparar con algunos de esos resultados. Depende de quien lo utilize le saldrán mejor o peor. Por eso opino que estas comparaciones no son aceptables al 100%. Lo que se puede hacer para llegar a una buena conclusion es un modelo complicado, que el resultado visual del renderizado sea el mismo y ver cuanto tardan en renderizar. Un amigo me dijo que si queria saber cuan potente era mi procesador que lo pusiera a renderizar. Y ademas blender puede crear juegos(+1).
desiresportal 1 month ago
Blender wins!!
Sluggaboy1000 1 month ago
1:21 is that really a 3d environment? or is that a real pic? If its just a model then bravo to whoever made it, its amazing!
Mangaman1100 1 month ago
Fuck off Cheater....I am using 3ds max for almost 3 years and I bet you I can create photo real renders using max. You just put the crap in 3dsmax section calling it a final render? I donot criticize or promote any software coz I knw Softwares doesn't matters but it's the Artist's creativity that matters a lot.
manavarora22 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Your obviously incredibly biased here, especially considering i make better models than the ones you showed in 3DS Max and i'm a PROGRAMMER.
BoltonBoro 1 month ago
Comment removed
BoltonBoro 1 month ago
Comment removed
BoltonBoro 1 month ago
I'm a blender user, but why the hell did you show those low resolution noob renders from 3Ds Max ? 3Ds Max is better than Blender in some ways and Blender is better than 3Ds Max in some ways.. You made it look like 3Ds Max sucks...
AcAnimate 1 month ago 2
blender es el mejor, salve blender, salve o freesoftware
A5modeoh 1 month ago
blender is free, beat that
Phonikman 1 month ago 83
@Phonikman anim8r and google sketch up are also free. I'd rather pay for the right tools, were just lucky blender is free.
HectagramTv 1 month ago
@Phonikman And 3ds is like 1000+ dollars so,yeah.
KorintioX 1 month ago
@Phonikman So is 3ds max, just use the Student Version.
ChineseEngineer 3 weeks ago
@Phonikman They are both free >.<
TheNorthernNalkyrie 3 weeks ago
@Phonikman But 3ds max 2012 is still better.
houghtob1234 2 weeks ago
@Phonikman so is 3DS max well at least the student version only facebook required
NwoSwat 1 week ago
Really? Slap a bunch of simple and even low quality Max renders alongside some of the better Blender renders and call it a comparison? Tools are tools but dishonest information like this really doesn't help anyone.
xGecTx 1 month ago 2
Um, in the blender section, why did I just see real life photos? Oh wait ;)
RukiryoProductions 1 month ago
Лажа. Взял отстой недоучек, слепленный в максе, и лучшее, что ему попалось из блена и сравнил. Так что угодно опустить можно.
MrStarina 1 month ago
This video is especially dumb now -- Blender 2.61 has an unbiased rendering engine now :D
SGPMPSGA 1 month ago
One thing puts an end to all of this.
The Third & The Seventh.
Nothing matters when such beautiful things exist in 3D artistry.
unbrokenjack 1 month ago
Blender wins, and that is for this reason. You can do the same things you can do in 3ds max only easier or less easier. and blender is free so you can get it how when and where you want.
lightstudiosLSA 1 month ago
It's 3D Max VS Blender. 3D Max doesn't exist. There is only 3Ds Max.
RazorX313X 2 months ago 2
it's funny cuz the video didnt show the nice artwork that have been done in max lol but big respect for those two program
WheezyMasta 2 months ago
Blender 3DS Max 1000 times better! Cycles with Blender 2.61 and modifiers, Python Scripts, Post Production, Video Editing, sculpting, etc. Game Engine. etc.. the beauty is that makes this wonderfully! 3DS Max throw it in the bucket;)
MeshMan3D 2 months ago
Сосал 3ds max у блендера
dimanDll 2 months ago
ok people lets consider this, blender is free! therefor it is superior to anythinig that cost me money(thogh 3d max is easier to use
aglewi41 2 months ago 2
By the like/dislike bar Blender have 108 votes and 3DMax have 53 *ting ting ting* BLENDER WINS!
