This song is completely different from the Laura Nyro music I have been listening to for the last week (essentially every song on You Tube). What a new dimension. It reminds me of Joni Mitchell's Hissing of Summer Lawns, but is not derivative of her style, if that makes sense. Another amazing feat of this wonderful artist.
I don't think any Actress or Singer should try to play her in a live action film, no one even comes close i.m.h.o. If they must do a bio movie, I'd prefer an animated one, kinda like "Persepolis", I really like that film. I think Eliza Jane Schneider could perhaps catch a bit of the essence of her speaking voice, and of course the songs would be DEFINITELY need to be the original recordings.
Ultimately tho, I just wish we had more footage of the REAL Laura!
Sorry everyone, I have only just found this video and comment thread. Is someone actually going to do a film about Laura or are just just discussing what it would/should be like. I'm not going to get too excited just in case!!
@atisaseret - Most films have actors play the musicians in question, not other musicians. In Laura's case, a good candidate would be Heather Matarazzo who looks like her.
@DaysOfBrokenArrows - While that's true, it would be better, in my opinion, if someone could actually Sing and Play Laura's composition - that in itself, is a pretty mean feat! While Heather (who's also a Long Island Native) looks a little like Laura, it would be preferable to someone who can not only Act, but do everything across the Board. I'll try to keep an Open Mind -
this is an overlooked album. you should hear her "I am the Blues" on this album. I remember the Village Voice music critic saying when the album came out that only Laura Nyro could sing I am the blues. It is an amazing piece. Even more amazing when she sang it live.
I think I was responsible for that suggestion 4 months ago :D
I agree with you that no single person could play her. I therefore suggest Polly Harvey, Amy Winehouse and Laura Marling to all play her in the same movie, as in the Dylan biopic "I'm Not There".
That's a very good point. My 3 choices are all British, Laura was half Italian, half Jewish-Russian with, presumably, a New York Bronx accent. Hmm. Let's call the whole thing off & just listen to her magical records. :)
@SteveMorrisBala personally I really don't think anyone can play Laura Nyro at this point. Amy Winehouse is out - as far as I'm concerned -she's NOTHING like Laura except for having Long, Dark Hair. Polly Harvey's songs are Dark mostly (which I like), but her style is very different from Nyro's. I do know someone who's played her on Broadway, and AT THE TIME, looked (and sounded a bit) like Laura - JUDY KUHN. Several Female Singers got together and did a Broadway Show called: ELI'S COMING..
@atisaseret I don't think that Amy Winehouse could ever play Laura Nyro - I'm friends with 2 people who were close friends of Laura's and knew her in a very personal way - and from their recollections, photos - I KNOW those people mentioned to play her cculd NEVER portray the REAL Laura Nyro. Pity
This is ANOTHER GREAT LAURA NYRO SONG - she is INCOMPARABLE!
@neverforeverkate@atisaseret - Most films have actors play the musicians in question, not other musicians. In Laura's case, a good candidate would be Heather Matarazzo who looks like her.
@atisaseret - Most films have actors play the musicians in question, not other musicians. In Laura's case, a good candidate would be Heather Matarazzo who looks like her.
Just got a notice that the album this tune is on, Mother Spiritual will be re-issued in afew days.. check out Amazon.. cd was un available long time.. I cherish my copy.. and the original lp, too.
I can't think of anyone known that could play Laura.She was unique.She was totally unHollywood...Ya know...this is gonna sound crazy,but I think Amy Winehouse,if she was healthier,could do this some justice....maybe???????
I think you have a point. I think Laura was a prototype for artists like Amy. This is the first time I've heard this song, the title caught my eye. It's great! :-)
I've never heard this one,and I'm a huge fan from back in the day...WOW!!!!A real treat.I love her sentiments on this one,particuliarly these days when so much seems unreal and disconnecting to whom anyone really is.
yes , of course ,u and i are the both of us " free thinkers " ...and laura ...well...hey now !...check my favorites list....talk about ecclectic....! i know u got soul...
She is so consistently great! she is missed, she could make her songs intricate and yet easy to listen to. ???? If their was a movie and it was done really good...who would you cast as Laura.
Hi, I am glad you're a fan of Laura as well. I don't know exactly who I would cast for Laura. Maybe Jennifer Connelly? They probably would have to cast an unknown.
