sometimes I feel that when Bach writes music for vocals he assumes they can sing this music as easy as if he is playing it on his organ ... he makes singers suffer but listeners reach ecstasy !
Nikolaus Harnoncourt's performance is theatrical yet so passionate. I love so much this part that I keep re-playing it, at times just to watch Harnoncourt! The orchestra and choir are absolutely magnificent. Thanks for posting the videos and the lyrics.
Harnoncourt's performance is so passionate. I love so much this part that I keep re-playing it, at times just to watch Hamoncourt! The orchestra and choir are absolutely magnificent. Thanks for posting the 12 videos and the lyrics.
@TheEs379 Nicolaus Harnoncourt is one of THE most influencial and prolific conductors of the last 30 years in Europe. He is also one of the most fascinating music scholars (his knowledge is staggering) and promotor of musical education for children.
@rambeiro Bach did that on purpose--sort of as a "bookend." It's a well-known music-writing practice. Carl Orff did almost the same thing when he composed "Carmina Burana"--it was a cycle, and he had the opera open and close with the same song, the famous "O Fortuna."
I just find a little defect in Bach´s Music: it has end. Harnoncourt and Bach: the perfect tandem. Great Bach, in You we trust. Thank you for your neverending Music.
@triskubitch I say this as a 20 year old "kid." There are many more kids listening to this music than you think...who makes up all the youth orchestras? And those are the kids PLAYING this kind of music! Believe it or not I know a lot of musician's kids who listen to a whole lot of Romantic music (Baroque takes some maturity I've found). Its best to let the music speak for itself, if you act condescendingly or try and force it on people you will just turn them away...
The bars for the word 'Gloria' are in irregular division (tripplets) with syncopes - the most difficult part for the choir. I hear no mistakes and unsteadyness. I love it - i melt.
At age 65, Harnancourt is to me up there with Sir Henry Wood and Sir Malcolm Sargent as the best ever choral conductors. His own passion, and the passion he evokes from both choralists and musicians is, and always will be, quite extraordinary. My sadness is never having seen him conduct in person, but long may he reign!
The orchestra is really good; Mr Harnoncourt is undoubtedly great; Bach is... how shall I put it?Bach is only the God... Mr Harnoncourt´s face at the beginning of the movement is really electrifying... Thank you, Mr Harnoncourt, for this wonderful performance. Thank you, our great Bach, for this celestial inspiration... You are always in my heart.
God, I love to watch Harnoncourt during the last 30 seconds, So full of passion but serious enough not forget a single note. And of course I also love the music!
Well I wondered if it had anything to do with the nature of the music, being about eternal subject matter, which has no beginning and end. I've read that there is a lot of symbolism in the way Bach composed his sacred music, and thought maybe this was part of it - but it's just a speculation!
No entiendo sobre música clásica, pero creo que alguien tendía que estar sordo y ciego para no reconocer que es una delicia con la fuerza de un tornado.
The crisp diction from the choir and soloists, especially in the "Sicut erat in principio" are awesome, especially in the end of the next line "in principio et nunc". The entire choir/soloists end the word "nunc" about as clearly and crisply as I've ever heard!
Other than the bass soloist poor ending in Sicut Locutus Est with his timing off with the ending words "in saecula", this entire oratorio was OUTSTANDING!
I wish I could put the audio portion on CD and wear it out in my car.
I completely agree with you. The oratorio was outstanding. I find I am sometimes at odds with Harnoncourt's sound since he aims for authenticity using period instruments and could be a bit rushed. One thing is for sure. This piece was executed superbly.
Quite the "magnificent" moment when we finally sung it through with no errors. Managing to do that really puts Bach into scale... this guy wrote pieces like this in less than thirty minutes.
I hate to resurrect a 10-12 month old thread, but this is unanswered here. Bach was German. Harnoncourt is aiming for a period-authentic performance with period instruments and how Bach's choirs pronounced the Latin -- with German diction rules.
As far as the interpretators of latin poems can be trusted, german is quite close to latin in its prononciation, much closer than english or french. So don't care, love Musik, wo immer sie gespielt werden möge.
I think his conducting is brilliant as he really causes the vocals to gain volume and power at the beginning and this sustains through out the peice 10/10 for Harnoncourt.
