I first want to compliment you on the overall performance because it was superb. secondly, I am learning this piece and I just have trouble with that middle section! when the tempo changes to allegro it just gives me such a hard time! Do you have any suggestions on how I should practice it? Oh and for some of those chords I cannot reach all of the notes . Thank you!
Oh, wow... I heard the song once in a film and I didn't know what the song was called and now I know and I'm so happy. The song is great and the performance as well. Again, WOW!!!
Milos : Heartbreakingly beautiful! I shed a tear listening to this. Everything is so beautifully measured and poetically placed. There is a simple truth here.
I like your sensitivity. but I think taking a bit less freedom with tempo might be better because I see this music as a very still (as in not moving) picture that has a introverted sadness. this is from 1998. have you played it recently?
merci pour cette interpretation, jouée avec grande sensibilité, et délicatesse j'apprécie vraiment et vous écoute souvent .......... continuez à nous faire plaisir.
merci pour cette interpretation, jouée avec grande sensibilité, et délicatesse j'apprécie vraiment et vous écoute souvent .......... continuez à nous faire plaisir.
i've been working on this song for a month , and on my birthday ( 18th may) i'm going to play it at the school concert. hope to do even a cent of what you did ! congratulations from italy
i love this piece. i had the sheet music for it, until my brother went overseas and took the music with him. i would like to learn it. could anyone tell me how to download this sheet music for free?
Overall a gorgeous adaptation. However I didn't particularly like the way you played the "middle" section. The appegiated diminished chords I found happened too quickly for my liking. But that's just my own thoughts...
Yes, I can agree partially about that. After 12 years I am sure that "quick" will have different meaning but 12 years ago- I felt perfect about that. I am sure that you will understand what am I talking about :-)
@nick69rose yup absolutely with you there. It's nice to hear his interpretation of this part anyway. I didn't find it particularly bad, but he didnt put enough stress on it imho. Those clear chords are a release from the depressive emotions suggested from the first part, maybe one shouldn't just rush it but let the audience dream for just a millisecond there before the theme returns to its dark atmosphere again.
you are very musical.. i love your interpretation in terms of how you make it very personal, especially the inner sound that you brought out to us in the transition part, i wouldn't notice how beautiful the melody is
You are the ONLY pianist (aside from me, apparently) who plays the rising arpeggios at the end of the middle section correctly--as eighth notes. Every one else (including his excellency, the great Sviatoslav Richter) suddenly transforms them to quarter notes! Listen to the other recordings on YouTube and you will hear it. Why do they do that?
I am the italian translator of the american book 'Balanchine's Tchaikovsky': I know very well Tchaikovsky's music, and life; so I can deeply appreciate your musical approach. Thank you.
Very nice performance! I love how you brought out the melody in the left hand. Especially in the second part when the two melodies of right and left hand come together, you still make them both come out. A real joy for listening! Thank you.
Actually I'm playing this one as well and I really liked what you did with it but I think the major part (Allegro giocoso) should sound a bit more like a hymn... Well, my playing is not half as good as yours, so it's just a jealous girl's attempt to feel better^^
Don't try to play chords there. Just understand the melody and try to understand that those chords are integrated into that melody. If you feel and know how to play that melody the way you want, the chords will be fine as well...
Very, very beautiful - thank you for posting. Your playing is sensitive, imaginative and lyrical, and you perform this piece with a lovely simplicity.
I first want to compliment you on the overall performance because it was superb. secondly, I am learning this piece and I just have trouble with that middle section! when the tempo changes to allegro it just gives me such a hard time! Do you have any suggestions on how I should practice it? Oh and for some of those chords I cannot reach all of the notes . Thank you!
emildudetei79 3 months ago
GOOD
petrz32 9 months ago
Happy Holidays :)
cuoylyf 10 months ago
This is truly magical, bravo Milos!
jaleksandra 1 year ago
HAPPY 2011 Milos!!
cuoylyf 1 year ago
Saludos!