This blows me away... I only see a space in front of me...and I'm moving...moving... my body is dancing and my smile is leading...
TheDaniel1916 2 months ago
This song is completely different from the Laura Nyro music I have been listening to for the last week (essentially every song on You Tube). What a new dimension. It reminds me of Joni Mitchell's Hissing of Summer Lawns, but is not derivative of her style, if that makes sense. Another amazing feat of this wonderful artist.
DenJamMac3 3 months ago
I don't think any Actress or Singer should try to play her in a live action film, no one even comes close i.m.h.o. If they must do a bio movie, I'd prefer an animated one, kinda like "Persepolis", I really like that film. I think Eliza Jane Schneider could perhaps catch a bit of the essence of her speaking voice, and of course the songs would be DEFINITELY need to be the original recordings.
Ultimately tho, I just wish we had more footage of the REAL Laura!
Lovemylovething 3 months ago
Sorry everyone, I have only just found this video and comment thread. Is someone actually going to do a film about Laura or are just just discussing what it would/should be like. I'm not going to get too excited just in case!!
BARNAPE 1 year ago
@atisaseret - Most films have actors play the musicians in question, not other musicians. In Laura's case, a good candidate would be Heather Matarazzo who looks like her.
DaysOfBrokenArrows 1 year ago
@DaysOfBrokenArrows - While that's true, it would be better, in my opinion, if someone could actually Sing and Play Laura's composition - that in itself, is a pretty mean feat! While Heather (who's also a Long Island Native) looks a little like Laura, it would be preferable to someone who can not only Act, but do everything across the Board. I'll try to keep an Open Mind -
atisaseret 1 year ago
@atisaseret - Long Islander (I Live here) didn't mean that Laura Nyro is a Long Islander - she's from the Bronx. Sorry about the confusion.
atisaseret 1 year ago
IST SONGS>ELI>NY TENT..>GONNA TAKE A MIRICLE MASTERPEICES THEN ALL DOWNHILL
arundelthomas 1 year ago
awesome tune. i'm just discovering it this evening!
Agoateeman 1 year ago 2
@Agoateeman Awww I remember the first time I discovered this song. I found very nostalgic for some strange reasons.
neverforeverkate 1 year ago
this is an overlooked album. you should hear her "I am the Blues" on this album. I remember the Village Voice music critic saying when the album came out that only Laura Nyro could sing I am the blues. It is an amazing piece. Even more amazing when she sang it live.
mervie2 1 year ago 2
@mervie2
I totally agree. Many people forget about this album. It has many gems.
neverforeverkate 1 year ago
The music of Laura Nyro is fantastic! More of this album please!
BoyleInn 1 year ago
I've never heard this one before. Great LN song. Thank you for posting. Makes me miss the 70's so much.
Gertrudis67 1 year ago
I've heard that PJ Harvey might be a candidate. She's a singer from the UK.
Personally, I can't even begin to imagine anyone like Laura. She was so gifted and so far beyond and INCOMPARABLE.
atisaseret 2 years ago 3
@atisaseret
I think I was responsible for that suggestion 4 months ago :D
I agree with you that no single person could play her. I therefore suggest Polly Harvey, Amy Winehouse and Laura Marling to all play her in the same movie, as in the Dylan biopic "I'm Not There".
SteveMorrisBala 1 year ago
@SteveMorrisBala Wow, those dialect coaches would have their work cut out, I think.Have you actually heard Amy speak?
candelise 1 year ago
@candelise (I used to be SteveMorrisBala)
That's a very good point. My 3 choices are all British, Laura was half Italian, half Jewish-Russian with, presumably, a New York Bronx accent. Hmm. Let's call the whole thing off & just listen to her magical records. :)
gwranda 1 year ago
@SteveMorrisBala personally I really don't think anyone can play Laura Nyro at this point. Amy Winehouse is out - as far as I'm concerned -she's NOTHING like Laura except for having Long, Dark Hair. Polly Harvey's songs are Dark mostly (which I like), but her style is very different from Nyro's. I do know someone who's played her on Broadway, and AT THE TIME, looked (and sounded a bit) like Laura - JUDY KUHN. Several Female Singers got together and did a Broadway Show called: ELI'S COMING..
