Barrbra's version is excellent, Steinmans is mediocre but forme, this is the best version. Saw Meat sing it live on tour with just a piano & meat in an armchair, as if he was waiting for his 'date'.
He's pretty good here, and the emotion as always is perfect. But his control and tone when he's singing quietly is nothing compared to him in his prime.
Can't listen to him sing Heaven Can Wait and similar ones these days...
Oh, I don't know people. I think Barbra and Meatloaf are a tie! The discussion continues! My opinion equally good, but "different!" The other are really good,
but these two are the best in "my viewpoint!" viewpoints3
@Monrocsol hehe, Her voice matches her disposition. She admits she is very hard to work with, treats people absolutely horrible, and is extremely arrogant. That shows in her voice. The absolute antithesis of Meat Loaf. I know many people that don't like her voice, separate from her terrible disposition. Regards.
@Monrocsol Oh, you read all about her too? Hehehe My view comes from many years of interviews, observations, etc. You are good for a laugh at least! I forgot to mention, she also admittedly is VERY PROUD of those characteristics (from a Live Interview she did.) Her UGLINESS of disposition sure shines through! Meat Loaf puts his heart, and soul into all his music, without such non-sense. Great people don't forget where they came from, Meat Loaf is still genuine. Streisand... A Promoted Joke!
@Monrocsol You might try to address that to me. Hehe. No, I get information from many places, at many different times, and she is not young. I believe that quote was from a Biography, on TV. It was in her words, right out of the horses mouth, there was NO mistaking it! I do have witnesses. Hehehe No Joke! Fact is, you like her regardless, I do not. She is highly promoted, far beyond her true talent, and primarily a studio artist. Enough said.
@tajtt1 - so which is it? The original by Jim in 1981 or Babs' cover from 1984?
Each version is different; the emotion content is the interpretation each artist make - and yes Babs probably has the best voice. But Jim's version has more venom in the "anger" parts to the song, and Meat draws at my heart strings like he always does in the melancholy moments.
@tajtt1 - so which is it? The original by Jim in 1981 or Babs' cover from 1984?
Each version is different; it's the emotional content in the interpretation each artist makes - and yes Babs probably has the best voice. But Jim's version has more venom in the "anger" parts to the song, and Meat draws at my heart strings like he always does in the melancholy moments.
a) The original version was recorded by Jim Steinman, who also wrote it.
b) Like all the songs on Steinman's Bad For Good album, they were written for Meat Loaf. But his voice needed a prolonged break after touring to promote Bat Out Of Hell and Steinman got fed up with waiting.
If you prefer Streisand's version, fair enough. But Steinman's version was first and this is how it was always supposed to sound.
@KCKevinCarter That happened with several songs that got postponed, and done by other artists. I will always have a soft spot in my heart for Meat Loaf, but this would have been better had they not had to put it off. Although it is still awesome! Same with "It's all coming back to me know."
Saw Meat live and he was asked about this song, he told the story of how it was written and the late night call he received at the time. Then he just blew us away with a live version that was so unbelievable. Not a dry eye in the house.
Such a powerfull song. Amazing stuff and Meat Loaf does it really well. I do like Jim´s version a bit more though. He´s got, i don´t know. More passion and pain in his singing in this song
Barbra's version is very good but this is the best - Jim Steinman writes awesome songs but alas hasn't the voice to do them true justice. The passion Meat shows in this is amazing - you could almost feel the emotion.
Absolutely brilliant. I've listened to all three versions and I'm still not sure which is best. No one touches Steinman when it comes to passion and contrast.
BooKittyRadley..Thank You! You have made my day..really! I am laughing...and as I have just listened to both of them..and love them both..whatever the words! signing off..and looking forward to talking to you again on Barbra or Meatloaf's site! viewpoints3
BooKittyRadley..Ok..I give in! You are correct! We have spoken before I believe!
Yes, this is a "judgement" of the music to be sure...and I agree.."not meant in the most serious fashion." My gosh...In the "judgement of the music" I "know" we can listen to them both and appreciate what this man and woman both give as individuals to the music! I think we appreciate them equally..and I will listen again and again to both. I'm sure we will cross paths again as we both like good music! viewpoints3
Hey BookittyRadley...you are "partial to this as he says "so take off your dress." What would you have Barbra say? That is Not a judgement of the music. viewpoints3
For everyone who saying Barbara's is better or Meat's better. Here's a realllllll quick, everything Meat Loaf covers instantly becomes the superb, definitive addition.
Superb song, Meats version is superior to any other. I have Jims BFG, sorry but the guy just can't sing. Great writer and producer, thats where his genius shines through.
