aku rasa agnes memang tak boleh lawan jac.. memang ketara sangat kalau dua penyanyi ni menyanyi mesti tenggelam habis suara agnes..ahahahahhahaha. proud to be malaysian..
kalah lah vokal agnes berbanding jac.. memang ketara sangat suara agnes tak sejuat suara jac.. kalau masuk pertandingan confirm jac akan menang..agnes tu pakai miming boleh lah.. artis indon memang suka miminya?????
Orang iri ngan Agnes,tanda tak laku macam jack.jack.jack.JELEK.ITAM.MACAM KAYU KERING,.,..TENGOK BODY JACK NI,.UEEEEKKKK..TENGOK ANJING I LAGI BAGUS.,GO AGNES GO GO GO GO
agnes monica sudah berkarier di luar negeri di LA ,di brazil aja agnes udah punya penggemar orang asli sana ,search aja di youtube nanti jg ada videonya ,jaclyn wajahnya jelek cuma juara di daerah lokal ,belum pernah dapat pengahargaan di kompetisi internasional aja maw dibandingin ama agnes yang sudah berkarir d luar negeri yang bener aja!!!
Di singapore sni,tiap hari i dgr radio,tengok Tv Suria,tak ada org putar lagu2 Jack,tak ada org nak minta lagu2 jack,.80% org minta lagu2 Indon.,kerna memang lagu2 Indon bnyak yg minat kat singapore sni...,ntah knapa lagu2 Indon lebi populer di banding lagu2 Malay.
@mondaybetween ye ke? aku tak pernah pun dgr lagu agnes! aku ada dgr dia buat konsert di Malaya tapi gagal! tak ada orang datang, kesiannya....hahahaha
Muka jelek mau compare sm Agnes,.nyanyi pun macam nak berak,suara ko tu Jac macam kereta rosak.,body pun i tengok mau muntah,.'..go Agnes,good girl.,ur big fans frm Singapore.
@ivonengky ek'eleh.. ko pesal lak nak keji2 jac.. xyah nk mnyamar jd org Singapore la.. dasar Indon tu Indon gak la.. mcm la jac tu yg kasi ko mkn smpai ko nk terberak muntah bagai.. sengal!!
Mereke berduet menerusi lagu Together We Will Shine. Ternyata benar suara Jaclyn lebih tinggi daripada agnes! agnes nyanyi a...a...a... it's horrible!
@mondaybetween Ye...kenapa? masa pembukaan sukan sea di indon, aku ada perasan yang mikrofon yg dipegang agnes audionya lebih kuat berbanding Jac dan KC. Jac tetap hebat mengalunkan suaranya berbanding agnes jelek! pandai indon beza-bezakan audio microfon yang dipegang artis ye...indon jelek!
I know this video uploaded by Indonesian, but you cannot say "Agnes Monica better than Jaclyn" You should proud of this two singer.. even I'm from Malaysia, I love Agnes Monica also her Voice! I think Jaclyn & Agnes got Natural talent from GOD :)
for me both of them a best and superd...no need to compare any way of them sing.....both them are the best....why must figthing every in youtube video between indonesian n malaysian..??? damm....jacklyn asian idol not only malaysia ok.....and i dun want to critict anyone else because i i also like agness monica....so no need war in youtube ....come on laa guyssss.......
OMG.. Tomdadivine.. Pls la.. Dis is juz a video.. Post by ppl that hope for all youtube user to give any comment only.. Dun b so emotional la.. Seems like u r so childish to bring up all this issue.. All singer have their own advantage lor.. Not juz only received an award so u can say this 1 is the best.. This 1 is not.. C the others.. They all comment bout vocal and the artist technique only.. That 1 is what we need.. To improve music industries.. Plz wake up.. B more open-minded!! Orait!!
How you compare A MTV AWARD NOMINEE With some IDOL out of some IDOL SHOW?? What SHE NOMINATED FOR? THE BEST SINGER VIA SMS IN YOUR COUNTRY?? AGNES GOT NOMINATED FOR THE BEST IN THE WORLD. One does not simply put World Class Artist with some Local artist.
@TomDaDivine ahahaha.. best in the world??? Lick my ass!! Agnes is a loser!! Agnes can't even win over Siti Nurhaliza!!! she lose with Siti Nurhaliza in many competition!! now, i DARE u to give me the links that show Agnes is nominated as the best in the world.. tell me!!
Hei Just saying is this Jacklyn Victor is better than Agnes... She (Jacklyn) should be Some won or at least nominated for some kind of award in music. Agnes got nominated for Asia best singer by MTV europe music award..... Agnes Contender was BIG BANG, and other International ARTIST. The point is one does not simply Put Agnes with some out of nowhere IDOL IN THE SAME LEAGUE.
sbb bibir jac ngelebar kmu kutuk dia.....ngakui aja vocal die mmg mantap si....bkn psl parsa mukanya....tp vocalnya....dia lantunkn corus aja relek.....tgok agness.....hampir2 aja mau pitam....mujur aja bibirnya ga besar ama jac.....kalo jac td cntik...udah psti kamu suka dia....this is unfair to jac coz of her faces u'll compare her with agnes....agnes my favorite singer n rossa at indo....but i never critic bulshit bout indon singer .....wtf...
ya klo dr title singer mgkn jaclyn lebih baik dr range vocal n highest not-nya,,tp agnes jg pandai memainkan dinamika suaranya,bukan sekedar singer,dya jg dancer,composer,designer (byk baju hsl design sendiri),entrepeneur,trendsetter,presenter and many more!!!!!
Are you guys done??? saling kritik / saling puji,,,menambah masalah aja. Mereka aja gak menghiraukan apa yang kalian pusingkan. Sorry tobe honest , aku lebih mengakui suara Agnes yang lebih variatif , strong dan lebih berimprovisasi. But both of them have a good voice. Seharusnya kita bangga dengan mereka as we are satu rumpun. Saluuutt for them.
Pleace dont fight arguments on this. Hargailah guys....Thank you
kenapa harus diperbandingkan 2 orang yg berbeda..agnes maupun jacklyn punya karakter masing2..
coba banyangkan dalam satu keluarga inti aja semua anak memiliki sifat dan karakter yg beda2,padahal 1 bapak dan 1 ibu,tp anak2nya berbeda sifat dan karakterkan??
jadi hanya orang berpikiran sempit yg membanding2kan dua org yg jelas2 beda suku bahkan beda negara..dasar payah...
well.... different singing techniques.... in my opinion both are good singers..... agnes with higher pitch control..while jacklyn put feelings in her song.....
im neither malaysian nor indonesian so i will not be biased.....in my opinion, indonesian got load of talents other than or even better than agnes monica as compared to malaysian....BUT, if you compare agnes monica and jacklyn victor... jacklyn victor, obviously, will win...infact, i believe that she's the only talented malaysian, she's Malaysian treasure....
..eh skalian mO NYADARIN ada cuplikan dari WIKIPEDIA "Meskipun demikian, cukup banyak pula penyanyi Indonesia yang terpengaruh Agnes dalam hal gaya bernyanyi dan penampilan. Penyanyi dari negara tetangga, Stacy, bahkan mendapat julukan sebagai "Agnes Monica Malaysia" akibat pengaruh Agnes pada dirinya. Agnes memiliki jenis suara sopran yang melengking dengan jangkauan vokal mencapai empat oktaf." wah bGga-NY Qt pNy aGnez. Terima ksh apresiasinya Wrg Malaysia. N TLG jgn Klaim apapun Dr bGsa Kami!
