Added: 1 year ago
From: guihoiticica
Views: 413,878
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,239)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Desafina un poquito no? xd

  • this woman has made a career as a people?

  • OHHHHHHHH NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

  • i dont care how she sings. she sings alive,no lipsync. thats a plast.

  • she only sound good with autotune but still a hottie

  • Omg

  • people are you all deaf? the only "weird" part was " your so hypnotizing"

    this version is much mor authentic than the one on the record! vocally it was not her best during the verses but she killed it at 3:06 +

    just because she's singing in another style this doesn't mean it's bad/she can't sing.

    and we all know she can sing as we saw her on x factor with the one that got away or all her old thinking of you videos or her MTV Unplugged show, right? Right! And now get the fuck off katys stage!

  • Acho que os noobs não perceberam que ela está cantando em outro tom. '-'

  • Half the people in these comments are fucking stupid. You're all probably saying it sounds bad because it's not like the album version. Here's a little hint: Most artists don't perform songs like they do on the albums. I actually really like this performance because it's obvious she had fun with it. She wasn't out of tune, out of key or bad. She still sounded good, it's just different.

  • am i the only one that thinks 3:05 is amazing ?

  • katy perry <3 if you listen till the end she is actually amazing.

  • To everyone who like this vid try to here the real one, and then this peaace shit after. I will ensure your'll change your mind.

  • Bad

  • so much gaga fans here :|

  • katy perry gives a new meaning to the word UNTALENTED

  • It amazes the fuckout of me how you can't find 1 good performance by this girl,her dancing is pathetic,her voice is got man in it andshe tries to be funny and shit and she can't even do that and she made 44 million in 2011??? Man she better be glad her face is cute as hell that is until she opens her mouth and a studio because if it wasn't for that and I am not talking about her body because its weird to except her boobs.Her deception skills are what rises to the top,she is a master at that

  • @jp221073 Are you ten years old or just a fucking retard? I really want to know.

  • I sing the song better

  • it sucks so much oh my gosh!

  • wtf

  • her eyes is green???

  • worst singer ever....

  • wtf

  • She is a piece of shit!!!

  • Che figa.

  • @nothingciop

    l'unico commento sensato ;-)

  • @u2b3r4o Eh beh, grazie! Magari ha cantato male per via della stanchezza o stava male, ma rimane figa!

  • MY EARS ARE BLEEDING

  • wtf ???

  • See that Walmart Soundcheck video on the right. Click that now. ->>

  • my ears are bleeding. 

  • Ouch !!!! Whats heard can not be unheard .....

  • Stop hating people, this is just a bad performance of her, all of artist have at least one. She is amazing live, and if you dont belive go check her performance on Mtv Unplugged, or Walmart, or Victoria Secret Fashion Show... All the people can hear she has a strong voice!

  • What happens in this performance is that it goes from worse to good. 3:08 is quiet epic actually.

  • This gave me a headache -.-

  • I kind feel bad for the people that paid to see this... -_-

  • just fabulous!...

  • Pretty good post.

  • okayyyyyyy dis is coolllllll yehaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

  • youtube.com/watch?v=18oYGsmUpr­M

    find 1M difference!!!

  • Comment removed

  • LOL, this is actually funny, i can't belive she win best live on EMA's, EMA obviously cheat couse Gaga should win all awards, and then EMA give these awards to poor Katy Perry and Justin Beaver :)

  • I'm crying right now...Because she can't sing.

  • Ema's Best Live? No guy! GaGa Is Better!

  • EPIC FAIL

  • woa.i could not believe this voice won ema's best live :-O.

  • this ish. gaga has eeveha a messed up, disgustipmancke this. You could tell katy tried to fix her vocals, but it only made it worse :/ NICE TRY!

  • this is horroristic o.O she could kill with her live voice...

  • she cant sing live :/

  • Never judge an artist just by one live. IT'S KATY PERRY BITCH. And if u wanna proofs of her talent, watch it: /watch?v=P-_arx-IfyU

  • Computer's miracles. That's what is Katy Perry .