IsisSlovenska 1 year ago
Merry Christmas and A Happy New Year :)
Love Isis
IsisSlovenska 1 year ago
@IsisSlovenska lol happy new year 2012 ;) xD
MrDannypoodle 1 month ago
Ajd kad svi nesto komentarisu i traze zamerke i ja da se prikljucim:
moja jedina primjedba je na frizuru, sve ostalo je fenomenalno :))
arsencarkic 1 year ago 2
@arsencarkic
... mogao si jos dodatnih 12 godina da sacekas da bi mi to rekao :))))))
Hvala druze moj. Pozdravljam te.
mihajmi 1 year ago
Love your play!!! blessings and much love
cuoylyf 1 year ago
Great to watch the original performance of Isis' wonderful video. Thank you very much
fairlytaleofnewyork 1 year ago
Bravos to you!
OldRabit 1 year ago
awesome
carlogiove63 1 year ago
A lovely and convincing interpretation. Well done.
orionedwin 1 year ago
Beautifully played....... Terry UK
terryclary 1 year ago
LOVE!
criticism1000 1 year ago
@criticism1000 yes LOVE !!!!
cogermax91 1 year ago
Hermosa interpretación
AndresGabrielPal 1 year ago
Beautifully played.
You are a true musician.
PhillipLWilcher 1 year ago
COOL!!!!!!!
Poljub19 1 year ago
FAVOLOUS!!!!!
cuoylyf 1 year ago 3
Best thing ever heard in my life. And the most emotional interpretations
Thank you
TheToinesBand 1 year ago
GREAT GREAT GREAT!!!!
geraldinechaplin1 1 year ago
Oh, wow... I heard the song once in a film and I didn't know what the song was called and now I know and I'm so happy. The song is great and the performance as well. Again, WOW!!!
jody93 1 year ago
COOL!!
InterBrian 1 year ago
I've seen the work of cuoylyf, really beautiful!
ELPIANYSTA 1 year ago
BRAVO!
RomanVonEckstein 1 year ago
AWESOME!!!!!!
criticism1000 1 year ago
Love Isis
cuoylyf 1 year ago
Beautiful...I found this piece today and worked on it for hours. You are inspirational!
TheKeenanBoy 1 year ago
Very beautiful and it touches my heart!
pcleo123 1 year ago
Awesome!!
Portogallo3008 1 year ago
Milos : Heartbreakingly beautiful! I shed a tear listening to this. Everything is so beautifully measured and poetically placed. There is a simple truth here.
Thank you for your eloquence. Bless you!
PhillipLWilcher 1 year ago
It is so wonderful!
OldRabit 1 year ago
Cool!!
Astrid8002 1 year ago
Hermoso
AndresGabrielPal 1 year ago
heavently played !
dzeljpiano 1 year ago
Played beautifully........ Terry UK
terryclary 1 year ago
very beautiful!!!
clarawieck100 1 year ago
GREAT!!!!
IsisSlovenska 1 year ago
good song + good pianist = good performance :)
ngonguyen123 1 year ago
I like your sensitivity. but I think taking a bit less freedom with tempo might be better because I see this music as a very still (as in not moving) picture that has a introverted sadness. this is from 1998. have you played it recently?
charmingemily 1 year ago
@charmingemily
Well, that's the beauty of subjectivity :-)
We all hear different "things" but anyway, thank you for commenting. I really appreciate your sincerity.
And no- I haven't play that recently but I will of course. I'm sure that it will sound different but not fundamentally.
All the best,
M.
mihajmi 1 year ago
very beautiful
mitaibiru 1 year ago
Beautiful, how sensitive and yet dynamic. As i feel Tchaikovsky. Thank you!
Swedchap 1 year ago
@Swedchap
No- thank you for listening and spending some of your time here...
I appreciate that.
mihajmi 1 year ago
you're very aware of the audience. great playing though
willashland 1 year ago
merci pour cette interpretation, jouée avec grande sensibilité, et délicatesse j'apprécie vraiment et vous écoute souvent .......... continuez à nous faire plaisir.
Milane45 1 year ago
merci pour cette interpretation, jouée avec grande sensibilité, et délicatesse j'apprécie vraiment et vous écoute souvent .......... continuez à nous faire plaisir.
Milane45 1 year ago
@Milane45
Merci beaucoup. Merci pour votre commentaire. :-)
mihajmi 1 year ago
i've been working on this song for a month , and on my birthday ( 18th may) i'm going to play it at the school concert. hope to do even a cent of what you did ! congratulations from italy
KeyboarderGio 1 year ago
Search google for 'imslp'
ethositachi 1 year ago
sooo charming! love it!