Agnes uda p'nah duet ma keith martin, michael bolton, J. Timbaland n more.., Jaklyn??ehh da pd lupa apa agnez p'anh konser tunggal diMalaSYAIton, jaklyn nnyi cman dikandang doang awardpun dari luar g ada!! agnes p'nah 2 kali dpt "The Best Asian Artist Award"di ASF Korea Jd nie udh bukti agNEZ is D'Best in ASIA ^_* dan siap untuk meluncurkan ALBUM INTERNATIONAL nya di amerika dan London. AQ malu Ngapain sih bandingin koG ma Jeklyn SIAPA YANG KENAL DIA ???
your always proud to those singer of yours.. you know what all of your singer..are bullshit they didnt know how to sing... and you always said that indonesian are always winner to those international contest.. but there is no news about it fucking lie...and plss dont make those irretating videos cause you indonesian are trying hard... your singer have a low voice not high they didnt know how to scream..lol .and by the way filipino singer are not yelling....wht they do is using there vocal power.
@king0875 i like u coment.....all singer the best no matter indonesian, malaysian or filipin or where ever....coz they r singer....the bullshit is who alwaz compare n critic the singer sucker....who alwaz said indonesian is good....i advise u go forwar...jgn jadi katak bw tmpurung dong...akui aja sume penyanyi itu hebat..kaloga hebat ga jadi penyanyi si.....ape pn jac vocal dy tetap mantap....aku sokong mne2 penyanyi hebat ga kira bangsa apa ato negara apa...
@king0875 THERE IS NO NEWS ABOUT THE FUCKING LIE??? please make sure if u want to harshly comment,, and I DONT GIVE A F00000, as long as they CAN SING, indonesian, filipinos, or whatever, they are still human and not ALIEN
@king0875 i love u coment superb.....who's post this video really suck.....alwaz proud indonesian singer the best....damm..!!please la be open minded la guys.....every singer hve the way to sing.....peace no war..!!
fuck this singer agnes bullshit... even though im a filipino i am in favor of jaclyn victor.. she know hows to hit the highnotes and she knows how to put a feelings on it.. even though i do not understand the song but i feel the emotion that jacklyn victor gave.... and why is that you indonesian are so trying hard
lihat viedeo agnes live di indigo trans or dekade transcorp, dia nyanyi lagu "rindu", or medley di trans dekade, sdia menyanyi live sambil dance. masing2 punya kelebihan dan kekurangan, gw belum pernah denger jac bernyanyi dg headvoice. agnes udah masuk nominasi EMA dan co-host AMA
hello, menurut q menikmati musik itu tergantung orgnya. Its ok bl ada yg bilang Agnes lebih bagus. Karena dia suka jenis musik dan suara agnes. Dan Ok jg bila ada yg bilang Jacklyn lebih bagus, karena dia suka musik dan suara jacklyn.
tapi sy sendiri tergantung lagunya. Agnes sy suka dengan lugu MATAHARI. Untuk Jacklyn, saya suka lagu WAJAH...
@azharkent have you listened to the Agnes' new song "Rindu" ? she does the whistle voice, but ya, she still need a little more time to make her voice like Mariah Carey
@cacad648 wah .. ntar dulu.. ente nilainya dari mana ?? Gw rasa ente cuma nilai dari tinggi nada suara mereka.. lihat dong kemampuan agnes dalam menyanyikan lagu yang berfariasi... secara garis besar kemampuan mereka sama.. Jacklyn cuma menang di tinggi nada, bukan teknik bernyanyi...
@Omegared20081 : Big liar...jangan ngaku2 orang Indonesia. Sekalipun elu betul orang Indonesia, paling salah satu hater yang kerjaannya mencela dan menjatuhkan orang lain. Gak heran kok haters Indonesia punya cara yang licik dan pikiran yang picik. Baik Agnes Monica maupun Jaclyn punya style masing2. Ada kelebihan maupun kekuarangan. Gak usah dicompare. Just enjoy the music
@omega bulshit bngt loe ngaku2 orang indonesia!agnes lbh bagus ketimbang s victor lu liat d opening seagames yg s agnes nyanyi trio sama s kc n,zack nilai sendiri!s zack,suaranya nyaring tp artikulasinya gk jelas,huruf A jd e........hallo............n s victor kgk bisa dance ky agnes
dont ever compare it with jacklyn... she is the most strongger voice that ive heard... try u compare agnes monica, krisdayanti and inul with sitinurhaliza, ziana zain nn ning baizura...
sorry for malaysia, the fact is agnes has plenty of fans in malaysia, no matter agnes's voice bad, sucks, terrible, jacklyn victor's voice better than agnes or whatever that is, agnes still has a lot of fans there, her films, her songs are popular there.
@bubu4745 LOL.. how do u know that Agnes is so popular in Malaysia, while in fact you are not even a Malaysian..?? From where did you get that fact?? FYI, for most of the concerts held by Indonesians' artistes here in Malaysia, almost ALL the viewers are Indonesians' workers who are working in Malaysia.. that's the fact!! and FYI, there are more than 1million Indonesian's people in Malaysia as per today.. Agnes Monica is NOT that popular among Malaysians!!
sorry ya for indonesia people . . . menurut i Jaclyn lagi bagus lah drpd agnes . . coz agnes nyanyi mcm org stress jak nak teriak2. . .tengok lah 2 lagu baru die mcm org kena rasuk nak teriak2 mcm org GILA . . better u x payah nyanyi lah .. bagus u ikut 2 org gila teriak kat tepi jalan . . hahahah .sorry if u terasa . .
@MegaNadirah97 sorry ya for malay people..lo hanya liat dari segi vocal..tapi secara keseluruhan..packaging agnes complete, kalo si jaclyn sih suara oke..tapi membosankan..
both of them are good, Jacklyn has a high-pitched voice while Agnes has a big voice and she can do whistling, both of them are superb, can't even compare those two
well bukannya gw ga nasionalis,tapi secara objective gw pastinya milih jaclyn kalo dari segi vocal.. high note tapi ga bising. u know what im sayin rite!? gw fans Agnes kog so no offense please ^^
This video is uploaded in 2009. hey, now 2011 we can see that Agnes is much better than Jaclyn. Agnes can sing with whistle register now. and her voice become wider than before.
@vitosatwika that's not even whistle.. learn exactly on how the whistle sounds, then only u can reply.. Agnes always do the high falsetto, NOT whistle, and sometimes, she sounds like screaming.. Agnes is not even reaching the whistle notes.. please do a homework about whistle, buddy.....
okelah buat orang awam seperti kita2 ini tak mengerti mengenai whistle lah, falsetto lah..high note lah..tapi disini membuktikan agnes emang sudah sangat berkembang..dan saya lebih menikmati improvisasi agnes menyanyi ketimbang jaclyn..rasanya kalo dengar dia nyanyi yg denger pada meringis..
and one more thing. I think agnes was lip-sync in the video karna suaranya sma dgn lagu asal.. jaclyn membawa lagu orang lain dgn gaya sndiri.. idk la~~
menurut gue..suara jaclyn emang mempunyai teknik vokal yg baik..tapi untuk menjadi seorang entertainer..apalagi penyanyi..packaging agnes lebih enak dilihat..baik dari cara dia bernyanyi, berinteraksi dengan audience, improvisasi, penghayatan lagu, apalagi dari fisik dan outfitnya lebih baik si agnes, untuk itu agnes lebih unggul daripada jaclyn, kalau untuk vocal..ya beda tipis lah..apalagi di opening sea games kemaren..suara agnes lebih melengking dan menonjol sekarang..itu krn banyak berlatih
@akujoeyful For me Agnes better,agnes miming kalo lagi nari, itupun sudah sangat jarang dia lakukan, kalo untuk lagi slow dia tak pernah miming..lagian supaya tetap bertahan di dunia entertaint..vokal emang no.1 tapi tetep harus didukung oleh penampilan, performance kita diatas panggung..percuma punya suara bagus..tapi cara bernyanyinya tak bisa dinikmati audience..cara seprti itu tak kan bisa bertahan lama..
