U cant compare instrumental music with bands like LZ , GNR, JHE... i think, its diferent kind of music, i think satriani, vai or batio, those guys are much closer too you.
If we are looking at the actual technical ability then you'd have to call Buckethead, but that isn't to say that if the techniques currently employed by guitarists such as him were commonplace in the 1960s that Jimi Hendrix couldn't have matched him, because he was quite clearly the outstanding guitarist of his generation.
If you were to compare the musical output of the two, well in my opinion you would still have to go a long way to beat some of Jimi's output.
You can discount Jimmy Page & Slash from this immediately. Self indulgent twaddle was the sum total of their output.
Now as for comparing Jimi Hendrix & Buckethead the problem I think that there is here is that guitar playing as a form has progressed significantly since the 1960s to the current day. Jimi Hendrix was a self taught player & whilst I don't know anything about Buckethead's background he is obviously a very technical player so one must assume lessons of some sort.
Yeah Buckethead had lessons from Paul Gilbert, explains his technical side. However I don't judge a guitarist by technical ability rather emotion and passion put into the music. All 5 of them are extremely passionate about their guitar playing but the one I can feel the most is Buckethead. Hendrix was obviously a god of guitar.
Gosh you guys are all so crazy! Its dumb to compare music. If you asked any good musician if they were better than "so and so" they will always reply, somewhat irritated, with something to the effect of "no I'm not any better.. He plays music his way, and I play music my way."
No one is the "best guitarist." Sure, there may be some that are better than others, but no one is the best. Everyone is creative in their own way. Like supercoolninjayo said, music is a form of art. A certain guitarist may be the best guitarist in your own opinion, because you like their style the most, but that does not mean that they're the best among every other person who has ever picked up the guitar. It's all about creativity.
the sampling is faulty. jerry garcia alone easily overmatches the sample tunes + performances on 100 songs in 1000 performances.
page & buckethead, et al friggin rox and they can take you to the Great Backstage and beyond. why try to overstate that?
if you haven't seen pretty much all the masters you got no business embarrassing yourself with an opinion. if you have seen them all, these are not gonna be your choices.
Buckethead is clearly the most technical and most skilled among these guitarists, but its hard to compare him with some1 like hendrix or page who were great guitarists in the 60s and 70s, music changes with time its like comparing metal to classic rock, but still i vote for Buckethead he is my secound favorite guitarist
Jimmy Page is probably the best guitarist out of these when it comes to writing riffs and stuff, but Buckethead is the most skilled and diverse, in my opinion.
Nice vid, but come on. You got a video of buckethead at the ending shredding his head off and improving insanely, you gave Jimmy Paige minimal credit by making him look like a nutter playing a guitar with a violin bow. If you gave all of them the opportunity to shred by themselves instead of following a song, they'd give buckethead a fair and hopefully bloody awesome challenge.
I couldn't find any vids of Page doing other solos, which I was kind of gutted about. Either way none of them can shred like Buckethead but what really counts is the emotion and passion that they all play with.
Totally agree, bucketheads control and technique is undescribably good. Wish there was some better footage of the others though to do them proper justice.
WTF??? WHY IS BUCKETHEAD HERE??? HE EVEN ISNT A GUITARIST!!! in his place should be Carlitos Santana papa!! or Kirk Hammet or Toni IommI, r many musicians in the world n u put one that even isn't a guitarist
At least obviously i vote for the greatest musician of all time SLASH!!!
hahahaha nice smatass response- buckethead is insane i vote for him. although hendrix and paige were revolutionary for their time and now even. kirk is good, but not that good. ha.
Hendrix is the man because 1. he is lefty 2. he strung his guitar, himself , to be lefty 3. he taught himself how to play 4.have you heard his songs?????
Wow just to begin a lot of different playing styles and you didn't have some of Jimi Paiges best solo's. But my vote has to go to JP His riff and solo's are great just can't beat them also everyone know's him.