  • come on... even this is not a hard piece to sing! maybe she should try Jingle Bells...

  • Gaga is beter

  • @mehdidufrasne Katy perry is 100x better than Lady gaga

  • @Rishita81 /watch?v=oP8SrlbpJ5A watch that and try to say that sentence again (if you wanna skip the intro go to 1:30).

  • @mehdidufrasne Who the fuck cares? Listen to them both. I do.

  • @mehdidufrasne Gaga is fucking awful live and most of the time she lip syncs

  • omg omg omg..she really cant sing live...her voice sound terrible live...thats why she never win grammys..lol

  • russel brandt is an ALIEN

  • Hellooo, is just beauty :/ where is voice? C'mon

  • @fanylaia The sad thing is that she's caked in make-up too...

  • okay she started in the wrong key. eeee

  • so good!

    

  • C'mon, she's can't sing!

  • What computers wont do ... Though i enjoy her songs...But for real.. Computers are a miracle to man kind :)

  • this is complete shit

  • Katy is amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • LOOL SHE DOESN'T KNOW TO SING THIS SONG LOOK AT THIS THIS IS DEC 10 20 10.THIS SONG HASN'T CAME OTU TILL 2011. DUMBASES. SHE'S EXPEMRMENTING YOU COULDN'T DENIE HER VOCALS AT THE STRONG PARTS.

  • @CheesyYellowCrumbles This song was out in 2010 on her album. The only thing new was the music video and Kanye's part.

  • @CheesyYellowCrumbles lol, please don't be kidding, she rls Teenage Dream in 2010, do u know anything about her bad vocal ?

  • imsick of people saying people cant sing live if they couldnt sing they wouldnt be famous for singing if u think ur so good make a video of u singing and put it on youtube cause thats how katy became famous all of u r faggots

  • SING???????????????????????

  • I agree, I think it's the song choice.. not her. Even Adele loves Katy Perry's voice, it's very powerful. it's just her stupid songs. her looks just make her appeal more to audiences and that's a powerful aid nowadays

  • Can u sing better than she? Do a video and show how much better you sing haha :) If she don't sings well tell me why she's one of the most famous sings in the world, tell me why she won too much awars, tell me why she reach the #1 on billboard. She's amazing, haters gun hate.

  • @kamyleregina She's one of the most famous singers because she wears tight clothes and shows off her body

  • @FireRubies1 watch?v=g-DpB4M3e7U&feature=re­lated It's her voice. I Like it. If you don't like just close the video and stop hatin ;)

  • Is this meant to be good?

  • This is just fucking awful

  • Shes hot (:

  • a voz dela e muito foda c ela nao existise tinha que ser inventada,parabens katy...

  • canta mal heim??

  • canta mal heim??

  • gostosa!

  • 0:20 measuring my size. you know what i mean, or do you?

  • ALL OF U SHUT UP KATY IS THE BEST SINGER IVE EVER HEARD IN MY LIFE !

    AND LIKE ANY OF U PPL R BETTER THAN HER . PSH NO! SHES AWESOME I LUV HER SHE HAS AN AMAZING VOICE SO RESPECT THT AND IF U LIKE IT THEN DONT LEAVE A MEAN COMMENT !

  • this is a bad live, but YES, she can sing live !

  • o god katy, =[

  • Face it: She cant sing live.

  • Yeah, she can sing. Look up "ET Katy Perry Walmart" and then come back here and thumbs up my comment. lol

  • Linda, você é demais!

  • HAHAHAHAH I WAS AT THE JINGLE BALL IN BOSTON AND SHE SUCKED!

  • She has amazing voice, but the flow is very bad here.

  • Haha guys this is Dec 10. She didn't know how to sing this song. She's jsut experiminting guys.. Give her a fucking break no ones perfect, Dickheads -,-

  • the album version is beautiful but why is it she butchers her own songs live? first firework now ET? damn i thought she would make this one prove the haters wrong smh

  • she can sing this song : see E.T. Live walmart soundcheck

  • @pedfurlan1 Thanks, that was a really good tip...unfortunately this was the first thing I saw when I looked for ET performed live and I found it really depressing. :< Guess this was just a blah venue/performance! Walmart soundcheck was really great, much better!