Wow... Jacklyn Victor's voice is Great! but just great. When I saw her name, I thought she were a man. LoL. Meanwhile, Agnes Monica's voice is having a characteristic. and it makes her one step ahead from Jacklyn.
@akujoeyful hahah..saya pernah liat cara jaclyn bernyanyi..tapi rasanya saya deg deg an liat dia bernyanyi...liat dong opening sea games kemaren..agnes punya suara lebih menonjol dari jaclyn..agnes bisa tetap bertahan sampai sekarang..karena dia punya karakter, performance selalu improvisasi, selalu ada perubahan..jadi penonton gak boring liat agnes nyanyi..geto loh.
@jenchen81 wow..kami negara suportif..bukan karena kami tuan rumah..jadi maksud loe..si jaclyn kasih kesempatan buat agnes nyanyi yg lebiih kenceng suaranya.hellowww...siapa aja boleh menonjol kalo emang punya kemampuan..sah sah aja kok..
@MsChilla911 memang supportive sebab tu jemput penyanyi2 dari negara lain. im talking abt performance wise. ada yg sing melody ada yg sing harmoni. Agnes duk dkt tgh2, sesuai la dia nyanyi melody to honour the games and the other singers. kalau nak suruh masing2 nyanyi solo performance, menonjol juga. jac finished with a high note at the end while Agnes sang the melody. ok la tu.
@MsChilla911 Agnes itu dulunya suka nyanyi miming, gak bisa nyanyi live.. ketika SEA games, mic nya Agnes d kuatkan.. that's obvious!! Of course as a host, Indonesia wants to promote their artist.. that's why the volume of Agnes' mic has been double up, so that the other two artistes seems like unable to out shine Agnes.. that's common as a way to promote one singer's vocal ability, it's a trick.. but the truth is, Jaclyn still better than Agnes in terms of vocal.. period!
@azharkent hahah..sapa bilang tak bisa nyanyi live..agnes miming kalo lagi dance..but..bukan berarti dia tak bisa dance sambil nari..untuk vocal mungkin bisa dibilang jaclyn oke..but overall packaging agnes lebh complete..jaclyn menyanyi tak ada penghayatan..membosankan,
@azharkent analisa lo bisa2 aja..bilangin volume mic agnes dikuatin..sbg fans saya tau betul perkembangan vocal agnes..setiap tahun atau bahkan setiap perform, kematangan suara agnes terlihat sekali..dari dia kecil, remaja hingga dewasa sekarang..okelah kita bilanglah vocal jac better but overall agnes lebih menyenangkan..dan entertainer sejati.
aduhh si jeklin emang bisa dance??..beda kaliii... agness more powerfull than si jak tu..
aq tu ya kalo liat si jaklin nyanyi jantungan bukkk,, g tau kenapa?..soalnya takut aja bibirnya koyak....,,soalnya mulutnya terlalu terbuka besarr dalam bernyanyi kayak mau ketelan tu mic dibuatnya....
seriously i don't want to compare both of them but seriously jac got more powerful vocal compared to agnes! so indonesian stop to comparing your LOSER singer with others! SHAME ON YOU!
just terima je lah hakikat..indonesia pnye pnyanyi mmg xde pape yg leh dibanggakan....korg sndri memuja siti nurhaliza bagai nak rak....kami x pernah memuja artis dr indonesia...becoz they have nothing to be proud of..if btol artis indonesia bgs,knpe x menang mase asian idol..even malaysia pon x menang tp atleast dpt no 2..ko hado??harapan je lah..hahahahha
@lanjer92 aduhh g kebalikk bukk,, jujur ya gw banyak teman kuliah dari malaysia, mereka senang tu dengan artis indo, terutama wali boleh tahan lagunye sedapjerr,, gitu dalam bahasa melayu mereka bilang,, hehhe...
gw g terlalu kenal ma si jaklin, kalo yg dari malaysia senang siti :), tapi skrang jarang siti datang ke indo buat konser?..g taula kenapa.. jadi kangen ma siti euy....:(
@lanjer92 indonesia masih punya lebih dri agnes... Ada => Gita Gitawa, Putri Ayu, Joy Tobing, Nania, Vina Panduinata, Dewi Sandra, Ruth Sahanaya, ect!!! Salma kalah... haha...
gue orang indonesia, tapi terus terang suara jeklin lebih bersih ketimbang agnes yg kedengaran seperti pecah. biarpun saya kurang ngerti bahasa malaysia. but i love both them :D
nyatanya jaclyn nyanyiannya jauh lebih bagus kalau dibandingin dengan agnes..even agnes only lipped-singing masig ngak boleh melawan kehebatan vocal jaclyn yang tiada bandingannya..gue tetap bangga walaupun gue bukan org malaysia...kerana kita serumpun syabas Malaysia!!!!!!!!
jaclyn gue akui kalau nyanyi kayak diva..malah ngak keterlaluan jika gue katakan yang jaclyn punya suara dan kualitas vokal setanding dengan penyanyi intarnasional seperti withney houstan, celine dion dan mariah carey..syabas Malaysia!!!
aku pun blh nyanyi kot lagu agnes tu... tp lagu jacklyn aku x berani bwk klu kat mn2 function coz tinggi power n mantop....!! yesss...!!!! go MALAYSIA ku yg POWER!!!!!
walaupun gue org indonesia..gue secara jujurnya tetap mengakui jaclyn mantop dan punya suara yang terbaik sekali bandingan agness yang suaranya biasa2 aja...syabas malaysia!!!!
agnes punya power vocal cukup bagus,, dan lagu yang dibawainnya punya tingkat kesulitan yang lumayan,, ngak banyak penyanyi yang mampu membawakannya,, selamat buat agnes,,
@indonesiadude weh...sedar2 lah diri tu sikit... kau tu menumpang MALAYSIA... x tau malu...
farracet6995 3 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
org yg buat video ni adalah punca pergaduhan.... nak tau sape??? ORG ENDON JUGAK.....
farracet6995 3 days ago
Comment removed
farracet6995 3 days ago
aku rasa agnes memang tak boleh lawan jac.. memang ketara sangat kalau dua penyanyi ni menyanyi mesti tenggelam habis suara agnes..ahahahahhahaha. proud to be malaysian..
popboyman1 3 days ago
kalah lah vokal agnes berbanding jac.. memang ketara sangat suara agnes tak sejuat suara jac.. kalau masuk pertandingan confirm jac akan menang..agnes tu pakai miming boleh lah.. artis indon memang suka miminya?????
popboyman1 3 days ago
Orang iri ngan Agnes,tanda tak laku macam jack.jack.jack.JELEK.ITAM.MACAM KAYU KERING,.,..TENGOK BODY JACK NI,.UEEEEKKKK..TENGOK ANJING I LAGI BAGUS.,GO AGNES GO GO GO GO
ivonengky 5 days ago
kelakar la baca komen-komen kat sini...pasal penyanyi pun nak gaduh..aduh..parah generasiku
takdernama 1 week ago
komentarnya pedes pedes .
bisanya ngejelekin satu sama lain .
sedangkan yg coment gak punya bakat seperti agnes dan jacklyn.
dua duanya bagus kok dan saling mengharumkan negri nya masing masing ,
banggalah pada masing masing artis jgn kasi statment yg gak jelas dan gak mutu di tambah gak berpendidikan.