ScientificAndMore 2 months ago
Mansses774, vc ta errado cara. Pesquise mais, estude mais, e vai ver que os dois programas são muito bons. Seu video foi injusto, pois vangloriou o Blender, e deixo o Max como uma coisa amadora, mas quem ja viu "Matrix: Reloaded" sabe que não é bem assim, todos os efeitos foram feitos em Max.
Fora que não adianta nada o programa ser o melhor do mundo, se o usuário não souber usar, e usar bem, pois apenas decorar passos, não faz um bom dançarino.
Estude mais, boa sorte e não seja mais injusto.
klebersonqsl 2 months ago
C4D ftw :D
RuteNL 2 months ago
Quem postou este vídeo ridículo agiu de má fé. Colocou imagens infantis para o Max e imagens bem feitas por último, que na verdade o 3D Max consegue fazer a mais de 10 anos!!!
arquimedes311 2 months ago
blender is awesome!
manoslash2 2 months ago
Dont forget to compare prices :P i used max for ages but recently been swapping to blender to create my own game to save on a comercial license love some of the features
purkie103 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i think blender is better for making models, but 3d max is better for making animations
FLS96 2 months ago
Comment removed
FLS96 2 months ago
There really is no point in bashing platforms, sheesh, its about as immature as the Mac vs PC purists.
KeelerMediaGroup 2 months ago 8
blender and 3d max are both cool programs, but the artist is what matter, not the program. (sorry for my bad english, im argentinian)
XxxXDylanXx 3 months ago
1:03 ...blender has done a good job a detailing a run down house
Hornetpilot18 3 months ago
am I the only one that thought blender looked bletter?
alienjoe123 3 months ago
comparing renders its a very stupid way to compare 3d software..
rufogongora 3 months ago
I think that 90% of users and companies can use Blender for what they need to do. Fact is as always free products are seen in a bad way just because they're even without trying them.
Well, i'm giving Blender its chance 'cause you see they put a lot of effort and, more important, love/passion in their work..also all the students etc. should learn Blender instead of cracking 3DS Max.
P.s. anyway this video is just dumb, you chose great Blender images and shitty 3DS Max ones on purpose. not fair
Margalus89 3 months ago
loooool
35mmGaming 3 months ago
Its not about the tool, its about the skill of the artist.
MattexFilms2006 3 months ago 107
@MattexFilms2006 you said all there was to be said.. so i just left a comment xD
Alanf15 2 months ago
@MattexFilms2006 I have to agree to that!
RedofYellow 2 months ago
@MattexFilms2006 Indeed!!
TutorialsVillage 2 months ago
@MattexFilms2006 In Mexico, we say "El que es perico donde quiera es verde", in english is something like "Who is a parrot will be green everywere"
Kokoroasakura 1 month ago
@MattexFilms2006 Well said.
CoffeeBitLPs 1 month ago
Bullshit. Check a google pictures for 3D's max, U can find pics better more than Blender. Blender is cool, but in 3D max more features.
P.S.: Sorry for my bad english, i'm Russian.
SlayerDUDE1993 3 months ago
Lol, get a life or something, actually I expected some functionality comparison, but definitely not to see some butthurt dumbfuck moaning.
