My interpretation is that Caleb's mother hated his father. The father was abusive with Caleb and his mother so that's the first part of the story. His mother hated his father so much, that she turned Caleb in a person like his father ("He's the portrait of a man his mother drew to hate forever") so she could hate him, even when his father died. During his childhoood she was good with him, teached him good things, he wanted to "keep up the charade until the end" Thats it xD!
Caleb... One of those songs you both love and hate at the same time. You love it because it truly brings out the emotions of the actions, AND it sounds epic, but the message is so sad and dismal that it almost makes you sick emotionally... A hard song to describe, but no one can argue about the fact that it is a great song.
My interpretation of this song is that maybe the Caleb wasnt the biological son of his father: "His mother came up with such a clever way to save the day with a little white lie." And the father somehow knew it or had a clue and therefore hated him...And his mother couldnt get to love him for the same reason and calls him her "biggest shame" but yet wanted to "keep up the charade".
is it me who is hallucinating, or after Tony sings "in my suite in Hell..." around 4:13 there's an echo saying "Dana..Dana...Dana...". okay, it's just me hallucinating, but it sounds like it!
@Purebonestorm its about an abusive father, a son, and his mother that lied to him and basically turned him into his father, just so she could hate him long after his real father died.
The story of Caleb continues in Don't Say a Word, The End of This Chapter, and Juliet.
I am ACTUALLY the Caleb this was written about. If you are curious as to how this song came about, you can message me and then message the band. they will tell you the same. Almost everyone commenting on this song is waaay off the mark. They just so happen to come across my story. It has nothing to do with ditching country service to Finland
@thefallingdream i don't have any intentions on arguing or saying that your are or not the real caleb, as a matter of fact i believe that is possible. but the fact that sonata send the same history as you could easily means that they have already send it to you. but again i'm not saying is not you...
@hitmanieves its not me, i just talk shit to watch people go crazy. although my name really is caleb. hahahaha. as ive said, elementary fun maybe, but worth it. you should see how many people actually fly off the handle over such remarks. die hard fans and such. i got plenty of emails over this comment. I was cussed out on 4 occasions for it. hahahaha. humans are so interesting....in a bad way MOST of the time. if u can turn bad times into entertainment, u will be happier. hahaha, cheers
I've actually talked to Tony after a show. Yes, Jani not serving his military duties was only a small part of why they parted ways. But he told me it was more of a series of things than just that and didn't went into the details.
I think I got someting..."im sorry, only once as I remeber" "the child is not right he's my greatest shame"
I think the mother is the fathers SISTER or even his mother :O he raped her once..she got pregnant..the child is not right..and a lot of shame cuz of incest...
I love their songs! If you read all of the lyrics carefully, they all descibe and tell some really important situations and stories that can happen or have happended to all of us!
full moon, replica, power of one, victorias secret, the cage, the boy who wanted to be a real puppet, black sheep, 8th commandent, just to name a few, get all their albums you´ll like em, better yet look up Jani liimatainen, andall his projexts trust me, peace bro enjoy
yeah me either thats because theres no Jani influence he used to write most of the musci, which is who they got their sound, and they tried replacing him with this guy, whos more ofa shreadder no way its gonna be nearly as good
Yeah the only music i hate is country and rap everything else is pretty much awesome... I agree with Yamiimax every Sonata album has been musically and lyrically righteous in my opinion, and his i guess... :P
didnt mean nothing like that even thought i do like any thing like that i meant that impliing somthing like kiling a child in its sleep is something strong to say
why hate black metal? theres no point in hating an entire sub genre of music especialy with bands like hate forest as shining examples of the excellence that black metal has
yeah its wrong hating something i just ignore this sub genre i like melodic metal and i know that folk, pagan and viking metal has black elements but folk/pagan/viking sounds melodic same as i do not like pure death i also dislike (pure) black but i kinda like melodic death^^
@yamiimax It isn't wrong to hate someting, it's a feeling, a perspective; what is wrong is to use that hate as an excuse for our conscience to allow us to do stupid thins such as hurting people, lying, or believieng we have right to destroy whatever is that that we hate.
i like this, its a bit different, but ya know. i get who is who, and i like the sotry behind it. its nice. and the reaction to the question was completly uncalled for. i seriously dont understand why people cant just be nice to someone else?
You, Giannakaros, are the idiot. I'm a firm believer that you have to be some what intelligent to enjoy Power Metal, Prog Metal, ect... And you have proven that you are not intelligent, therefor, you shouldn't be watching this video in the first place. Jani asked an innocent question and your reaction was uncalled for and plain stupid. Good job.