TheLii44 1 week ago 3
stupid who compare this two
wonderyear09 1 week ago
I agree .. !not because I'm an Indonesian, so defend agnes! but it's true :)
melinasvtr 1 week ago
agnes monica sudah berkarier di luar negeri di LA ,di brazil aja agnes udah punya penggemar orang asli sana ,search aja di youtube nanti jg ada videonya ,jaclyn wajahnya jelek cuma juara di daerah lokal ,belum pernah dapat pengahargaan di kompetisi internasional aja maw dibandingin ama agnes yang sudah berkarir d luar negeri yang bener aja!!!
aa4229 1 week ago
Di singapore sni,tiap hari i dgr radio,tengok Tv Suria,tak ada org putar lagu2 Jack,tak ada org nak minta lagu2 jack,.80% org minta lagu2 Indon.,kerna memang lagu2 Indon bnyak yg minat kat singapore sni...,ntah knapa lagu2 Indon lebi populer di banding lagu2 Malay.
ivonengky 1 week ago
@ivonengky lagu singapore plak dimane???? di telan singa????? pukimat....jahanam la ko.....
agnazrulzarith 1 week ago
And don't forget,Agnes Won 7 Awards in Jpop Asian Award.
mondaybetween 2 weeks ago
@mondaybetween ye ke? aku tak pernah pun dgr lagu agnes! aku ada dgr dia buat konsert di Malaya tapi gagal! tak ada orang datang, kesiannya....hahahaha
amz1985full 2 weeks ago
Di Asian Idol sudah dikatakan oleh juri,Jack menyanyi dgn suara tinggi tp menyanyi hanya untuk dirinya sendiri.
mondaybetween 2 weeks ago
@mondaybetween Juri mana yang cakap tu? setahu aku semua juri puji Jac!!! Tgk pada Indon Idol, dah la gemuk gedempol, suara pun tak sedap! hahaha
amz1985full 2 weeks ago
Muka jelek mau compare sm Agnes,.nyanyi pun macam nak berak,suara ko tu Jac macam kereta rosak.,body pun i tengok mau muntah,.'..go Agnes,good girl.,ur big fans frm Singapore.
ivonengky 2 weeks ago
@ivonengky Aku rasa agnes lebih jelek daripada Jaclyn! hahaha
amz1985full 2 weeks ago
@ivonengky ek'eleh.. ko pesal lak nak keji2 jac.. xyah nk mnyamar jd org Singapore la.. dasar Indon tu Indon gak la.. mcm la jac tu yg kasi ko mkn smpai ko nk terberak muntah bagai.. sengal!!
azharkent 1 week ago
Mereke berduet menerusi lagu Together We Will Shine. Ternyata benar suara Jaclyn lebih tinggi daripada agnes! agnes nyanyi a...a...a... it's horrible!
amz1985full 2 weeks ago
@amz1985full Jaminankah suara yg lebih tinggi itu lebih bagus?
mondaybetween 2 weeks ago
@mondaybetween Ye...kenapa? masa pembukaan sukan sea di indon, aku ada perasan yang mikrofon yg dipegang agnes audionya lebih kuat berbanding Jac dan KC. Jac tetap hebat mengalunkan suaranya berbanding agnes jelek! pandai indon beza-bezakan audio microfon yang dipegang artis ye...indon jelek!
amz1985full 2 weeks ago
agnes the best :) she's always put her soul in the song... tehnik vocal'x pun lbih ok. jacklyn bsa'x teriak tak karuan
ch0o0k1 2 weeks ago
hhahaa.... u cannot compare both singer because they're in different voice range...so both of them are the best themselves..^^
kimkiwook90 2 weeks ago 2
: Both are the best , jac more to vocal and agnes more to performance , dua2 ada kelebihan masing2 :D
AminTr1 2 weeks ago
I know this video uploaded by Indonesian, but you cannot say "Agnes Monica better than Jaclyn" You should proud of this two singer.. even I'm from Malaysia, I love Agnes Monica also her Voice! I think Jaclyn & Agnes got Natural talent from GOD :)
FYI spell it right JACLYN not ---> JACKLYN ;)
FareezCullenVEVO 3 weeks ago 2
sedihh... satu lagi video yg menghancurkan industri muzik asia.. fikir secara profesional.. jgn guna kepala lutut k..
mrijoie86 3 weeks ago
vocal, jacklyn more better, peformance, agnest more better.
fajargumanty 3 weeks ago
mmg jac yg menang lhaa . 10x better than agnes
MsMrsljoe 3 weeks ago
jack byk lgu yg best.... agnes lgu matahariku je yg best...lgu laen faill......bungkus nasi lemak lgi bgus....
agnazrulzarith 3 weeks ago 2
@agnazrulzarith Lagu Jack tak satupun diputar di tv disini :P
mondaybetween 2 weeks ago
@mondaybetween mungkin karna kalian menutup peluang pasaran malaysia ke indonesia . malaysia lebih bersifat terbuka gitulorh . .
redveto93 2 weeks ago
@mondaybetween Aku tak kenal siapa ganes sebenarnya! itulah kenyataannya...dia bukan indon idol, dia hanya indon diva yang tak popular!
amz1985full 2 weeks ago
x kisah la korang nk pilih sape..
tp aku nk sgt dowg berduet..
MrShamizie 3 weeks ago
for me both of them a best and superd...no need to compare any way of them sing.....both them are the best....why must figthing every in youtube video between indonesian n malaysian..??? damm....jacklyn asian idol not only malaysia ok.....and i dun want to critict anyone else because i i also like agness monica....so no need war in youtube ....come on laa guyssss.......
MrHoneygreen22 4 weeks ago
hahahahhahaah
mailkanssas 1 month ago
AWESOME VOICE IN THIS VIDEO @ 0:54
berundung1 1 month ago
For me both of them are best perfomer or artist and bring their own unique technique!! I luv u both!! Superb agnes and jacklyn!!
TheShaq86 1 month ago
OMG.. Tomdadivine.. Pls la.. Dis is juz a video.. Post by ppl that hope for all youtube user to give any comment only.. Dun b so emotional la.. Seems like u r so childish to bring up all this issue.. All singer have their own advantage lor.. Not juz only received an award so u can say this 1 is the best.. This 1 is not.. C the others.. They all comment bout vocal and the artist technique only.. That 1 is what we need.. To improve music industries.. Plz wake up.. B more open-minded!! Orait!!
TheShaq86 1 month ago
Quality vocal sih menurut aku Jaclyn lebih OK tapi techniquenya Agnes lbh mantap.
diane1556xj 1 month ago
How you compare A MTV AWARD NOMINEE With some IDOL out of some IDOL SHOW?? What SHE NOMINATED FOR? THE BEST SINGER VIA SMS IN YOUR COUNTRY?? AGNES GOT NOMINATED FOR THE BEST IN THE WORLD. One does not simply put World Class Artist with some Local artist.