The enthusiasm is absolutely necessary. It can't be any other way. Bach builds up a massive cathedral of sound on top of a series of pedals. The columns of this cathedral are the three members of the Trinity. When the Cathedral has been erected he ushers us in with the final movement, a variation of the first, which leaves us humble mortals bathed in awe before God's immortal and omnipresent presence.
If you ask me, the only thing immortal here is Bach's infinite brilliance.
et in saecula saeculoruuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuum ... please continue singing for ever and ever ..
waeman 1 week ago in playlist Bach Magnificat
sometimes I feel that when Bach writes music for vocals he assumes they can sing this music as easy as if he is playing it on his organ ... he makes singers suffer but listeners reach ecstasy !
waeman 1 week ago in playlist Bach Magnificat
WOW!!! Just Brilliant..
errpinin 4 weeks ago
Brilliant, Harnoncourt's musical director is very fine indeed. Can you tell me where this performance was done? Many thanks. Christopher
8000Christopher 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Nikolaus Harnoncourt's performance is theatrical yet so passionate. I love so much this part that I keep re-playing it, at times just to watch Harnoncourt! The orchestra and choir are absolutely magnificent. Thanks for posting the videos and the lyrics.
rockymtndude 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Harnoncourt's performance is so passionate. I love so much this part that I keep re-playing it, at times just to watch Hamoncourt! The orchestra and choir are absolutely magnificent. Thanks for posting the 12 videos and the lyrics.
rockymtndude 1 month ago
Comment removed
rockymtndude 1 month ago
What's the name of the conductor, he's awesome!
TheEs379 3 months ago
@TheEs379 His REAL name is Count Nikolaus Harnoncourt de la Fontaine und d'Harnoncourt-Unverzagt.
askim925 2 months ago
@askim925 wow.....thanks : D
TheEs379 2 months ago
@TheEs379 Nicolaus Harnoncourt is one of THE most influencial and prolific conductors of the last 30 years in Europe. He is also one of the most fascinating music scholars (his knowledge is staggering) and promotor of musical education for children.
kapost01 1 month ago
Where was this? And who is the conductor? Its wonderful !!
MVR326 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@MVR326 His REAL name is Count Nikolaus Harnoncourt de la Fontaine und d'Harnoncourt-Unverzagt.
askim925 2 months ago
I just cannot stop listening to this recording. Harnoncourt' s passion is so addictive and his interpretation is probably the best I have ever heard.
kapost01 5 months ago
Tremendous Passion
oakleymelton 7 months ago
OMG. . . why does the Magnificat have to be so g*******d short???
volk410 7 months ago 3
@volk410 Just sing it slowly.
Spncrgmn 5 months ago
Estoy volviendo a Bach.Después de dar muchas vueltas no hay nada que se le aproxime.
Patinir68 8 months ago 3
The best interpretation ever!
anothertry75 8 months ago
A little bit of heaven on earth...magnificent!
wurlic300 10 months ago
"Sicut erat in principio" whit the same music of the first movement. Brilliant!
rambeiro 11 months ago 2
@rambeiro Bach did that on purpose--sort of as a "bookend." It's a well-known music-writing practice. Carl Orff did almost the same thing when he composed "Carmina Burana"--it was a cycle, and he had the opera open and close with the same song, the famous "O Fortuna."
PCCphoenix 8 months ago
What an incredible emotion and Divine sound...
kapost01 11 months ago
I just find a little defect in Bach´s Music: it has end. Harnoncourt and Bach: the perfect tandem. Great Bach, in You we trust. Thank you for your neverending Music.
butannin 1 year ago
if only kids of thsi generation would listen and like this type of music
triskubitch 1 year ago
@triskubitch I'm a kid of this generation and Bach is my favorite composer.
jonfender123 10 months ago 2
@triskubitch I say this as a 20 year old "kid." There are many more kids listening to this music than you think...who makes up all the youth orchestras? And those are the kids PLAYING this kind of music! Believe it or not I know a lot of musician's kids who listen to a whole lot of Romantic music (Baroque takes some maturity I've found). Its best to let the music speak for itself, if you act condescendingly or try and force it on people you will just turn them away...
