Jay Chou - Secret - Travelling 20 years / 周杰倫 不能說的秘密 - 去20年前

[tinglisuan]

i smile when you press the last key.... wrong key duh...

[taeyeonwong]

Sorry to say this, but, this piece is too difficult for you. You need to get your technique up before you can play this !

[kimikimch]

how long did it take you to learn how to play the piano so amazingly? :D

[charylyn7000]

dont just play with your fingers.. :) play with a heart.. :)

[Trashme23]

The tempo is off. you sped off during parts where u were btr. u should keep a stable tempo.

[GuitarBoyZ100]

1:42 last note fail?

[shukishukshukable]

@GuitarBoyZ100 ... it says "The last note is deliberately wrong to give it the KARLNG888 originality stamp."

[TheCheesyCheesus]

lmao last wrong intended my ass. its obvious he was searching for the key and hit the wrong one, the entire performance was bad enough but to make such an obvious lie really destroys his reputation

[xDeadDreamz]

Awww...

This is the worst of you covers I think.

Try to play it slowly and with emotion ! ;)

[Sukaitora]

cant feel the emotions of the secret.. :/ ... ur fingers' emotions is like killing... not time traveling..

[cb95331233]

唔夠熟阿,練多d啦 加油*v*

[z258123]

開頭快之麻...後面慢到x_x

無啦啦快無啦啦慢!!!

[superyesung20]

he pressed so hard.. out of emotion -_- same until the end..

[mandy1122879]

I also laughed at last =.=

[KSTeong]

shit..wasted my 2 mins to watch this

[simpatic14]

like your stamp :D

[asiankeeg]

why are you playing so FAST???!!!

[ahhhhhDE]

@asiankeeg isn't the answer obvious. the pianist wants to go back into time!

[asiankeeg]

@ahhhhhDE isn't it obvious time travels impossible? haha jk. he's rushing it like the pianos going to run away:P

[noobcakesltd]

so can you actually travel time? :P

[InnocentOracle]

There are too many obvius mistakes and your tempo is too inconsistant. Last note...

[cheryllboberyll]

WHY ARE YOU PLAYING SO FAST?!!??!?!?!?!?!?!?!!

[Lestrangel]

Don't play at such a fast tempo in the beginning, as you screwed up from 0:40 onwards. And sorry to say, you sucks. Go learn the right notes first, then maintain tempo for whole song, then increase tempo.

[TalesIncs]

@Lestrangel Giving criticism and advice for improvement is one thing. Saying YOU SUCK(s?), is uncalled for. Can you pls play something first instead of creating a youtube account just to say you sucks, then you can say "you suck(s???)".

[lolcabal]

its E note i think

[Atarien6]

LOL you hit a D at the end :P

[rlf2ex]

@Atarien6 ya, it should be an E

[zzfoggyzz]

needs more practice : D

[Ralt1c]

You should change the name of your video. It contains major spoilers for those who still want to see the movie.

[TheJudgeXD]

awwe, nice piano you got there [:

keep practicing though.

[ZatakiYuki]

this is 3years ago, he probably mastered it by then

...and went back in time...

[ticklish1986]

LOVE dun HATE....

[ticklish1986]

if his version is a failure then mine would be a epic failure!

[Bruce868686]

你回不去了XD

[shaunld]

the last note. =D

[kulleza7290]

can you make a tutorial? :D

[merobots]

A beautiful film. A beautiful piece and a beautiful rendition.

[MultiHanhan]

He didn't fail that was really good like to see you try

[MeeYuee]

fail!!

[MoonlightSonata69]

Yes I agree, he made a few mistakes and tempo isn't balance BUT seriously fcuk all you people who say he fails or he sucks, I'm sure he hasn't master it fully, but he is doing a pretty decent job, so lay off the trigger if not post a video and show us what you got.

[ninsodsing]

Why Tempo Slowdown ?

[Shinypoopypants]

jay chou did it faster! :)

[kiikasi]

I hear a lot of mistakes and many tempo changes. Your dynamics aren't very good either. Your notes at the end are like daa daa daa daa instead of the datdatdatdat like they are supposed to be. It needs a lot of work, but you're doing good.

[wycjam]

LOLOLOLOLOLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL­LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL

nice jobb man i like it especially the last note.. :)

[AsIanRuL3S]

TOO FAST!

[6fortyam]

I may get hated for this but: I just don't feel you playing. D:

Your fingers dig into the keys without emotion. o_o

[TheYellowHalo]

@6fortyam Many people do that. But really, the people that call people on that. are probably a lot worse or in case I can confidently say your version of "Digging into the keys WITH emotion" is a song with a lot reverberation.