TomDaDivine 1 month ago 2
@TomDaDivine ahahaha.. best in the world??? Lick my ass!! Agnes is a loser!! Agnes can't even win over Siti Nurhaliza!!! she lose with Siti Nurhaliza in many competition!! now, i DARE u to give me the links that show Agnes is nominated as the best in the world.. tell me!!
azharkent 1 week ago
Hei Just saying is this Jacklyn Victor is better than Agnes... She (Jacklyn) should be Some won or at least nominated for some kind of award in music. Agnes got nominated for Asia best singer by MTV europe music award..... Agnes Contender was BIG BANG, and other International ARTIST. The point is one does not simply Put Agnes with some out of nowhere IDOL IN THE SAME LEAGUE.
TomDaDivine 1 month ago
sbb bibir jac ngelebar kmu kutuk dia.....ngakui aja vocal die mmg mantap si....bkn psl parsa mukanya....tp vocalnya....dia lantunkn corus aja relek.....tgok agness.....hampir2 aja mau pitam....mujur aja bibirnya ga besar ama jac.....kalo jac td cntik...udah psti kamu suka dia....this is unfair to jac coz of her faces u'll compare her with agnes....agnes my favorite singer n rossa at indo....but i never critic bulshit bout indon singer .....wtf...
MrHoneygreen22 1 month ago
@MrHoneygreen22 Bukan mau pitam sih, Agnes melantunkan dg penuh expresi. Justru klu nada tinggi expresi relax, artinya tidak menghayati.
diane1556xj 1 month ago
Mmmm bagi sy suara sama aje meletop cume dari segi imej jgn bandingkan di antara malaysia ngan indonesia
Ponaponi1980 1 month ago
ya klo dr title singer mgkn jaclyn lebih baik dr range vocal n highest not-nya,,tp agnes jg pandai memainkan dinamika suaranya,bukan sekedar singer,dya jg dancer,composer,designer (byk baju hsl design sendiri),entrepeneur,trendsetter,presenter and many more!!!!!
razmochful1 1 month ago
how do you guys judge which one is better? This is so unfair!
jimbu0711 1 month ago
Are you guys done??? saling kritik / saling puji,,,menambah masalah aja. Mereka aja gak menghiraukan apa yang kalian pusingkan. Sorry tobe honest , aku lebih mengakui suara Agnes yang lebih variatif , strong dan lebih berimprovisasi. But both of them have a good voice. Seharusnya kita bangga dengan mereka as we are satu rumpun. Saluuutt for them.
Pleace dont fight arguments on this. Hargailah guys....Thank you
yunikssr34 1 month ago
yaaaaaa...jac mmg terbaikkkkkkkkkk.....love u jac..
dailyfady 1 month ago
kenapa harus diperbandingkan 2 orang yg berbeda..agnes maupun jacklyn punya karakter masing2..
coba banyangkan dalam satu keluarga inti aja semua anak memiliki sifat dan karakter yg beda2,padahal 1 bapak dan 1 ibu,tp anak2nya berbeda sifat dan karakterkan??
jadi hanya orang berpikiran sempit yg membanding2kan dua org yg jelas2 beda suku bahkan beda negara..dasar payah...
ruydmj 1 month ago
samasama punya suara bagus. tapi teteplah agnes juara
achynsr 1 month ago
kedua2ny best!!!!
nineycomel 1 month ago
helllllo agnes punya suara lg power ker.... think wisely............ saya suka agnes monica tp dah tentu la suara jac lg power kot
haleemizman 1 month ago
well.... different singing techniques.... in my opinion both are good singers..... agnes with higher pitch control..while jacklyn put feelings in her song.....
ignnovi 1 month ago
Ga penting suara siapa yg paling bagus,,yg penting siapa yg paling menjual,, that's business.. by the way who is jacklyn victor?? -__-"
almabaitytiwi 1 month ago
im neither malaysian nor indonesian so i will not be biased.....in my opinion, indonesian got load of talents other than or even better than agnes monica as compared to malaysian....BUT, if you compare agnes monica and jacklyn victor... jacklyn victor, obviously, will win...infact, i believe that she's the only talented malaysian, she's Malaysian treasure....
malorinovalee 1 month ago
..eh skalian mO NYADARIN ada cuplikan dari WIKIPEDIA "Meskipun demikian, cukup banyak pula penyanyi Indonesia yang terpengaruh Agnes dalam hal gaya bernyanyi dan penampilan. Penyanyi dari negara tetangga, Stacy, bahkan mendapat julukan sebagai "Agnes Monica Malaysia" akibat pengaruh Agnes pada dirinya. Agnes memiliki jenis suara sopran yang melengking dengan jangkauan vokal mencapai empat oktaf." wah bGga-NY Qt pNy aGnez. Terima ksh apresiasinya Wrg Malaysia. N TLG jgn Klaim apapun Dr bGsa Kami!
Meesbah8Bzalm 1 month ago
Agnes uda p'nah duet ma keith martin, michael bolton, J. Timbaland n more.., Jaklyn??ehh da pd lupa apa agnez p'anh konser tunggal diMalaSYAIton, jaklyn nnyi cman dikandang doang awardpun dari luar g ada!! agnes p'nah 2 kali dpt "The Best Asian Artist Award"di ASF Korea Jd nie udh bukti agNEZ is D'Best in ASIA ^_* dan siap untuk meluncurkan ALBUM INTERNATIONAL nya di amerika dan London. AQ malu Ngapain sih bandingin koG ma Jeklyn SIAPA YANG KENAL DIA ???
Meesbah8Bzalm 1 month ago
Anges kutilanak !! sakit teliga gue.
dealovaxxx 1 month ago
jaclyn won..
asiamage 1 month ago
Agnes Monica the winner :D
LianLynz 1 month ago
dua2 pun ok daripada org yg x pandai nyanyi..
hahahahahahahahahahahah
1991hendro 1 month ago
your always proud to those singer of yours.. you know what all of your singer..are bullshit they didnt know how to sing... and you always said that indonesian are always winner to those international contest.. but there is no news about it fucking lie...and plss dont make those irretating videos cause you indonesian are trying hard... your singer have a low voice not high they didnt know how to scream..lol .and by the way filipino singer are not yelling....wht they do is using there vocal power.
king0875 1 month ago 9
@king0875 i like u coment.....all singer the best no matter indonesian, malaysian or filipin or where ever....coz they r singer....the bullshit is who alwaz compare n critic the singer sucker....who alwaz said indonesian is good....i advise u go forwar...jgn jadi katak bw tmpurung dong...akui aja sume penyanyi itu hebat..kaloga hebat ga jadi penyanyi si.....ape pn jac vocal dy tetap mantap....aku sokong mne2 penyanyi hebat ga kira bangsa apa ato negara apa...
MrHoneygreen22 1 month ago
@king0875 THERE IS NO NEWS ABOUT THE FUCKING LIE??? please make sure if u want to harshly comment,, and I DONT GIVE A F00000, as long as they CAN SING, indonesian, filipinos, or whatever, they are still human and not ALIEN
vegetablesairlines 1 month ago
@king0875 i love u coment superb.....who's post this video really suck.....alwaz proud indonesian singer the best....damm..!!please la be open minded la guys.....every singer hve the way to sing.....peace no war..!!