Wally773MTG 8 months ago
@triskubitch We do! :)
bravesiremma 2 months ago
Un final glorieux!
mayou59500 1 year ago
The bars for the word 'Gloria' are in irregular division (tripplets) with syncopes - the most difficult part for the choir. I hear no mistakes and unsteadyness. I love it - i melt.
LifeforArt 1 year ago
Brings tears... absolute genius.
akrebs74 1 year ago 2
Simply Bach...
MrDexter116 1 year ago
una gran interpretación.
MrQuequestring 1 year ago
Angucken und nur auf den Dirigenten Nikolaus Harnoncourt achten. Wirklich zum lachen! :-D
Speedfish90 1 year ago
Great!
Euplors 1 year ago
That was dang good.
FlamingCamera 1 year ago
sicut erat in principio et nunc et semper et in saecula saeculorum!
¡Salud, paz y una sonrisa!
ariastoteles 1 year ago
First time to ever hear this piece of music. Mesmerizing. I can barely describe...
RayCathode100 1 year ago 3
Yay I can't believe that I know enough Latin, to understand the song as they're singing it!
designedsayer 1 year ago
@designedsayer check Google Translate, it can translate from Latin to English !
waeman 1 week ago
Pity we can't see the standing ovation!!!
marcosromanojujuy 1 year ago
he looks demoniac
newFranzFerencLiszt 1 year ago
he look demoniac
newFranzFerencLiszt 1 year ago
I've just clicked for the 101th time "I like it"
BachHarmony 1 year ago
the conductor is excellent....look at his eyes...XD
xxxxxxxemiliaxxxxxxx 1 year ago
gloria patri means glory of the father
NativeChick4ev 1 year ago
ottima esecuzione
TheSEM85 1 year ago
At age 65, Harnancourt is to me up there with Sir Henry Wood and Sir Malcolm Sargent as the best ever choral conductors. His own passion, and the passion he evokes from both choralists and musicians is, and always will be, quite extraordinary. My sadness is never having seen him conduct in person, but long may he reign!
strachs100 2 years ago
The orchestra is really good; Mr Harnoncourt is undoubtedly great; Bach is... how shall I put it?Bach is only the God... Mr Harnoncourt´s face at the beginning of the movement is really electrifying... Thank you, Mr Harnoncourt, for this wonderful performance. Thank you, our great Bach, for this celestial inspiration... You are always in my heart.
butannin 2 years ago 6
et Spiritui Sancto!
dihydroxypho2009 2 years ago
Einer der Wenigen, die Bach zum Klingen bringen!
caesar10081959 2 years ago 4
Wie wahr, macht süchtig!!
caesar10081959 2 years ago
love him!he must be very scaring if you play to his orchestra!!!!
mention 1:16 he gives the trill to the trumpet and he miss it although he was perfect in tune before!!!
sifakis123 2 years ago
Actually the answer to the ''riddle'' can be answered by looking closely to the lyrics: ''Sicut erat in principio et nunc et semper''.
sportfc 2 years ago 3
Wow, that guys looks intense at the start!
browilliams 2 years ago 3
God, I love to watch Harnoncourt during the last 30 seconds, So full of passion but serious enough not forget a single note. And of course I also love the music!
Zeobit 2 years ago
thanks so much for posting it all - it's just wonderful:)!!!
jirihozpodebrad23 2 years ago
Why do you think Bach ended with the beginning?
MissElfreda 2 years ago
In the time period that the oratorio was written, this was a common practice. A musical "reprise", so to speak.
Hope this helps answer your question.
Rev. Dr. J. Dean McNamara
First Baptist Church
Sedan, KS USA
deanmnaz 2 years ago
Many thanks!
MissElfreda 2 years ago
yeah if you listen to many of his works they mostly all end with a reprise, as deanmnaz says.
jirihozpodebrad23 2 years ago
Well I wondered if it had anything to do with the nature of the music, being about eternal subject matter, which has no beginning and end. I've read that there is a lot of symbolism in the way Bach composed his sacred music, and thought maybe this was part of it - but it's just a speculation!
MissElfreda 2 years ago
...well observed, could indeed also be what he meant to mean! maybe this one was the first one he ever did that way;-) don't know:)
jirihozpodebrad23 2 years ago
No entiendo sobre música clásica, pero creo que alguien tendía que estar sordo y ciego para no reconocer que es una delicia con la fuerza de un tornado.
patriciaesna 2 years ago 2
semplicemte perfetto
autocritica 2 years ago
Praise God! Praise God! Praise God!