[6fortyam]

@TheYellowHalo

Yeah.. I use too much reverberation but I'm learning to fix that problem.

When I get time off from school assessments, I'll upload myself playing this and "Chopin Waltz (Op. 64, No. 2)"

[TheYellowHalo]

@6fortyam I definitely wont waste my time watching it. :) 

[Juggernaughty824]

@6fortyam can't blame him, he wanted to time travel further into the past...

[poyingeric]

1:41  I laugh

[R3bzx]

@poyingeric I lol'd too

[CookingCowell89]

hmm, you played but you rushed for a second, and slowed down for a second.. why did u do that? :( i know i can't play this piece either, *stil learning though* but, your tempo isnt balance :(

[ElatedScherzo]

Nice! A major pet peeve of mine is that the notes are too hard though. It's not you...that's the way jay chou plays. Tempo DOES need some working on tho.

[Sorayoushi]

Good try but like all other people that commented, I think that your tempo could use some work

[hekanealiloa]

yo you play ow you want karlng888. music isnt something has has to be played in one certain way, your touch is an expression of who you are. I can dig the changes in tempo, they kept me on my feet, and I'm okay with that

[banditzp]

lul. too slow

[SuperJinj]

Your playing tells you are not confident enough. Do not change tempo. It does not make you a Chopin. There is no rubato stated in the score. Besides, it is either fast or slow from the start and keep it at that pace. Don't make Jay Chou laugh at your playing mate.. Food for thought. ;)

[l00nylun]

@SuperJinj agreed =( changing the tempo just spoils the piece

[ellogoodbye808]

playing too fast, tempo is off you speed up then slow down then speed up then slow down made the song kinda weird

[258654fred]

Fail....tempo is inconsistent....need to work on it!!!

[BukLaoRulesYoAll]

@258654fred Why dont u make a better one...

[hkkkk]

fail

[jafeverXsze]

it's not that good as your other videos,but learn from mistakes and practise makes perfect!! +oil!!

[kcmasta911]

hahaha the last note

good playthrough though :)

[stardominic]

not too bad. the 16ths are tough. you gotta find the right fingerings. idk if you're still playing this piece because i see the date on this video lol but good job. keep it up. :]

[hojohan2003]

it is gd to record this.... so u can know ur mistake keep trying to work hard in accuracy add oil!

[Bitchtoken]

waaaah youre such a bad player sorry dude but youre not good!

[Keiess855]

I can play that fast, but sound diff though.

[LoweyLiu]

try relaxing ur fingers more eh~

nice try tho ^^

[tomheartcass]

learn the song better then upload LOL :)

[SelloHunter]

0:32 is so easy... why you got so slow there? -.-

[Disendant]

ewwwwwww bad good try though

[AznKudos]

improvement please

[MercifulAreWe]

Very good, i like this a lot, the movie was awesome in so many ways!:) Keep it up.

[xXAzNBa0Xx]

introduction too fast

the other parts too slow if u compare to the introduction

sorry but this was bad :(

[TOMOazn]

I just learned this song at the beginning of summer after school was over, and I know how to play it...just...really...slowly. I still need alot of practice...lol. But it's fun playing the song. :D

[xyq145147]

哈~！最後個個音錯得好得意~~~5熟譜點翻20年前啊~~~加­油啦！！

[nb971127]

when you started playing the 16th you slowed down DRAMATICALLY, dont play the introduction too fast

[themosthappiestgirl]

it was @0:31

[themosthappiestgirl]

@0.31 is my favourite part=D

[vietmauzzzy1]

whoa,i played it too,this is so much better!it took me probably 3 weeks with 5 hours of practice each day,and now it's been a year and even now i can't play it perfectly xD

[kyle556owns]

@vietmauzzzy1 Damn... thats alot of practice lol... D:

[kupOnut11]

Man I wish I had the skills to play this peice, maybe in another 5 years 8D

[bldude2]

It's a good thing he didn't play it perfectly, or else we would have a paradox on our hands...

[sammylilee]

haha i love how you played the last note wrong on purpose!>v<

I'm learning this song for my OMEA's, i have a while untill it starts... but this song is gonna be so tough to learn!!! How long did it take you to play the song and memorize it?

Btw GOODJOBBB!!!! I freakin loved it!!!:]]

[deGUEV]

LOL.

The last note sounded kinda funny.

[mpreidl1982]

you cannot cover your mistakes by sustain pedal. that is just wrong !!! but i like your interpratation and expression. keep up.