Meat plays characters in his songs and the character he plays in this song is a lesbian lover. Since I heard this in an interview the song has never sounded the same. I absolutely love this song!!!!!!
Have you ever heard the Swedish version by Cecilia Vennersten?
"Lämnad i mörkret"
No youtube video, but you can find it on grooveshark.
Not saying it's better, but kinda interesting if you're a fan of this song.
zayatz 2 months ago
What a touching lyric and song. I´ve been there so I can feel it.
fagermannen01 4 months ago in playlist Liked
this song reminds me of my ex boyfriend :(
blackveilbride1 4 months ago
Only this man could pull off this song after Barbra did it in 84
kerribare1 5 months ago
Only this could pull off this song after Barbra did it in 84
kerribare1 5 months ago
5 ppl were left in the dark
sineadc1973 5 months ago
you can't beat the raw emotion sadness passion his sexy voice love love love meatloaf
sineadc1973 5 months ago 2
Barrbra's version is excellent, Steinmans is mediocre but forme, this is the best version. Saw Meat sing it live on tour with just a piano & meat in an armchair, as if he was waiting for his 'date'.
meatloaf93 6 months ago
Wish Meat had recorded this back in the day.
He's pretty good here, and the emotion as always is perfect. But his control and tone when he's singing quietly is nothing compared to him in his prime.
Can't listen to him sing Heaven Can Wait and similar ones these days...
greyztone 7 months ago
fan...tastic! I didn't know he sang this. Thank you.
awatchernamedwidget 8 months ago
Oh, I don't know people. I think Barbra and Meatloaf are a tie! The discussion continues! My opinion equally good, but "different!" The other are really good,
but these two are the best in "my viewpoint!" viewpoints3
viewpoints3 9 months ago
@viewpoints3 Streisand? You have to be kidding! Ughh! Meatloaf's superior, Streisand voice is ugly!!!!!
torro454 4 months ago
@torro454 You are Nutz. And the only one that thinks Streisand voice is "ugly."
Monrocsol 2 months ago
@Monrocsol hehe, Her voice matches her disposition. She admits she is very hard to work with, treats people absolutely horrible, and is extremely arrogant. That shows in her voice. The absolute antithesis of Meat Loaf. I know many people that don't like her voice, separate from her terrible disposition. Regards.
torro454 2 months ago
@torro454 Obviously, you repeat what you have read.
Monrocsol 2 months ago
@Monrocsol Oh, you read all about her too? Hehehe My view comes from many years of interviews, observations, etc. You are good for a laugh at least! I forgot to mention, she also admittedly is VERY PROUD of those characteristics (from a Live Interview she did.) Her UGLINESS of disposition sure shines through! Meat Loaf puts his heart, and soul into all his music, without such non-sense. Great people don't forget where they came from, Meat Loaf is still genuine. Streisand... A Promoted Joke!
torro454 2 months ago
@Monrocsol I am willing to make a bet that you will never find that interview, but if you do please upload it.
Monrocsol 2 months ago
@Monrocsol You might try to address that to me. Hehe. No, I get information from many places, at many different times, and she is not young. I believe that quote was from a Biography, on TV. It was in her words, right out of the horses mouth, there was NO mistaking it! I do have witnesses. Hehehe No Joke! Fact is, you like her regardless, I do not. She is highly promoted, far beyond her true talent, and primarily a studio artist. Enough said.
torro454 2 months ago
meatloaf is so sexy with short hair
sineadc1973 10 months ago
Comment removed
ajcvikingboy 10 months ago
Remember when you could watch a video without having to sit through commercials?
Remember when music videos were uploaded by users and not VEVO
Remember when all the info was to the right of the video?
Remember you could rate a video 1-5 stars?
Remember the famous yellow subscribe button?
Remember when the users controlled the site and not corporations?
Post this in every video and lets start a youtube revolution!
Thumbs up to keep at the top of the page!
ajcvikingboy 10 months ago
nobody beat the original....barbra streisand she is the best. This version is horrible
tajtt1 10 months ago
@tajtt1 - so which is it? The original by Jim in 1981 or Babs' cover from 1984?
Each version is different; the emotion content is the interpretation each artist make - and yes Babs probably has the best voice. But Jim's version has more venom in the "anger" parts to the song, and Meat draws at my heart strings like he always does in the melancholy moments.
gelureian 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@tajtt1 - so which is it? The original by Jim in 1981 or Babs' cover from 1984?