Jimi Hendrix got a very close second, cause that guy did whatever came to mind, and he was so relaxed onstage, it's impossible not to like somebody with as much technique as him,
but Buckethead definitely takes my vote. Too flawless to not consider
hmm, i didn't like jimmy pages performance here at all, and slashes was mediocre, he has his moments, but mostly he is overrated, and i love the sound of bh and the feeling of hendrix, but hendrix is terribly overrated, yet, buckethead is probably the most chosen to win and as much as i would prefer to go with an underdog im gonna say bucket, if not only for those incredible hammer ons
хуита
Feuerrader999 6 months ago
U cant compare instrumental music with bands like LZ , GNR, JHE... i think, its diferent kind of music, i think satriani, vai or batio, those guys are much closer too you.
No offense i am big fan BH :)
kicek81 1 year ago
@kicek81
I'm not really Buckethead lol
Bucketheadhead 1 year ago
Comment removed
kicek81 1 year ago
@Bucketheadhead it was my mistake :)) i think u r not mad of this :))) should be " ... closer to Buckethead " :)
kicek81 1 year ago
@Bucketheadhead then why is ur account name buckethead ?
TheMahir1811 5 months ago
@TheMahir1811 because I like Buckethead
Bucketheadhead 5 months ago
Yay Sultans of Swing intro! :D fun fun
tastytasters 1 year ago
Post 2.
If we are looking at the actual technical ability then you'd have to call Buckethead, but that isn't to say that if the techniques currently employed by guitarists such as him were commonplace in the 1960s that Jimi Hendrix couldn't have matched him, because he was quite clearly the outstanding guitarist of his generation.
If you were to compare the musical output of the two, well in my opinion you would still have to go a long way to beat some of Jimi's output.
CityGov 1 year ago
Post 1.
You can discount Jimmy Page & Slash from this immediately. Self indulgent twaddle was the sum total of their output.
Now as for comparing Jimi Hendrix & Buckethead the problem I think that there is here is that guitar playing as a form has progressed significantly since the 1960s to the current day. Jimi Hendrix was a self taught player & whilst I don't know anything about Buckethead's background he is obviously a very technical player so one must assume lessons of some sort.
CityGov 1 year ago
@CityGov
Yeah Buckethead had lessons from Paul Gilbert, explains his technical side. However I don't judge a guitarist by technical ability rather emotion and passion put into the music. All 5 of them are extremely passionate about their guitar playing but the one I can feel the most is Buckethead. Hendrix was obviously a god of guitar.
Bucketheadhead 1 year ago
@Bucketheadhead for a month. He spent eight years with Pebber Brown.
Iluvbuckethead1 1 year ago
THE PEOPLE SAY: BUCKETHEAD!
guitarracustica1 1 year ago
THE PEOPLE SAY: !BUCKETHEAD!
guitarracustica1 1 year ago
Steve Vai!, Zakk Wylde and of course...BUCKETHEAD
you4guitarist 1 year ago
Gosh you guys are all so crazy! Its dumb to compare music. If you asked any good musician if they were better than "so and so" they will always reply, somewhat irritated, with something to the effect of "no I'm not any better.. He plays music his way, and I play music my way."
QuotidianHegemony 1 year ago
No one is the "best guitarist." Sure, there may be some that are better than others, but no one is the best. Everyone is creative in their own way. Like supercoolninjayo said, music is a form of art. A certain guitarist may be the best guitarist in your own opinion, because you like their style the most, but that does not mean that they're the best among every other person who has ever picked up the guitar. It's all about creativity.
swtjesus771 1 year ago
Hey guys, music is an art that you take by an opinion. There is no best.
supercoolninjayo 1 year ago
JH duh
jamalsoundninja2 1 year ago
Thats fuckin dirty but its impossible to pick a best guitarist... what do you use as criteria?
napalm 2 years ago
Bucketheadd!!! hubieras puesto el solo de jordan man , el de nothinham lace estuvo bien!
chukzeppelin 2 years ago
i just don't like buckethead at all ... and since slash's my fav ..go slash :)
megababagiga 2 years ago
buckethead
gdog0864 2 years ago
Buckethead. Always. Wins.
kergio17 2 years ago
Buckethead definetley takes this one in my opinion!!