Hsun1989 1 year ago
i love this piece. i had the sheet music for it, until my brother went overseas and took the music with him. i would like to learn it. could anyone tell me how to download this sheet music for free?
thanks.
jwrathall 1 year ago
I just love the first two measures of this song. I don't fully understand why, but the accent sounds so profound on beat two of those meauses.
anzioa 2 years ago
one of the best interpretation i've heard so far, especially the handling in the change of tones...keep up the good work!=D
TheMCjai1991 2 years ago
Thank you very much.
mihajmi 2 years ago
it s wonderful listen to your playing. Could i have a free sheet music for my daughter??? thanks in advance
orchidea2008 2 years ago
I want to send you a link but I can't because you have "friend lock"
Thanks for comment
mihajmi 2 years ago
my old dance school had a dance choreographed to this song and its it is such a beautiful song
howbeautifultherain 2 years ago
im playing it and i just wanted to hear how it sounds when it is played well- ty it was good :)
ultramalfunction999 2 years ago
Thank you. :-)
mihajmi 2 years ago
Overall a gorgeous adaptation. However I didn't particularly like the way you played the "middle" section. The appegiated diminished chords I found happened too quickly for my liking. But that's just my own thoughts...
nick69rose 2 years ago 7
Thank you. I appreciate your sincerity.
mihajmi 2 years ago
@nick69rose
Firstly, thank you for comment.
Yes, I can agree partially about that. After 12 years I am sure that "quick" will have different meaning but 12 years ago- I felt perfect about that. I am sure that you will understand what am I talking about :-)
Thank you again and all the best.
M.
mihajmi 1 year ago
@nick69rose yup absolutely with you there. It's nice to hear his interpretation of this part anyway. I didn't find it particularly bad, but he didnt put enough stress on it imho. Those clear chords are a release from the depressive emotions suggested from the first part, maybe one shouldn't just rush it but let the audience dream for just a millisecond there before the theme returns to its dark atmosphere again.
tsavolde 6 months ago
Ovo je mnogo lepo odsvirano, tako osecajno i sa dinamikom; milina za slusanje. Svaka cast.
goggie018 2 years ago
beautiful voicing in both hands! The spirit of Tchaikovsky is in you. Bravo!
bassoostenuto1 2 years ago
I LOVE it !! It's God's music =) ! Congratulations !
lepianiste36 2 years ago
you are very musical.. i love your interpretation in terms of how you make it very personal, especially the inner sound that you brought out to us in the transition part, i wouldn't notice how beautiful the melody is
sesukaku1 2 years ago
You are the ONLY pianist (aside from me, apparently) who plays the rising arpeggios at the end of the middle section correctly--as eighth notes. Every one else (including his excellency, the great Sviatoslav Richter) suddenly transforms them to quarter notes! Listen to the other recordings on YouTube and you will hear it. Why do they do that?
scooterbarf 2 years ago
nice
edopiano88 2 years ago
Really nice of you. Thank you!
mihajmi 2 years ago
I am the italian translator of the american book 'Balanchine's Tchaikovsky': I know very well Tchaikovsky's music, and life; so I can deeply appreciate your musical approach. Thank you.
AIEOK 2 years ago
thank you!!!!!
Haroldfg23 2 years ago
You welcome ... :)
mihajmi 2 years ago
touched by the emotional performance. Love Tchaikovsky's great music..
MemoryCarrier 2 years ago
Thank you for commenting. Glad you like it...
mihajmi 2 years ago
Very sensitive and delicate: in the 2nd part You have touched the inner nevrotic and obsessive 'coté' of the russian composer. All my compliments
AIEOK 2 years ago
Thank you!
mihajmi 2 years ago
@AIEOK
Wow! Thank you very much. That was one of the ideas actually.
mihajmi 1 year ago
Very nice performance! I love how you brought out the melody in the left hand. Especially in the second part when the two melodies of right and left hand come together, you still make them both come out. A real joy for listening! Thank you.
roelvermeulen1 2 years ago 3
Really nice of you. Thank you.
I am glad you like.
mihajmi 2 years ago
@roelvermeulen1
Thank you. I really like that part too. So many mixed emotions...
mihajmi 1 year ago
@roelvermeulen1
Thank you very very much. I don't know what to say... I'm flattered
mihajmi 1 year ago
And also what's with the excessive rubato? It's not a Chopin piece!
ttt8699 2 years ago
Excessive rubato is only for Chopin. I always forget that. Thank you for reminding me.