TheBypasser 3 months ago 3
anyway blender maya 3dsmax or sketchup look a lot better using indigo renderer^^
Nagby3 3 months ago
Comment removed
StefanC4D 3 months ago
Oo cara, ai vc tento valorizar o blender. Vamos fazer uma comparaçao mais justa:
Compare o filme Toy Story (3ds Max foi utilizado) com o curta Sintel (feito no blender). =] os dois programas são otimos nao fiquem comparando
MrLukinhah 3 months ago
@MrLukinhah y "planeta51"??? tuvo ayuda de blender. Pero no es la cámara, es el fotógrafo. Mala comparación entre los dos programas
otir12 1 month ago
eu uso só o 3d max, nunca usei e nem sei mexer no blender e jamais quero aprender a mexer no blender. Mas dizer que blender é melhor que max é burrice, pois o software 3d mais usado no mundo é o 3dmax e é bem caro, enquanto que o blender é de graça. Na realidade eu prefiro em primeiro lugar 3d max, depois cinema 4d e depois maya, o blender fica logo depois desses que falei,
cineastaAmadorx 3 months ago
@cineastaAmadorx que preconceito, só porque é gratis aushauhsuahu, mas eu entendo. Uso o 3ds Max e sei mexer no blender, mas comparar programas é idiotice, todos os programas tem basicamente as mesmas ferramentas e finalidades, vai do gosto de cada um
MrLukinhah 3 months ago
@cineastaAmadorx Acho melhor aprender a mexer no blender antes de falar qualquer coisa.... Claro que o 3DS Max é pago e talz, tem mais recursos... Mas o 3DS Max faz jogos? Esculpe? Não? Ah... você precisa comprar pelo menos 3 programas pra fazer esses tipos de coisas... ZBrush pra esculpir e Unity/UDK pra criar um jogo....
Blender faz tudo isso de graça 8D
Pedru000 3 months ago
Você só esqueceu de um importante detalhe, o código do game criado no blender é aberto para qualquer um mexer. Sem falar que a maioria das empresas utilizam maya e max. Gosto do blender e sou usuário, porém em questão de estabilidade minha preferência é maya.
marcelomoraification 2 months ago
@marcelomoraification É possível criar um .exe sem expor o código do jogo, também, se não estou enganado, é possível criar outros tipos de executáveis nele, sem expor o .blend.
Pedru000 2 months ago
@Pedru000 Então, eu não tenho ciência se realmente da para gerar um executável. O melhor motor de jogo bom para criar jogos é a Unity 3d e UDK. Ambos bem documentados na medida do possível. Até hoje eu vi um jogo bom feito em blender , uma replica do mario galaxy. Se for verdade isso que você está falando, realmente vale a pena. Abs...
marcelomoraification 2 months ago
This is an invalid discussion.
TheodenN 3 months ago
This competition is Rigged have you seen blur studios animation vs your sintel :)
MrIsiah777 3 months ago
Que merda de video. Eu uso blender, mas para dizer que ele é melçhor que o 3D max e colo9car meia duzia de trabalhos mal feitos em 3D max não rola.
3D max é um otimo programa, e se consegue resultados minimamentes tão bons quanto os que se consegue em blender, basta saber mexer em ambos.
Esse video na real depõe contra usuários do blender, de vez fazer uma boa propaganda para o software livre.
awartss 3 months ago
I use both blender and 3ds max.
youdontknowxpand 3 months ago
thumb up if u r using 3d MAX ;)
PeshrawRozh 3 months ago 2
Max is the best :X
kailed 3 months ago 2
Exactly. Blender is very good since it's very simple to use and it's in constant evolution, and it has the advantage of not costing the same as a 2nd hand scooter. But 3DS Max is much more advanced and has more powerful render engine.
youdontknowxpand 3 months ago
@youdontknowxpand There are good render engines available for Blender, such as LuxRender, Octane, V-Ray, Yafaray and now Cycles (still early development)
For example, I am sure a few of those blender ones had to be LuxRender or Yafaray... Blender Internal cannot do those
zeealpal 3 months ago
@zeealpal Yeah, that's true.
youdontknowxpand 3 months ago
The important thing is not the program, the important thing is who is behind it!
Hytachyfdp 3 months ago
Any 3D app is only as good as the person using it...
...but Blender sure as hell whips the pants off 3dsMax in quality/price ratio.
D0p3Smuggl3r 3 months ago
Ah cara, sério... Blender possui excelentes ferramentas sim, no entanto cara, não tem nem como comparar rrs... o Blender tem 27MB o instalador (funciona somente em um sistema 32bit, mas com modo de compatibilidade com 64bit).
