Dreamed a Dream Comparison

[dotbishop]

PATTI LUPONE!!!!

[ValeriiCifuenti]

Idina Menzel. Just amazing :3

[noemia7323]

eu amo a mãe da Rachel

[MegaSunnybob]

next to ruthie henshall, Elaine Page has the best version, in my opinion

[23pointy23]

I love Elaine Paige´s voice in Cats... & since I heard the versio Glee version I liked the version by Susan Boyle. Idina & Lea are so AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!! Definetely the BEST version!!!!!!!!

[tragicdeceit]

The lack of Ruthie Henshall is discouraging

[zannabarnowl]

I'm going to say Susan. Hate me if you want. It's just personal preference.

[vieattlechick]

lea's voice is kinda whiny and doesn't suit this song. i think idina's voice is more powerful and still settle enough for my ears. XP

[iWALKtheLINEx3]

Ruthie Henshall?! She gives the best performance of this song hands down.

[christoddur]

Susan Boyle, hands down

[drexel6337]

.........add Laurie Beechman to the mix and she beats all!!!

[naruto231000]

for me hands down IDINA. shes just sooooo amazing

[jaynecdavison]

Elaine Paige is too theatrical, voice weak in parts. Susan Boyle has smoother tone to her voice and obviously a great story from Britains Got Talent. Her version is great. My favorites however are Idina Menzel and Lea Michele. Making the song to be about a reunion of mother and daughter is very emotional from Glee. Idina's voice and Broadway career, Tony Award, concerts and now to TV shows her versatility. She has a great voice as does Lea Michele, who also is from New York and Broadway and can

[jumigomo]

I know what Mrs. Paige means in the story of musicals. But what about RUTHIE HENSHALL?

[lovebette]

Lea, as she is youngest and she has the naivity of the character. But I love Susan Boyle's version, too. And Idina is cool, also. Elaine Paige has way too much of strange accent for my taste.

[nettynho14]

Just Idina...

[brahmandpedigree]

I'm not judging Susan Boyle based on her looks, I swear... But I honestly don't like her singing voice either.

[marijo96cr]

Idina and Leah!!!

[ChelexBebop]

i REALLY like susan boyle's.

[hlwatt]

Idina and Lea sound young and fresh. Susan sounds rich and powerful. Not mad on Elain Paige

[thetopsinger101]

Idina and Lea. There is so much expression!

[Broadwaytheatregirl]

I think Idina and Lea because they sang the clearest and I could really get the feel of the song

[phoebe21]

Definitely Idina and Lea...I feel like there is too much vibrato in the other two...

[wispa694]

idina and lea of course! There's has the most feeling in it

[mikyfdh]

idina!!! all the way, susan too..

[mdillow31]

Susan Boyle wins by a landslide. What a voice with such great vocal range. Fantastic Susan !!

[foreverurgurl]

Lea and Idina then Susan then Elaine.

[roaringmouse100]

Susan definitely. The duet was interesting though.

[moywa1]

Susan Boyle is best. Richer sound and more melodious. She owns this song forever.

[sailette01]

Elaine's is very professional, stage ready...Lea & Idina's is dramatic but grating in the mix. Susan's is unpretentious, heartfelt and exquisite at every note with strength and heart wrenching believability.~~~/)~~~

[coloradomilehighful]

When Susan sings, I feel what she sings, I believe that she has experienced it. The others are great in there own right, but my only preference is Susan, she touches my heart, I cant say that about the others.

[TheTommyUSA]

Susan by a landslide.......although the others are very good too.

[katebien]

Idina and Lea's version!!!! oh and at 2:06 it's Lea still singing not idina

[cayodomingues]

@katebien i runned out of pictures heheheh

[LoudFast1234]

@cayodomingues nice grammer! lol u do know the correct word would be "ran" out

[mickey5387]

Susan!!!!!

[catylaloca]

first Lea&Idina, then Elaine and last Susan :D

[AlexFanDeSusanBoyle]

Susan!

[mikyfdh]

IDINA

[Sawyerfan87]

I love

Lea/Idina version the best