[csungyoung]

:] Loved this movie~~

Awesome playing!!!

Can't get enough of this song ^^

[BrackNigel]

I could see the shadow of your hand at the end, thinking if you should press the correct or wrong note .LOL . Good Video!

[johnblink]

Rhythm. You totally messed that up. And the last part of the piece.... There are missing notes in it that took the whole feel away and why did you slow down at the end? It's a weak interpretation of the score. For this piece, It's supposed to be a virtuoso piece and shows off your piano abilities but you totally ruined it. I am sorry to say this but this sucks.

[XxXxXxKOFOLAxXxXxX]

@johnblink oh really? if you think you are so smart why you do not show us your talent. Good video btw

[johnblink]

@XxXxXxKOFOLAxXxXxX maybe you can go learn some music then tell me what you think. I'm now chewing him out. Just stating facts. If you can't see that the tempo and the rhythm is off, you should go see a doctor or something. But as a musician, you are taught to listen to things and rhythm is one of them.

[gastmania933]

too many mistakes that totally mess up the rhythm, and very inconsistent speed. You really wanna travel 20 years?

[DuskMoonFlower]

Can i get the sheet music for this?

[Wolvesblood97]

isn't the last note played wrong sometimes in the movie too? I thought this was deliberate. AND KARL, you kick my ass at piano xD

[omg0what0happened]

Lol since when did not playing a song right, make it 'original'?

[gastmania933]

gotta work on the consistency of tempo. and the song doesn't flow well.

[BlankieeBlankX2]

很好听！！ hahas!! Love it!! XDXP

[Mylena82]

Hahahhahaaa :) I can play this song too now :D

so proud... but not really perfect at the ending part. still have to work on it.

And u know what? I'm still waiting for ur next video. :)

[pking199]

some part were flawless but some part is okay only

[chaktinglam]

the last key is wrong...

the tempo is not constant....

[TheEveneven]

Beautiful music and film good

You play as in a film _))

[mell1503]

you're so great! awsome.

[asiamusic]

omg :D

[JWEICJ]

Tats OMG

Check out mine 2

HOpe ya can give some advice

[setfire3]

I don't know much about piano, but isn't the way your fingers press the keys seems a bit wierld?

[secret2812]

wow.. your fingers are so strong.. hehehe.. i practised my school's piano, but... irealised that piano keys are harder to press than keyboard keys.. 8l

[chris110012]

@secret2812

Late comment! But look for a keyboard that has weighted keys!!(if anything, semi-weighted). They really help in the long run.

[JJ4ev3r]

@secret2812 And that's actually why i prefer a piano above a keyboard ^^ you really feel the piano =)

[4UXtra]

@secret2812

haha yeah it's true!

[secret2812]

@4UXtra yeah, and my fingers look.. weird and other students would laugh at me. sigh. it makes me look like i'm a REAL BEGINNER T_T

[dragoninja000]

@secret2812 have you tried playing those expensive keyboard pianos that cost over $1200

Rolands and a few Kawaii keyboards feel like a Grand.

[Tikilakaa]

This one is better than mine =(

[melmusica]

Everytime that I play this song, or attempt to play...I like to imagine that I am travelling in time~~ maybe I can meet Jay Chou (a younger version) :D

[jarry161290]

rofl xD

[jarry161290]

great.... so I upload and learn this piece for nothing sigh... oh well back to the piano I guess, errr does anyone have this version ima need it then pls thanks

[jarry161290]

Hey man its still pretty good coz not many people can play it so who gives a fuck!! 10/10 maybe just need to neaten otherwise still good

[Chibiisuke]

Tempo, Pedal, Note... Then u will play nice.. ^^

[jarry161290]

hmmmmm i think im playing a different version coz mine don't sound like this, pls tell me am I playing wrong version or what????

[asianxpuppy]

It's a different version.

The one you have is shorter and easier to play, kinda-ish.

[secret2812]

whoa dude/girl, from hearing the OST's in Secret, I think this is one of the hardest piece to play, not like 'Lu Xiao Yu' , it's a little bit easy.. So... why don't you make a video on how to play this piece.. I know many viewers would want them... : ) , piece .. , btw, you're SO LUCKY.. :D

[Mooniebarbie]

u did quite a good job.but wats wrong with the temple? at first u played really fast,then the part which got ur left hand switched and need to be fast,u slow it down,u also forgot some notes too :(

[Kawaiixxx]

this is version of the "hasty key " ..... u slow down in couple of parts... overall you played well !!! ^_^ keep up the good work....