112fsd 2 years ago
Bucky
fightinglucan 2 years ago
If you talk about emotion, one of the best can be heard in the intro to this vid :P
Knopfler, Gallgher, BB King, Buddy Guy,....
phallogan 2 years ago
Jimmy Hendrix
CallMeHaSLeS 2 years ago
buckethead
Metalhead13a 2 years ago 2
the sampling is faulty. jerry garcia alone easily overmatches the sample tunes + performances on 100 songs in 1000 performances.
page & buckethead, et al friggin rox and they can take you to the Great Backstage and beyond. why try to overstate that?
if you haven't seen pretty much all the masters you got no business embarrassing yourself with an opinion. if you have seen them all, these are not gonna be your choices.
it's called humility. look it up.
reallybigco 2 years ago
fuck off
Bucketheadhead 2 years ago
suck my balls mate and fuck off
eminemforlifenoshit 2 years ago
Think about it. Over 40 years ago Page started writing the book. The rest followed.
olpmmone 2 years ago
and what about george harrison and bb king?
SirAwsomness 2 years ago
and you know, i mean, cmon: CLAPTON????
SirAwsomness 2 years ago
Buckethead owns all except paul gilbert, jason becker an jesus
TheWhocares233 2 years ago
jesus sucks ass.
rockingowl55 2 years ago
Page.
pappeter 2 years ago
Buckethead
michnun 2 years ago
Buckethead is clearly the most technical and most skilled among these guitarists, but its hard to compare him with some1 like hendrix or page who were great guitarists in the 60s and 70s, music changes with time its like comparing metal to classic rock, but still i vote for Buckethead he is my secound favorite guitarist
mandms4life 2 years ago
Not bucketheads best solos like Jordan welcome to buckethealand
But BH FTW
Ethythebeefy 2 years ago
Buckethead!!
#He is so fucking amazing
Ethythebeefy 2 years ago
Jimmy Page is probably the best guitarist out of these when it comes to writing riffs and stuff, but Buckethead is the most skilled and diverse, in my opinion.
MrBucketBot 2 years ago
Jimi-fucking-Hendrix.
They all are absolutely awesome,though. And I'm a huge Buckethead fan, yet I must admit Hendrix is epic.
hp071174 2 years ago
Page and Buckethead.
deadithink 2 years ago
Nice vid, but come on. You got a video of buckethead at the ending shredding his head off and improving insanely, you gave Jimmy Paige minimal credit by making him look like a nutter playing a guitar with a violin bow. If you gave all of them the opportunity to shred by themselves instead of following a song, they'd give buckethead a fair and hopefully bloody awesome challenge.
Deadstar6969 2 years ago
I couldn't find any vids of Page doing other solos, which I was kind of gutted about. Either way none of them can shred like Buckethead but what really counts is the emotion and passion that they all play with.
Bucketheadhead 2 years ago
Totally agree, bucketheads control and technique is undescribably good. Wish there was some better footage of the others though to do them proper justice.
Deadstar6969 2 years ago
@Deadstar6969 hahah i thought the same thing with the violin bow rather funny though
anderson5908 1 year ago
god...its Jimi!...holy shit not Jimmy...
xTHExCHEATx 2 years ago
I know, I made the vid in a hurry.
Bucketheadhead 2 years ago
wats with the EDS-1275s
rockmanX117 2 years ago
JIMMY PAGE!!!!
LedZepGuitar 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
WTF??? WHY IS BUCKETHEAD HERE??? HE EVEN ISNT A GUITARIST!!! in his place should be Carlitos Santana papa!! or Kirk Hammet or Toni IommI, r many musicians in the world n u put one that even isn't a guitarist
At least obviously i vote for the greatest musician of all time SLASH!!!
MikeHalo080 2 years ago
Are you a moron? If Buckethead is not a guitarist then what the fuck is he?
Bucketheadhead 2 years ago
u just named 3 of the worst guitarist ever u fucking idiot, bucket head owns all those losers
OneEyedPoker 2 years ago 5
You, sir, are a moron.
Cobrevolution 2 years ago
duude please, where is zakk wylde ?? where is dimebag darell ? where is kirk hammett ??
psikoseb69 2 years ago
Wherever the fuck they are in the world? How do you expect me to know?