Yes, I also think your reaction is really stupid, 'cause I think there isn't only one way to understand a song. Your truth is not the truth for everyone, so close your mouth
beautiful piano intro but a kind of screwed up song
cooner9898 1 week ago
beautiful....and sad and tragic. What a masterpeice
KacieHoltzinger 1 month ago
My name is Caleb :(
clubsandwich77 1 month ago
Such a deep story in an awesome song. Sonata Arctica knows how to pull it off. Great song.
ErikTheSwiftv2 2 months ago in playlist Liked videos
how do i live without the ones i love?
Mabd2009 2 months ago in playlist sonata historia
My interpretation is that Caleb's mother hated his father. The father was abusive with Caleb and his mother so that's the first part of the story. His mother hated his father so much, that she turned Caleb in a person like his father ("He's the portrait of a man his mother drew to hate forever") so she could hate him, even when his father died. During his childhoood she was good with him, teached him good things, he wanted to "keep up the charade until the end" Thats it xD!
BurnedDown914 2 months ago 2
If someday I have a son, I'll name him Caleb. Such an epic name :D
BurnedDown914 2 months ago
Caleb... One of those songs you both love and hate at the same time. You love it because it truly brings out the emotions of the actions, AND it sounds epic, but the message is so sad and dismal that it almost makes you sick emotionally... A hard song to describe, but no one can argue about the fact that it is a great song.
TheDarkMortality 2 months ago
@TheDarkMortality Ur right, but there's still ppl who can dislike this song. JB-girls, f.ex :(
7powermetal 2 months ago
hahahaha this song is a discription of my life i am caleb
relliksailsboats 3 months ago
My interpretation of this song is that maybe the Caleb wasnt the biological son of his father: "His mother came up with such a clever way to save the day with a little white lie." And the father somehow knew it or had a clue and therefore hated him...And his mother couldnt get to love him for the same reason and calls him her "biggest shame" but yet wanted to "keep up the charade".
RockmySoul11 3 months ago 7
@RockmySoul11 wow I had never looked at it this way! It's actually very interesting! That's very very likely :) you need many many thumbs up.
evanescence9314 3 months ago
@evanescence9314 Thank you dear!! :)
RockmySoul11 3 months ago
is it me who is hallucinating, or after Tony sings "in my suite in Hell..." around 4:13 there's an echo saying "Dana..Dana...Dana...". okay, it's just me hallucinating, but it sounds like it!
evanescence9314 3 months ago
@evanescence9314 He's certainly repeating something, but I'm pretty sure it's not Dana.
imtkain 3 months ago
@evanescence9314 I think that he's saying "hell"
minerva1210 3 months ago
Such emotion, this song is a masterpiece.
7powermetal 3 months ago
Have you noticed how Sonata Arctica can make any subject matter into an epic masterpiece?
Neoximax 4 months ago 15
my life story
pieman173 5 months ago
I Love this song =)
9999900004222 6 months ago 4
is this song about an exercutionor and his son? sorry for poor spelling and if this question has already been answered, thanks
Purebonestorm 7 months ago
@Purebonestorm its about an abusive father, a son, and his mother that lied to him and basically turned him into his father, just so she could hate him long after his real father died.
The story of Caleb continues in Don't Say a Word, The End of This Chapter, and Juliet.
Dare2bDumb 6 months ago 5
@Dare2bDumb ahk cool as cheers
Purebonestorm 6 months ago
Comment removed
Kuroine 7 months ago
I am ACTUALLY the Caleb this was written about. If you are curious as to how this song came about, you can message me and then message the band. they will tell you the same. Almost everyone commenting on this song is waaay off the mark. They just so happen to come across my story. It has nothing to do with ditching country service to Finland
thefallingdream 9 months ago
@thefallingdream i don't have any intentions on arguing or saying that your are or not the real caleb, as a matter of fact i believe that is possible. but the fact that sonata send the same history as you could easily means that they have already send it to you. but again i'm not saying is not you...
hitmanieves 7 months ago
@hitmanieves its not me, i just talk shit to watch people go crazy. although my name really is caleb. hahahaha. as ive said, elementary fun maybe, but worth it. you should see how many people actually fly off the handle over such remarks. die hard fans and such. i got plenty of emails over this comment. I was cussed out on 4 occasions for it. hahahaha. humans are so interesting....in a bad way MOST of the time. if u can turn bad times into entertainment, u will be happier. hahaha, cheers
thefallingdream 7 months ago
@thefallingdream then you must be a naughty man scaring that poor woman in the song "The End of This Chapter"
tomgynther 7 months ago
@tomgynther Then screaming things at her in "Don't Say a Word" and trying to murder her in "Juliet" :P
SuperrSparky 7 months ago
@tomgynther And the sick fuck in don't say a word
pipanakakka 6 months ago
@tomgynther LMAO!!! Well played... Although I am naughty, HA!
thefallingdream 6 months ago
I am Caleb and this sounds about right to me
darkmark61 9 months ago
I Love and hate the feelings Sonata Arctica produce me >.< Damn songs that strike my heart and release my supressed emotion XD I really love them!
katvert 10 months ago
Man, if I ever get kids I want to name my son Caleb, I just love the name so much <3
vampireshadow1990 10 months ago
3 people are the Father.