  • This her worst performance in my opinion, but she can sing, her mtv unplugged performance prove that. And this is not that bad...

  • Eww

  • i like her hair ! <3

  • Comment removed

  • the only thing i can say it's that i don't know how this person make millions singing like that....i have no words...

  • ATTENTION ALL IDIOTS: It's called a different way of singing. It's a very theatrical song she's trying sing theatrical.xP

  • Lets all make a hateful comment so that we can fit in with the other youtubers :D haha listen to the note at 3:04, the vocals are there, this performance was just off...shes not that perfect....Sidenote: she writes every song so dont say "why did they give her a song she cant sing".

  • @Melcs0fly Well said 110% agree with you(:

  • I luv Katy bt the video is so bad :(

  • horrible

  • I LOVE U KATY ♪

  • She's a good singer, it's just the fact that this is a terrible song for her. She should actually sing more rock songs. I think at least

  • @jujubee998 fuck ya..she is truly sucks singer...a good singer can bring any genre of songs...like gaga..she can sing jazz(lady is a tramp),disco,pop,rnb,electroni­s......BOOOOOO!!!!!.....she said herself wrote this song...no point saying sheis a good singer.....

  • @Mrhaylee4000 I'm sorry, I really am not trying to seem mean, but I don't know what you're saying. You say She is a truly sucks singer? Do you mean she truly sucks as a singer?

    You say, she said herself wrote this song, I think you mean she said that she wrote this song herself.

    and you act like you agree with me,  though you think she's a bad singer, when I think she's good but ET is a bad song for her, what you wrote is irrelevant to what I wrote. sorry if I interpreted your comments wrong!

  • @jujubee998 donot beat about the bush,,,admit it,,,shes sucks

  • @jujubee998 SHE CANT SING LIVE..EVERYBODY's know it...im not mean u have to hate her..but i want u to realize that she cant sing live...she might a sweet nice vocal in studio coz her voice is being autotuned....next time if you really obsessed to something dont be so illuminati(close 1 eye & not to see the other side)...everything seems ok and nice if you like someone

  • @Mrhaylee4000

    NOW, you have started to slightly piss me off, just slightly.

    One, YOU HAVE TERRIBLE GRAMMAR. I know it's a comment, I shouldn't care, but c'mon, you could at least try a LITTLE, because I DON"T KNOW WHAT YOU'RE SAYING! I just-it's like you are speaking in another language.

    Two, just for the record (and this is for help, not hurt) if you want to do the you know, ... thing, you use periods not commas. That's just for future reference (because I use it all the time :)

  • @Mrhaylee4000 Illuminati DOES NOT mean that you close one eye and not see the other side, and I'm not doing that even if that IS what it meant, I understand, in this song, yes she's TERRIBLE, she has a man voice not for E.T. but I still believe that she would be a good rock singer. She's got tone and everything, just not a high range.

    I'm not obsessed with Katy Perry, in fact, I was just curious, I'm more into the alternative genre.

    Also, leave people to their beliefs, and that includes me.

  • @Mrhaylee4000 One more thing, Illuminati means that you feel superior in things such as Religion or politics, it also means (sort of the same with what I just said) that people possessing or think they possess a certain enlightenment. Hope that Helps!

  • @jujubee998 u retarded dunno to relae/apply what u learn with reality...u only open one eye and close the other one..i think thats the reason u said katy perry is a gud singer...there are many others artist thatbetter than katy monkey perry..u need to watch more decent song from others like adele,gaga,jessie,beyonce,they are all good live singer....leona lewis too....u doesnt know that??pathetic

  • @Mrhaylee4000 **relate

  • @jujubee998 Not only that, a vocal coach to help her sing some of those more difficult songs live on stage could go a long way! It's different singing in a studio then moving around on stage. I see some spots of this song where she should have been coached on how to sing it live. But like your opinion (which I agree with), this is just my opinion as well. *shrugs* lol

  • You can tell she CAN sing, and GOOD, this song just ISN'T for her voice I don't why they would give her a song she can't sing.