atisaseret 1 year ago 4
@atisaseret I don't think that Amy Winehouse could ever play Laura Nyro - I'm friends with 2 people who were close friends of Laura's and knew her in a very personal way - and from their recollections, photos - I KNOW those people mentioned to play her cculd NEVER portray the REAL Laura Nyro. Pity
This is ANOTHER GREAT LAURA NYRO SONG - she is INCOMPARABLE!
atisaseret 1 year ago
@atisaseret I love Pj Harvey. Shes one of my favs. She was pretty big during the whole grunge scene.
neverforeverkate 1 year ago
@neverforeverkate I have to admit that I do like her myself, but I'm hung up on Laura Nyro - she's SO Incomparable.
atisaseret 1 year ago
@neverforeverkate @atisaseret - Most films have actors play the musicians in question, not other musicians. In Laura's case, a good candidate would be Heather Matarazzo who looks like her.
DaysOfBrokenArrows 1 year ago
@DaysOfBrokenArrows I don't think Heather Matarazzo looks like Laura. This is just my opinion.
neverforeverkate 1 year ago
@atisaseret - Most films have actors play the musicians in question, not other musicians. In Laura's case, a good candidate would be Heather Matarazzo who looks like her.
DaysOfBrokenArrows 1 year ago
Oh, yes... :)
iamcora1 2 years ago
mmmmmmmmmmm . . . Laura's voice is as smoooooth as sex on a stick! She certainly was is) way out there ahead of the musical pack!
Toyboy789 2 years ago
goddess
MarionBartoliFanBlog 2 years ago
More than 40 years since I first heard her. Still the sweetest songbird in the meadow!!! Incomparable, Unequaled,
Simply the best of the best!!!
aquamoon22 2 years ago
@aquamoon22 Totally !!!!!
philgar5 1 year ago
After 40 years - Still the sweetest songbird in the meadow!!!
Incomparable, Unequaled, Simply the BEST!!!
aquamoon22 2 years ago 2
The more I listen to it the better I feel tonight.God Bless Laura...still healing my artist,creative,marginalized self
ToeIn2194 2 years ago 2
I love that song Sophia. I might upload it.
neverforeverkate 2 years ago
Just got a notice that the album this tune is on, Mother Spiritual will be re-issued in afew days.. check out Amazon.. cd was un available long time.. I cherish my copy.. and the original lp, too.
vsibirsky 2 years ago
I can't think of anyone known that could play Laura.She was unique.She was totally unHollywood...Ya know...this is gonna sound crazy,but I think Amy Winehouse,if she was healthier,could do this some justice....maybe???????
ToeIn2194 2 years ago 2
I think you have a point. I think Laura was a prototype for artists like Amy. This is the first time I've heard this song, the title caught my eye. It's great! :-)
heru1966 2 years ago
I dont think so just because nyro's voice is several keys higher then winehouse.
quamquat92 2 years ago
NO, NOT MAYBE!.. NOT AT ALL!!!!!!
candelise 2 years ago
Are you kidding or what. I like AW, but not even close.
aquamoon22 2 years ago
Yes it sounds crazy because it IS CRAZY!!
candelise 2 years ago
I've never heard this one,and I'm a huge fan from back in the day...WOW!!!!A real treat.I love her sentiments on this one,particuliarly these days when so much seems unreal and disconnecting to whom anyone really is.
ToeIn2194 2 years ago
The effect she has on me is total and indescribable. No other singer/songwriter grabs me the way Laura does. Magic Time!
I miss her.
brink1000 2 years ago 2
yes , of course ,u and i are the both of us " free thinkers " ...and laura ...well...hey now !...check my favorites list....talk about ecclectic....! i know u got soul...
nedmanxxx 2 years ago 2
back at ya, fellow music lover...isn't Laura devastating?
brink1000 2 years ago 5
Absolutely!
neverforeverkate 2 years ago
lol You're welcome.
neverforeverkate 3 years ago
She is so consistently great! she is missed, she could make her songs intricate and yet easy to listen to. ???? If their was a movie and it was done really good...who would you cast as Laura.
Aslanspal 3 years ago 3
Hi, I am glad you're a fan of Laura as well. I don't know exactly who I would cast for Laura. Maybe Jennifer Connelly? They probably would have to cast an unknown.
neverforeverkate 3 years ago
Jennifer wold be great...
wish I could see her again...
the best EVER our dear Laura!
tribecalofter 2 years ago