and who the FUCK are you? dummass.. what did You do for Anthropology or science in general? Go back to US where You came from and be proud of being member of the most stupid, fatest, greedy and idiotic nation of all!!
I like Victorian Culture due to the Age of Enlightenment, Romantic era, etc. However I found the exploration of other "less advanced" cultures very offensive. In the warmer climates one is able to live of the means of the land, in colder climates resources are hard to come by, which is why societies in the North developed. Just an idea though. :)
@raysima Off the Veranda is a different movie from the 1980s. My Anthro teacher told me it's only on VHS at the moment. Off the Veranda is a little more to the point, none of the reenactments. But it does not mention Malinowski's journals at all, which paints a different side to him. (i.e. he's not so accepting of different cultures as he seemed.)
Thanks for uploading this vid, anthropology is so interesting, im studying my bachellor degree and we´ve made a work abouth Malinowsky´s work on my anthropology´s class, this is so interesting because we´re similar to primitive cultures! this vid is really useful, thanks for uploading it! Greetings from Mexico
Qué bueno. Casi todos los trabajos interesantes están en inglés, hay la obligación de saber inglés, y uno se pregunta: ¿por qué inglés?¿por qué no otro idioma?
Malinowski me parece sin duda uno de los mejores etnografos de la historia, ya fuera por razones accidentales, (la antropologia acaso no es eso?) logro hacer un excelente trabajo de campo, pero claro, su diario nos dejo conocer las cosas que atraviesan al investigador, subjetividad que nos habia sido arrebatada por la ciencia en su afan objetivista, y que, gracias entre otros a él, estamos recuperando....alguien sabe si esta este documental en español? no entiendo muy bien....Gracias!
Many American anthropologists, especially feminists (who currently hijacked anthropology department), refused to use Malinowski's method because they call him a "racist" and "sexist" who impose "white men's science" to the "primitive societies".
As an anthropology student, I am very disappointed in current American anthropologists who only care about political interest and terminology rather than studying humankind.
Yes, I agree it's a shame. Malinowski's professional work in the Trobriands showed his readers that people in so-called 'primitive societies' were exactly like people in the West insofar as they were complex and self-interested. In doing so he de-exoticized the other while showing that much of what we took for granted as 'natural' was socially constructed. The unfortunate diatribes in his diaries, never meant to be published, have to be understood as acts of catharsis during stressful fieldwork.
You're welcome. I've done eight terms of fieldwork in places most people in North America or Europe would regard as 'exotic' and I know how stressful and frustrating this kind of work can be. Note that living in one place for some time is a completely different kind of experience to 'travelling'. Like most other anthropologists I know with this kind of experience I'm prepared to cut Malinowski a little slack for what he wrote in his diaries, viewing it as letting off steam.
Congratulations, you were able to do fieldwork in interesting places, an experience that anthropologists from countries of the "Third World" couldn't even dream doing.
bueno malinowski es todo un hito en la antropologia. eso de que escribia en su diario cosas que sentia, es normal, ya que el era una persona con una cosntruccion mental de su propia cultura y jusgaba segun eso. a las finale stodos los antropologos jusgamos asi, segun nuestra vision, pero lo que nos hace cientificos es que nos logramos despojar de eso para poder explicar.
"pero lo que nos hace cientificos es que nos logramos despojar de eso para poder explicar." pff si malinowkski nunca lo logró realmente, tú crees que tú sí?
Verdaderamente q esta brutal el hecho q frente a mundo el presenta esa cultura de una manera aceptable y en su diario el se desahogaba por decirlo asi y hablaba muy mal de ellos..era como sacar todo lo mal que se sentia...
B.M. wanted to disprove S. Freuds "anal Eroticism" theory. When, he said he found none in these people it was so reported to Sigmund who replied "what, dont they have assholes!?"
Yo creo que está bien documentado; tiene entrevistas con Adam Kuper, por ejemplo, y además ubica la obra de Malinowski en el contexto de un debate teórico.
daughter: "who is to blame him?"
grandson : "me"
and who the FUCK are you? dummass.. what did You do for Anthropology or science in general? Go back to US where You came from and be proud of being member of the most stupid, fatest, greedy and idiotic nation of all!!
mlembrant 2 months ago
Comment removed
swertyman 3 months ago
I like Victorian Culture due to the Age of Enlightenment, Romantic era, etc. However I found the exploration of other "less advanced" cultures very offensive. In the warmer climates one is able to live of the means of the land, in colder climates resources are hard to come by, which is why societies in the North developed. Just an idea though. :)
helliop 4 months ago
ya mum
MrAdriantse 4 months ago
^____^
133742069 4 months ago
GOLF WANG
ThemThems 4 months ago
Damn!! Look at those tig-o-bitties!!
jacobs0808 4 months ago 2
is this also called Off the Veranda?
raysima 6 months ago
@raysima Off the Veranda is a different movie from the 1980s. My Anthro teacher told me it's only on VHS at the moment. Off the Veranda is a little more to the point, none of the reenactments. But it does not mention Malinowski's journals at all, which paints a different side to him. (i.e. he's not so accepting of different cultures as he seemed.)
ohyeahigotit 4 months ago
Algun link para verlo subtitulado en castellano?
PingoLimon 8 months ago
NOT promiscuous sex! NOOOO!
Aprilshowersss 9 months ago
my last name is Malinowski :D :D
Sinnlosx01 10 months ago
Thanks for uploading this vid, anthropology is so interesting, im studying my bachellor degree and we´ve made a work abouth Malinowsky´s work on my anthropology´s class, this is so interesting because we´re similar to primitive cultures! this vid is really useful, thanks for uploading it! Greetings from Mexico
GerardoMontalvo 11 months ago
Like if youre being forced to watch this for an anthro class :/
rockoncat89 1 year ago 107
@rockoncat89 I'm supposed to do a presentation on this video for my anthropology class...
