Bruson is, of course, amazing. As with all truly great singers, what he could always do well, he still does well at 70. The line, leagto and way with the language are incomparable, and do not exist on this level among singers 30 years younger. Fleming does what she can, but this is Verdi Light. Quite nice actually, but not really great. She would probably sound somewhat better as Violetta Valery if the Germont were Thomas Hampson, but in this company - well, it's a bit embarasssing, isn't it?
Bravo Bruson. Not bad for 70. Is it me or does Fleming sing very much in her head? Bruson sings with much more appoggio, which is why his voice sounds more present than hers.
... but I have heard Bruson in this part some months ago in Avenches (open air), and it was , actually, really not good anymore. Perhaps a bad evening? But I felt like the acute is somehow damaged, and he has to enormously cover and push the notes to get it... He is a very great singer, though. Unforgettable.
Tengo la excelente grabacion de Renato Bruson en el papel de Giorgio Germont efectuada hace 20 años con Lucia Aliberti como Violeta Valery. Ambos junto a Peter Dvorsky dirigidos por Roberto Paternostro conduciendo la Orquesta Filarmonica de Tokyo.El paso del tiempo no ha dominado al magnifico Bruson que se crece con el tiempo.
i just can't listen to someone else sing germont. bruson just owns this role.
bachboy111 1 year ago
This breaks my heart every time I watch it. Thank you for posting.
DMBKristen41 1 year ago 4
Bruson is, of course, amazing. As with all truly great singers, what he could always do well, he still does well at 70. The line, leagto and way with the language are incomparable, and do not exist on this level among singers 30 years younger. Fleming does what she can, but this is Verdi Light. Quite nice actually, but not really great. She would probably sound somewhat better as Violetta Valery if the Germont were Thomas Hampson, but in this company - well, it's a bit embarasssing, isn't it?
assindiastignani 1 year ago
Comment removed
flouraki 2 years ago
The best Violetta and Germont! forever
PukKoleszka 2 years ago
Bravo Bruson. Not bad for 70. Is it me or does Fleming sing very much in her head? Bruson sings with much more appoggio, which is why his voice sounds more present than hers.
trem0lo 2 years ago
Bruson was born in 1934. In this videos he was 72 years hold and his is the greatest GIORGIO GERMONT!!!!!!!!!!!!!
pavarottithebest 2 years ago
In Los Angeles
operafan85 2 years ago
where was this performance?
zongorista 2 years ago
grande bruson!!!!
nonostante la sua età mantiene la freschezza e il legato che manca a tanti cantanti molto più giovani di lui!!!!
MuSicSoprano85 3 years ago
This is mesmorizing. Her voice makes me melt and i feel that she's very "dramatically efficient." What more could you want from a Violetta?
singer19862008 3 years ago
I've never heard a soprano grunt like that before a high note. 0:55
frankinside 3 years ago
Is it positive or negative?
aurorixix 3 years ago
I don't know. It's kind of funny.
frankinside 3 years ago
You could have taught her some style, Renato!!!
viafilodrammatici 3 years ago
Incredible! Bruson is 72 (he was born in 1936) and still singing.
operafan85 3 years ago
... but I have heard Bruson in this part some months ago in Avenches (open air), and it was , actually, really not good anymore. Perhaps a bad evening? But I felt like the acute is somehow damaged, and he has to enormously cover and push the notes to get it... He is a very great singer, though. Unforgettable.
francescobi 3 years ago
I don't get it... I really don't get it. Callas didn't do half this circus and she was WAY MORE dramatically efficient than this, well, person.
barleggero 3 years ago
how old is Bruson? he´s still great!!
corellilover 3 years ago
Bruson is 74...... and he is great
pavarottithebest 3 years ago
Renato Bruson and Leo Nucci are marvels of longevity. Amazing.
BTW - did Renato (Bruson) and Renata (Scotto) ever perform together. I Due Renati!!
mjmacmtenor 3 years ago
Many times. They are together for instance in Riccardo Muti's Traviata studio recording for EMI (1981) in which Alfredo is Maestro Kraus
asisecanta 3 years ago
Tengo la excelente grabacion de Renato Bruson en el papel de Giorgio Germont efectuada hace 20 años con Lucia Aliberti como Violeta Valery. Ambos junto a Peter Dvorsky dirigidos por Roberto Paternostro conduciendo la Orquesta Filarmonica de Tokyo.El paso del tiempo no ha dominado al magnifico Bruson que se crece con el tiempo.
jorgepoveda 3 years ago