This is proof that the drumming can be over the top (bad) - even in this great tune. Superchunk or no - the drummer sounds horrible. Check out the version where Bob is accompanied by Brendan Canty (Fugazi) on the drums. It's a far better version!
Sadly, I missed out on the Huskers magic back in the day, not having discovered the band properly until 1991. This song's their bittersweet meisterwerk. Is it my imagination, or did they play Glastonbury sometime in the late 80's?
That's Superchuck drummer, Jon Wurster. Bet you feel bad now you elitist indie snobs. Who the fuck cares! Next you'll be nitpicking that it it's not authentic Husker because Bob isn't 400 pounds. You guys are dumb. Be glad Bob still plays the song.
This drummer is so NOT in the pocket :( and he plays so fucking loud .. All we hear are those STUPID needless cymbals on every other beat.. So Buddy: Calm down #1, and #2 lock it in. You're RUINING the song. Go back and listen to the way GRANT grooves :|
Well noticed. When did Grant needlessly bash away at the hi-hat while overstating the obvious on the crash? He needs to go back to 16-Beat school, where the groove to this song would have been taught in lesson one. And fills? Sad to see such sacred material desecrated in such a way. :)
Yeah; the song is going way to fast for its' own beat... Big Drill Car covers this song, and does it very well! It's on their new release "A never-ending endeavor" Check em out!
I'm pretty sure that the drummer playing is Brendan Canty of Fugazi, who is a more technical (ie - better) drummer than Grant Hart (nothing against Grant). If the "drums are too loud" then it's the sound guy's fault. If it's too fast, then you're too old. It's a punk rock song played at punk rock speed.
I don't think that is Brendan. Brendan has only played a handful of live shows with Bob (mostly a few years ago). This guy is not as technical as Brendan, but he sure does have a lot of energy!
Sure, you raise a valid point.. But it does not explain away the fact that this drummer is just not swinging the groove like Grant did, tho he's got real good chops. ..Grant was a HUGE reason that people liked husker du. He was a very nimble, fairly light-hitting, interesting drummer, and he really respected the groove. Being groovy is what set them apart, if you ask me.. But I'm just ranting now.. Plus I just detest crash cymbals; they are vile beasts that have no business living amongst us
Damn. Bob is really gaining power with this stuff. Husker punk has really aged wonderfully. What a deeply-ingrained memory this band is. When those songs were new, we were young and really passionate about this stuff. Like it meant everything to be showered in feedback and that WHITE blaze of stagelight. That V. Greg's uber-dork 'scissors kicks.' What a celebration.
Well said. I love how Bob's playing his Husker & Sugar material along with his killer solo songs when he plays live. I hope he keeps on playing & composing for a long time.
it's not authentic hüsker dü, because Bob is not overweight.
heroiniskindacool 7 months ago
Jon is having so much fun. I would too. Respect the guy.
chefragoo 8 months ago
This is proof that the drumming can be over the top (bad) - even in this great tune. Superchunk or no - the drummer sounds horrible. Check out the version where Bob is accompanied by Brendan Canty (Fugazi) on the drums. It's a far better version!
garagerocks 1 year ago
Comment removed
garagerocks 1 year ago
Sadly, I missed out on the Huskers magic back in the day, not having discovered the band properly until 1991. This song's their bittersweet meisterwerk. Is it my imagination, or did they play Glastonbury sometime in the late 80's?
spuffchops70 2 years ago
That's Superchuck drummer, Jon Wurster. Bet you feel bad now you elitist indie snobs. Who the fuck cares! Next you'll be nitpicking that it it's not authentic Husker because Bob isn't 400 pounds. You guys are dumb. Be glad Bob still plays the song.
leonardkilledteddy 2 years ago 3
Bob rules, but the Drummer is so loud. Grant and Greg please come back !!! I would do everything for a Reunion !!!!
mackusch 2 years ago
This drummer is so NOT in the pocket :( and he plays so fucking loud .. All we hear are those STUPID needless cymbals on every other beat.. So Buddy: Calm down #1, and #2 lock it in. You're RUINING the song. Go back and listen to the way GRANT grooves :|
nonewmccarthyism 2 years ago 10
Well noticed. When did Grant needlessly bash away at the hi-hat while overstating the obvious on the crash? He needs to go back to 16-Beat school, where the groove to this song would have been taught in lesson one. And fills? Sad to see such sacred material desecrated in such a way. :)
Gingalib 2 years ago 2
Yeah; the song is going way to fast for its' own beat... Big Drill Car covers this song, and does it very well! It's on their new release "A never-ending endeavor" Check em out!
nakedgun93 2 years ago
I'm pretty sure that the drummer playing is Brendan Canty of Fugazi, who is a more technical (ie - better) drummer than Grant Hart (nothing against Grant). If the "drums are too loud" then it's the sound guy's fault. If it's too fast, then you're too old. It's a punk rock song played at punk rock speed.
martkra 2 years ago
I don't think that is Brendan. Brendan has only played a handful of live shows with Bob (mostly a few years ago). This guy is not as technical as Brendan, but he sure does have a lot of energy!
gravelyma 2 years ago
have you considered the volume of the drums/cymbals its to do with the recording?
strooka 1 year ago
Sure, you raise a valid point.. But it does not explain away the fact that this drummer is just not swinging the groove like Grant did, tho he's got real good chops. ..Grant was a HUGE reason that people liked husker du. He was a very nimble, fairly light-hitting, interesting drummer, and he really respected the groove. Being groovy is what set them apart, if you ask me.. But I'm just ranting now.. Plus I just detest crash cymbals; they are vile beasts that have no business living amongst us
nonewmccarthyism 1 year ago
Comment removed
nonewmccarthyism 2 years ago
Damn. Bob is really gaining power with this stuff. Husker punk has really aged wonderfully. What a deeply-ingrained memory this band is. When those songs were new, we were young and really passionate about this stuff. Like it meant everything to be showered in feedback and that WHITE blaze of stagelight. That V. Greg's uber-dork 'scissors kicks.' What a celebration.
kc7fys 3 years ago 2
Well said. I love how Bob's playing his Husker & Sugar material along with his killer solo songs when he plays live. I hope he keeps on playing & composing for a long time.
p4horror 3 years ago