CNN/YOUTUBE Republican debate q: Military Commissions Act

[Salladsdressing]

Great question!!! Hope you get on the debate!

[thebigbossnahhh]

Adolf Hitler probably tried to justify the Enabling Act as well.

But will the Americans react the same way as the German people and submit?

[JustThisGuyYaKnow]

Tools in the war on terror have already been shown to be the wrong tools. W started tapping phones months before 911. Didn't help did it?

[anonjay]

ECHELON... 'unwarranted' phone tapping has been going on since at least the 70s.

"But will the Americans react the same way as the German people and submit?" not submit, but like the germans actually did, we will embrace it.

not just americans, but europeans as well..

Q: what country do you think has the biggest video surveillance culture?

A: The UK

[zombo611]

If you aggree to this tell to reps to Support the American Freedom Agenda Act "restore the Constitution's checks and balances and protections against government abuses.."

Sponsored by Congressman Ron Paul!

[TheLastKeeper]

Hmmm, smells an awful lot like Rome...

[thatoneguyagain]

Hmm, I belive it is somewhat necessary but only letting a single person decide such a thing is a bad decision. Possibly a committee of somesort can define who is a foe and who is an ally would be the best way to go. Though this war on terror seems a bit overblown and inflated much more than what it actually is.

[xraptor10]

Wanna Go to camp?

Bush 08!

or

You could join "The Boycott"

The easiest thing you'll never do.

Its simple, on 4- 20- 2008, don't do anything.

Don't go to work, don't buy anything, just stay home.

check my page, and crappy video for more info.

[wakeboard77]

Unfortunately, they probably will never get to this question. They'll be addressing keeping guns legal, bringing prayer back to school, making abortion illegal, killing the troops, further bankrupting the country, pro-invasion of Iran........you know all the things that continue to send our country backwards.

[Pleblian]

You can call me crazy but mark my words, six months form the 2008 election bush will call for MARSHAL LAW.

[kebon]

Pleblian, I guess as long the winning card is retained by Hillary or Giuliani, or indeed any other except for Kucinich/Paul/Gravel, Bush would not be instructed to call Marshall Law before 08 elections.

But it won't be a great surprise if he is so instructed.

[Pleblian]

keborn, I agree with you, but it's not the winning cards they have in their hand, it's the stacked cards they play against the people. The whole electral sytem is riged and people are fed up with it, there's going to be a passive revolt after the primary which will be kept in check by law enforcement. This will start a chain reaction that will lead into an outrite revote.

[Pleblian]

I'm not psychic and I'm not eceptionally

intelligent I'm just doing the math.

My friends used to make fun of my political predictions which I have been making since 98 where I have been right on ever count, they don't laugh anymore.

I don't know what it is I'm just good at solving political trajectories.

[kebon]

I see, Pleblian, so you're actually referring to people becoming restless... good reason for Marshall Law to suppress a Revolution by "homegrown homeland terr'rists"... you might be not far off the mark. Afterall, there does seem to be an air of freedom, just a breeze perhaps, but it could gain wind.

[RedH0Tmama]

Unfortunately all that is required is a yes/no answer - how about a WHY?

[desire4liberation]

One day, some of us will be sitting in a FEMA camp because of H.R. 1955. (Thought Crimes) derrived from the individuals internet correspondance.

FEMA will have a "press conference" explaining to the tv sheeple that everthing is going well.

Welcome to New World Order!

watch EndGame by alex jones

[Brawk]

It all reminds me too much of pre WW 2, circa 1935 Germany.

[orki1960]

of course the pussy-whipped congress will allow the shrub all the constitional violations he wants to do.

[Krealix]

i would love for ron paul to get elected, but the government would just kill him like they did kennedy

[kebon]

Latest Ron Paul speech - Iowa Oct 27 - in 3 parts:

watch?v=dCc37TiYaQU

He's getting better without mainstreaming his message in any way or manner.

He's one of a kind.

[kebon]

...and from the same Iowa speech, Ron Paul speaks about the need to end the war on drugs: watch?v=aC9nyPaVPXA

[InfoJunkieHolland]

Hey DF, isn't Groton near a big nuclear sub base?

I fucking looove subs. They rocketh.

[MBRHIndustries]

if this is going to the republicans, I'm gonna take a shot in the dark and guess that you're going to hear more yeas than neas.

[6782485]

Excellent question

[DKfansown]

i bet mit romney is going to argue yes.