[JessicaRox2414]

i envy u!!

i learned most of this... i cant get that whole part coming down from :49

X.x

[kithic14]

Wow, this is fast. I tried learning it after watching the movie but every time I got far enough into the piece, I'd give up cause I would want to start crying again. The movie really touched my heart.

[Rennec]

The last note made me smile. =]

[JAZsful]

need more practice..din follow the tempo~

[seannysean23]

teach me how to paly...

[dibilcik]

it's hard isn;t it?

the movie is  good indeed, my fav at the moment.

but i think it has to be played more legatto at the begging.

goof work!

[watsuwach]

ยังจะมีหน้ามาอัพอีก !

[joann87]

both thumbs up!!

[Karas033]

too fast...

[winnietheshyt]

haha last note wrong! i think u played a F?

[RichardGold8]

Oh no ppl, its the D note he played wrong , not F he played wrong! Trust me.

[khazhaexotic]

After hearing this piece it made me go back time by 1:44 min of his video cos i wan hear again hahaah!

[nickel24drums]

ya, pedals are impt

[jennyv0]

you got the last note wrong man...

and that's the biggest point of the song ahahahah

i kid

but other than that tis alrightt

[nickli1992]

that wasnt very good

[CHRISTINE18UUEN]

Every song you played was great, can't stop me from watching another song which is played by you.

Bravo!!!

Nice song too!

[speedshot0503]

and he probably played the wrong note cuz he didnt want to travel back in time

[CHRISTINE18UUEN]

LOL...quite a good comment!!!

you make me laugh=)

[vyminh]

@speedshot0503 is it really that if you can play this song perfectly (well, with the tone, the rhythm, the speed) you can travel back in time? If it's true then this song is pretty awesome to practice :X :X

Nice vid :x

[deGUEV]

@speedshot0503 LOL, oh but of course!

[MirareruNo]

@speedshot0503 LOOOOOL ikr...

[speedshot0503]

im actually learning this by ear.. :/

[ch3jko]

hf  i wont get their by 5months xD

[doraemonrox]

I suggest using the right pedal a bit more x)

[kungfoo47]

man im still workin on that song

i practice 5 min a day at skool

and i need a piano at home so i can practice more longer

:(

[ninhkhang91]

Great performance, but you kinda missed the emotion of the song as well as some keys.

Don't focus too much on the speed as i will kill your song. And you should try the pedal on the middle part of the song to give its mysterious and "secret"  feelings.

Keep up the good work.!!!

[waishudai]

lol do you mean "it will kill your song"?

[sori1004jyIsupportU]

yah it's funny oppa...

the last note....LOL

[fattyrunslow]

wow your piano sounds really nice !!

[furubarulz1996]

:D Woah.. impressive! You played it really well... I don't think you need to use pedal.. if you do, I think that it'll make the song sound really clouded and heavy. It's good enough as it is now! Well done :)

[fattyrunslow]

LOL AT ENDING NOTE

[Obenjamin0]

wow :D cool but for me i think u shuld try stepping on pedal covering up all the holes in the middle unless theres rest >.>

[scythekidd]

請問一下你彈得時候有沒有踩踏板??

[CheeHao93]

0:26 时候有

[MissWeiLun]

omg those are scary hands... but

COOL JOB! you kinda rushed on parts

but if you work hard it could be better! :D

[Mylena82]

wow. can't find words to discribe. I love this Drama ! :D

[BbYLtheoriginal]

O.o a nice attempt. bt if u dun mind comments, its a bit off timing! :X the front was fast, back was slow. :X

[KynosaurTheMighty]

Protip: When you're crossing your hands, have your right thumb on the G. This tends to make it alot easier to move onto the next part with all the spread out notes. Good video!

[bubuchahchah]

Starting was fine... and then it went a little downhill from there.

[janethpa84]

ha ha in BOGOTA 13 GRADES

[warriorore]

man.. i cant play the last part

[ichiiizen]

what's the name of this song?

[bryan2424]

Secret. or Time-Travel

[vivee123]

I am absolutely jelous of your hands.....I play piano, currently studying grade nine, but I go tstuck with small hands and short stubby fingers. ;-;

[KittyMelisa]

Theres grade 9 ?

[rachelxtlo]

in asia there're only 8 grades, in canada and america there're 10.

[SuperJinj]

Work on your pedals.. Mistakes CAN be corrected.. Good Try..=)

[celestdramashow]

can i ask u where do u get the score

[0169855887]

last note wrong...xD

[warriorore]

haha u're rite

[0169855887]

reli wrong la... noob dun - my comment

[0169855887]

E he played D...==