Each version is different; it's the emotional content in the interpretation each artist makes - and yes Babs probably has the best voice. But Jim's version has more venom in the "anger" parts to the song, and Meat draws at my heart strings like he always does in the melancholy moments.
gelureian 10 months ago
@tajtt1
a) The original version was recorded by Jim Steinman, who also wrote it.
b) Like all the songs on Steinman's Bad For Good album, they were written for Meat Loaf. But his voice needed a prolonged break after touring to promote Bat Out Of Hell and Steinman got fed up with waiting.
If you prefer Streisand's version, fair enough. But Steinman's version was first and this is how it was always supposed to sound.
KCKevinCarter 9 months ago
@KCKevinCarter That happened with several songs that got postponed, and done by other artists. I will always have a soft spot in my heart for Meat Loaf, but this would have been better had they not had to put it off. Although it is still awesome! Same with "It's all coming back to me know."
torro454 4 months ago
@tajtt1its beats not beat. and by the way youre full of shit fucking lesbo. LONG LIVE MEAT
laracroftrulez 7 months ago
This kicks the crap out of the Barbara Streisand version several times over IMO.
RichXbox360 11 months ago
It's amazing how he can do all of this without even moving his face or opening his mouth, a TRUE artist
Zebonka 11 months ago
u r the best ever xxx
taraloo1 1 year ago
Saw Meat live and he was asked about this song, he told the story of how it was written and the late night call he received at the time. Then he just blew us away with a live version that was so unbelievable. Not a dry eye in the house.
I have loved it ever since.
c44holmes 1 year ago
@c44holmes
Please tell us what he said. It has to be profoundly bittersweet...
SDschmetterling 1 year ago
whoooooooooooo great music
TheTaker1293 1 year ago
Such a powerfull song. Amazing stuff and Meat Loaf does it really well. I do like Jim´s version a bit more though. He´s got, i don´t know. More passion and pain in his singing in this song
blasabb 1 year ago
This song is just right for me and the lyrics fits perfectually.
fagermannen01 1 year ago
@fagermannen01 ......its just right for me too......could have written this song myself
MsJamqueen 1 year ago
This is so incredible. I love Meatloaf. This song is so intense and so full of
passion! viewpoints3
viewpoints3 1 year ago
OH...I cannot choose between Barbra and Meatloaf! Wow! I love him!
He is So Good! viewpoints3
viewpoints3 1 year ago
Barbra's version is very good but this is the best - Jim Steinman writes awesome songs but alas hasn't the voice to do them true justice. The passion Meat shows in this is amazing - you could almost feel the emotion.
meatloaf93 1 year ago
Can't stay away from this....love Steinman, not s'much lovin' the Streisand version...but, this version....heartfelt & haunting. Love it.
sinfinitii 1 year ago
Comment removed
sinfinitii 1 year ago
Love Meat Loaf no matter what song he sings - this one is just one of the best when you need it most
MsMistressM 1 year ago
GOD
AngelBatistaPenis 1 year ago
This is so incredible! I LOVE Meatloaf! He puts so much "emotion" in his songs!
This is a Wonderful song! Awesome! I stil love both his and Barbra's version...and
consider them comparable...but so different! viewpoints3
viewpoints3 1 year ago
One of THE best Meatloaf songs ever in my opinion.
RichXbox360 1 year ago
I have never heard this version. But, I am so glad that I checked it out. Meat Loaf is awesome!
pcaz84 1 year ago
i love this song
clareisabel 1 year ago
Hi BooKittyRadley!
I am "back here" again...still love both Barbra and Meatloaf!I I also like Steinman's version....no matter what...this is a
wonderful, passionate song! Wow! viewpoints3...
thanks for this one coming back again!
viewpoints3 2 years ago
la mejor interpretacion no hay otra...
this is the best performed of all no more...
leoncastillofam 2 years ago
Absolutely brilliant. I've listened to all three versions and I'm still not sure which is best. No one touches Steinman when it comes to passion and contrast.
PureMajic 2 years ago
I will never stop listening to this song! I love Barbra's
version....but, Meatloaf is just wonderful also!
I could never decide between them...they're both..equal, but
different...both incredible! viewpoints3
I haven't listened to this for a long time...have listened to
both versions...incredible! Thanks to both!
viewpoints3 2 years ago
Fantastic record.
bobbystormont 2 years ago
5/5 ofc.
jessicaofrinkaby 3 years ago 2
jim stiemens song always, never will be beaten for sheer passion.