SuperWillie900 11 months ago
HAHAHA my names Caleb!
Normalcheese 11 months ago
I've actually talked to Tony after a show. Yes, Jani not serving his military duties was only a small part of why they parted ways. But he told me it was more of a series of things than just that and didn't went into the details.
amarao77 1 year ago
If you look at the bottom right of album cover, there is an outline of a person's face. (Possibly Caleb's)
thelivingbrain123 1 year ago
Kinda let down on the outro but the solo was totally amazing and should have been longer. =P
SilentStormBand 1 year ago
@SilentStormBand *agree
ChienesSaventPas 1 year ago
3:36 EPIC PART....
wyctreman 1 year ago 3
5:00 hasta el final...
Breuco 1 year ago
a ok XD
magofelpanera 1 year ago
dove è il testo??,c'è scritto lyrics
magofelpanera 1 year ago
@magofelpanera lol nelle informazioni..xD
ItalianShinja 1 year ago
This song is amazing beyond belief
evilemonattack 1 year ago
AGUANTE CALEB
1555658505 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I think I got someting..."im sorry, only once as I remeber" "the child is not right he's my greatest shame"
I think the mother is the fathers SISTER or even his mother :O he raped her once..she got pregnant..the child is not right..and a lot of shame cuz of incest...
Comments?
89ABO 1 year ago
I love their songs! If you read all of the lyrics carefully, they all descibe and tell some really important situations and stories that can happen or have happended to all of us!
EmberBurn333 1 year ago
Muahahaah Funy doode
SonataProFAN 1 year ago
a thousand times better than the new album.
Sorry to say.
Frankyavalone 1 year ago
All Sonata is best,all songs from them!
Greetings from Finland !!
MrFinlandian 2 years ago
the solo is amazing!! :D
losodioatodos360 2 years ago 10
my favourites songs are shy,tallulah,fullmoon,shamandaile,letter to dana,flag in the ground,last amazin grays and the power of one
LiThe96 2 years ago 2
@LiThe96 Replica and kingdom for a heart are great too, sweeeeeet metal
pespiz2000 2 years ago
@LiThe96
The End of This Chapter can whoop those anyday :))
Bugholeexcalibur 1 year ago
few more song's shy and tallulah are also very good >:3
KibaNoKaze 2 years ago 4
Wonderfull song, great Lyriks, made me sad, but glad to be allive.
Greatings from Germany.
ravenslegacy 2 years ago
Just started listening to this band since yesterday , they are unique and sound very good :D
can any1 reccomend me any songs ?
metalmayhem007 2 years ago
almost every1 of their songs are at least worth of listenning :)
iippari 2 years ago 4
yeah i like nearly all the songs i've heard so far, not really into the slow songs (not my thing as i'm into fast paced stuff like thrash metal)
metalmayhem007 2 years ago
white pearl, black oseans=)
sonataarctica777 2 years ago 2
The Last Amazing Grays, Flag in the Ground, Full moon, Paid in Full and In Black and white are my favorites
lqleviathan 2 years ago 3
paid in full, full moon, last drop falls, broken, ruins of my life, tallulah, wolf & raven, i could go on forever haha its an awesome band
Marcelolarsen 2 years ago 4
just listen from the first album to the last...every song has their unique style and thats what makes them an awesome band..
warlord070 2 years ago
full moon, replica, power of one, victorias secret, the cage, the boy who wanted to be a real puppet, black sheep, 8th commandent, just to name a few, get all their albums you´ll like em, better yet look up Jani liimatainen, andall his projexts trust me, peace bro enjoy
KenMxRockero 2 years ago
thanks i've heard those, been listening to a lot of their stuff , not really into their new stuff yet though
metalmayhem007 2 years ago
yeah me either thats because theres no Jani influence he used to write most of the musci, which is who they got their sound, and they tried replacing him with this guy, whos more ofa shreadder no way its gonna be nearly as good
KenMxRockero 2 years ago
Yeah the only music i hate is country and rap everything else is pretty much awesome... I agree with Yamiimax every Sonata album has been musically and lyrically righteous in my opinion, and his i guess... :P
BringerOfOmnipotence 2 years ago 3
3:44-4:14...no words can describe the epicness of that verse
kinoc12 2 years ago 3
fuck me
ciluffo321 2 years ago
caleb strode and jacob pickey are gay and they have sextuplets
ciluffo321 2 years ago
2:26 - 2:55 ftw!