O 3ds Max possui 2 instaladores de 3GB cada (um pra 32 e outro pra 64 bits)... olha só o tamanho da diferença... logo, vc conclui que o 3ds Max tem recursos mais avançados e precisos... muito mais recursos... até o maya é melhor.
o Blender é mais pra quem tá começando.
tonigui 3 months ago
blender and 3DS max are pretty much the same cause there both 3D engine's and sure one has a different than the other and viceversa but they will do all the same thing some time you see better renders in 3DS max than in blender and viceversa personally i use maya cause they have good set of tools to animate and blender might be good in modeling and 3DS might have better specular maps and stuff but they do all the same thing
vjstudio 4 months ago
some photoes looked good like photos made in real life
Romanian901 4 months ago
i use both 3d max and blender. i honestly like blender better but still, the 3d max pictures are made by noobs and the blender pictures are pros. this video is not very fair. Both are wins!
momo6899 4 months ago 2
Blender=Maya+3Ds Max+Mudbox+After Effects+Final Cut+V-Ray/ Renderman(ok, Renderman is a stretch, but cycles is pretty sweet).
Oh, and it is open source, and free.
But how much of this is how well you knew textures in the program and how much was the actual program. Also, isn't 3ds max's renderer just crap? I have heard that a lot of people use external renderers for it (though some people use yafaray in Blender- even though the render is pretty good, and the new Cycles is even better). I use
GeekinsteinTutorials 4 months ago
@GeekinsteinTutorials ok thats just bullshit XD After Effects??? have you ever even used after effects!? it cant be compared to blender they are completely different.
123tejas 3 months ago
@123tejas Tell me one thing After Effects can do that Blender cannot.
GeekinsteinTutorials 3 months ago 2
@GeekinsteinTutorials umm..they are COMPETELY different. After Effects doesn't even do 3d! sure you can motion track a 3d a object but i geuss thats it :/ . But can you key out a green screen in blender? How about use masking layers so you can have effects like this?/watch?v=84Fm353GuQ8 and im talking about editing REAL footage you have taken with a REAL camera. How about slowing down real life clips more than 30fps should allow with frame blending and plugins like twixtor??? AE is video editing
123tejas 3 months ago
@123tejas Blender can do ALL of those things.
GeekinsteinTutorials 3 months ago 36
@GeekinsteinTutorials Nope, it can do Keying but you cant really edit a 1 hour long video in blender lets be honest, and you can do motion tracking with after effects, u need like boujou or whatver to motion track with blender.
123tejas 3 months ago
@123tejas You can edit full length films in the video sequencer. You can track in the movie clip editor {tomato branch} You can mask (compositor). I am sure someone has made a plugin to slow down the frame rate. And, if you dont know how to use the compositor, you can always use images as planes. You can do anything After Effects can, it just might be a little harder.
GeekinsteinTutorials 3 months ago
@GeekinsteinTutorials Colour Correction.Creating a Dvd menu.
123tejas 3 months ago
@123tejas Color correction yes, i don't know if there is a way to create DVD menu- but Blender is open source, so if enough people wanted it, it would happen. This is part of the reason why I want more people using Blender, it makes the program better.
GeekinsteinTutorials 3 months ago
@123tejas You even get all of the graphs/ scope things for color correction.
GeekinsteinTutorials 3 months ago
Blender 3d will be releasing a new system that does not limit you to 3 or 4 sided polygons. I am sure it will be a bit weak the first year or so but it is close to done! Other thinks to look at, Ocean, Dynamic Paint, Motion tracking, new Unwrap tools, a new cycles render engine (you still have the old one too), reworked boolean tools, and a new remesh tools. All this is in the current version or at at least the SVN version (downloadable no compiling required at graphical). BTW this film SUCKS.
xomagick 1 week ago
@123tejas You don't know what you are talking about. Perhaps you should learn a program BEFORE you go and write BS like this.