  • @GottaL0veMe this song is hers,she wrote it,so i dont think thats it...

  • she really knows how to sing!! she's amazing!... yeah no

  • @onfire4000 You try singing better than that and put a cover up on YouTube; then we'll see who's better.

  • @Angad6484 yeah because I'm the one who's doing that for a living when I sing horribly..

  • This was last year she can sing now guys. Fuck off with the negative comments.

  • @CheesyYellowCrumbles I know.. that's what I'm sayin'. Fucking haters gotta find a new reason to hate.

  • no es que cante mal ,, esque se equivoco de tono al principio

  • ela e linda *-*

  • You cannot deny how amazing her vocals sound here > 3:06 !

  • shut up people she was just trying to be creative and she wasn't used to the vocals because this was when it just like came out. and when you hear 2:58 - 3:13 , you can NOT say she can't sing.

  • She can sing better now you idiots. Look at how old this performance was!

  • WOW.. i could even sing better than that ;)

    LOL!!

  • @323645655 me too!

  • @323645655 OH YAH U COULD BETTER THAN KATY PERRY . IN UR DREAMS!

  • @323645655 me to

  • Better than remixes.

  • and katy stans say she's the new MJ.

  • honestly I think she is famous because of her beauty and her body her songs are average and even in the records her voice isn't something you can say ''omg her voice is incredible'' ( I am not not a huge fan of her but like when you hear Beyonce's ) I mean my voice is better than hers and I haven't even trained as she has.I admit it's difficult to sing when you are dancing but if you can't sing when you are dancing so stop dancing and torturing the listeners.Sorry but someone had to say that...

  • Im a fan of her but because of this i am NEVER going to her concerts!!!

  • you're so disappointing. you could be a killer, you could be a feeler.. your voice, irritating! haha

  • LOL! OMG! WHAT IS AIR?!

  • just 3:07 - 3:14

  • omg katy :(((((

  • shit!!!!!!!

  • lol she started out singing at a really high pitch then she was like oh shit...

  • omg!! this is horrible!! sb please make her shut up!

  • wow, she sounds like crap in this video.

  • Her voice gives out FAST! she needs to consult a professional singer like...corey taylor from slipknot/stone sour. that guy can SING

  • am i the only one who likes this?

    Actually i prefer this more than the studio version.

    0:50 - 1:20 is much more authentic than on the record, it sounds more ... i don't know, like she's telling a scary story :D

    and if you didn't know, 3:07 - 3:14 is singing too, it's called belting and she did it very good! if you still think she can't sing type in 'Katy Perry Acoustic' . Click the 1st video and get the fuck off ! :D

  • i thought she can sing... but that's horrible!! :S:$

  • EWW! sorry fans but she is horrible.

  • @spuffix10 i agree.

  • How come people PAY to listen to that? More and more I get convinced that all she's got is a pretty face and big boobs.

  • better she make music inside studios.crappy performance thx industrial music producers.

  • You are little not in the music text and the notes, but I like it a lot, I don´t know why.... I sing this song better than you ... but you have got something sprecificly in your voice .. :=)

  • SO go there and sing bitches! you people talk TOO much! I wanna see only one of you fags doing 2% of that! Stop talking, go there and do it best!

  • Guys, i sound just as good as katy perry does. Should i use autotune and become a super famous singer?

  • @2014sportsgirl You should !

    Go ahead! KILL THE MUSIC!

    Tell me if you have good hair and I tell you if you can become a singer

  • @LetsdestroytheNWO I actually do! It's really soft and my hair lady told me it's really healthy!

  • I love Katy, but she's umm... Not so good live.

  • @HerrNordmann it's because of all of that autotune. at least she's better than ke$ha.

  • u sound terrible

  • NO, it's not terrible!

    it just sound weird at first but the rest is fine.

    you think it's terrible because the album version is so much better than this. remember this is live so much is going on there.

  • Comment removed