MuffinWithAnAxe 2 years ago
After I've listened to ALL of your Sonata Arctica videos, I got a new favourite band!! =D
BloodElvis 2 years ago
this song is so awesome I listened to it 10 times and if anyone says this song is boring well to hell with them
zuhead100 2 years ago 6
yeah i must listen to it few times to understand the greatness of this album but Winterhearts Guild is still my fav album of Sonata
just my opinion but i think all album of Sonata have nearly the same level of creativity (musically and lyrically) to make this band unique
yamiimax 2 years ago 3
New album in September I think...soon anyway. :D
MudTide1993 2 years ago
yeah single comes out now... today^^
oh must look^^
yamiimax 2 years ago
3:44 to 4:14 = <3 Tony has the greatest voice ive ever heard
ChronosTheDemon 2 years ago 4
tony said that in the next album "the stalker we've known as Caleb returns to meet his maker"
i'm quite curious about it.
LordPetee 2 years ago
caleb is the father but later on when the son becomes like the father he becomes caleb himself
baterosinalma 2 years ago
Just turn his head when the kid is still and has a weak neck.
man that is a hard thing to say in a song and is not even death metal
baterosinalma 2 years ago
lol i dont understand this sentence in the song can you explain?
yamiimax 2 years ago
it means he want to break his neck
baterosinalma 2 years ago
so i guess you like death metal too?
Its hard to understand this sentance clearly
im not really like death metal but i really hate black metal
yamiimax 2 years ago
didnt mean nothing like that even thought i do like any thing like that i meant that impliing somthing like kiling a child in its sleep is something strong to say
baterosinalma 2 years ago
why hate black metal? theres no point in hating an entire sub genre of music especialy with bands like hate forest as shining examples of the excellence that black metal has
vallecaucano114 2 years ago
yeah its wrong hating something i just ignore this sub genre i like melodic metal and i know that folk, pagan and viking metal has black elements but folk/pagan/viking sounds melodic same as i do not like pure death i also dislike (pure) black but i kinda like melodic death^^
yamiimax 2 years ago
@yamiimax It isn't wrong to hate someting, it's a feeling, a perspective; what is wrong is to use that hate as an excuse for our conscience to allow us to do stupid thins such as hurting people, lying, or believieng we have right to destroy whatever is that that we hate.
katvert 10 months ago
I believe caleb is the father and the boy. the boy took his fathers name.
NativeSamurai8 2 years ago
i cant help me it remind me of this amok runnings these days
yamiimax 2 years ago
i like this, its a bit different, but ya know. i get who is who, and i like the sotry behind it. its nice. and the reaction to the question was completly uncalled for. i seriously dont understand why people cant just be nice to someone else?
Nessie0Loves0Jacob 2 years ago 5
Is Caleb the father or the boy?
JaniLiimatainenFan 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
You sir are an idiot. It's both the father and the son.They both got the same fucking name fucking get it motherfucker?
GiannakarosMaiden 2 years ago
I see. But saying "fuck" three times in a sentence is more of a sign of idiocy than asking a normal question about lyrics
JaniLiimatainenFan 2 years ago 35
This has been flagged as spam show
This sir makes no sense.Fail.
GiannakarosMaiden 2 years ago
@JaniLiimatainenFan Do you know why Jani left the band?
RavenHinamori 1 year ago
@RavenHinamori
Wasn't it something about skipping out on mandatory military service?
Naresomez 1 year ago
@Naresomez He didn't do his civil duty to Finland or something...
DancingInDreamWorld 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
You, Giannakaros, are the idiot. I'm a firm believer that you have to be some what intelligent to enjoy Power Metal, Prog Metal, ect... And you have proven that you are not intelligent, therefor, you shouldn't be watching this video in the first place. Jani asked an innocent question and your reaction was uncalled for and plain stupid. Good job.
NitroThunderForce 2 years ago 37
Yes, I also think your reaction is really stupid, 'cause I think there isn't only one way to understand a song. Your truth is not the truth for everyone, so close your mouth
kysennah 2 years ago 4
"Known to us from this day on like his father, Caleb"
Caleb is the father.
shseat 2 years ago
no Caleb is the son, but they named him after his father.
CellPhoneMern 2 years ago
I love this song <3
Saaharaa 3 years ago 7
I remember the sillent hill whit this song
sonatanighwish 3 years ago 3
Silent hill??? WoW, you mean the film or the games???
Kr0n808 3 years ago 3
the game , on special the origins only the intro
sonatanighwish 3 years ago 4
the game origins
sonatanighwish 2 years ago 4
I got silent hill origins :D
BaalsBrother 2 years ago
4:14 the first part of the 'solo' is awesome :3
steffy1992 3 years ago 6