MrHoneygreen22 4 weeks ago
fuck this singer agnes bullshit... even though im a filipino i am in favor of jaclyn victor.. she know hows to hit the highnotes and she knows how to put a feelings on it.. even though i do not understand the song but i feel the emotion that jacklyn victor gave.... and why is that you indonesian are so trying hard
king0875 1 month ago
lihat viedeo agnes live di indigo trans or dekade transcorp, dia nyanyi lagu "rindu", or medley di trans dekade, sdia menyanyi live sambil dance. masing2 punya kelebihan dan kekurangan, gw belum pernah denger jac bernyanyi dg headvoice. agnes udah masuk nominasi EMA dan co-host AMA
zetya51 1 month ago
hello, menurut q menikmati musik itu tergantung orgnya. Its ok bl ada yg bilang Agnes lebih bagus. Karena dia suka jenis musik dan suara agnes. Dan Ok jg bila ada yg bilang Jacklyn lebih bagus, karena dia suka musik dan suara jacklyn.
tapi sy sendiri tergantung lagunya. Agnes sy suka dengan lugu MATAHARI. Untuk Jacklyn, saya suka lagu WAJAH...
arisblogspot 1 month ago
@azharkent have you listened to the Agnes' new song "Rindu" ? she does the whistle voice, but ya, she still need a little more time to make her voice like Mariah Carey
vitosatwika 1 month ago
bukan pasal malaysia ni bgs sgt...cuma indon je yang babi sgt :) Peace, no war..pig
TheNokia90 1 month ago
agnes miming laaa!!
thenikkhazami 1 month ago
kita harus akuin lo si jaclyn emang lebih baik d banding agnes,,
klo menurut gw mah sing is sing jadi vocal lah yang pertama yg harus di nilai,merea kan penyanyi buan penari,maanya d sebut singer not dancer
cacad648 1 month ago 25
@cacad648 wah .. ntar dulu.. ente nilainya dari mana ?? Gw rasa ente cuma nilai dari tinggi nada suara mereka.. lihat dong kemampuan agnes dalam menyanyikan lagu yang berfariasi... secara garis besar kemampuan mereka sama.. Jacklyn cuma menang di tinggi nada, bukan teknik bernyanyi...
Linggar21 1 month ago
Comment removed
amsal2frida3 3 weeks ago
@cacad648 jaclyn teknik nyanyi Ok, tapi dia cuma asal nyanyi, tanpa memberi nyawa pada lagunya. Kedengeran lebih seperti teriak2an daripada nyanyian.
amsal2frida3 3 weeks ago
yang jelas agnes monica calon diva dunia..... g'd ragukan lg
udah cantik pintar lg..... sepantasnya lo brbangga hati bahwa ada anak bangsa yang mampu berprestasi d kancah internasional....
andri3228 1 month ago
@Omegared20081 : Big liar...jangan ngaku2 orang Indonesia. Sekalipun elu betul orang Indonesia, paling salah satu hater yang kerjaannya mencela dan menjatuhkan orang lain. Gak heran kok haters Indonesia punya cara yang licik dan pikiran yang picik. Baik Agnes Monica maupun Jaclyn punya style masing2. Ada kelebihan maupun kekuarangan. Gak usah dicompare. Just enjoy the music
Steven300182 1 month ago
aku suka agnes, tapi dalam ni jac live, dia obviously miming, macam mana nak compare..
addamjuhari 2 months ago
masing2 punya kelebihan jaclyn top di vocal agnes top di perform :)
githaVega 2 months ago
@omega bulshit bngt loe ngaku2 orang indonesia!agnes lbh bagus ketimbang s victor lu liat d opening seagames yg s agnes nyanyi trio sama s kc n,zack nilai sendiri!s zack,suaranya nyaring tp artikulasinya gk jelas,huruf A jd e........hallo............n s victor kgk bisa dance ky agnes
heru8870 2 months ago
iye gue juga jacklyn lebih baik vokalnya !
secretmeditation 2 months ago
ceh..agnes miming..pahape!
Mrs25Volt 2 months ago
dont ever compare it with jacklyn... she is the most strongger voice that ive heard... try u compare agnes monica, krisdayanti and inul with sitinurhaliza, ziana zain nn ning baizura...
feeqteef 2 months ago
sorry for malaysia, the fact is agnes has plenty of fans in malaysia, no matter agnes's voice bad, sucks, terrible, jacklyn victor's voice better than agnes or whatever that is, agnes still has a lot of fans there, her films, her songs are popular there.
bubu4745 2 months ago
@bubu4745 LOL.. how do u know that Agnes is so popular in Malaysia, while in fact you are not even a Malaysian..?? From where did you get that fact?? FYI, for most of the concerts held by Indonesians' artistes here in Malaysia, almost ALL the viewers are Indonesians' workers who are working in Malaysia.. that's the fact!! and FYI, there are more than 1million Indonesian's people in Malaysia as per today.. Agnes Monica is NOT that popular among Malaysians!!
azharkent 2 months ago
sorry ya for indonesia people . . . menurut i Jaclyn lagi bagus lah drpd agnes . . coz agnes nyanyi mcm org stress jak nak teriak2. . .tengok lah 2 lagu baru die mcm org kena rasuk nak teriak2 mcm org GILA . . better u x payah nyanyi lah .. bagus u ikut 2 org gila teriak kat tepi jalan . . hahahah .sorry if u terasa . .
MegaNadirah97 2 months ago 3
@MegaNadirah97 sorry ya for malay people..lo hanya liat dari segi vocal..tapi secara keseluruhan..packaging agnes complete, kalo si jaclyn sih suara oke..tapi membosankan..
MsChilla911 2 months ago
@MsChilla911 bodoh amat...
MegaNadirah97 2 months ago
@MegaNadirah97 hahhaa..haha..iya bodoh amat yah
MsChilla911 2 months ago
@MegaNadirah97 ini lagi... ... dah ketauan 22nya bagus.. cuma masing2 punya klbhan. kl kau bilang agnes kayak orang stress salah besar kau.. Coba kau suruh adik, kakak, tante kau nyanyi macam si Agnes.. mmpu tidak mereka.. PSTI TERPROPOKASI INI.. hahahaha... PEACE AH..
Linggar21 1 month ago
@MegaNadirah97 yahhh,,jaclyn jg teriak2 ko,,bibirnya aja ampe ngelebar gtu,,
razmochful1 1 month ago
agneslah... jacklyn nyanyinnya kuno n gak inovatif... agnes tu sll pux inovasi dlm bernyanyi dgn improfisasi yg tak terduga...
chanrihi 2 months ago
tak usah gaduh.saya dari malaysia.saya suka kedua2 penyanyi ini.so support 1 sama lain. okey ;)
adem891 2 months ago
both of them are good, Jacklyn has a high-pitched voice while Agnes has a big voice and she can do whistling, both of them are superb, can't even compare those two
vandanatacia 2 months ago
well bukannya gw ga nasionalis,tapi secara objective gw pastinya milih jaclyn kalo dari segi vocal.. high note tapi ga bising. u know what im sayin rite!? gw fans Agnes kog so no offense please ^^
JeremeeV 2 months ago
Agnes monica cant sing live.. she's miming.. Jaclyn victor is no 1 in asia..
beyonce5224 2 months ago
This video is uploaded in 2009. hey, now 2011 we can see that Agnes is much better than Jaclyn. Agnes can sing with whistle register now. and her voice become wider than before.
vitosatwika 2 months ago
@vitosatwika that's not even whistle.. learn exactly on how the whistle sounds, then only u can reply.. Agnes always do the high falsetto, NOT whistle, and sometimes, she sounds like screaming.. Agnes is not even reaching the whistle notes.. please do a homework about whistle, buddy.....
azharkent 2 months ago
okelah buat orang awam seperti kita2 ini tak mengerti mengenai whistle lah, falsetto lah..high note lah..tapi disini membuktikan agnes emang sudah sangat berkembang..dan saya lebih menikmati improvisasi agnes menyanyi ketimbang jaclyn..rasanya kalo dengar dia nyanyi yg denger pada meringis..