;-)
mihajmi 2 years ago
Waaay too fast!
ttt8699 2 years ago 2
is soooo beautifull!!!
i hope i can play something near it someday ^^
diegowsanchez 2 years ago
Thank you. You will. Just play music.
mihajmi 2 years ago
Very nice. I just digitally recorded my Van Cliburn LP with this piece, and this still sounds fantastic.
the2012report 2 years ago
Thanks. It was 1998 - VHS only :-)
mihajmi 2 years ago
complimenti, grande sensibilità nel fraseggio, bellissima questa barcarolle...
mohenj 2 years ago
Grazie mille :-)
mihajmi 2 years ago
It was really good! And unlike some other pianists you emphasize on music and melody which is very important!!!
tolismanolo 2 years ago
Thank you my friend :-)
That is a point - music is important.
mihajmi 2 years ago
This is Tchaikovsky competition I think. I know by the lists that you don't win, but.. why??
ipvac1 2 years ago
It is. It was 1998. Thanks for commenting ;-)
mihajmi 2 years ago
Best interpretation I've heard. So light and beautiful!
Panamalynne 2 years ago 4
Very kind of you. Thank you.
mihajmi 2 years ago
@Panamalynne
Thank you very much. Very nice of you.
mihajmi 1 year ago
Actually I'm playing this one as well and I really liked what you did with it but I think the major part (Allegro giocoso) should sound a bit more like a hymn... Well, my playing is not half as good as yours, so it's just a jealous girl's attempt to feel better^^
Buschkopp 2 years ago
There is no good or bad playing. Just show me what you feel and if you can do that- it is the right way of playing.
But thank you jealous girl ;-) and please, don't be... :*
mihajmi 2 years ago
i really liked how u played. im trying to learn this now.
can u give me any advise with the fast part with all those chords. thnx
cbinasoy 2 years ago
good job i really like ur sound, im trying to learn this right now lol
anyadvice for the fast part with all those chords thnx.
cbinasoy 2 years ago
Don't try to play chords there. Just understand the melody and try to understand that those chords are integrated into that melody. If you feel and know how to play that melody the way you want, the chords will be fine as well...
mihajmi 2 years ago
This is my favorite classical piece.
JazzBassDude 2 years ago
:D
:)
=)
=P
ll19980408 2 years ago
very nice! ilike it a lot, bravo!
klausknulp 2 years ago
Thank you. Hope you like the rest... ;-)
mihajmi 2 years ago
very good performance. When the major part starts, it's not boring at all, like it is often with other interpreters.
julienbencze 3 years ago
Nice performance :P:P:P:P
Rhesusftw 3 years ago
excelent,thanks
polescalante 3 years ago
Bad recording, sound not clear.
ilr61 3 years ago
I am sorry for that - they gave me only VHS since it was 1998. (there wasn't DVD that year) so the final result is - your post...
mihajmi 3 years ago
i agree
ll19980408 2 years ago
Excellent, very sensitive playing. This piece is decevingly not easy to play
canardroti 3 years ago
that was a beautiful performance
bomberchicken 3 years ago
Thanks.
mihajmi 3 years ago
Very, very beautiful - thank you for posting. Your playing is sensitive, imaginative and lyrical, and you perform this piece with a lovely simplicity.
dpslm 3 years ago
Thank you. I'm glad you like.
mihajmi 3 years ago
please, THIS IS TCHAIKOVSKY COMPETITION???????
perdipe 3 years ago
Of course it is. :-)
Why?
mihajmi 3 years ago
I can't understand as a pianist at this technical level failed to win Mr matsuev...
perdipe 3 years ago
I was only at I stage...
... and kicked after that. :-)
mihajmi 3 years ago
By mistake I erased your last comment. Sorry. 2 many coctails for this evening did it :-)
Glad to have you as a friend. Don't be suprised about the results. I am not. Better- I don't care. I play because I like to play and that's all ;-)
mihajmi 3 years ago
kicked. yes it s so wrong. you are beautiful pianistt.
chad410 3 years ago
Thank you.
mihajmi 3 years ago