AddictedtotheDarke 4 months ago
What did he do for sex ?
markbikes 1 year ago 2
Margaret mead has a huge vagina
edanxkr 1 year ago
0:38 "That's the fifth monocle this week, I simply must stop being so horrified."
boredmuskoxen 1 year ago 2
haha, why is the last bit cut out? the good old rational ... French, is it?
punkpoetry 1 year ago
świetny film o wybitnym Polaku
jaceksebastiang1 2 years ago
Very interesting video! I love reading the works of Malinowski in my Anthropology classes.
theemceemurdah 2 years ago
yo la verdad no se ingles
cantomortal 2 years ago
@cantomortal
Qué bueno. Casi todos los trabajos interesantes están en inglés, hay la obligación de saber inglés, y uno se pregunta: ¿por qué inglés?¿por qué no otro idioma?
No es lindo que nos impongan cosas.
desfondo 1 year ago 2
I love the BBC´s ability to make good documentaries. Thank you sharing this.
ontic5 2 years ago
Malinowski me parece sin duda uno de los mejores etnografos de la historia, ya fuera por razones accidentales, (la antropologia acaso no es eso?) logro hacer un excelente trabajo de campo, pero claro, su diario nos dejo conocer las cosas que atraviesan al investigador, subjetividad que nos habia sido arrebatada por la ciencia en su afan objetivista, y que, gracias entre otros a él, estamos recuperando....alguien sabe si esta este documental en español? no entiendo muy bien....Gracias!
IsobelAmor 2 years ago
Thank you for this film.
inferno0020 2 years ago
Hooray for anthropology ! :P
jhvirring 3 years ago 9
wow this videois so kool but i only found it causei typed in my name amber malinowski
awesome
rewindingmylife 3 years ago
Many American anthropologists, especially feminists (who currently hijacked anthropology department), refused to use Malinowski's method because they call him a "racist" and "sexist" who impose "white men's science" to the "primitive societies".
As an anthropology student, I am very disappointed in current American anthropologists who only care about political interest and terminology rather than studying humankind.
inferno0020 3 years ago
Yes, I agree it's a shame. Malinowski's professional work in the Trobriands showed his readers that people in so-called 'primitive societies' were exactly like people in the West insofar as they were complex and self-interested. In doing so he de-exoticized the other while showing that much of what we took for granted as 'natural' was socially constructed. The unfortunate diatribes in his diaries, never meant to be published, have to be understood as acts of catharsis during stressful fieldwork.
LadyPuddleton 2 years ago 22
Above comment meant for inferno0020,
LadyPuddleton 2 years ago
Thank you LadyPuddleton
inferno0020 2 years ago
You're welcome. I've done eight terms of fieldwork in places most people in North America or Europe would regard as 'exotic' and I know how stressful and frustrating this kind of work can be. Note that living in one place for some time is a completely different kind of experience to 'travelling'. Like most other anthropologists I know with this kind of experience I'm prepared to cut Malinowski a little slack for what he wrote in his diaries, viewing it as letting off steam.
LadyPuddleton 2 years ago 4
@LadyPuddleton
Congratulations, you were able to do fieldwork in interesting places, an experience that anthropologists from countries of the "Third World" couldn't even dream doing.
I'm from Argentina.
desfondo 1 year ago
Queer.
DaveO15 2 years ago
bueno malinowski es todo un hito en la antropologia. eso de que escribia en su diario cosas que sentia, es normal, ya que el era una persona con una cosntruccion mental de su propia cultura y jusgaba segun eso. a las finale stodos los antropologos jusgamos asi, segun nuestra vision, pero lo que nos hace cientificos es que nos logramos despojar de eso para poder explicar.
Milichay 3 years ago
"pero lo que nos hace cientificos es que nos logramos despojar de eso para poder explicar." pff si malinowkski nunca lo logró realmente, tú crees que tú sí?
whateva1983 2 years ago
EGOTISTICAL NEANDERTHALS
zohar5150 3 years ago
NEANDETHALS
zohar5150 3 years ago
Thanks for the movie. Im from Belgrade universety, and we have watch these movie on some class at first year.
DanielaVT500 3 years ago 3
Verdaderamente q esta brutal el hecho q frente a mundo el presenta esa cultura de una manera aceptable y en su diario el se desahogaba por decirlo asi y hablaba muy mal de ellos..era como sacar todo lo mal que se sentia...
nilva27 3 years ago
Malinowski single handedly invented fieldwork as we know it today. A great story.
EagerBoy59 3 years ago
B.M. wanted to disprove S. Freuds "anal Eroticism" theory. When, he said he found none in these people it was so reported to Sigmund who replied "what, dont they have assholes!?"
hypnotstcollector 3 years ago 4
Thank you
Anthro' student, BGU
IC4nia 3 years ago
Yo creo que está bien documentado; tiene entrevistas con Adam Kuper, por ejemplo, y además ubica la obra de Malinowski en el contexto de un debate teórico.
ultravioletta1983 3 years ago
Excelent! can u tell me how I can download it? Is it at BBC's?
tracksomething 3 years ago
fantastic series, Thanks.
bluedingoe 3 years ago
very interesting!
enricat112 4 years ago
i am an anthropology major and this movie is kick ass! -thanks guy
slinkyman2tall 4 years ago
Pretty useful stuff, thanks ever so much!
kashikosa 4 years ago
Thank you for posting this. Excellent program.
kazsimir 4 years ago