MsChilla911 2 months ago
Guys, cant u see that Agnes is miming over there ? Shittt !
thepeaceist 2 months ago
@thepeaceist yup..
camerland 2 months ago
and one more thing. I think agnes was lip-sync in the video karna suaranya sma dgn lagu asal.. jaclyn membawa lagu orang lain dgn gaya sndiri.. idk la~~
alexbert95 2 months ago
jaclyn, not jacklyn. make sure you check your words before you post your comment. 10Q.
alexbert95 2 months ago
dua2nya punya karakter masing2
saya suka dua2nya
btw nulis jaclyn aja salah mau compare sgala ckckck
yg ngupload ni agnezious kali ya :)
Thiozard 2 months ago
menurut gue..suara jaclyn emang mempunyai teknik vokal yg baik..tapi untuk menjadi seorang entertainer..apalagi penyanyi..packaging agnes lebih enak dilihat..baik dari cara dia bernyanyi, berinteraksi dengan audience, improvisasi, penghayatan lagu, apalagi dari fisik dan outfitnya lebih baik si agnes, untuk itu agnes lebih unggul daripada jaclyn, kalau untuk vocal..ya beda tipis lah..apalagi di opening sea games kemaren..suara agnes lebih melengking dan menonjol sekarang..itu krn banyak berlatih
MsChilla911 2 months ago
@MsChilla911
yahh..untuk jadi seorang intertainer itu embak ya,
\yg paling penting vokalnya loh
bukan miming,
dasar munafik!!!!!!!
nyanyi perlu lahir dari hati,
bru baru auranya nyampe d audience,
btw jaclyn is the best!!!!
akujoeyful 2 months ago
@akujoeyful For me Agnes better,agnes miming kalo lagi nari, itupun sudah sangat jarang dia lakukan, kalo untuk lagi slow dia tak pernah miming..lagian supaya tetap bertahan di dunia entertaint..vokal emang no.1 tapi tetep harus didukung oleh penampilan, performance kita diatas panggung..percuma punya suara bagus..tapi cara bernyanyinya tak bisa dinikmati audience..cara seprti itu tak kan bisa bertahan lama..
MsChilla911 2 months ago
Agnes Monica is Good! Jacklyn Victor is Good!
Finish! :P
annisadirga 2 months ago
Wow... Jacklyn Victor's voice is Great! but just great. When I saw her name, I thought she were a man. LoL. Meanwhile, Agnes Monica's voice is having a characteristic. and it makes her one step ahead from Jacklyn.
Shouichie 2 months ago
@Shouichie
having characteristic????hahahha
agnes,out!!! suara nya sengau,
vokal xpower,rendah..
kalau note tinggi..dia menjerit lorh..
bukan nyanyi...huhuhuu,
akujoeyful 2 months ago
@akujoeyful hahah..saya pernah liat cara jaclyn bernyanyi..tapi rasanya saya deg deg an liat dia bernyanyi...liat dong opening sea games kemaren..agnes punya suara lebih menonjol dari jaclyn..agnes bisa tetap bertahan sampai sekarang..karena dia punya karakter, performance selalu improvisasi, selalu ada perubahan..jadi penonton gak boring liat agnes nyanyi..geto loh.
MsChilla911 2 months ago
Boleh ketiga2 penyanyi menonjolkan suara. tapikan masa tu Indosia tuan rumah. Agnes pula artis terkenal. mana boleh penyanyi lain lagi menonjol. :)
jenchen81 2 months ago
@jenchen81 wow..kami negara suportif..bukan karena kami tuan rumah..jadi maksud loe..si jaclyn kasih kesempatan buat agnes nyanyi yg lebiih kenceng suaranya.hellowww...siapa aja boleh menonjol kalo emang punya kemampuan..sah sah aja kok..
MsChilla911 2 months ago
@MsChilla911 memang supportive sebab tu jemput penyanyi2 dari negara lain. im talking abt performance wise. ada yg sing melody ada yg sing harmoni. Agnes duk dkt tgh2, sesuai la dia nyanyi melody to honour the games and the other singers. kalau nak suruh masing2 nyanyi solo performance, menonjol juga. jac finished with a high note at the end while Agnes sang the melody. ok la tu.
jenchen81 2 months ago
@MsChilla911 Agnes itu dulunya suka nyanyi miming, gak bisa nyanyi live.. ketika SEA games, mic nya Agnes d kuatkan.. that's obvious!! Of course as a host, Indonesia wants to promote their artist.. that's why the volume of Agnes' mic has been double up, so that the other two artistes seems like unable to out shine Agnes.. that's common as a way to promote one singer's vocal ability, it's a trick.. but the truth is, Jaclyn still better than Agnes in terms of vocal.. period!
azharkent 2 months ago
@azharkent hahah..sapa bilang tak bisa nyanyi live..agnes miming kalo lagi dance..but..bukan berarti dia tak bisa dance sambil nari..untuk vocal mungkin bisa dibilang jaclyn oke..but overall packaging agnes lebh complete..jaclyn menyanyi tak ada penghayatan..membosankan,
MsChilla911 2 months ago
@azharkent analisa lo bisa2 aja..bilangin volume mic agnes dikuatin..sbg fans saya tau betul perkembangan vocal agnes..setiap tahun atau bahkan setiap perform, kematangan suara agnes terlihat sekali..dari dia kecil, remaja hingga dewasa sekarang..okelah kita bilanglah vocal jac better but overall agnes lebih menyenangkan..dan entertainer sejati.
MsChilla911 2 months ago
they're both awesome..
tp buat aq sih,aq lebih suka karakter nya jacklyn..
lebih mantep and mateng..
kalo agnes kadang2 suaranya suka masih kerasa teenage nya..
ya mungkin faktor usia ngaruh kali atau entahlah..
no offense,but i prefer jacklyn to agnes..
kurangnya jacklyn, lagunya "kurang berani"
keep up the good work both of u
go asian diva!
MsCrazysiblings 2 months ago
dua2 suara power....namalah pnyanyi kan...tapi agnes klau mnyanyi live x oke sngt..
badgurl8895 2 months ago
aduhh si jeklin emang bisa dance??..beda kaliii... agness more powerfull than si jak tu..
aq tu ya kalo liat si jaklin nyanyi jantungan bukkk,, g tau kenapa?..soalnya takut aja bibirnya koyak....,,soalnya mulutnya terlalu terbuka besarr dalam bernyanyi kayak mau ketelan tu mic dibuatnya....
so jadi scare gimannaaaa gitu kitanya dehhh.....