[PGAJAMIE411]

HR 1955 is a new piece of legislation already half way through Congress. If it is passed and signed into law by the Nazi Bush, then it is the end of America and the freedoms that we enjoy. Check it out. Google HR 1955. It will be a crime to "think." For the vast majority of you, you won't have to worry as you don't think anyway.

[ddrmegamixer]

The way I see it it's only terrorism when they are not doing the terrorising. Depends on which side of the line you are on.

[projectdurden]

I think most Americans probably think its ok to detain suspected terrorists, however, the terrorists are soon not going to be extremists, but infact, constitutionalists.

[tyrbolo]

My advice...

Make some Art and don't forget the barbs.

The one thing this current group cannot

defend themselves against is laughter,

FEMA couldn't wipe their own ass even if

they had an instruction book...LOL

[wizardswisdum]

The internment camps are already being built. Where? Where else. Texas.

[InfoJunkieHolland]

Necessary? Let me tell you what's necessary;

a little human fucking decency. That's necessary. All this talk of torture like it's a legal institution makes me SICK.

Empathy for all, I would waste the one granted wish one it.

[scooter952]

four(ish) words: Stephen Colbert in '08!

[DKfansown]

aint that the truthiness.

[crazycatfguy]

Thanks for the tip about it being on Google video. There was no way in hell it was going to play anywhere in redneck land where I live.

[Beadbud5000]

Hallalueia! Einstein IS truely a genieous and so are you my friend!

LET"S ALL DO IT!

[brtndr98]

Good question. I know what Ron Paul's answer will be. "No" (That is if they give him a chance to answer the question?) As for the other candidates "Yes"

And ya'h know Giuliani will use the false flag terrorist attacks of 9/11, and his image as the hero of 9/11. To pull on the heart strings of all those brainwashed fake conservatives. Who believe in giving up their liberties and inalienable human rights, to fight the war against the government controlled CIA tool Alqaeda. You just watch.

[paralleldivergence]

Of course it is.

How else can you lock up large groups of the population without warrant nor provocation nor any good reason what-so-ever?

Those FEMA civilian internment camps aren't going to fill themselves you know.

[SuperAtheist]

NO, but

it is a necessary tool in the war on liberty!

[Beadbud5000]

Is the war on Liberty in Iraq? No Iran? No Internal American government? Yes. Look for me in an interment camp...

[SuperAtheist]

the bush war on liberty is world wide.

I think bush even wants to stomp out the illusion of freedom.

the bush administration believes the u.s. government owns the world and every one in it.

let's take bush to school and give him an attitude adjustment!

Ron Paul for president 2008!

[scooter952]

War! huh! what is it good for? absolutely NOTHING!

[madwebb]

Say it again

[Spective10]

My question: On 9/11, we lost approximately 3K people. The Terrorist did fatal harm to approximately 0.001% of the U.S. population on 9/11. In contrast, the passed legislation (e.g. USA Patriot Act I&II, Military Commissions Act, and secretive presidential signing statements) subverts the U.S. Constitution, which affects 100% of us. Who poses the GREATER risk to 100% of Americans: Foreign terrorists or profiteering U.S. politicians bent on drastically changing our Constitution and liberties?

[manyonerise]

NO, not necessary! If the normal court system isn't effective or good enough for our government to use against terrorism suspects, then it isn't good or effective enough to be used against ANY criminal suspects at all and should be dismantled. IF the government succeeds with this, eventually your everyday local police will be able to do the same to you for any reason they deem suspicious. I guarentee IT! Good work Davis! Thank you for distinctly asking this important question.

[ZoeyMay]

I completely agree

[wisdomknight777]

Is it me or do I hear the "Imperial March' sound from Star Wars

[visioninverse]

:) lol

[ZoeyMay]

awesome question, and i don't think the military commissions act is right

[ARUaruTANkenNAInaiBA]

neither is t.w.a.t.!

davis, keep it up man. excellent ideas coming out of your channel.

[oDennisKucinich2008o]

Smart Question.

[ehhjeep]

Answer to your question HELL NO.

[ARUaruTANkenNAInaiBA]

that is the only right answer!

[libassbug]

Good question.

[CitizenWorm]

that's a damn good question

[RonPaulClips]

Great video, as always!

No, it's not! It's just another reason we need RP

Ron Paul has been BANNED from "RedState". We just posted the coverage of it from Tucker/MSNBC