Bucketheadhead 2 years ago
hahahaha nice smatass response- buckethead is insane i vote for him. although hendrix and paige were revolutionary for their time and now even. kirk is good, but not that good. ha.
girlofwar2 2 years ago 3
Big B
xTiLkx 2 years ago
Page is the best!! and second slash
xxxTheRockerxxx 2 years ago
Hendrix is the man because 1. he is lefty 2. he strung his guitar, himself , to be lefty 3. he taught himself how to play 4.have you heard his songs?????
olebikdaddy 2 years ago
Jimi Hendrix cuz he´s lefty and he revoluzzed guitar playing for the guitar being a solo instrument!
Alex1710XVII 2 years ago
being a lefty doesnt have to do w/ being a good guitarist!
LedZepGuitar 2 years ago
That might be but many lefties were!
Alex1710XVII 2 years ago
absolutely buckethead :D +1
PanDeBarra 2 years ago 2
Slash <3
helveteskarl 2 years ago
They're all great..... Jimmy Page is The Master
eclipsemobilewelding 2 years ago
buckethead....OFC :D +1
pinkpuppyball 2 years ago
+1 for buckethead
lauker 2 years ago
Jimmy Page,,,,,Just watch and listen to Since Ive been loving You Live :)
ZosoPage101 2 years ago
watch Buckethead: asylum of glass, live =)
brokoli99 2 years ago
Buckethead
was the first solo from Soothsayer?
AngryMusicalSloths94 2 years ago
Whitewash
Bucketheadhead 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
SLAASHHHHH♥♥♥
favourite guitarist no contest
van halen also amazing
btn18 2 years ago
the jimi hendrix's solos aren't the bests he has.. and the same whith jimi page. but JIMI HENDRIX
dir3straits 2 years ago
Yeah but I couldn't find that many great live solos of his, but no question, he was a god of guitar.
Bucketheadhead 2 years ago
Wow just to begin a lot of different playing styles and you didn't have some of Jimi Paiges best solo's. But my vote has to go to JP His riff and solo's are great just can't beat them also everyone know's him.
icebrakerman26 2 years ago
I Think Hendrix maybe win my vote,but i liked the buckethead solo,and my vote goes to the buckethead.
lucianodsb 2 years ago
Buckethead has my vote
Bungle41582 2 years ago
buckethead
P34V3Y7 3 years ago
Buckethead
supermariobros3636 3 years ago
0:01
BUDTHEGREAT1 3 years ago
buckethead fftw!!!!!!!
11XXXShawnXXX11 3 years ago
Buckethead.
NecropolitansC02 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
slash.
mwellbass 3 years ago
buckethead
ifureadthisdie 3 years ago
Slash makes me gag, nothing but power ballads
Jimi Hendrix got a very close second, cause that guy did whatever came to mind, and he was so relaxed onstage, it's impossible not to like somebody with as much technique as him,
but Buckethead definitely takes my vote. Too flawless to not consider
SlunkLord57 3 years ago 2
AWESOME.
Buckethead FTW.
xnick01295 3 years ago
BUCKETHEAD
8uckethead 3 years ago
SLASH
o0o8ra1no0o 3 years ago
nice video my favorite are slash and buckethead
vivelequebec45 3 years ago
I would say Jimi, then right after comes buckethead
thelastalchemist 3 years ago
oh and i shared this vid with all my friends to get more voters, not many at the moment :/
TheImperialNinjA 3 years ago
hmm, i didn't like jimmy pages performance here at all, and slashes was mediocre, he has his moments, but mostly he is overrated, and i love the sound of bh and the feeling of hendrix, but hendrix is terribly overrated, yet, buckethead is probably the most chosen to win and as much as i would prefer to go with an underdog im gonna say bucket, if not only for those incredible hammer ons
TheImperialNinjA 3 years ago
I'd probably have to say Buckethead.
Then it's an all out brawl for second because they're all good.
Can I ask what's the song/name of the first video of Buckethead that you put on?
I can't seem to put my finger on which video it is.. D:
CFloBucket 3 years ago
It's Whitewash but that is the live version, the studio version is a bit different.
Bucketheadhead 3 years ago