TheJuwitata 2 months ago
seriously i don't want to compare both of them but seriously jac got more powerful vocal compared to agnes! so indonesian stop to comparing your LOSER singer with others! SHAME ON YOU!
jerwloveanne 2 months ago
just terima je lah hakikat..indonesia pnye pnyanyi mmg xde pape yg leh dibanggakan....korg sndri memuja siti nurhaliza bagai nak rak....kami x pernah memuja artis dr indonesia...becoz they have nothing to be proud of..if btol artis indonesia bgs,knpe x menang mase asian idol..even malaysia pon x menang tp atleast dpt no 2..ko hado??harapan je lah..hahahahha
lanjer92 2 months ago
@lanjer92 aduhh g kebalikk bukk,, jujur ya gw banyak teman kuliah dari malaysia, mereka senang tu dengan artis indo, terutama wali boleh tahan lagunye sedapjerr,, gitu dalam bahasa melayu mereka bilang,, hehhe...
gw g terlalu kenal ma si jaklin, kalo yg dari malaysia senang siti :), tapi skrang jarang siti datang ke indo buat konser?..g taula kenapa.. jadi kangen ma siti euy....:(
TheJuwitata 2 months ago
wats?
whos crazy comparing jacklyn wif agnes,agnes is suckkkkkkkkkkkkkk!
jaipunkrock 2 months ago
compare dgn salma r...baru syok.....agnes kompem mati tercekik..huahuahuahuahuahuahuahua
lanjer92 2 months ago
@lanjer92 indonesia masih punya lebih dri agnes... Ada => Gita Gitawa, Putri Ayu, Joy Tobing, Nania ect!!! Salma kalah... haha...
indoPOPLOVERS 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@lanjer92 indonesia masih punya lebih dri agnes... Ada => Gita Gitawa, Putri Ayu, Joy Tobing, Nania, Vina Panduinata, Dewi Sandra, Ruth Sahanaya, ect!!! Salma kalah... haha...
indoPOPLOVERS 2 months ago
Jacklyn punya suara lebih kuat but kaku .... Agnes lagunya lebih enak didengar ....
Jacklyn punya suara lebih tinggi but kaku ... Agnes improvisasinya lebih indah ...
lukman15081985 2 months ago
agnes miming jeeeeee....
mamaOamie 2 months ago
agnes miming only . loser
1055481 2 months ago
apaan tuh jaclyn victor banddingin ama rini idol jauh lebih bagus
girosimanjuntak 2 months ago
my gawd both the best man! i would love to see both of them battle each other. it sure will be epic.
fiqx87 2 months ago
jaclyn victor = nelly furtado
agnes monica = christina aguilera
thumbs up if you agree :)
suharsya 2 months ago
perfect!
PrincessKiryu 2 months ago
gue orang indonesia, tapi terus terang suara jeklin lebih bersih ketimbang agnes yg kedengaran seperti pecah. biarpun saya kurang ngerti bahasa malaysia. but i love both them :D
babilah83 2 months ago
nyatanya jaclyn nyanyiannya jauh lebih bagus kalau dibandingin dengan agnes..even agnes only lipped-singing masig ngak boleh melawan kehebatan vocal jaclyn yang tiada bandingannya..gue tetap bangga walaupun gue bukan org malaysia...kerana kita serumpun syabas Malaysia!!!!!!!!
omegared20081 2 months ago 2
@omegared20081 Terima kasih, saudara/saudari ku dari Indonesia :)
mimifakhira3005 2 months ago
perlu ke nk compare dua2 artis ni..dua2 hot okey
adamizkandar 2 months ago
Who r u to judge? yet, its ur own video, of course u will choose Agnes... As if ur forcing people to agree with ur opinion.... LOL
mikelnaru 2 months ago
@mikelnaru Btw, Jac's singing LIVE here, on the other hand Anges lipped-sing.
p.s: I loved both vocal actually, peace!
mikelnaru 2 months ago
Both best ...
gidong5109 2 months ago
dont ever ur compare my both favourite singer ok...
sam44710 2 months ago
Dari segi vokal, Jaclyn lebih bagus tetapi dari segi persembahan Agnes lebih baik.
LynCairo 2 months ago
jaclyn gue akui kalau nyanyi kayak diva..malah ngak keterlaluan jika gue katakan yang jaclyn punya suara dan kualitas vokal setanding dengan penyanyi intarnasional seperti withney houstan, celine dion dan mariah carey..syabas Malaysia!!!
omegared20081 2 months ago 18
jacklyn is better
sherwinmuzic 2 months ago
what!! agnes dibandingin ma org katro gini, suaranya blh melengking tp gaya? org buta aj yg blg Jv lbh keren ;-P
TheYiyi84 3 months ago
please make a video about agnes vs salma... hehehehe
XaverioJustinian 3 months ago 2
aku pun blh nyanyi kot lagu agnes tu... tp lagu jacklyn aku x berani bwk klu kat mn2 function coz tinggi power n mantop....!! yesss...!!!! go MALAYSIA ku yg POWER!!!!!
akufaradie 3 months ago
walaupun gue org indonesia..gue secara jujurnya tetap mengakui jaclyn mantop dan punya suara yang terbaik sekali bandingan agness yang suaranya biasa2 aja...syabas malaysia!!!!
omegared20081 3 months ago 29
tq...anda juga mantap...klau dibandingkan dua2 artis ini,pasti meletup habis kan?
sheelaputeh 2 months ago
Agnes Monica From INDONESIA The BEST !!!!!
Love INDONESIA
qaq23 3 months ago
agnes punya power vocal cukup bagus,, dan lagu yang dibawainnya punya tingkat kesulitan yang lumayan,, ngak banyak penyanyi yang mampu membawakannya,, selamat buat agnes,,
chamoets1 3 months ago
Well they all great ASEAN singers... If not they would not choosen to performed there... Love from Indonesia!
gunjakarta 3 months ago
i like both of them , but when jaclyn more into ballad i thing agnes more fit into r & b
fukutanable 3 months ago
I am from London.I think Jaclyn is more better than Agnes.But don't mind because they both are awesome!
LittleMonsters280296 3 months ago
BUT AGNES REALLY MAKE A GREAT AWESOME PRIDE OF INDONESIA
JulyTse 3 months ago
BRAVO TO TALENTED PEOPLE
JulyTse 3 months ago
i totally love and like Jacklyn Victor!!! im from the Philippines.. :)
AkoSiJade18 3 months ago
I'm Indonesian...in terms of vocal quality, Jacklyn won....
bungamentari 3 months ago
They Both are best in their way to perform. I like them both. Bravo Agnes and Jaclyn..
khristanto 3 months ago
BICARA TENTANG VOKAL? TENTULAH JACLYN VICTOR LEBIH BERTENAGA..TETAPI JIKA BICARA SOAL STYLO, SECARA PERIBADI SAYA MEMILIH AGNES..
Kamadudin 3 months ago
Comment removed
Kamadudin 3 months ago
Vokal ,,,India Malaysia Vs Cina Indonesia..
MsTerung 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
INDONESIA THE WORST SEA GAMES HOST EVER!!! >>>> JUST TYPE ( SEA Games 26 - Pencak Silat Final (Indonesia - Thailand) - what a shame gold medal ).....
TUMBS UP TO THE MYAMMAR ATHLETE FOR PROTECTING THAILAND ATHLETE FROM BEING HURT BY INDONESIAN'S DOG!!
THIS THING HAPPENED WHEN INDON PEOPLE LOVE TO DRINK "KOPI TAIK MUSANG"....THAT'S WHY THEY ACT LIKE ANIMAL...INDOG!! WOOFF!! WOFF....!!!
eijavy 3 months ago
hek eleh... 2 jer yg mampu??? ahaha... lawak la indonesia ni!!
shafiq9014 3 months ago
hahahaha..bgitu buruk suara agnes mau d bandingkan dengan jacklyn..hahaha...suara jamban punya agnes..
chentamocca0203 3 months ago
@chentamocca0203 jamban kau bunyi macam tu ke ? bez ah jamban kau..
liacokelat 3 months ago