42hydro 3 years ago 3
BooKittyRadley..Thank You! You have made my day..really! I am laughing...and as I have just listened to both of them..and love them both..whatever the words! signing off..and looking forward to talking to you again on Barbra or Meatloaf's site! viewpoints3
viewpoints3 3 years ago
BooKittyRadley..Ok..I give in! You are correct! We have spoken before I believe!
Yes, this is a "judgement" of the music to be sure...and I agree.."not meant in the most serious fashion." My gosh...In the "judgement of the music" I "know" we can listen to them both and appreciate what this man and woman both give as individuals to the music! I think we appreciate them equally..and I will listen again and again to both. I'm sure we will cross paths again as we both like good music! viewpoints3
viewpoints3 3 years ago
I Kiss You!
:-*
BooKittyRadley 3 years ago
Hey BookittyRadley...you are "partial to this as he says "so take off your dress." What would you have Barbra say? That is Not a judgement of the music. viewpoints3
viewpoints3 3 years ago
I would have her say, "so take off your dress".
A little homo-erotica of the female flavour. Call it charity.
Yes I am aware that she is heterosexual.
My comment was not meant in the most serious fashion. But this IS a judgement of music.
:-)
BooKittyRadley 3 years ago
sadness at 6:11
lougaroupX3 3 years ago
Wow! This is incredible! I will listen to Barbara...but..."nobody" can surpass this! viewpoints3
viewpoints3 3 years ago
I like both Meatloaf's version and Streisand's version. But I'm partial to Meatloaf's just because he says 'so take off your dress'.
If only Streisand had used that line instead of 'as I watch you undress'...
BooKittyRadley 3 years ago
dis song is lovely!
olomc2008 3 years ago 3
1 million times Meat Loaf version...The emotion, the sadness...I just want to get at the truth..
lougaroupX3 3 years ago 18
For everyone who saying Barbara's is better or Meat's better. Here's a realllllll quick, everything Meat Loaf covers instantly becomes the superb, definitive addition.
dopestar6666 3 years ago 3
Very heartfelt, prefer Barbra's tho.
attwist 3 years ago
Superb song, Meats version is superior to any other. I have Jims BFG, sorry but the guy just can't sing. Great writer and producer, thats where his genius shines through.
Ellehcim38 3 years ago 13
meats version is better than barbras
bornfromashes2008 3 years ago 2
awesome song, so much better then barbara's version! =]
i love meat loaf <3
LadyVixie 3 years ago
One of Meatloaf's very best songs...."who made the very first move"..love that little part at the very end...
sparkette49 3 years ago
this was written by steinman and his version was fantastic. check out the album bad for good.
SUPAALBION 3 years ago 3
listen at 6:11 - how sad
lougaroupX3 3 years ago
this is a classic Jim Stienman song and when jim sings it, it sends shivers down your spine.
42hydro 3 years ago
It sounds like cowboysong i still like the original version of barbara streisand
Chardebarle 3 years ago
i like both versions. Jus love the big guy!
darle 3 years ago 2
Barbra's version is just so much better
Dannyjhb 3 years ago
Far the best version of this song. Beautiful.
1967jea 3 years ago
you don't leave us in the dark, ML, you are the best
lougaroupX3 3 years ago
Meat Loaf; The Rock God. Absolute legend.
steinmanloaf 4 years ago 2
wat a song plz dnt take dis song dwn!!! Big man is brillanr keep her lit!!
BanditCountry1916 4 years ago
Meat plays characters in his songs and the character he plays in this song is a lesbian lover. Since I heard this in an interview the song has never sounded the same. I absolutely love this song!!!!!!
ollie241189 4 years ago
this is song reminds me of my ex boyfriend we like this song.
Amonkey13 4 years ago
meatloaf is the best singer ever
notmrealname 4 years ago
what can you say about meat loaf he the best i love watchin him love him till my diyin day keep up the good work meat loaf
kelly310886 4 years ago 3
1996 sydney concert ... ML was sitting down singing this ... lucky me, front row . dead centre ... what awesome power !!!
Waskwy 4 years ago 3
i love this song
darle 4 years ago
How very sad song - listen to the words on ML Welcome to the Neighbourhood....
lougaroupX3 4 years ago
awesome..brilliant song..i dont suppose you have MARTHA do you..cheers
navibren 4 years ago
yes and my sister name's is Martha and she is a ery lonely person...
lougaroupX3 3 years ago
Streisand's version is the best, plus she is Hot as Hell in that video.
Jennmoore69 3 years ago
I guess she looks ok in that video... from the neck down.
BMJcYn 2 years ago
barbra streisand is a beautiful woman.
08ravenwhitney 2 years ago