Glorthac 2 years ago 3
The conductor is very dangerous. He is probably training KUNG-FU. I'm frightened.
razowiec69 2 years ago 6
The crisp diction from the choir and soloists, especially in the "Sicut erat in principio" are awesome, especially in the end of the next line "in principio et nunc". The entire choir/soloists end the word "nunc" about as clearly and crisply as I've ever heard!
Other than the bass soloist poor ending in Sicut Locutus Est with his timing off with the ending words "in saecula", this entire oratorio was OUTSTANDING!
I wish I could put the audio portion on CD and wear it out in my car.
deanmnaz 2 years ago 8
I completely agree with you. The oratorio was outstanding. I find I am sometimes at odds with Harnoncourt's sound since he aims for authenticity using period instruments and could be a bit rushed. One thing is for sure. This piece was executed superbly.
jepcorp 2 years ago
@deanmnaz great notice .. they pronounce the "c" in "nunc" at exactly the same second !
waeman 1 week ago
(...) et Spiritui Sancto!
dihydroooodings 2 years ago 3
pause it at 0:04 =]
Bankai95 2 years ago 2
very interesting
udilio 2 years ago
Bach and an excellent conductor... what can you ask more ?
Tazeruk 2 years ago 32
@Tazeruk ..and a most excelent lyrics
mxgzn 3 months ago in playlist bach magnificat
Gloria!
l000kin 3 years ago 4
Absolutely brilliant. The conductor really makes it though in the opening seconds
Cankdtank 3 years ago 12
wow it was so so so awesome...we are starting to work on it in my choir at school its impressive..
BBTumble 3 years ago
As are we.
Quite the "magnificent" moment when we finally sung it through with no errors. Managing to do that really puts Bach into scale... this guy wrote pieces like this in less than thirty minutes.
KaitousFlame 3 years ago
The sicut erat is the best I've ever heard.
Lotiolenti 3 years ago 7
Bach is brilliant, Harnoncourt is brilliant, and i with anisometropie: :'(
Eye2watch 3 years ago 4
it's already finished :'(
anisometropie 3 years ago
Wonderful performance, only problem is the very bad pronunciation of the Latin...
HumilisServus 3 years ago
We can only make educated guesses as to precisely how we *think* for example ancient Romans spoke Latin, we cannot know for sure.
zinpgh 3 years ago
Church Latin is pronounced differently than ancient Roman Latin. Church Latin has a more Italianate quality. Will a Jesuit please back me up on this?
jmdez 3 years ago
I hate to resurrect a 10-12 month old thread, but this is unanswered here. Bach was German. Harnoncourt is aiming for a period-authentic performance with period instruments and how Bach's choirs pronounced the Latin -- with German diction rules.
sibeliustx 2 years ago
As far as the interpretators of latin poems can be trusted, german is quite close to latin in its prononciation, much closer than english or french. So don't care, love Musik, wo immer sie gespielt werden möge.
HorstKowalczik 2 years ago
YES
mattmarcucci1 3 years ago
Magnific=) Great!!!
Erethras 3 years ago 3
I think his conducting is brilliant as he really causes the vocals to gain volume and power at the beginning and this sustains through out the peice 10/10 for Harnoncourt.
nerdyal 3 years ago 6
Awesome music, but I seriously think Harnoncourt is going to eat my brains out.
car2052 4 years ago 3
The enthusiasm is absolutely necessary. It can't be any other way. Bach builds up a massive cathedral of sound on top of a series of pedals. The columns of this cathedral are the three members of the Trinity. When the Cathedral has been erected he ushers us in with the final movement, a variation of the first, which leaves us humble mortals bathed in awe before God's immortal and omnipresent presence.
If you ask me, the only thing immortal here is Bach's infinite brilliance.
onionpizza 4 years ago 29
@onionpizza agreed but that conductpr is still hylarious
benxr2006 1 year ago
WOW at the beginnig, Nikolaus Harnoncourt, that's what i call enthusiasm for music lol
mercurygm757 4 years ago 8