張惠妹 A-Mei - 卡門(歌聲妹影香港紅磡管弦樂演唱會)

[wmsun07]

妹唱得好.....但.....有空.....聽一下羅文的..­....

[hi4u47m701]

歌詞有一點無辱男生



[sukarsan]

不濫情、不煽情、詮釋得高尚、時尚，香港的朋友真有福氣，有這麼­好的 Concert!

[tseyunsan]

比不上朱咪咪，更比不上杜麗莎。

[shurookramoun]

the best singer in china .

[samsonwtl]

收音不好

[davidcheung2010]

曲好 ! 辭好 ! 阿妹唱的勁好 ! 無懈可撀 !!!

[yxliful]

卡门的中文翻译得真好~



[blackrabbit0418]

演唱會與歌劇的詮釋方式不同

個人覺得阿妹唱得還不錯

沙沙的聲音很有特色別有一番風味

[kagome155]

Nice song there

[quincypua]

即使是他聲音不好的狀態依然打倒所有其他歌手～

[billvong1984]

佢利害於這些唱到爛的歌唱到好听,

[maastricht85]

that is nice never thought a mei could sing this type of music great old classic

[aaaaa50601]

聽的出來聲音相當的疲累

但是對一個職業的歌手

阿妹做了一個最棒的榜樣

一樣拿出高水準的演出

值得讓人佩服

[manoftheking]

i love a mei

[JASONYOUNGBY]

i like it so much!

[Karel3007]

I like the Chinese version!

[bbq2010abc]

看完葛蘭前輩版本除了salute外沒有可說什麼，但阿妹是另一­輕鬆方式演譯也應該欣賞啊！

[TheAznecho]

she is sexy but her voice lacks the strength and pitch.

[ajoe999]

@TheAznecho

拜託那時候她開過不知多少演唱會了 將近三四年沒休息 嗓音還是最疲累的狀況

還能有這種水準也代表她的實力不凡

若別的歌手像她當時那樣不間段的唱早倒嗓了

[TheAznecho]

@ajoe999 - i am not trying to be too harsh in my criticism. Mine is just an objection point of view that should be taken constructively.

[ichig0p0cky]

@TheAznecho have you heard the original? this song is pretty hard to sing/copy !

her own version is quite okay actually

[rynetien]

演唱精準流暢

不落俗套



[eeelaine2008]

活潑有餘，騷勁不足。

[Shingen789]

I love A-Mei.!!!

[ajoe999]

而且葛蘭女士的版本 是有點演像音樂劇式表現

而阿妹這是演唱會並不能相提並論

[LilJellyS]

i wish she sang it in a higher key.

[metawilo]

葛蘭的版本就在 youtube 搜尋卡門 or 野玫瑰之戀，

六十年前可以把卡門的騷勁表現得這麼讚，

就算現在來聽，也是超水準的 :)

[WANZHIBO1988]

···弹钢琴的那位 ying 了没？lol

[dingding123]

葛蘭女士是阿妹的前輩再前輩

六十年代的女歌手

下面的小朋友不懂 不要說過 " 葛女士? 誰呀!!!" 這種說話

聽聽前輩風範及唱功

即使阿妹輸給這位老前輩也不代表阿妹不好

阿妹粉絲別太激動

[sealuise]

阿妹穿长裙好漂亮啊！

[udon890]

The musical band is excellent. The singer is good. Perfect.

[iqandei]

我覺得好好聽,聽落感覺好舒服呀!!!

[peiwen124]

阿妹虽然在这首歌没有呈现原唱的味道，但是她有东方人轻柔的声音­，有点沙哑的。。真好听～～

[ajoe999]

人家 阿妹渾身是青春熱情帶點拉丁律動的感覺呢

葛女士?誰呀!!!

[bluexxbird]

@ajoe999 比起葛蘭， 张惠妹完全唱不出卡门这首歌的韵味..

[ajoe999]

@bluexxbird

每個人欣賞角度不一

你喜歡你的那叫什麼的葛蘭 有人也喜歡阿妹式的卡門壓^^  我到喜歡阿妹自然演唱的風格

[taijicheng]

the song is not right for her

[edwardchow04]

a mei is good, also my idol but this song seems a bit high note for her normal singing

when she sings the 3rd & 4th "lamour" around 2:35, it sounds better, a kind of opera-singing :P

[TheEcnarf]

C'est de la daube!

[f1238106]

@MegaMusicwhore

葛蘭女士那麼強ㄚ~~~ 那請她出來唱一首bad boy 給我們聽聽吧

[dingding123]

葛蘭是老前輩 已七八十歲了

[psychochun]

Unlike 葛蘭, 惠妹 dancing and singing does not seem to have the kind of captivating emotion and feeling to it. I think 葛蘭 performance was still more what i call "Soul Capturing" !

[yo33lo]

Friends, pls check out the classic by Ge-Lan, you'll be blown away by her naughty and sexy version...

葛蘭 - 卡門 電影《野玫瑰之戀》Carmen [GeLan / Grace Chang]

[meixiu79]

同意之极. 葛兰唱的卡门简直骚到入骨. 相信没人足以超越她. 甭说阿妹.

[MrHuangHK]

@meixiu79 非常认同

[dtq3m1hf]

she laugh at 0:11 ~

[hkking83]

Her sound is just so so, but she is pretty and I like the orchestra better. They are all good.

[ellenyumizeng]

她的聲音是好，but not that good in this song,

[cla043008]

powerful + 強勢！天后的實力！

[Xxx5hihi]

她的声音很情很好！

[Xxx5hihi]

shes sing so wonderful

[caocao000]

her voice very good!

love it

[Oceane13457]

COOL!!!!!!

[omgihavenoidea]

so soft, we can hardly here her voice :(

[sexythicklip]

渾然天成