BTW you could change frame rate for like the last 15 years of Blender. LOL
xomagick 1 week ago
@xomagick calm down, i said my comment 3months ago. Also, im just gonna say yh blender can do a lot of stuff but it isnt as good at it as specialised softwares. Yh you can do some decent effects with it but in After Effects its a lot easier, less time consuming and easier to make look better than what you can make with blender. Im not talking about ''changing frame rate'' im talking about frame blending like Twixtor for after Effects. Blender is not some kind of ULTIMATE SOFTWARE XD
123tejas 1 week ago
and it cant slow down frame rates like after effects can with Twixtor!
123tejas 3 months ago
@123tejas
How much is After effects? How much is Blender? You go pay all that money for a program that is a one trick pony I'll use blender and create great videos, games, animations, 3d art work, 2d artwork and work with a dedicated community striving to make it better and make me better.
Leadman1989 2 months ago
@Leadman1989 After Effects is better at videos editting tho, sorry but its true. Blender isnt just like some god of programming. Most people use blender with after effects.
123tejas 2 months ago
@123tejas
For the price it better be good at what it does. But don't worry you'll be paying 200$+ for plugins to help it do extras. Blender does everything I need it to do comparably and free. Oh and if I want a plug in bad enough I can code it myself and put out there for everyone to enjoy. The COMMUNITY is one of the best parts. Tutorials, help, inspiration, and friendly competition is everywhere.
Leadman1989 2 months ago
@Leadman1989 ok, every1 is havaving a rage at me lol. all im saying is this video is a biased representation of blnder vs 3ds max.
123tejas 2 months ago
@123tejas
I AGREE read most of the comments around you including the one that I wrote that wasn't directed at you. We believe in blender and don't think that people have to make ill-representative videos to support it. No body's raging at you just defending the software we prefer, and trying to convince others that it's good as well, but everyone has they're preferred software to each his own.
:D
Leadman1989 2 months ago
@Leadman1989 The price is what started me on it, but now I have MAYA (student version), (and it is great) but the program itself is what makes me use it. I like how everything is in one package and I don't have to render out everything separately and composite it in AE.
GeekinsteinTutorials 1 week ago
@GeekinsteinTutorials
I don't quite understand what you're trying to say.
Leadman1989 1 week ago
@Leadman1989 I am saying that even though I have the option of using MAYA, i still use Blender. This shows that price has no real influence in my program choice.
GeekinsteinTutorials 1 week ago
@GeekinsteinTutorials
That's what I thought you were going for, just worded a little confusingly. Lol, I agree. Which ever program an artist chooses they should be comfortable with and confident in their skill to use it that is (almost) all ways the determining factor for quality of work.
Leadman1989 1 week ago
@123tejas There are FOSS optical flow framerate adjustment soft wares...
MisterSensational 2 months ago
@GeekinsteinTutorials 3dsMax is best of all!!!!
123arskas 2 months ago
@123arskas I know that I was vigorously defending Blender before, and I still prefer it, but if you like 3DS Max, and it does what you need it to, then use it, and make amazing art.
GeekinsteinTutorials 1 week ago
blender wins cuz its not just a modeling program its also a game engine :)
benjamin98ish 4 months ago
i disliked this video, still i prefer blender, this video is crap!
maKALLEchine 4 months ago 2
its about the user tbh, you can get some one who is crap at max but good at blender and vice-versa but blender wins hands down because its free and is just as good as max and is almost as good as z brush with the new 2.5
hutstuff156 4 months ago
@hutstuff156 its also a game engine... duh :)
benjamin98ish 4 months ago
@benjamin98ish lol blender is just as powerful as max, let me guess ur a max user? i usto use it but i like blender better faster work flow however maya is slightly better for animating.
hutstuff156 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@hutstuff156 if you would just visit my channel you wouldnt have to guess, you would know im not a max user. :)
benjamin98ish 4 months ago
if you go comparing 3d programs don't do it with models..
rather wa